Sundowns have turned the Premiership into a farmer's league
Since Bidvest Wits lifted the title in 2017, the Brazilians have danced their way to every championship crown.
Mamelodi Sundowns have just secured their eighth consecutive league title. That's not just dominance, its total control. While the club deserves immense credit, it's impossible to ignore this uncomfortable question: has the South African Premier League become a farmer's league?
Sundowns have become like PSG
The term 'farmer's league' is often thrown around to mock competitions where one team runs away with the title season after season. It's been used to describe the French Ligue 1, where Paris Saint-Germain (PSG) have often strolled to victory, and the Bundesliga, where Bayern Munich have made the trophy their personal property.
ALSO READ: Mamelodi Sundowns seal eighth straight Premiership title
So if we can call those leagues farmer's leagues, why should the Betway Premiership be any different? Since Bidvest Wits lifted the title in 2017, the Brazilians have danced their way to every championship crown. Year after year, they've set the standard, and no one's really come close. At this point, you'd be very brave to bet against them making it nine in a row next season.
That's not to take anything away from what they've built. The winning foundation that was laid by Pitso Mosimane still underpins everything they do. They've maintained a clear footballing identity, invested smartly, and developed depth that most other clubs can only dream of.
This is not luck, but long-term planning and the facts are undeniable. I don't think we will ever see anything like this again.While we can admire Sundowns' brilliance, we must also question the competitiveness of the league.
Where are the challengers? Orlando Pirates and Kaizer Chiefs have struggled to mount any serious title push in recent years, but it's not just about the traditional big two stepping up, the whole league needs to improve.
Clubs must invest smarter
A strong domestic league depends on balance, unpredictability, and competition. Right now, fans can almost predict the title winner before the season even kicks off and that's not healthy for the game. It weakens rivalries, lowers excitement, and risks disengaging supporters altogether.
The challenge now lies with the rest of the league. Clubs must invest smarter, develop better, and think bigger. The goal can't be just finishing in the top eight. It has to be about raising the bar and challenge the juggernaut that is Sundowns.
Credit to the Tshwane giants for their relentless obsession with success, but the local game needs a stronger league. Dominance is fine, but without competition, it becomes a problem. It's time for the chasing pack to raise their standards.
ALSO READ: Chiefs' Maart thanks 'father' Kaizer Motaung
For me, the argument about Downs' financial huge muscle being the only reason for their success is both lazy and boring. The conversation has to be bigger than that. If we keep moving in this direction with one club miles ahead of the pack, we may have to accept the farmer's league tag, no matter how uncomfortable it sounds.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
an hour ago
- The Citizen
Kaizer Chiefs transfer target not here to ‘impress big teams'
'I don't pay attention to that a lot because I play to entertain people,' the Richards Bay striker told FARPOST. Yanele Mbuthuma is reportedly on the radar of Kaizer Chiefs. Picture: Backpagepix Kaizer Chiefs transfer target Yanele Mbuthuma has spoken out on his potential move to Amakhosi. ALSO READ: Bafana's Broos praises Pirates youngster Mbuthuma has recently signed a new contract at Richards Bay amid speculation that he is wanted by Chiefs for next season. Chiefs 'not in my mind' 'I don't pay attention to that a lot because I play to entertain people, not because I wanna impress big teams,' Mbuthuma told FARPOST. 'For now, that's not in my mind. I'm still okay at Richards Bay, so I can just prove myself even more.' The 23 year-old forward scored six goals in all competitions this season for the Natal Rich Boyz. He added that he was surprised to be called up by Bafana. 'I'm very happy that I have been given an opportunity and was called to the national team,' said Mbuthuma. 'I just want to score more goals so that I can progress even more and grow as a striker. 'I was very shocked when I got this opportunity because I wasn't expecting it. When I first started playing football, I wasn't even picturing myself at this level.' Amakhosi look to improve squad Chiefs are looking to bolster their squad ahead of next season, after a disappointing Betway Premiership campaign saw Nasreddine Nabi's side finish ninth in the table, and miss out on a place in next season's MTN8. ALSO READ: Sundowns' Cardoso reacts to Zwane non-selection It was Richards Bay who ultimately made it into the top eight when they beat SuperSport United 2-0 in their final Premiership match of the season, with Mbuthuma one of the goalscorers.
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Sundowns' Cardoso reacts to defeat and Zwane non-selection
'This group has a lot of quality players and obviously Themba is one of them,' said Cardoso. Mamelodi Sundowns coach Miguel Cardoso issued a candid assessment following their 2-1 defeat to Pyramids FC in the second leg of the CAF Champions League final which took place at the 30 June Stadium on Sunday night. Pyramids edged the overall tie 3-2 on aggregate after the two teams played to a 1-1 draw in the first leg. The Egyptian club made history by claiming their first continental championship. Cardoso insisted that the Cairo-based outfit displayed greater desire to lift the trophy. ALSO READ: Pyramids FC edge Sundowns to win Champions League 'When I say that it's important to compete at the highest level, that is exactly the answer that I've given so many times this season when playing Champions League,' said a crestfallen Cardoso. 'Why is it so difficult to beat teams from the north of Africa? It's because those teams can play football but they also play at a high level. Every duel is a life changer and every ball they fight for, they fight with all the energy they have. 'In some moments, I felt like those were things that were missing from our part. I don't think that we were worse when playing football against Pyramids. 'It was shown in both matches but Pyramids were competent and capable in both matches to position themselves in a way that prevented us from playing the way we wanted. But most of all, they gave their lives for every ball they played for and that's what makes a difference in the final sometimes.' One of the night's biggest talking points was Cardoso's decision to leave veteran midfielder Themba Zwane on the bench. Zwane, a crucial figure in Sundowns' 2016 title-winning campaign, was an unused substitute, a move the Portuguese tactician chose not to justify. 'I totally understand what kind of an answer you want and you are looking for but it's not time to speak about individual performance of players. This group has a lot of quality players and obviously Themba is one of them,' Cardoso added. 'It's not a matter of accepting that we lost but it's a matter of accepting that we didn't play a game at a level that we should have played in the first three parts of the game. ALSO READ: PSG have achieved 'our ultimate goal', says Luis Enrique 'We needed to play in a different way to be able to fight. When we did, by not worrying about the other side and only worried about what we could do we could do, we have even won.'
TimesLIVE
2 hours ago
- TimesLIVE
Swiatek digs herself out of deep hole, Alcaraz powers on at French Open
Four-time champion Iga Swiatek clawed her way back from the brink to reach the French Open quarterfinals by defeating her clay court nemesis Elena Rybakina while men's title holder Carlos Alcaraz also went through after a tough workout on Sunday. Fifth seed Swiatek looked out of sorts as she trailed 6-1 2-0 on Court Philippe Chatrier, leaving the crowd stunned. But Swiatek found her groove and some grit to prevail 1-6 6-3 7-5. Her final opponent from last year, Jasmine Paolini, was on the wrong end of another last-16 clash against 13th seed Elina Svitolina of Ukraine, the Italian wasting three match points in a 4-6 7-6(6) 6-1 defeat. Svitolina will provide the next test for Swiatek, who continues her quest to become the first female player since tennis turned professional to claim the singles' title four times in a row at Roland Garros. The only women to win the singles at Roland Garros in four straight years were Jeanne Matthey from 1909-12 and Suzanne Lenglen from 1920-23 when only French players competed. Since tennis turned professional in 1968, Swiatek is one of three women with Monica Seles and Justine Henin to enjoy three consecutive triumphs in Paris and on Sunday it looked like her quest for a fourth straight was going to crash to a halt. The 12th-seeded Rybakina made a bullet start, putting Swiatek on the back foot with some powerful baseline play and racing to a 5-0 lead, threatening to inflict on the former world number one her first bagel at a Grand Slam. 'It was as if I was playing [men's world number one and heavy hitter] Jannik Sinner,' Swiatek joked. If there was any sign that Swiatek was rattled, it was her three double faults at 2-2 in the second set. The fifth seed still held though and it proved to be a turning point as she went on to break to love and move 4-2 up, bagging 10 consecutive points in the process to send the clash into a decider. At 4-4, with Rybakina serving at 15-40, the Kazakh appeared to have double-faulted on break point. Both players were walking towards their benches when chair umpire Kader Nouni's deep voice overruled the line judge's call. The reversal offered Rybakina an unexpected lifeline as the air filled with electricity. Swiatek later saved a game point with a blistering forehand winner, but it was Rybakina who ultimately secured the crucial hold, shifting the weight of expectation squarely onto her opponent's shoulders. Swiatek cooled down and held, then broke and finished it off on the second match point before unleashing a huge scream and bumping her chest in a mix of released anger and relief. 'In the first set, with her playing like that I felt I did not have a single chance,' said Swiatek, who had lost to Rybakina in their two previous encounters on clay. 'Using the top spin was the plan from the beginning but I did not feel she gave me the space to do that. But I'm happy that I was patient enough to stay in the game and use any opportunity that came to me.' Elsewhere in the top half of the draw, Olympic champion Zheng Qinwen battled on, the Chinese eighth seed overcoming Russia's Liudmila Samsonova 7-6(5) 1-6 6-3, with a potential clash against world number one Aryna Sabalenka looming. In the men's draw, Carlos Alcaraz etched his name deeper in clay by overcoming American Ben Shelton 7-6(8) 6-3 4-6 6-4 for his 100th tour-level win on the surface to reach the quarterfinals for a fourth successive year. Victory was far from simple and Alcaraz said he fought against himself in the mind. 'I just tried to calm myself. In some moments I was mad, I was angry with myself. Talking not really good things but I am happy to not let those thoughts play against me,' he added. 'I tried to calm myself down and I tried to keep going.' Up next for him is world number 12 Tommy Paul, who blitzed Alexei Popyrin 6-3 6-3 6-3 to become the first American male player to reach the French Open quarterfinals in 22 years. Paul matched Andre Agassi's run from 2003 after Americans on Saturday equalled a 40-year-old record with five women and three men reaching round four of the clay court Grand Slam. Another American in the last eight is Frances Tiafoe, who beat Germany's Daniel Altmaier but will find himself with a mountain to climb in the next round as he takes on Italian craftsman Lorenzo Musetti. World number seven Musetti beat Denmark's Holger Rune 7-5 3-6 6-3 6-2, showing his impressive palette of clay court game. He has reached at least the semifinals of all three Masters events on the slow surface this season. Sabalenka battled past 16th-seed Amanda Anisimova 7-5 6-3 to become the first player to reach the quarterfinals in 10 straight Grand Slams since American Serena Williams between 2014-17. The Belarusian squandered a total of seven match points before seeing off Anisimova to set up a clash with Zheng.
