Forget compass, crows can spot geometric flaws without Math tools: Latest study
A crow doesn't need a compass or a protractor to know when something looks off. That's the latest revelation from a study in Science Advances, which shows that carrion crows can spot geometric regularity- symmetry, parallel lines, and right angles. Two birds, no math class, and yet they could tell when a shape wasn't spot on.
We humans have long considered geometric intuition our exclusive domain. The ability to recognise when shapes follow orderly principles and to instinctively grasp concepts like symmetry and perpendicularity has been described as a unique human talent. Geometry is a way of thinking found across cultures, even in people with no formal education. This basic sense of shape regularity underpins centuries of human thought, from Euclid's Elements to modern design.
But that story may need a rewrite, or at least a footnote.
Researchers at the University of Tübingen in Germany trained two crows to play a visual game on a touchscreen. Six shapes would appear, and the task was to peck the one that didn't belong. At first, the differences were obvious --- five identical shapes and one distinctly different one. Then came the real test --- sets of four-sided shapes that looked almost identical. Squares, parallelograms, trapezoids, and versions with just one angle or edge slightly off.
Despite having never encountered this type of geometric challenge before, the crows performed well. They didn't just identify the intruder; they showed a pattern of performance that closely mirrors how humans perceive shapes.
The birds were most accurate when the base shapes were regular. Their accuracy dropped as the regularity declined, suggesting their sensitivity to symmetry and parallelism matches our own. Even their mistakes resembled ours. Like many human subjects, the crows struggled most with the rhombus, a shape that often slips past our intuitive sense of irregularity.
Also Read: Two crow deaths at Gorakhpur zoo increase bird flu worries
What makes this finding especially striking is that other species have failed at similar tasks. Baboons, despite being far more closely related to us, couldn't learn to detect these geometric differences, even after extensive training. Yet crows, whose lineage diverged from ours more than 300 million years ago, succeeded spontaneously.
Crows have been surprising people for years. They belong to a remarkably intelligent bird family, the corvids, known for solving problems that stump other animals. Crows craft tools, solve multistep puzzles, remember human faces for years, and even grasp the concept of zero. In one well-known experiment, a New Caledonian crow bent a straight wire into a hook to retrieve food from a narrow tube --- a task that requires abstract reasoning and defeats many young children.
The crows in this study were familiar with visual tasks and interacted with a touchscreen to earn treats. But this experiment tested their understanding of shape regularity, something far more abstract. To rule out chance, the researchers rotated and resized the shapes, randomized their positions, and analysed dozens of trials per bird. The crows still got it right.
Birds navigate complex environments, build nests with structural precision, and use spatial memory to cache thousands of food items. A natural grasp of shape, angle, and spatial relationships would be useful. What we consider abstract mathematics might, for them, be a survival skill.
Also Read: Caw of the wild: Meet the Mumbai crows with an Instagram following
The researchers don't claim that crows are unique- only that they're the first non-human animals shown to have this ability. Their findings open the door to testing other intelligent species such as parrots, dolphins, and elephants that might also possess this form of visual reasoning.
If birds and humans both show this ability, despite their vast evolutionary distance, then perhaps geometric intuition isn't a human invention. It may be older, more deeply rooted, and not limited to humans and crows.
Anirban Mahapatra is a scientist and author, most recently of When The Drugs Don't Work: The Hidden Pandemic That Could End Medicine. The views expressed are personal.
Get 360° coverage—from daily headlines to 100 year archives.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NDTV
2 days ago
- NDTV
Astronomers Uncover Most Powerful Explosion Since The Big Bang
Astronomers from the University of Hawai'i's Institute for Astronomy have identified a new class of cosmic explosions, termed "extreme nuclear transients" (ENTs), marking the most energetic events observed since the Big Bang. These phenomena occur when massive stars, at least three times the mass of our Sun, are torn apart by supermassive black holes at the centres of distant galaxies. The resulting explosions release energy equivalent to what 100 Suns would emit over their entire lifespans, making them visible across vast cosmic distances. This discovery offers new insights into the dynamic interactions between stars and black holes in the universe. The team's findings were detailed today in the journal Science Advances. "We've observed stars getting ripped apart as tidal disruption events for over a decade, but these ENTs are different beasts, reaching brightnesses nearly ten times more than what we typically see," said Jason Hinkle, in a statement, who led the study as the final piece of his doctoral research at IfA. "Not only are ENTs far brighter than normal tidal disruption events, but they remain luminous for years, far surpassing the energy output of even the brightest known supernova explosions." The immense luminosities and energies of these ENTs are truly unprecedented. The most energetic ENT studied, named Gaia18cdj, emitted an astonishing 25 times more energy than the most energetic supernovae known. While typical supernovae emit as much energy in just one year as the sun does in its 10 billion-year lifetime, ENTs radiate the energy of 100 suns over a single year. As per a news release by W M Keck Observatory, ENTs were first uncovered when Hinkle began a systematic search of public transient surveys for long-lived flares emanating from the centres of galaxies. He identified two unusual flares in data from the European Space Agency's Gaia mission that brightened over a timescale much longer than known transients and without characteristics common to known transients. "Gaia doesn't tell you what a transient is, just that something changed in brightness," said Hinkle. "But when I saw these smooth, long-lived flares from the centres of distant galaxies, I knew we were looking at something unusual."
Indian Express
3 days ago
- Indian Express
How climate change and rapid development are pushing the Himalayan region to the brink
'The Himalayas are sounding alarm,' Union Environment Minister Bhupender Yadav warned at a climate summit in Kathmandu in May. 'As a consequence of global warming due to human activity, glaciers are retreating, threatening the future of water security for populations downstream.' Yadav's remarks mirror a growing consensus among environmentalists and scientists who warn that unchecked construction, coupled with global warming, is causing severe and potentially irreversible damage to mountain ecosystems. Scientific studies have long shown that Himalayan glaciers are melting at an unprecedented pace due to climate change, threatening water availability, agriculture and livelihoods. According to a 2019 research article Acceleration of ice loss across the Himalayas over the past 40 years, published in the peer-reviewed journal Science Advances, 'glaciers across the Himalayas experienced significant ice loss over the past 40 years, with the average rate of ice loss twice as rapid in the 21st century compared to the end of the 20th century.' 'Due to global warming, Himalayan glaciers are continuously depleting, forming artificial lakes known as GLOFs (Glacial Lake Outburst Floods). When they burst, they wreak havoc. We saw this recently at South Lhonak Lake in Sikkim, which caused a devastating flood in the Teesta River valley in October 2023… It destroyed the Teesta III hydroelectric dam and caused widespread damage,' says Guman Singh, environmental activist and coordinator at Himalaya Niti Abhiyan, a grassroots movement advocating for a sustainable, mountain-specific development model in the Himalayas. A similar GLOF was behind the 2013 Kedarnath floods, which claimed over 6,000 lives. Another catastrophe occurred in Uttarakhand's Chamoli district on February 7, 2021, when an ice-rock avalanche triggered flash floods, killing over 200 people and destroying hydroelectric projects. Scientists and environmentalists warn that such floods are likely to become more frequent in India's hill states as climate change accelerates the melting of glaciers. According to a report Monitoring of Glaciers, Climate, and Runoff in the Hindu Kush-Himalaya Mountains, published in the South Asia Water Initiative, remote sensing data estimates that there are around 7,500 glacier lakes in Himalayan states like Himachal Pradesh, Uttarakhand, Sikkim, and Arunachal Pradesh. Of these, 190 are classified as 'very high' risk for causing a GLOF. Singh also draws attention to riverbed encroachments. 'When massive water flow meets narrowed river channels, it causes large-scale destruction. We saw this during the 2023 Himachal floods when rivers changed course and entered human settlements, leaving hundreds dead,' he says. 'You cannot tame a river.' Infrastructure boom, ecological bust The Himalayan region is witnessing a rapid infrastructure push — highways, tunnels, hydropower plants — posing a significant threat to its delicate ecology, they often ignore local geology and environmental constraints. 'The government's infrastructure projects have penetrated deep into the Himalayas, threatening the region's overall health. Roads are being constructed without considering the fragile geology, using techniques suited for the plains,' says environmentalist Ravi Chopra, who chaired the Supreme Court panel reviewing the Char Dham highway project in 2019. He later resigned when construction continued despite the panel's warnings about severe ecological risks. Chopra also criticised the disregard for the mountains' carrying capacity, an issue echoed by senior environment journalist Hridayesh Joshi. 'Joshimath is one of several places facing land subsidence. The Mishra Committee, back in 1976, had already warned that Joshimath was vulnerable, built on landslide debris, and worsened by blasting activities. Yet, the development model continues to ignore these warnings,' says Joshi. The situation raises urgent questions. Can a seismically active, hydrologically complex, and geologically unstable region bear the pressure of mega projects? 'Hydropower projects in the Himalayas face two constant and serious threats — catastrophic earthquakes and destructive floods triggered by glacial lake outbursts. What happens if these dams fail during such events? What will become of the region? Scientific studies have long warned of a powerful earthquake, exceeding magnitude 8, striking this area. Why, then, are we not prioritising sustainable development for the region?' aks Singh. Meadows turning into dumpyards Plastic pollution is another mounting crisis in the Himalayas. A viral video recently showed plastic bags, bottles, and animals rummaging through a forest in Kasol, Himachal Pradesh — not a landfill, but a tourist spot. Similar visuals from Parvati Valley depict garbage heaps and polluted rivers. When you enter Himachal, you pay a green tax in the name of nature conservation — and this is what the government and administration do with those crores: openly dumping garbage in forests and near rivers. Welcome to Kasol, an international tourist hub turning into a dump! — Nikhil saini (@iNikhilsaini) May 27, 2025 'This is not an isolated case,' says Joshi. 'Many ecologically sensitive zones are turning into dumping grounds. Waste is often discarded behind hotels and resorts, with little regulatory oversight.' According to reports, Shimla generates approximately 2,800 tonnes of solid waste, while Manali produces over 1,100 tonnes per month. These are the numbers that double during tourist season. In response, the Himachal government in May this year approved a scheme requiring a refundable deposit on non-biodegradable items to incentivise return and recycling. But the problem runs deeper. According to an alliance by Zero Waste Himalaya, an anti-waste collective of NGOs, an organisation based in Gangtok, and the Integrated Mountain Initiative based in Dehradun, single-use food and beverage packaging accounts for 84% of the plastic waste in the region. Alarmingly, 70% of plastic waste collected across the Himalayan belt is non-recyclable and has no market value. 'The authorities are inviting tourists in large numbers without any waste management plan. If you generate revenue, you must manage the waste too,' says Singh, urging tourists to 'carry your garbage back with you. The mountains cannot absorb such massive piles of waste.' The perils of an unregulated tourism Tourism in the Himalayas is booming, and so is the damage, pushing the fragile mountain ecosystem to its limits. According to the Himachal government's 'Economic Survey' report for FY 2024-25, the state recorded its highest tourist footfall in five years, 1.8 crore domestic tourists and 83,000 foreign visitors. Meanwhile, Uttarakhand reported 5.96 crore visitors in 2023, up from 3.68 crore in 2018, according to the state's tourism department. 'Unregulated tourism is stripping this ecologically sensitive region of its natural character,' says Mansi Asher of Himdhara, Environment Research and Action Collective, an autonomous, non-registered environment research and action collective based in Himachal Pradesh. 'Religious tourism is being promoted in an unstructured, unregulated way. Helicopters swarm over sensitive areas like Kedarnath, which is a wildlife sanctuary. Laser shows, ropeway movements, and excessive noise pollution exceed permitted decibel levels,' says Joshi. Bachi Singh Bisht, of Janmaitri Sangathan, adds, 'Helicopters fly from dawn to dusk in Kedarnath Valley, affecting locals, including schoolchildren, some of whom are now partially deaf.' Unregulated tourism is also fueling outmigration. As per 2011 Census, the population in most of the mountain districts of Uttarakhand declined. There was an absolute decline of 17868 persons in the population of Almora and Pauri Garhwal districts between 2001 and 2011. 'Migration is growing, traditional livelihoods are vanishing, and the ecological backbone of the Himalayas is buckling', Bisht says. What can save the Himalayas? Rising temperatures, erratic weather patterns, growing human-wildlife conflict, depleting water sources, and an alarming increase in landslides, floods, heatwaves, forest fires, and droughts are quickly becoming the new normal in the Himalayan region. But what is the cure? Experts say that top-down solutions are failing. 'Multinational consultancies are being brought in to tackle problems that require local understanding, while the knowledge and experience of local communities are being overlooked. This approach must change,' says Mansi. Singh believes the Infrastructure development also needs a major shift. 'We don't need large-scale infrastructure projects. What we need is small-scale, sustainable development. Tourism should be decentralised, focusing on lesser-known destinations rather than building up major hotspots. We must adopt a policy that ties conservation with livelihood generation.' Is it possible to balance development with sustainability while promoting tourism? Joshi thinks so, but not with the current strategy. 'We should revive the traditional style of pilgrimage, which lasted for months, supported local economies, and was deeply harmonious with nature.' Parveen K Dogra is Assistant Editor at and is based in New Delhi. ... Read More
India Today
30-05-2025
- India Today
Rare discovery on Mars could finally reveal why the planet died
Mars always had water, but then the planet changed and the water disappeared leaving behind a barren dead what could be one of the biggest findings from Mars, Nasa's Mars Atmosphere Volatile Evolution (MAVEN) mission has detected an elusive atmospheric escape process called could help answer longstanding questions about the history of water loss on Mars. Mars is believed to have lost the water after its magnetic field disappeared exposing the planet to the solar wind and solar storms. As the atmosphere began to erode, liquid water was no longer stable on the surface, so much of it escaped to are interested in finding out how its once thick atmosphere got stripped away. They think sputtering was behind it. Sputtering, a phenomenon where energetic particles from the solar wind crash into Mars' upper atmosphere and knock atoms into space, may have played a central role."It's like doing a cannonball in a pool," said Shannon Curry, principal investigator of MAVEN. "The heavy ions are the cannonballs, and they splash neutral atoms and molecules out of the atmosphere."While indirect evidence of sputtering existed — particularly in the uneven distribution of argon isotopes in the Martian atmosphere — this is the first time scientists have observed the process a trio of MAVEN instruments, including the Solar Wind Ion Analyzer and Neutral Gas and Ion Mass Spectrometer, the team collected rare data from both the dayside and nightside of the result: a high-resolution map showing argon being ejected from Mars' atmosphere precisely where solar particles collided with it. This sputtering occurred at a rate four times higher than previously thought, and intensified during solar discovery, published this week in Science Advances, confirms sputtering as a major mechanism behind the atmospheric erosion that led to Mars' dramatic climate shift.'These results establish sputtering's role in the loss of Mars' atmosphere and in determining the history of water on Mars,' said Curry. The findings could significantly reshape our understanding of Mars' past — and its potential to have once supported Reel
