MPs call for increased protections for vulnerable benefit claimants
A cross-party committee of MPs has called for greater protections for vulnerable benefit claimants after hundreds of cases of deaths and serious harms linked to safeguarding failures by welfare officials.
The work and pensions select committee said many of these cases, which include instances where claimants took their own lives, could have been prevented had the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) discharged its responsibilities effectively.
It cited the cases of Errol Graham, a disabled man with a long history of mental illness, who starved to death in 2018 after his benefits were cut off, and Philippa Day, a mother wrongly deprived of disability benefits for months, who died in 2019 after taking an overdose.
In both instances, coroners identified failures by DWP officials to properly take into account the acute difficulties both claimants faced in engaging with a benefits system they had found to be alienating and unsupportive.
These high-profile cases, and the DWP's prioritisation of cost-cutting over 'genuine care and support' for vulnerable people in recent years, had 'sorely damaged' public and claimant trust in the system, the committee said.
It published testimonies from benefit claimants saying their interactions with the DWP made them anxious, stressed and traumatised. One said it felt as if 'a system that is meant to wrap its arms around us is strangling us'.
Social security policies such as benefit sanctions and deductions were too often misapplied to vulnerable claimants, the committee said, leaving those individuals facing substantial hardship and putting them at risk of harm.
The committee chair, Labour's Debbie Abrahams, said 'deep-rooted' cultural change in the DWP was desperately needed to improve its treatment of vulnerable claimants.
'That people continue to face harm after dealing with the DWP is a self-evident failure of safeguarding in the system,' she said. 'We heard evidence that the process of engaging with the DWP itself too often led to mental distress. Where this led to not being able to get financial support, many had paid the ultimate price.'
Since 2020 at least 240 internal DWP reviews have been carried out into deaths or cases of serious harms where actions or omissions by officials may have been a factor, the committee said. On nine occasions since 2013, coroners have issued the DWP with formal reports recommending action to prevent future claimant deaths.
However, the impact of DWP safeguarding deficiencies was not properly understood within the department, the committee concluded. 'We remain concerned that the true scale of deaths and serious harms of vulnerable claimants is currently unknown,' it said.
The committee called for an independent scrutiny body to be created to investigate serious safeguarding failures and take appropriate action, amid concerns that the DWP was 'marking its own homework' over cases it may have mishandled.
Sign up to Headlines UK
Get the day's headlines and highlights emailed direct to you every morning
after newsletter promotion
The committee recommended that a legal duty to safeguard vulnerable claimants should be imposed on the DWP. Although in the past ministers have resisted the suggestion, the work and pensions secretary, Liz Kendall, told MPs last November she was open to the idea.
'A statutory safeguarding duty would help to drive and embed culture change in the department, support the consistent delivery of safeguarding practices, and improve accountability should failures occur,' the committee said.
The chief executive of the charity Rethink Mental Illness, Mark Winstanley, said a statutory DWP safeguarding duty would improve accountability. 'For too long, vulnerable people living with mental illness have suffered devastating harm and lost their lives due to failures in the benefits system,' he said.
A DWP spokesperson said: 'This government is committed to protecting the people who use our services and fixing the broken welfare system we inherited so it works for those who need it. That's why we are currently consulting on a new safeguarding approach, and our reforms will improve people's lives and rebuild trust by establishing an approach that genuinely supports vulnerable people.
'As we deliver our plan for change, we encourage people to have their voices heard through our consultation so we can build a safeguarding approach that works better for all.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
‘Women' targeted in prostate cancer campaign by major charity
A leading prostate cancer charity has been promoting the stories of 'women with a trans history' above men on its website. Prostate Cancer UK has a webpage dedicated to the 'real-life stories' of men who have undergone prostate treatment. But the first stories that readers see underneath a sub-heading of 'here, men share their experiences' are those of Suzanna and Alice. The charity moved the two stories to the bottom of its website after being approached by The Telegraph. The trans women make up two of the 20 stories published by the charity – which has been accused of causing confusion among men seeking advice and guidance – despite one of them never being diagnosed with prostate cancer. Campaigners said Prostate Cancer UK risked 'harming its target audience' with the 'unclear activist language'. 'Trans history' The first story describes Suzanna as a '72-year-old woman with a trans history' who was treated for 'an enlarged prostate' and did not have cancer. She had her genitals removed in 2013 and later developed incontinence issues. The story says: 'I went to the GP. I had no qualms about doing this, unlike some women with a trans history, as had been at the practice for years and the GP knows about my trans history.' The protein-specific antigen test revealed nothing but an MRI scan suggested that the prostate was twice the size it should be. Suzanna was given drugs to 'calm an 'overexcited' bladder' and another 'to relax my urethra so that I could pass urine more easily'. The story concludes: 'I know that some health professionals don't understand the issues with regards to trans women and that education is needed, but my consultant was very thorough and professional. There were no issues like, 'Why are you here, you are a woman?'' Of the 20 stories included, it was one of just two in which the person was not diagnosed with cancer. The other was a story of a young man living with prostatitis, which is inflammation of the prostate. The other trans woman's story describes how 'Alice was diagnosed with an enlarged prostate and prostate cancer before she transitioned'. The story says: 'When I was diagnosed, I thought, 'Great, take the lot away', until I quickly learnt that the prostate remains after genital reconstructive surgery. At this time, no one treating me for prostate cancer was aware of my gender dysphoria. 'Overall, my experience is that no one who has spoken with me – urologists, GPs or gender specialists at the gender identity clinic – have indicated that they are aware of any specific issues required for a trans woman with prostate cancer. 'In the end, I had to suggest that my urologist was contacted by the gender identity clinic staff as the urologists were treating me as a male, not as a trans woman.' 'Wrong way to go about it' Fiona McAnena, the director of campaigns at human rights charity Sex Matters, said it was 'helpful that Prostate Cancer UK reminds all men about this male-specific cancer, and that identifying as a woman doesn't mean a man is no longer at risk'. She said: 'But describing these men as 'women with a trans history', as the charity does, is completely the wrong way to go about this.' Ms McAnena said that 'confused young trans-identifying women who've been taught a nonsense version of science based on gender ideology at school in recent years may think this refers to them', while 'some trans-identifying men claim they have become biologically female'. She said that 'no responsible charity should leave room for such disinformation' and warned that it risked losing the importance of biological sex, such as in the case of cervical campaigns, which she said 'have all but abandoned clear words like 'woman' and 'female' and instead talk confusingly about 'people with a cervix''. 'Prostate Cancer UK risks harming its target audience – that is, all men, however they identify – by embracing unclear activist language,' she added. 'Must be based on biological reality' Dr Alice Hodkinson, a GP and co-founder of Biology in Medicine, said that 'prostate cancer care must be based on biological reality, not gender identity, to ensure patient safety'. She said: 'Most men who identify as trans women have not undergone surgery, are not on cross-sex hormones, and all retain their prostates, so they remain at risk of prostate cancer. 'Trans women who have had genital surgery or are taking hormones, may face additional risks.' A Prostate Cancer UK spokesman said: 'We're here to stop people dying from prostate cancer, and to support all those affected by it. That includes men, trans women, non-binary and intersex people, and their family and friends. 'As part of our mission to raise awareness of prostate cancer and its impact, we tell the stories of a diverse range of hundreds of people each year in the press, across our social media, and on other channels including on our website, emails to supporters, and many more.'
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
Job losses at Totally as urgent NHS call firm collapses
A healthcare firm, which provided urgent care services in NHS 111 call centres, has gone into administration with the loss of 100 which employed 1,400 people across several sites in the UK, including Stockton-on-Tees and Newcastle, said workers had lost their jobs across the group but did not confirm how many had been affected at each company has been sold to PHL Group, another healthcare provider to the NHS - with the immediate transfer of 600 of its Vance, joint administrator at EY-Parthenon, said he was pleased that hundreds of jobs and "critical frontline NHS services" had been safeguarded by the sale. Derby-based Totally had been struggling since losing the NHS 111 support contract in February. Mr Vance said: "We are pleased to have agreed the sale of Totally plc which safeguards critical frontline NHS services and includes the retention of over 600 jobs." Follow BBC North East on X, Facebook, Nextdoor and Instagram.
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
My painful restless legs are stopping me from relaxing & nothing seems to work – I'm desperate for help
WE are often drawn to supplements to 'fix our health'. But, unless we are deficient in certain nutrients, then lifestyle changes are more likely to bring about noticeable changes. Most of us should get all the nutrients we need from eating a balanced diet. But we sometimes need a little extra help. For example, vegetarians and especially vegans should consider supplementing with vitamin B12, and possibly calcium, iron and zinc. Irritable bowel syndrome patients might find a probiotic is helpful to alleviate symptoms, and people with sleep issues may want to try magnesium. The only supplement the NHS recommends for all adults is vitamin D, which our bodies create in response to sufficient sunlight. The advice is to take it between October and April, but some people are advised to take it all year round, including people who have dark skin and those who are not often outdoors, for example, if they are in a care home. Here's a selection of what readers have asked this week. Q) AS soon as I relax in bed, I get a crawling sensation under my skin in my legs. Lately, it seems to be getting worse, affecting my arms. I am an 82-year-old lady and have suffered from restless legs syndrome for many years. My GP first prescribed pramipexole, which didn't help, then ropinirole, which doesn't work on its own, so I have to take co-codamol. Cardiologist explains when chest pains aren't a heart attack I worry I will have to take these for the rest of my life. My doctor won't increase the ropinirole because of the side-effects. I've been told there is nothing else that can be done. I have tried exercising, a warm bath, a massage, but nothing helps. A) Restless legs syndrome (RLS) is a neurological disorder characterised by an irresistible urge to move the limbs accompanied by uncomfortable sensations. While it most commonly affects only the legs, the arms are occasionally affected, too. Symptoms tend to be worse at night and this often affects sleep. It's not understood why people get it and there's no known cure unless it's linked to an underlying, reversible condition. Iron deficiency or low iron levels can cause it, so it's worth your GP checking these if they haven't already. It can also be caused by certain medications, including some anti-nausea drugs, antidepressants, antipsychotics and antihistamines – so again, if you take any other meds, it's worth checking if there could be a link. Ropinirole used to be recommended as a first-line treatment, but the guidelines have changed and now gabapentin (and similar drugs) are advised. Some people are unable to take this due to potential interactions. Some people have side-effects, especially older adults. So your GP might have opted away from this, but it is worth asking them. You can always download the NICE guidelines yourself or attach the link in an e-consult request for them to consider. Just search 'NICE' and 'restless legs syndrome' and you'll reach the right webpage. It may also help if you reduce caffeine and alcohol, don't smoke, sleep well and be physically active. To relieve an attack, relaxation, stretching, walking or massage can help. RLS-UK ( has useful advice and resources. My doctor said it was pointless having an X-ray, but I have had corticosteroid injections, which did nothing to ease the pain. 3 I am a 63-year-old type 2 diabetic, and I have also been having physiotherapy, which has noticeably improved my range of movement. My physiotherapist is not entirely convinced that it IS a frozen shoulder, though, and has suggested it could potentially be a form of arthritis or another condition. He has written to my doctor recommending that X-rays be carried out. I have started experiencing upper back pain, too. I am unsure whether this is connected. How do I approach my doctor on this? A) Frozen shoulder (adhesive capsulitis) is a condition that causes pain, stiffness and reduced range of movement of the shoulder joint. The symptoms are caused by the formation of adhesive or scar tissue in the joint. Studies indicate that people with diabetes may be two to four times more likely to develop frozen shoulder. Diagnosis is clinical, meaning it is based on the symptoms and examination findings rather than X-rays or scans. The main diagnostic test is whether you can do passive external rotation of the shoulder. This means that the doctor supports the patient's arm in a bent position (imagine holding a kettle) and tries to move the arm to the side. Inability to do this movement is highly suggestive of frozen shoulder. If an X-ray is obtained, it should demonstrate a normal shoulder joint. Most patients get physiotherapy, which can be supplemented by steroid joint injections. It usually resolves on its own over a year or two, although some individuals may experience longer recovery times. Physios see frozen shoulder quite frequently, so if yours is experienced and believes that other causes should be considered, then your GP is likely to take that advice. Rotator cuff injuries, bursitis, osteoarthritis and shoulder impingement are examples of conditions that can be mistaken for frozen shoulder due to overlapping symptoms. 'My body has become my enemy' Q) I AM a 63-year-old female who has always been healthy and active until having a mobility issue with my right leg for the last 13 years. It has led to foot drop. It is easy to trip and fall. It was suggested I must have had a one-off viral attack which damaged an area of my spinal cord. 3 I am so angry and frustrated. This has taken a huge toll on me mentally, and my body has responded by going into overdrive. I am overwhelmed with tiredness, but cannot sleep, and have no appetite. I am unable to relax. My body has become my enemy. Please could you advise, before I collapse? A) It sounds like the 'fight or flight' part of your nervous system may be in overdrive and also that you have a lot of negative thoughts and emotions surrounding what has happened to your body. This statement, 'my body has become my enemy', is a clue that you are most likely to benefit from cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), which is available on the NHS. CBT could help you rebuild the relationship with your body. Please don't delay – self-refer on the NHS talking therapies webpage, or explore insurance or private options if these are available to you. Regarding the foot drop, in addition to physio and orthotics (which help prevent tripping and dragging of the toes), you should ask about whether electrical nerve stimulation would be an option for you. A device sends small electrical impulses to stimulate nerves that lift the foot and is sometimes used if the foot drop is caused by damage to the brain or spinal cord (eg from stroke or MS – multiple sclerosis). Research is ongoing into using stem cells or nerve growth factors to regenerate damaged nerves that cause foot drop. See if any trials are recruiting by asking your specialist team, exploring the NIHR Be Part of Research webpage, or by visiting
