New report by panel of experts claims killer nurse Lucy Letby is innocent
MANCHESTER, England — The trial of Lucy Letby made headlines around the world due to the sheer horror and scale of the crimes for which she was convicted, but some believe the neonatal nurse is innocent and the victim of a miscarriage of justice.
Letby, 35, was found guilty of murdering seven babies and attempting to kill seven more at the Countess of Chester Hospital in North West England during a year-long killing spree between June 2015 and June 2016.
She was portrayed by the prosecution as a "constant malevolent presence" on the hospital's neonatal unit and a "calculating and devious" nurse who liked "playing God."
'Cold-blooded' Nurse Lucy Letby Found Guilty Of Murdering 7 Babies At Hospital Neonatal Unit
In an apparent handwritten confession note found by police, she said she had killed babies "on purpose."
She also wrote, "I am a horrible evil person" and "I AM EVIL I DID THIS."
Read On The Fox News App
Letby, considered to be the United Kingdom's worst serial child killer, was sentenced to 15 life prison terms and has lost two bids to appeal her convictions.
But there has been a growing clamor among leading medical professionals, legal experts and commentators that she is innocent.
Ex-Conservative cabinet minister Sir David Davis has also spoken out and called for a new trial, telling fellow members of parliament (MPs) there was "no hard evidence" against her.
This week, a fresh report presented by a panel of 14 international experts has claimed there is "no medical evidence" she murdered or harmed any of the babies in her care.
During her first ten-month trial — Letby later faced a second trial — she was accused of murdering four of the seven babies by injecting air into their bloodstreams and attempting to kill others by the same method.
The prosecution claimed other babies were harmed by insulin poisoning, being force-fed milk or by trauma to the liver.
But the experts' report rules out any criminality and points to babies deteriorating due to natural causes or "bad medical care."
Therefore, it's claimed Letby is the victim of "one of the major injustices of modern times."
Letby's new lawyer, Mark McDonald, told The Guardian newspaper the report demolished the case against her, and there was "overwhelming evidence this conviction is unsafe."
Lucy Letby Trial: Father Testifies Baby Girl Was Left Severely Disabled After Nurse Tried To Kill Her
The report's findings have been sent to the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC), the body that investigates potential miscarriages of justice, which is now formally examining the case.
The CCRC will also be tasked with reexamining the contentious medical evidence used to convict Letby.
In particular, questions have been raised about the prosecution's main medical expert, Dr. Dewi Evans, who claimed babies died from having air injected into their bloodstreams, causing air embolism, a fatal condition.
During Letby's trial, he pointed to skin discoloration in several victims as an indicator of air embolism, citing a 1989 academic paper.
Nurse Lucy Letby Wrote Sympathy Card To Parents Of Baby Girl She's Accused Of Murdering
But retired Canadian neonatologist Shoo Lee, a co-author of the paper and chair of the panel, believes the research was misinterpreted by the prosecution, and Dr. Evans' findings have "no basis in evidence."
The panel has also cast doubt on supposed insulin poisonings after Letby's original defense team did not dispute them.
It's claimed that babies were not properly cared for, and there were failures to carry out "basic medical procedures, delays in their treatment and the misdiagnosis of diseases."
Dr. Lee also claimed the hospital was overworked and inadequately staffed, saying, "If this had happened at a hospital in Canada, it would be shut down."
It will take many months for the CCRC to review the case, and there's no guarantee it will be referred back to the Court of Appeal. So, Letby will remain in prison for the foreseeable future, with any bail application likely to be resisted by the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).
Meanwhile, a public inquiry examining events at the hospital is due to conclude next month while prosecutors are considering bringing further charges against Letby in other baby deaths at a second hospital, Liverpool Women's Hospital.
A CCRC spokesperson told Fox News Digital, "We have received a preliminary application in relation to Ms. Letby's case, and work has begun to assess the application.
"At this stage, it is not possible to determine how long it will take to review this application. A significant volume of complicated evidence was presented to the court in Ms Letby's trials.
"We anticipate further submissions being made to us."
A CPS spokesperson told Fox News Digital, "Two juries and three appeal court judges have reviewed a multitude of different strands of evidence against Lucy Letby. She has been convicted on 15 separate counts following two separate jury trials.
"In May 2024, the Court of Appeal dismissed Letby's leave to appeal on all grounds, rejecting her argument that expert prosecution evidence was flawed."Original article source: New report by panel of experts claims killer nurse Lucy Letby is innocent
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Video of Antonio Brown's altercation resurfaces after attempted murder charge
Several videos from the night during which ex-NFL wide receiver Antonio Brown allegedly fired a gun in Miami following a boxing match and brawled with several individuals, leading to an arrest warrant being issued for attempted murder with a firearm, have started to circulate again on social media. Brown, 36, claimed at the time he had been jumped in an attempt to steal his jewelry following a Brand Risk boxing event hosted by streamer Adin Ross. Two videos posted in a compilation by NFL aggregator on X @NFL_DovKleiman showed the former Steelers star brawling with several individuals outside a building, with Brown falling to the ground during the ruckus. He kicked a man after rising from the ground before another man attempted to calm him down. 9 A shot of Brown during the wildness. MEGA 9 Antonio Brown appearing to run. MEGA Warning: Unsettling videos Brown ran behind several cars during the skirmish. A third video in the compilation displayed a large group of people standing around in the aftermath before several people attempted to run away after what appeared to be gunshots ringing out. 9 Brown brawling with several men. @NFL_DovKleiman/X The person filming the clip stated, 'Shots is crazy,' while another compilation of videos posted May 17 at 6:30 a.m. ET from X user @ONLYinDADE showcased a longer video of the reaction to the alleged gunshots in which the person behind the camera said: 'Shots were fired.' That video collection also featured a shirtless Brown being escorted by an officer with his hands behind his back — seemingly wearing handcuffs — toward a cop car. 9 An arrest warrant has been issued for Brown. MEGA A third clip from that video featured Ross talking to Brown after the incidents, with Brown stating 'nothing happened' when asked about what transpired and claimed that he 'blacked out.' Brown clarified on May 17 that he had not been arrested, and TMZ reported he was let free 20 minutes later. 9 Brown before kicking a man during the ruckus. @NFL_DovKleiman/X 'I was jumped by multiple individuals who tried to steal my jewelry and cause physical harm to me. Contrary to some video circulating, Police temporarily detained me until they received my side of the story and then released me,' Brown wrote on X. 'I WENT HOME THAT NIGHT AND WAS NOT ARRESTED. I will be talking to my legal council and attorneys on pressing charges on the individuals that jumped me. I will keep you all posted step-by-step on the process. Thank you for the support and love.' 9 Brown running during the incident. MEGA The City of Miami police department said in a May 17 release that it received a ShotSpotter Alert around 3 a.m. on May 17, but no arrests had been made, nor had anyone been injured. The arrest warrant states an off-duty officer told the police he heard gunshots and saw Brown in a melee with another man, according to The Washington Post. 9 The arrest warrant reportedly lists a $100,00 bond. MEGA Those in the parking lot informed police that Brown had fired the shots, but the warrant also notes that Brown did not have a weapon on him when officers searched him. The warrant states investigators discovered two spent shell casings plus an empty gun holster, per the report. Officers later received videos allegedly showing Brown taking a gun from a security officer and running toward the man he had hit, according to The Washington Post. Cell phone video 'captures' two gunshots as Brown moved toward the man, per the report. 9 Brown during his time with the Buccaneers in 2022. AP The man told police on May 21 that Brown 'began to run toward him with a firearm' and shot him twice, potentially hitting him in his neck area. Brown and the man — who said he's known the former NFLer since 2022 — reportedly fought for control of the gun before Brown exited, and the man went to Aventura Hospital. 9 Brown after the incidents in question. @ONLYinDADE/X The arrest warrant reportedly lists a $10,000 bond and for Brown to remain under house arrest pending a trial. Brown did not respond to The Post's attempt to reach him Thursday night via the email listed on his social media account. The mercurial receiver starred in the NFL from 2010-21, mostly playing for the Steelers before appearing in one game for the Patriots and finishing his career by playing two seasons for the Buccaneers. He has since become a controversial figure for his X posts.
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Why Syrian antiquities are flooding Facebook Marketplace
When you buy through links on our articles, Future and its syndication partners may earn a commission. Listed alongside the more familiar knackered sofas and unwanted books are ancient, stolen treasures: Facebook Marketplace has become a profitable hub for the sale of looted and trafficked Syrian antiquities. Since the fall of the Assad regime, "widespread poverty" and the "collapse" of the nation's "once-feared security apparatus" have sparked a "gold rush" of looters, robbing 2000-year-old graves for artefacts to sell online, said The Guardian. Syria's location in the "heart of the fertile crescent where settled civilisation first emerged", means it is "awash" with "mosaics, statues and artefacts" that "fetch top dollar" from Western collectors. Nearly a third of the 1,500 Syrian cases that the Antiquities Trafficking and Heritage Anthropology Research project has documented since 2012 have occurred since December alone. When Assad fell, there was a "huge spike on the ground", said Amr al-Azm, a co-director of the ATHAR project. There was a "complete breakdown" of any of the constraints that used to control looting. "The last three to four months has seen the biggest flood of antiquities trafficking I have ever seen, from any country, ever," said ATHAR's other co-director Katie Paul. This has upset many Syrians and some have protested outside the National Museum in Damascus, demanding the protection of the nation's antiquities from illicit excavations. The "destruction" of our cultural heritage is a "blatant attack on our history", one of them told Syrian news agency Sana, and it must be confronted "by all possible means". The looters, "armed with pickaxes, shovels and jackhammers", come by night to "disturb the dead", said The Guardian. Under "cover of darkness", they dig up ancient graves in Syria's ancient city of Palmyra, searching for historic booty. Once the treasures are "out of the ground", they "make their way online", and Facebook has "emerged as a key hub" for their sale, with public and private groups offering "ancient coins, entire mosaics and heavy stone busts" to the "highest bidder". In one post on Facebook, "a user offered a pile of ancient coins for sale", writing, "I have been holding them for 15 years, Free Syria." In a video "shared in a Facebook group in March", a man with a Syrian accent displays "a mosaic depicting Zeus on a throne, using his mobile phone for scale". "This is the fastest we've ever seen artefacts being sold," said ATHAR's Paul. It used to take a year to sell a mosaic but now they can go in just two weeks. In response, ATHAR is tracking the route of trafficked Middle Eastern antiquities online and building a database of more than 26,000 screenshots, videos, and pictures. But the team wants more help from Facebook. In 2020, the social media behemoth banned the sale of historical antiquities on its platform but Paul says the policy is rarely enforced. So it continues to be used as a "gateway for traffickers", linking "low-level looters" in Syria to "criminal networks" that smuggle the artefacts out of the country and ship them "around the world to create fake bills of sale and provenance". After 10 to 15 years, the treasures make their way into legal auction houses, where collectors and museums, mostly in the US and Europe, "snap them up".
Yahoo
8 hours ago
- Yahoo
Karen Read trial nears its finale: What each side is banking on
With closing arguments scheduled for Friday morning, jurors will soon begin deliberating Karen Read's fate after 31 days of testimony in her second trial over the death of Boston cop John O'Keefe, her former boyfriend. Read, 45, is accused of clipping the 46-year-old outside a house party and leaving him to die on the ground during a blizzard on Jan. 29, 2022. Her defense denies that a collision ever happened, suggesting he was attacked by someone at the party and a dog instead. Judge Beverly Cannone denied the defense's second motion for a finding of not guilty Thursday – clearing the way for deliberations to begin. The following includes core evidence presented by both the prosecution and the defense. Karen Read Announces She Will Not Testify In Her Defense As Massachusetts Trial Nears Conclusion Taillight fragments in O'Keefe's clothes Experts say a glancing vehicle strike caused O'Keefe to fall on the back of his head Phone data aligns with prosecution timeline Read's alleged, repeated statements, "I hit him. I hit him. I hit him." Read's many public statements played in court Karen Read Murder Trial Reaches Final Stage With Closing Arguments Set For Friday Read On The Fox News App Former Whitey Bulger defense lawyer turned special prosecutor Hank Brennan, derided as a "mob lawyer" by Read's vocal supporters, came in to take over the case after last year's mistrial. Assistant Norfolk County District Attorneys Adam Lally and Laura McLaughlin returned from the first trial. Central to Brennan's case is that O'Keefe had plastic fragments that matched Read's taillight embedded in his clothes. Dr. Aizik Wolf, a renowned brain surgeon, said O'Keefe's injury is consistent with a "classic" fall backward on frozen ground. And a biomechanist named Dr. Judson Welcher testified that Read likely hit him with a glancing blow to the right arm and sent him stumbling backward before he cracked his head on the lawn at 34 Fairview Road in Canton, where he was found under a pile of snow hours later. Follow The Fox True Crime Team On X Final Defense Witness In Karen Read Trial Pumps Brakes On Lexus Collision Theory And in Read's own alleged words, she repeatedly said, "I hit him. I hit him. I hit him." The timing of Jennifer McCabe's Google search – "hos long to die in cold" – is another key factor, according to Paul Mauro, a retired NYPD inspector who is following the case. "If at 6:23 a.m., it corroborates Jen McCabe's testimony," he told Fox News Digital. "If you believe Jen McCabe, you pretty much have to convict. You could perhaps acquit on the top charge, but certainly you would have to convict on the manslaughter." Read asserts the crash never happened The Bowden defense – investigation was too sloppy to be adequate, and the lead detective got fired Experts say dog bites caused arm injuries, head injury did not happen on lawn and no signs of hypothermia Brennan's reference to holes in O'Keefe's hoodie that were put there by crime lab Sign Up To Get The True Crime Newsletter Read's legal team includes big-city lawyers from three states – Boston's David Yannetti, New York City's Robert Alessi, and Alan Jackson and Elizabeth Little from Los Angeles. In her first trial, Yannetti and Jackson argued that Read had been "framed" by local and state police. This time around, they focused on the theory that Read's 2021 Lexus LX 570 SUV never struck O'Keefe. They also deployed a "Bowden defense" – attempting to show the police investigation was "inadequate." Investigators collected evidence in red Solo cups and shopping bags, used a leaf blower to move snow, mislabeled evidence and did not seek a search warrant for the house at the address where they recovered O'Keefe's remains. Former Massachusetts State Trooper Michael Proctor, a homicide detective on the case, later lost his job for sharing confidential and law enforcement sensitive information on an R-rated text chain that also included lewd remarks about the defendant. GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE True Crime Hub Defense experts testified that the minor abrasions on O'Keefe's right arm were not caused by contact with Read's broken taillight, but rather by dog or animal bites. Dr. Daniel Wolfe and Dr. Andrew Rentschler disputed Welcher's findings with testing of their own, using a crash dummy arm that they said could not reproduce the same damage to a Lexus taillight. The blow to the back of his head – which fractured his skull – did not come from contact on the frozen lawn, but rather by contact with a ridged, grainy surface, according to Dr. Elizabeth Laposata, a forensic pathologist and clinical professor at Brown University. Laposata also disputed autopsy findings that indicated O'Keefe had hypothermia – testifying that his internal injuries came from resuscitation attempts and not damage from the cold. "The defense case is science, science and then more science," said Mark Bederow, a New York City attorney representing Read ally and Canton blogger Aidan Kearney. "No car accident, then no crime." Read faces 15 years to life in prison if convicted on the top charge. If convicted of drunken driving manslaughter, she would face 5 to article source: Karen Read trial nears its finale: What each side is banking on
