'Underclass of Australians': youth crime laws slammed
Australia has come under fire again for breaching its human rights obligations to children amid a national crackdown on youth crime.
The United Nations has criticised the Queensland government's latest round of "adult crime, adult time" laws, saying they threaten to create an "underclass of Australians".
Queensland plans to bolster its youth crime laws, with 20 more offences to carry lengthy sentences.
New offences include sexual assault and rape, attempt to murder, kidnapping, arson and attempted robbery.
A national crackdown on juvenile offenders came under the spotlight when Queensland's Liberal National government quickly passed "adult crime, adult time" laws after its election win in 2024.
They ensured children as young as 10 can serve a life sentence for murder and manslaughter, while prison time for offences such as grievous bodily harm doubled.
It came after several serious crimes, including a teenager who was charged with attempted murder following the alleged stabbing attack on a supermarket worker in Ipswich.
The United Nations criticised the state government for the controversial laws at the time, calling it a "flagrant disregard" for children's human rights.
The LNP government also earned the ire of advocates over the laws because of concerns the state's youth justice system would be overwhelmed.
Queensland locks up more children than any other jurisdiction, according to a report by the state's Child Death Review.
But the LNP government has rolled out the second tranche of youth crime laws, sparking more outrage.
The laws disproportionately impact Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, international human rights experts say.
"Children are suffering undue harm to their safety and well-being, as well as to their educational and life prospects as a result of short-sighted approaches to youth criminality and detention," the United Nations' Alice Jill Edwards and Albert K Barume said.
The two UN human rights experts have written a letter to Australian authorities expressing concerns about the expansion of Queensland's "adult crime, adult time" laws.
They said the amended laws would harm the lives of Aboriginal children and urged members of the state parliament to vote against the bill.
"The first goal should always be keeping children out of prison," the experts said.
"We are extremely concerned that present approaches are creating a future underclass of Australians."
Other states and territories have focused on youth crime amid Queensland's crackdown.
The Northern Territory is strengthening its bail laws following the fatal stabbing of a 71-year-old Darwin store owner allegedly at the hands of a teenager.
Victoria recently removed remand as a last resort for children while NSW made it harder for 14 to 18-year-olds to be released on serious charges while out on bail for similar offences.
The UN experts said Australia might be violating its international obligations to children with Queensland's harsh criminal laws and the nation's criminal age of responsibility, which is 10 in the Sunshine State and the Northern Territory and 14 in other states.
Australia has come under fire again for breaching its human rights obligations to children amid a national crackdown on youth crime.
The United Nations has criticised the Queensland government's latest round of "adult crime, adult time" laws, saying they threaten to create an "underclass of Australians".
Queensland plans to bolster its youth crime laws, with 20 more offences to carry lengthy sentences.
New offences include sexual assault and rape, attempt to murder, kidnapping, arson and attempted robbery.
A national crackdown on juvenile offenders came under the spotlight when Queensland's Liberal National government quickly passed "adult crime, adult time" laws after its election win in 2024.
They ensured children as young as 10 can serve a life sentence for murder and manslaughter, while prison time for offences such as grievous bodily harm doubled.
It came after several serious crimes, including a teenager who was charged with attempted murder following the alleged stabbing attack on a supermarket worker in Ipswich.
The United Nations criticised the state government for the controversial laws at the time, calling it a "flagrant disregard" for children's human rights.
The LNP government also earned the ire of advocates over the laws because of concerns the state's youth justice system would be overwhelmed.
Queensland locks up more children than any other jurisdiction, according to a report by the state's Child Death Review.
But the LNP government has rolled out the second tranche of youth crime laws, sparking more outrage.
The laws disproportionately impact Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, international human rights experts say.
"Children are suffering undue harm to their safety and well-being, as well as to their educational and life prospects as a result of short-sighted approaches to youth criminality and detention," the United Nations' Alice Jill Edwards and Albert K Barume said.
The two UN human rights experts have written a letter to Australian authorities expressing concerns about the expansion of Queensland's "adult crime, adult time" laws.
They said the amended laws would harm the lives of Aboriginal children and urged members of the state parliament to vote against the bill.
"The first goal should always be keeping children out of prison," the experts said.
"We are extremely concerned that present approaches are creating a future underclass of Australians."
Other states and territories have focused on youth crime amid Queensland's crackdown.
The Northern Territory is strengthening its bail laws following the fatal stabbing of a 71-year-old Darwin store owner allegedly at the hands of a teenager.
Victoria recently removed remand as a last resort for children while NSW made it harder for 14 to 18-year-olds to be released on serious charges while out on bail for similar offences.
The UN experts said Australia might be violating its international obligations to children with Queensland's harsh criminal laws and the nation's criminal age of responsibility, which is 10 in the Sunshine State and the Northern Territory and 14 in other states.
Australia has come under fire again for breaching its human rights obligations to children amid a national crackdown on youth crime.
The United Nations has criticised the Queensland government's latest round of "adult crime, adult time" laws, saying they threaten to create an "underclass of Australians".
Queensland plans to bolster its youth crime laws, with 20 more offences to carry lengthy sentences.
New offences include sexual assault and rape, attempt to murder, kidnapping, arson and attempted robbery.
A national crackdown on juvenile offenders came under the spotlight when Queensland's Liberal National government quickly passed "adult crime, adult time" laws after its election win in 2024.
They ensured children as young as 10 can serve a life sentence for murder and manslaughter, while prison time for offences such as grievous bodily harm doubled.
It came after several serious crimes, including a teenager who was charged with attempted murder following the alleged stabbing attack on a supermarket worker in Ipswich.
The United Nations criticised the state government for the controversial laws at the time, calling it a "flagrant disregard" for children's human rights.
The LNP government also earned the ire of advocates over the laws because of concerns the state's youth justice system would be overwhelmed.
Queensland locks up more children than any other jurisdiction, according to a report by the state's Child Death Review.
But the LNP government has rolled out the second tranche of youth crime laws, sparking more outrage.
The laws disproportionately impact Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, international human rights experts say.
"Children are suffering undue harm to their safety and well-being, as well as to their educational and life prospects as a result of short-sighted approaches to youth criminality and detention," the United Nations' Alice Jill Edwards and Albert K Barume said.
The two UN human rights experts have written a letter to Australian authorities expressing concerns about the expansion of Queensland's "adult crime, adult time" laws.
They said the amended laws would harm the lives of Aboriginal children and urged members of the state parliament to vote against the bill.
"The first goal should always be keeping children out of prison," the experts said.
"We are extremely concerned that present approaches are creating a future underclass of Australians."
Other states and territories have focused on youth crime amid Queensland's crackdown.
The Northern Territory is strengthening its bail laws following the fatal stabbing of a 71-year-old Darwin store owner allegedly at the hands of a teenager.
Victoria recently removed remand as a last resort for children while NSW made it harder for 14 to 18-year-olds to be released on serious charges while out on bail for similar offences.
The UN experts said Australia might be violating its international obligations to children with Queensland's harsh criminal laws and the nation's criminal age of responsibility, which is 10 in the Sunshine State and the Northern Territory and 14 in other states.
Australia has come under fire again for breaching its human rights obligations to children amid a national crackdown on youth crime.
The United Nations has criticised the Queensland government's latest round of "adult crime, adult time" laws, saying they threaten to create an "underclass of Australians".
Queensland plans to bolster its youth crime laws, with 20 more offences to carry lengthy sentences.
New offences include sexual assault and rape, attempt to murder, kidnapping, arson and attempted robbery.
A national crackdown on juvenile offenders came under the spotlight when Queensland's Liberal National government quickly passed "adult crime, adult time" laws after its election win in 2024.
They ensured children as young as 10 can serve a life sentence for murder and manslaughter, while prison time for offences such as grievous bodily harm doubled.
It came after several serious crimes, including a teenager who was charged with attempted murder following the alleged stabbing attack on a supermarket worker in Ipswich.
The United Nations criticised the state government for the controversial laws at the time, calling it a "flagrant disregard" for children's human rights.
The LNP government also earned the ire of advocates over the laws because of concerns the state's youth justice system would be overwhelmed.
Queensland locks up more children than any other jurisdiction, according to a report by the state's Child Death Review.
But the LNP government has rolled out the second tranche of youth crime laws, sparking more outrage.
The laws disproportionately impact Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander children, international human rights experts say.
"Children are suffering undue harm to their safety and well-being, as well as to their educational and life prospects as a result of short-sighted approaches to youth criminality and detention," the United Nations' Alice Jill Edwards and Albert K Barume said.
The two UN human rights experts have written a letter to Australian authorities expressing concerns about the expansion of Queensland's "adult crime, adult time" laws.
They said the amended laws would harm the lives of Aboriginal children and urged members of the state parliament to vote against the bill.
"The first goal should always be keeping children out of prison," the experts said.
"We are extremely concerned that present approaches are creating a future underclass of Australians."
Other states and territories have focused on youth crime amid Queensland's crackdown.
The Northern Territory is strengthening its bail laws following the fatal stabbing of a 71-year-old Darwin store owner allegedly at the hands of a teenager.
Victoria recently removed remand as a last resort for children while NSW made it harder for 14 to 18-year-olds to be released on serious charges while out on bail for similar offences.
The UN experts said Australia might be violating its international obligations to children with Queensland's harsh criminal laws and the nation's criminal age of responsibility, which is 10 in the Sunshine State and the Northern Territory and 14 in other states.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
37 minutes ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
‘Betrayal': NSW to cut battery subsidies as federal scheme kicks in
The NSW government will end its incentive to install a home solar battery from July in favour of an enhanced Commonwealth scheme, and use the savings to encourage households to allow their stored energy to be remotely accessed by the grid. Since last November, NSW consumers have been able to access a rebate of up to $2600 (depending on the size of the battery) to attach storage to their rooftop solar systems. The scheme resulted in 11,400 battery installations across the state in six months. The program will conclude at the end of this month, while the Australian government's $2.3 billion Cheaper Home Batteries Program is set to start on July 1. The federal rebate, announced before the election, will reduce the cost of a battery by about 30 per cent, making it about double the size of the state scheme. Heidi Lee Douglas, chief executive of consumer advocacy group Solar Citizens, said the NSW government had betrayed solar households with its decision and put its legislated net zero targets further out of reach. The NSW Net Zero Commission has warned that NSW would not reach its emissions reduction targets from 2030 to 2050. 'This surprise decision is a blow to solar home owners planning to buy a home battery in coming months, and a betrayal of the prime minister and Federal Minister for Climate and Energy Chris Bowen's assurance that the federal Cheaper Home Batteries program can be 'stacked' with state initiatives,' Douglas said. 'This bizarre decision puts the timely closure of the Eraring coal-fired power plant at risk. A key justification for extending the life of the plant was the lack of energy storage. The Commonwealth stepped in by boosting battery rebates further and now the NSW government is making that transition harder.' The NSW government said the money would remain within its Peak Demand Reduction Scheme, a program designed to reduce electricity demand during peak periods. The government would redirect the funds to double the payments to encourage solar households to sign up to a virtual power plant (VPP) – a group of solar-powered batteries linked by software, which are owned by households and small businesses that have consented for excess stored power to be sold to the grid. Industry support
West Australian
an hour ago
- West Australian
Crocodile Hunter's dad fires up over culling proposal
The father of Crocodile Hunter Steve Irwin has hit out at calls for the large reptiles to be culled in popular waterways, describing it as pointless. Bob Irwin took aim at proposed Queensland laws that would result in crocodiles found in populated sites being killed or relocated. Katter's Australian Party put forward the bill under a long-running campaign to enhance crocodile control laws, claiming numbers had "exploded" in the state's north. Queensland's Liberal National government said it would consider the findings of a parliamentary hearing into the bill and decide whether it was "fit for purpose". Mr Irwin says killing or removing crocodiles is not the answer. "Culling crocodiles is a pointless exercise, absolutely pointless," he told the hearing on Wednesday The Katter party renewed calls for crocodile control after a failed bid under the former Labor government. The bill would allow crocodile culls and safari-style hunting trips, amid claims more than 1200 crocodiles had been spotted in 2023 compared to 126 in 2010. Mr Irwin said if a large crocodile that protected a territory was removed or killed, a "juvenile delinquent" moved in and took over. "You're never going to be able to say to the general public you can swim in that river now, because you won't ever know that there are crocodiles still there," he told the hearing. Mr Irwin helped found Australia Zoo where his son grew up and developed a passion for wildlife, later becoming the world famous Crocodile Hunter before the livewire conservationist's tragic 2006 death. His daughter-in-law Terri Irwin had earlier echoed his concerns in a submission to the committee, saying the proposed laws would increase the likelihood of croc attacks due to a false sense of security in culled areas. The Queensland environment department's deputy director general said education was paramount in preventing crocodile attacks, not culling. "No amount of crocodile removal can guarantee the absence of crocodiles in a waterway, nor can it assure that an area is completely safe to swim," Ben Klaassen told the committee on Wednesday. Some community members threw their support behind the bill, with one group suggesting Aboriginal people should assist crocodile culls. Murrandoo Yanner won a landmark 1999 High Court case that ruled Aboriginal people could hunt crocodiles. He said Aboriginal people in Queensland's Gulf Country were hunting crocodiles and maintaining the population, so there was "no greater group" to aid a pilot culling program. "We hunt and eat them, but we're not in that camp that we just want to totally cull them," the Carpentaria Land Council Aboriginal Corporation stakeholder officer told the committee. "But we also know they're of great cultural significance, and they're in good numbers here, so we manage them very well." Recent estimates reveal there are around 20,000 to 30,000 crocodiles across northern Queensland. Mr Yanner hoped to work with the state government, advising how to cull crocodiles without eradicating the species. Two councils in the state's north, Mareeba and Whitsundays, also want the bill become a reality, saying there was a risk to residents and tourists. Mareeba Shire Council deputy mayor Lenore Wyatt said dozens of saltwater crocs in eastern waterways were not native after some escaped from a nearby farm in the 1990s. The area is already zoned to allow the removal of crocodiles, but the council wanted a faster process, saying a farmer had a reptile in his dam for more than six months. The committee report is due in August.
Perth Now
an hour ago
- Perth Now
Crocodile Hunter's dad fires up over culling proposal
The father of Crocodile Hunter Steve Irwin has hit out at calls for the large reptiles to be culled in popular waterways, describing it as pointless. Bob Irwin took aim at proposed Queensland laws that would result in crocodiles found in populated sites being killed or relocated. Katter's Australian Party put forward the bill under a long-running campaign to enhance crocodile control laws, claiming numbers had "exploded" in the state's north. Queensland's Liberal National government said it would consider the findings of a parliamentary hearing into the bill and decide whether it was "fit for purpose". Mr Irwin says killing or removing crocodiles is not the answer. "Culling crocodiles is a pointless exercise, absolutely pointless," he told the hearing on Wednesday The Katter party renewed calls for crocodile control after a failed bid under the former Labor government. The bill would allow crocodile culls and safari-style hunting trips, amid claims more than 1200 crocodiles had been spotted in 2023 compared to 126 in 2010. Mr Irwin said if a large crocodile that protected a territory was removed or killed, a "juvenile delinquent" moved in and took over. "You're never going to be able to say to the general public you can swim in that river now, because you won't ever know that there are crocodiles still there," he told the hearing. Mr Irwin helped found Australia Zoo where his son grew up and developed a passion for wildlife, later becoming the world famous Crocodile Hunter before the livewire conservationist's tragic 2006 death. His daughter-in-law Terri Irwin had earlier echoed his concerns in a submission to the committee, saying the proposed laws would increase the likelihood of croc attacks due to a false sense of security in culled areas. The Queensland environment department's deputy director general said education was paramount in preventing crocodile attacks, not culling. "No amount of crocodile removal can guarantee the absence of crocodiles in a waterway, nor can it assure that an area is completely safe to swim," Ben Klaassen told the committee on Wednesday. Some community members threw their support behind the bill, with one group suggesting Aboriginal people should assist crocodile culls. Murrandoo Yanner won a landmark 1999 High Court case that ruled Aboriginal people could hunt crocodiles. He said Aboriginal people in Queensland's Gulf Country were hunting crocodiles and maintaining the population, so there was "no greater group" to aid a pilot culling program. "We hunt and eat them, but we're not in that camp that we just want to totally cull them," the Carpentaria Land Council Aboriginal Corporation stakeholder officer told the committee. "But we also know they're of great cultural significance, and they're in good numbers here, so we manage them very well." Recent estimates reveal there are around 20,000 to 30,000 crocodiles across northern Queensland. Mr Yanner hoped to work with the state government, advising how to cull crocodiles without eradicating the species. Two councils in the state's north, Mareeba and Whitsundays, also want the bill become a reality, saying there was a risk to residents and tourists. Mareeba Shire Council deputy mayor Lenore Wyatt said dozens of saltwater crocs in eastern waterways were not native after some escaped from a nearby farm in the 1990s. The area is already zoned to allow the removal of crocodiles, but the council wanted a faster process, saying a farmer had a reptile in his dam for more than six months. The committee report is due in August.
