Portobello parents react positively over mobile phone pilot scheme
Parents and carers at Portobello High School have said they are optimistic about a new pilot scheme that keeps students off mobile phones during the school day.
The school is the first in Scotland to have pupils lock their phones in magnetic pouches for the duration of the school day.
Edinburgh Council hopes that it will see students focus more on their schoolwork, avoiding the distractions phones can cause in the classroom.
David Fraser, the parent of a S4 pupil at the school, says he has no issue with trying it out – but wants to see how well it works before passing judgement.
The 51-year-old Scottish Government worker told the Local Democracy Reporting Service: 'I'm of the opinion that better behaviour comes from better parents and kids. There's a lot of common sense that can be applied to this stuff.
'I personally have no issue with trying this. I'd hate to be a teacher these days, and anything we can do to help teachers, help quiet the classroom down is good.
'If it's disruptive kids and it's caused by phones and all, go for it. Let's try it. We'll give it a bash.
'I'm a firm believer that it needs to be given a trial, at least to see if it works or not.
'I'm not supportive of it, I'm not non supportive of it. I'll see what the proof in the pudding is first before we make any decisions.
'It took the kids by surprise, it took all of us by surprise.'
The magnetic pouches were distributed to families the week before the bank holiday weekend, with all pupils carrying mobiles required to use them.
Parents could make a voluntary payment towards the scheme, but the pouches were distributed to families whether they contributed financially towards it or not.
Fraser said his daughter, who is in S3, said some students were having trouble using the pouches, which he compared to the magnetic locks on alcohol bottles in supermarkets.
Another parent, Sirin, said she was supportive of the scheme.
The mother of an S4 pupil said: 'I think it's a good idea. It'll help them focus, it'll help them learn, be more social.
'They won't be tapping away at their phones all the time.'
And, some parents and carers hope that the scheme can help reduce some other harms from social media.
Jackie, the grandmother of an S3 pupil, said: 'It'll take the kids a while to get used to it, but once they're used to it it'll be good.
'There's too much bullying on social media with the kids nowadays. In the context of everything that's going on, they're all snapchatting one another. That'll stop that.
'I think it'll take a while to kick in with the kids, but I think it'll work.'
Queensferry High School will join Portobello in introducing the pouches on Wednesday, 14 May.
The scheme will run as a trial for two years, with officials watching feedback from parents and pupils and monitoring attendance figures and other data points to understand its impact.
Labour councillor Joan Griffiths, convener of the Education, Children and Families committee, said: 'I'm pleased to see Edinburgh schools leading the way in introducing a mobile-phone free school environment.
'Mobile phones in classroom settings are increasingly competing with the teachers for learners' attention and limiting access to mobile phones during the school day is only a positive thing for our young people.
'I know that schools across Edinburgh, and indeed the country, are exploring ways to manage mobile phone use, including restricting phone use during the school day.
'The new pouches provide an innovative way for our young people to have distance from their devices while having the reassurance that they are still in their possession.
'We hope that this new policy will increase focus on learning, reduce classroom distractions and help improve wellbeing.'
By Joseph Sullivan Local Democracy Reporter
Like this:
Like
Related
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scotsman
2 hours ago
- Scotsman
Almost half of over 50s are experiencing loneliness
Almost half of over 50s in Scotland experience loneliness some or all of the time, according to new research by Age Scotland. Sign up to our daily newsletter – Regular news stories and round-ups from around Scotland direct to your inbox Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... The survey also highlights crippling loneliness among carers, with 41% saying they felt lonely some or all of the time. To mark Loneliness Awareness Week, the Scottish charity for older people has published On Every Street - a report which shows the extent of loneliness among older people, with figures revealing that there is at least one chronically lonely older person living on every street in the country. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Anne, 60, from Glasgow was a carer for her mum and mother-in-law over the last 10 years. Anne, 60, experienced acute loneliness as an unpaid carer to her Mum 'Being a dementia carer was very isolating. I gave up my career in financial services to be a full-time carer for my mum and moved into her house. 'It's been a very lonely journey no matter who is around you physically and my husband and I feel very broken emotionally and physically.' Alex, 71, from Motherwell, also features in the report. He said: 'I've lived on my own since I came back to Scotland. I don't have any family or friends around now. The reality is that so many people fall away from your life as you get older. And before you know it, you're on your own. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'I put the TV on in the corner, but it's really just to stop the silence.' Alex, 71, says his Friendship Call from Age Scotland helps him feel less lonely The charity believes that if Scotland is to meet the needs of an ageing population, more investment is needed to tackle loneliness levels otherwise the health of the nation could be severely impacted. Katherine Crawford, chief executive at Age Scotland, said: 'Scotland is in the grip of an epidemic of loneliness with chronic levels of loneliness not going anywhere. 'It is heartbreaking to think that the equivalent of one older person on every street in Scotland feels lonely all or most of the time. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Our new report On Every Street lays bare the stories and people behind this shocking statistic and hears their deeply personal experiences of feeling locked out and lonely. 'Our helpline hears from people who have become lonely because they are trying to manage several contributing factors like, caring responsibilities, the rise in the cost of living or a disability. Loneliness can have a huge impact on someone's health, increasing the risk of heart disease, stroke and dementia, as well as contributing to significant mental health challenges. 'We are calling for the Scottish Government, local authorities, funders, politicians, and other partners to ramp up action and commit to renewed investment to support community groups with the resources and support they need to keep communities connected – without them the country faces a worse crisis of social isolation.'
Scotsman
5 hours ago
- Scotsman
Poem found in a box of junk written by 'titantic' Scots literary figure
Sign up to our History and Heritage newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... A forgotten manuscript written by a 'titanic figure' of the Scottish Enlightenment has been discovered in an old box of junk during a house clearance. The document was written by Edinburgh poet Allan Ramsay in 1719, with the manuscript , a mix of letter and verse, previously unknown. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The poem, called Address to the Town-Council of Edinburgh, sets out Ramsay's plea to Edinburgh City Council to act to prevent the pirating of his works. The verse was later published by Ramsay, but it is now believed that the newly- discovered document may have been part of the original sent to the city council as the poet sought protection for his song and verse, which were becoming popular at the time. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It is addressed to the Right Honourable William Neilson Esquire, Lord Provost, and others. Tommy Alexander, a valuer at Great Western Auctions, where the manuscripts will be sold next week, spent months researching the poem after contacting Scottish universities and literary organisations. He said: 'Prior to now, no manuscript copy of Allan Ramsay's Address to the Town-Council of Edinburgh was known to exist. 'This significant literary historical discovery sheds new light on his compositional process, as in the seventh line of the poem we can see Ramsay revising his original word choice, which is unrecorded to now. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'Ramsay penned the address as an appeal to the City Council, that they legislate against the pirating of his works. 'This they duly did, decreeing that vendors of Ramsay's verse were to retain only one third of their profits, with the majority share payable to Ramsay.' Were this to be flouted, the vendor was liable to be fined 20 pounds, have their stock confiscated and their licence for future trade revoked. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Mr Alexander added: 'Of interest here is the format in which Ramsay presents his poem, that of a letter literally addressed to named members of the Council. It may be the case that it was the receipt of this very document that prompted their intervention.' Mr Alexander described Ramsay, who is regarded as a major influence on Robert Burns, as a 'titanic' figure in the early Scottish Enlightenment. 'As a poet and playwright, as well as a collector of verse, he did much to crystallize the Scottish literary tradition. His influence can be strongly felt through the work of subsequent writers, among them Burns, Fergusson and Scott,' he added. The manuscript, which was found in a box of 'miscelleaneous ephemera', runs to only the fourteenth line of the poem - "In Rags wi' bluther'd Face". Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'We assume therefore that this is the first of numerous pages, with the remainder lost,' Mr Alexander added. The manuscript is expected to fetch between £800 and £1,200 when it comes up for auction at the GWA Summer Fine Art & Antiques Action on Friday and Saturday. Other lots at the sale include the painting Crucifixion by renowned Australian artist Roy De Maistre, who has been described as Francis Bacon's 'most important artistic contact in the 1930s'. The painting, which once hung in Iona Abbey, is expected to fetch between £10,000 and £15,000. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad It is believed the painting was bought directly by The Iona Community from the artist.
South Wales Guardian
9 hours ago
- South Wales Guardian
Government should auto-enrol eligible pupils for free school meals
There is variation in free school meal registration practices across England, research by the Education Policy Institute (EPI) has suggested. It comes after ministers set out plans to expand free school meals to all pupils in England from families on universal credit. Currently, households in England on universal credit must earn below £7,400 a year (after tax and not including benefits) to qualify for free school meals. The expansion of free school meals to all pupils in families on universal credit from September 2026 will make 500,000 more children eligible for free lunches, the Government has said. Parents currently have to apply for their children to receive free school meals and eligible children are not automatically enrolled. The paper, funded by The Nuffield Foundation, calls on the Government to introduce a national auto-enrolment scheme to ensure all eligible families are registered for free school meals. It said: 'Despite this expansion in FSM (free school meals) eligibility, without further action from the Government, children may continue to miss out on the free meals they are entitled to. 'The barriers to registration and differences in registration practices across LAs means children still face inequalities in access to free meals.' The report added: 'In terms of barriers families face in applying to FSM – including English as an additional language, stigma, confusion about eligibility – auto-enrolment would largely eradicate these issues.' Despite efforts to boost registration, language barriers and a lack of digital access are preventing the meals reaching children that need them, it said. An additional 77,700 children became eligible for free school meals in the past year, according to recent data published by the Department for Education. More than one in four (25.7%) pupils in England were eligible for free school meals in January, the equivalent of 2.17 million children – up from 24.6%, or 2.09 million, in January 2024. But the report from EPI – which is based on surveys and interviews with local authorities and multi-academy trusts in 2024 and early 2025 – found where a child lives or goes to school determines how hard it is for families to register for free school meals. In some local authorities, parents are required to make their own application while facing significant barriers and if found ineligible at the time must reapply when circumstances change. While in others, they use local auto-enrolment to proactively identify entitled children without relying on parents sharing details or making an application. The report also found that some children who attend maintained nurseries before and after lunch are missing out on free meals to which they are entitled. Dr Kerris Cooper, senior researcher for early years and inequalities at EPI, said: 'Our research shows that while the extension of free school meal eligibility is a very positive step, more needs to be done to ensure that all children entitled to free meals can actually access them. 'First, there are still significant barriers for families to register for FSM, and where a child lives plays too big a role in their chances of being registered. 'Second, the youngest children, who face the highest risk of poverty, will not benefit from this expansion in eligibility unless all children attending early education are also included and settings are supported to deliver this. 'Introducing national auto-enrolment and including children in early education would enable this expansion in FSM eligibility to more meaningfully extend access to more children in poverty.' Pepe Di'Iasio, general secretary of the Association of School and College Leaders (ASCL), said: 'The expansion of free school meals, to include all children in households on universal credit, is a positive move that recognises there are children living in poverty who have been missing out. 'Moving to a national system of auto-enrolment would be the next logical step to ensure that everyone who is now eligible under the new criteria will actually receive a meal and the intended benefits.' He added: 'We see no reason why a national system of auto-enrolment cannot be established relatively straightforwardly. 'This is something that would make a big difference to vulnerable families.' Last week, education minister Stephen Morgan told MPs in the Commons that the Government would be working to make it easier for people to apply. He said the announcement on expanding free school meals was a 'significant, straightforward process for parents to know whether they are eligible'. A Department for Education spokesperson said: 'Through our Plan for Change, this government has taken a historic step to tackle the stain of child poverty and spread opportunity – extending free school meal eligibility to all children in households on Universal Credit. 'This means over half a million more children will be able to access free meals from the 2026 school year, lifting 100,000 children completely out of poverty – and we will launch an upgraded eligibility checking tool next year to make it simpler than ever for parents to see if they can benefit. 'This forms part of our wider plan to put money back in the pockets of working families – with parents also set to benefit from our free breakfast club rollout and school uniform cost cap, helping them save up to £500 a year.'
