Team Canada sexual assault case: Defence ridicules ‘useless' witness as trial spirals into courtroom chaos
Defence calls witness 'useless' in the Hockey Canada sexual assault case (TSN/Twitter)
The sexual assault trial involving five former members of Canada's 2018 World Junior hockey team took another dramatic turn on Day 16, as the defence sharply criticized Crown witness Brett Howden, calling him 'generally useless' following a day of conflicting testimony.
Howden, who now plays for the Vegas Golden Knights, was under scrutiny for inconsistencies in his statements surrounding an alleged group sexual assault that took place in London, Ontario.
Defence calls witness 'useless' as Brett Howden's memory questioned in
Team Canada sexual assault trial
Justice Maria Carroccia ruled that although Howden's testimony revealed some contradictions, there was no evidence he was intentionally misleading the court or pretending to forget. 'In my view at this stage, I cannot find that Mr.
Howden is feigning lack of memory or is being insincere about whether he has a recollection of his earlier statements or particulars of the events he's asked to describe,' Carroccia said.
The decision followed an application by Crown attorney Meaghan Cunningham to cross-examine Howden under Section 9(2) of the Canada Evidence Act. The Crown highlighted 18 areas where his testimony had allegedly shifted, but Justice Carroccia found only four to be materially inconsistent.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Buy Brass Idols - Handmade Brass Statues for Home & Gifting
Luxeartisanship
Buy Now
Undo
Still, she stopped short of allowing cross-examination, deferring that decision for now.
In a striking moment, Carter Hart's defence attorney, Megan Savard, launched a scathing critique of Howden's credibility and demeanor. 'The witness is plainly unsophisticated. He didn't come to court dressed for court [he had messy hair and was wearing a brown hoodie]. He is inarticulate and a poor communicator... I would say, if anything, we may all say at the end of the day, this witness is generally useless,' she said.
Also Read:
Is $96M Mikko Rantanen just a playoff fraud? — Stars fans furious after Game 5 no-show
The trial centers on allegations that Michael McLeod, Dillon Dube, Alex Formenton, Carter Hart, and Callan Foote sexually assaulted a woman in a hotel room during the early hours of June 19, 2018, following a Hockey Canada event. McLeod faces an additional charge of being a party to the offence. All five players have pleaded not guilty. The case continues to unfold as the court navigates witness testimony and legal maneuvering.
Get
IPL 2025
match
schedules
,
squads
,
points table
, and live scores for
CSK
,
MI
,
RCB
,
KKR
,
SRH
,
LSG
,
DC
,
GT
,
PBKS
, and
RR
. Check the latest
IPL Orange Cap
and
Purple Cap
standings.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Mahmoud Khalil deportation case: Federal judge orders release of Palestinian activist; govt given till Friday to appeal
Federal judge blocks Trump administration from continuing to detain Palestinian activist Mahmoud Khalil A federal judge on Wednesday ruled that Mahmoud Khalil, a legal US resident and former graduate student at Columbia University, must be released from immigration detention. Khalil was detained in March following his participation in campus pro-Palestinian demonstrations against Israel's military action in Gaza. Judge Michael Farbiarz said that Khalil's continued detention is causing him 'irreparable harm,' citing damage to his career, personal life and free speech rights. 'The Court finds as a matter of fact that the Petitioner's career and reputation are being damaged and his speech is being chilled — and this adds up to irreparable harm,' the judge wrote in his ruling. Despite the decision, Khalil will remain in custody until at least 9:30 am Friday, allowing the US government time to file an appeal. He has also been asked to post a $1 bond before being released. Arrest and detention Khalil was arrested on March 8 in the lobby of his university-owned residence. He was the first person to be detained under a Trump administration crackdown targeting international students involved in Gaza protests. Khalil is married to a US citizen and recently became a father. After his arrest, Khalil was moved across the country to a detention facility in Jena, Louisiana, far from his lawyers and family. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 10 Signs Your Dog Loves You More Than Anything Liseer Read More Undo His legal team, led by the City University of New York's CLEAR project, challenged the detention as unconstitutional. 'The court's decision is the most significant vindication yet of Mahmoud's rights,' said Ramzi Kassem, co-director of CLEAR. 'But we aren't out of the woods until Mahmoud is free and back home with his wife and child," they added. Legal arguments Judge Farbiarz previously said that efforts to expel Khalil based on foreign policy concerns were 'likely unconstitutional.' The government has argued that Khalil's presence could harm US foreign policy. US secretary of state Marco Rubio invoked that statute to justify the deportation, saying Khalil's activism poses 'potentially serious adverse foreign policy consequences for the United States.' Khalil says he did nothing wrong and did not hide anything on his green card application. He told the court he only did a university-approved internship with the United Nations Relief and Works Agency, and was not an officer, as the government claims. In court filings, Khalil said the government's actions had already affected his career, with Oxfam International withdrawing a job offer due to the controversy. He also said the experience had discouraged him from engaging in future activism. No criminal charges, growing list of released activists Khalil was not arrested during the Columbia protests and has not been accused of any crimes. His public presence at the demonstrations drew attention from critics and the White House, which accused him of 'siding with terrorists' without providing evidence. He had served as a negotiator and spokesperson for student protesters who camped on campus. Columbia University later called in police to clear the encampment after a building was occupied, though Khalil was not involved in that action. Other legal residents detained for similar activism have recently been released, including students from Tufts, Georgetown and a Palestinian student from Columbia.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Two collectively lose 80L in online trading fraud
1 2 3 Pune: In separate cases, two men, including an engineering company owner from Kothrud and a private company official from Pimple Saudagar, collectively lost Rs 80 lakh to cyber crooks in online Forex and share trading frauds. Separate cases were registered with the Kothrud and Sangvi police. A 41-year-old resident of Kothrud came into contact with cyber crooks through a dating app. A woman, with whom the victim was chatting through the dating app, urged him to invest in Forex trading by claiming that she was earning well in Forex trading for the last three years. "The woman shared a link with the victim for registration in February this year. She then informed the victim about Forex trading. The victim earned a profit of Rs 2,200 on his initial investment of Rs 20,000. He could immediately withdraw the money," the officer said. He said that the victim then went on transferring amounts as and when the woman told him. "Whenever the man tried to withdraw his money, the woman used to lure him by promising more profit and making him invest more. In March this year, he could see that he earned a profit of Rs 53 lakh on his investments of Rs 48 lakh," he said. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Dieses Hörgerät kann 2025 alles verändern Gutes Hören Undo The officer said that when the complainant tried to withdraw his money, the woman told him to pay Rs 13 lakh more for the bank charges. "The victim realised that he was being duped and stopped responding to her," the officer said. He mentioned that investigations so far revealed that the victim transferred the amounts through 17 transactions. "We have sought the details of these transactions from the victim's bank," he said. In the Sangvi case, a 55-year-old private company official lost Rs 32 lakh to cyber crooks, who offered him good returns on his investments in the share market. The complainant, between May and June 4 this year, transferred the amounts to the different bank account numbers provided to him and lost it to the crooks. He approached Sangvi police on Monday and lodged a complaint. Pune: In separate cases, two men, including an engineering company owner from Kothrud and a private company official from Pimple Saudagar, collectively lost Rs 80 lakh to cyber crooks in online Forex and share trading frauds. Separate cases were registered with the Kothrud and Sangvi police. A 41-year-old resident of Kothrud came into contact with cyber crooks through a dating app. A woman, with whom the victim was chatting through the dating app, urged him to invest in Forex trading by claiming that she was earning well in Forex trading for the last three years. "The woman shared a link with the victim for registration in February this year. She then informed the victim about Forex trading. The victim earned a profit of Rs 2,200 on his initial investment of Rs 20,000. He could immediately withdraw the money," the officer said. He said that the victim then went on transferring amounts as and when the woman told him. "Whenever the man tried to withdraw his money, the woman used to lure him by promising more profit and making him invest more. In March this year, he could see that he earned a profit of Rs 53 lakh on his investments of Rs 48 lakh," he said. The officer said that when the complainant tried to withdraw his money, the woman told him to pay Rs 13 lakh more for the bank charges. "The victim realised that he was being duped and stopped responding to her," the officer said. He mentioned that investigations so far revealed that the victim transferred the amounts through 17 transactions. "We have sought the details of these transactions from the victim's bank," he said. In the Sangvi case, a 55-year-old private company official lost Rs 32 lakh to cyber crooks, who offered him good returns on his investments in the share market. The complainant, between May and June 4 this year, transferred the amounts to the different bank account numbers provided to him and lost it to the crooks. He approached Sangvi police on Monday and lodged a complaint.
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
RCB fully responsible for stampede, K'taka govt tells high court
The Karnataka government on Wednesday told the High Court that IPL franchise Royal Challengers Bengaluru (RCB) bore full responsibility for the deadly stampede outside Bengaluru's Chinnaswamy Stadium on June 4, which left 11 people dead and several others injured. Opposing the bail plea of RCB's head of marketing, Nikhil Sosale, who was arrested by the Central Crime Branch (CCB) on June 6, the state submitted that RCB's last-minute social media posts, including announcements about free passes and open invitations to the team's victory celebration, triggered the massive and unmanageable crowd buildup. The submissions were made before Justice SR Krishna Kumar, who has reserved orders on Sosale's bail application and is expected to pronounce the verdict on June 12. Terming the entire celebration 'illegal,' the government argued that RCB neither sought the requisite permissions nor implemented necessary safety measures to manage an event that ultimately drew lakhs of people. 'There was no permission taken. What they submitted was an intimation—not a formal request seeking approval,' Advocate General (AG) Shashi Kiran Shetty told the court. 'They tweeted to the world, inviting lakhs of fans without specifying who could enter or what protocols applied. The entire event violated legal norms,' he added. The AG cited multiple posts made from RCB's official handle on X (formerly Twitter) between 11:30 pm on June 3 and 8:55 am on June 4. These posts announced a victory parade from Vidhana Soudha to the stadium but offered no details on ticketing, crowd control, or security arrangements. When Justice Kumar asked whether the state's position was that RCB was 'completely responsible,' the AG replied: 'Yes. They have tried to shift the blame to the State, but the entire responsibility lies with them. The event was illegal under the Karnataka Police Act and Section 223 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, which deals with disobedience to lawful orders. This has criminal consequences.' Defending Sosale, senior advocate Sandesh Chouta argued that the marketing head was being unfairly targeted. 'He is merely an employee, not a decision-maker. He cannot be held vicariously liable for actions taken by the company,' Chouta told the court. Chouta also pointed out that Deputy Chief Minister DK Shivakumar had publicly invited people to the event, but the AG refuted this claim. When the bench sought clarity on Sosale's personal responsibility, Justice Kumar observed: 'He is not even a director; just a marketing official. You cannot conflate the company with the individual. Show us a document where it's his responsibility to seek permission.' In response, the AG cited a tri-partite agreement between RCB, BCCI and KSCA to underline RCB's obligations but admitted that the document did not directly implicate Sosale. However, Shetty maintained: 'We have identified the right person for arrest based on the investigation so far.' Chouta further argued that the arrest was procedurally flawed, pointing out that it took place on June 6, even though the investigation had been officially transferred to the CID on June 5. The AG, however, countered that local police were well within their rights to act until the handover was formally completed and insisted the arrest was lawful. Sosale has also challenged the legality of his arrest, alleging that it was carried out at the behest of Chief Minister Siddaramaiah -- an act he contends exceeds the CM's constitutional authority in criminal investigations.
