Environmental legal fund fighting Trump fishing order
Photo:
Supplied/ the Business & Human Rights Resource Centre
An environmental legal fund have sued US President Donald Trump in response to an executive order rolling back commercial fishing protections in the Western Pacific.
The April 17th order, "Unleashing American commerical fishing in the Pacific", expands fishing rights within the Pacific Remote Islands Marine National Monument, a protected area which surrounds various American-owned islands.
The monument was established by President Bush in 2009.
President Obama in 2014 expanded the size of the monument
to around 1,270,000 square kilometers of ocean space - or about twice the size of the state of Texas.
Obama also completely banned commercial fishing activity from that space.
Trump's order reverses those bans, which Earthjustice claimed leaves more than 80 percent of the monument's total area open to fishing.
David Henkin, lead attorney for the case, told
RNZ Pacific
that is illegal.
"The Antiquities Act gives American presidents the power to create national monuments and to reserve those lands to protect the resources, but it's one way ratchet.
"It doesn't give a president the ability to destroy a monument by stripping from it the essential protections that are necessary to preserve the the objects of historic and scientific interests within the monument."
Trump's side argues that the presence of commercial fishing vessels doesn't pose a significant threat to marine life.
"A host of federal protections exist under current laws and agency management designations to protect the area's natural resources, vulnerable marine species, and unique habitats, such as coral and seamount ecosystems."
Henkin's suit contends that vessels would actually pose a massive risk, directly contradicting Trump's justification for bypassing the Antiquities Act.
Species of critically endangered sea turtles in transit, as well as coral species and various other marine animals would be made vulnerable to fishing, Henkin said.
"There is a lot of interaction with all of these species which are supposed to be protected under the US Endangered Species Act. Yet the Fishery Service, which is charged with implementing the Act, failed to do any analysis about the effects of opening these protected areas to activities that they know kill and injure endangered and threatened sea turtles.
"It's that web of life that President Trump's proclamation and the Fisheries Service opening it to commercial fishing is tearing apart."
US Exclusive Economic Zones of the US Western Pacific region.
Photo:
Western Pacific Regional Fishery Management Council
At the same time, nearly half of US-owned territory in the Pacific Ocean had been made unavailable for fishing, Trump stated in the order.
"This has driven American fishermen to fish further offshore in international waters to compete against poorly regulated and highly subsidized foreign fleets.
"This disadvantages honest United States commercial fishermen and is detrimental for United States territories like American Samoa, whose private sector economy is over 80 percent dependent on the fishing industry."
One of Trump's supporters in the Pacific, Congresswoman Uifa'atali Aumua Amata of American Samoa, said that the food security that extra fishing provides for is vital for her community.
"Neither Presidents Bush, Obama or Biden ever asked American Samoa what they wanted before they took away our indigenous fishing rights without any science... President Trump asked and acted."
Henkin said it reflects Trump's "complete ignorance" about the Pacific.
"You need to go for days and days to get to Johnston Atoll, or to get to Jarvis Island and certainly Wake Island. There are fishing grounds much closer to the main Hawaiian Islands or to American Samoa that are and always have been available to fishers there."
Ensuring a space for fish stocks to replenish is vital for sustainability, Henkin argued.
"This is a concept that I think Polynesians long understood by putting areas to off limits to exploitation, you create more abundance. You create spillover effects. And so by protecting the species within the monument, there are more pelagic species, including tuna to catch outside of the monument."
In a separate executive order, 'Restoring American seafood competitiveness', Trump ordered the Secretaries of Commerce and the Interior to "review all existing marine national monuments and provide recommendations to the President of any that should be opened to commercial fishing".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
US-China trade deal 'welcome relief' for Kiwi exporters
Todd McClay at the Mystery Creek Fieldays yesterday. Photo: Monique Steele Agriculture Minister Todd McClay who also has Trade portfolio has welcomed news of [ a possible US-China trade deal]. US President Donald Trump says a deal with China is "done" after two days of high-level talks in London. The overnight announcement comes as the government welcomes the state of the country's agriculture sector. The Ministry of Primary Industries' Situation and Outlook report is projecting a double digit increase in New Zealand export revenues this year - though it warns about global uncertainty. It estimates New Zealand's agricultural export revenue could reach just under $60 billion by the end of June, up from a dip in 2023-4. Agriculture and Trade Minister Todd McClay told Morning Report if a US-China deal has been done it would be "good news". At an OECD trade ministers meeting in Paris last week he had met with the trade ministers of both China and the US. Both had then gone off for joint talks so some momentum had been building to try and find a solution to their tariffs impasse. If things calmed down for international trade it would bring "welcome relief" for exporters and result in some "sensible decision-making". McClay said the remarkable growth in primary exports was very positive. Dairy had enjoyed a solid season with a good supply of grass which had increased milk production. The meat sector was performing well and for the first time $5 billion worth of kiwifruit had been exported. Even the US market faced with tariff uncertainty was providing some opportunities for Kiwi exporters, citing the example of NZ King Salmon which has talked of increased sales at a higher price. Kiwi exporters were working hard to add value to their products, McClay said. One example was selling ready to eat burger patties to China which resulted in greater returns for farmers. "So we're seeing Kiwi exporters go for value, not competing on price anywhere as much as they used to." Photo: RNZ / Richard Tindiller A government-backed grass certification standard for dairy and meat exports had been launched at Mystery Creek Fieldays yesterday, McClay said. This would be highly desirable for markets in China, other parts of Asia and the Middle East, McClay said. "Grass fed now is increasingly wanted by consumers and they're willing to pay more." On sustainable products, Groundswell has been calling for New Zealand to exit the Paris Agreement on Climate Change. McClay said that was not going to happen mainly because it would make exports to many markets untenable. He believed Groundswell and others were worried about higher costs and lower production if they adopted sustainable measures. "We've been really clear - we think through technology and other things we can meet these obligations without putting farmers out of business." Alternatives to farmers going into the Emissions Trading Scheme were being worked on and would be announced soon. McClay said the requirement of reducing methane by 10 percent by 2030 was on track to be met. "So it shows farmers are willing to do it but we have to lean heavily into technology rather than just planting trees." A number of products, known as methane inhibitors , have been developed already although they might have to overcome consumer resistance. McClay said anything developed would have to go through rigorous scientific testing. There would be a range of solutions developed and farmers would decide which ones they wanted to pick up. "The overseas customers through the dairy company should be paying for this, not the New Zealand farmer."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
Tourism NZ launches new 100% Pure New Zealand global campaign
Tourism New Zealand has launched a new global campaign with a familiar twist, inviting the world to find their 100% Pure New Zealand. It's the first new global brand campaign since 'If You Seek' was launched in 2022 and aims to encourage travellers to book now with snapshots of the iconic landscapes and experiences on offer. Tourism New Zealand chief executive René de Monchy said this was a rejuvenation for the 100% Pure New Zealand brand that has been running for over 25 years. "This is our call for people around the world to be totally connected, present, inspired and fulfilled in one of the world's most breathtaking destinations," he said. The campaign complemented Tourism New Zealand's aim to grow tourism by $5 billion over the next four years by attracting more visitors outside of summer, de Monchy said. "The fact that we're encouraging people to find their 100% Pure New Zealand - we can tailor that to being 'what does it look like in the winter?' 'What does that look like in the autumn?' 'What does that look like if you're interested in the cycle trails or interested in fine dining?" It included a new experience planner to help people create their own 100% Pure New Zealand itinerary by choosing images of what they would like to experience and developing a custom itinerary. That could include telling them if they were 40 percent iconic New Zealand, 30 percent fine dining and 30 percent culture, which they could take to a travel agent to inspire their travel plans, he said. Tourism New Zealand has launched a new global campaign with a familiar twist. Photo: YouTube / 100% Pure New Zealand "You can flick through and go to and find all the different operators that sit under each of those categories, whether it's adventure tourism or fine dining," de Monchy said. "So it's really a tool that we've created to try and make it easier for you to make the booking and not just dream about it." The campaign cost about $5.45 million, launching across global social media channels and paid media in the United States on Thursday. The campaign was developed alongside agency TBWA Auckland and collaboration with iwi, regional tourism operators and the wider industry. It also included templates for regions and operators to create their own ads and showcase what they have on offer. "We're inviting the world to discover that New Zealand isn't just a place you visit, it's a place which fosters deep connection with the locals, with those you're travelling with, leaving you totally fulfilled" de Monchy said. "We know a trip to New Zealand is about more than just landscapes and landmarks. "There truly is something for everyone, whether that's adventure seeking thrills, finding - total rejuvenation in nature, or enjoying our world-class culinary scene". There were 155 million people actively considering a New Zealand holiday and he said the campaign encouraged them to make their booking now. Tourism New Zealand received two $13.5 million funding boosts from the government in recent months, aimed to boost marketing in the short and medium term. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
1News
an hour ago
- 1News
'Trump wants chaos': On the frontline of the LA protests
Rubber bullets. Tear gas. Fireworks. Graffiti. The never-ending chanting. This is Downtown Los Angeles, which has found itself the epicentre of protests against immigration raids. US Correspondent Logan Church reports from the front lines in Los Angeles. This all kicked off when federal immigration agents – colloquially referred to here as "ICE" – began raiding businesses and arrested dozens of "illegal immigrants". Donald Trump's administration calls these people "violent criminals" and "terrorists". Some are. Some are not. Some are just dads. Members of the community with people who love them. All of them, though, live in what is probably the most migrant friendly city in America – Los Angeles. ADVERTISEMENT And Angelinos are furious. Speaking from Los Angeles, 1News US correspondent Logan Church said "people here are deeply angry". (Source: Breakfast) As soon as I drove into the centre of the city, the first thing I noticed was the graffiti. Everywhere. All federal buildings were covered in messages – the most common being the simple "f*** ICE". People were casually adding more as I walked past, not caring if I filmed them. Most welcomed it. The second thing I noticed was the huge numbers of police and federal guards. They surrounded all those buildings like an army. And when protestors got too close – or the odd one threw something – they shot rubber bullets and tear gas. Standing a few blocks from the front line, a young protestor came running up, asking if I had seen a medic. He pointed frantically to an older man sitting on a bench with blood pouring down his tattered trousers. He'd just been shot with a rubber bullet. What was more surreal was seeing the line of police less than 5m away, doing nothing to help. 1News US Correspondent Logan Church reports from the front lines in downtown Los Angeles. (Source: 1News) Talking to protestors this week, they told me they were furious about the ICE raids – and that was why they were there. But they were even more angry about what they called a heavy-handed police response directed by Trump. ADVERTISEMENT "He's wanting to cause chaos," one protestor told me. "He's wanting to incite fear and cause violence in order to do martial law on us. He wants to enact something so he can have more rule over us and I don't stand for that." Another man said the reason he'd come out to protest was simple. "Everything they are doing is illegal, so when someone breaks the law you've gotta come and make sure they follow the law." Authorities stand in tear gas while trying to clear protesters at the metropolitan detention centre in downtown Los Angeles, Sunday, June 8, 2025, following last night's immigration raid protest. (Source: Associated Press) Perhaps the most fascinating chat I had though was with a pair of Kiwis who just happened to walk past where I was filming. They'd decided to join the demonstrators as they marched around the city. "We just arrived in LA about an hour ago, we are staying in downtown LA and we could hear the sirens, we could hear the helicopters, so we decided to go for a walk to check it out," said Tiana Griffin. "We had to join because this is the equivalent of the Te Tiriti Hikoi, fighting for the greater good, fighting for the most vulnerable communities. The people that are serving this country, it makes you want to sob at the mamae that you feel for these people is the same mamae that you feel for Māori in Aotearoa at the moment. So we had to. We were just drawn to it." ADVERTISEMENT "This felt like home," added Meretini. "We are standing in the middle of something that resonated for the both of us, having walked the hikoi down to government and this is their form of it — and everyone is really worried at home about how it would be for us in LA, but really this has been the best introduction to LA – to be able to stand with their people." For the pair, joining the marchers was an easy decision. "It's meaningful – our children are telling us to stay safe and stay out of trouble – but this is so peaceful. This is exactly like the Te Tiriti marches that we had in Aotearoa. Everyone is carrying their flags calling out in Spanish – I wish I knew what they were saying so we can join in but it's the same feeling, it's the same aroha as our marches back home." In my travels throughout America, I have met many people who believe that illegal immigrants are the cause of much of the country's woes. They're concerned about jobs not being available, housing costs rising, and crime. I've also met people deeply concerned about their friends, family, and neighbours, being increasingly treated as lesser beings by this country's leaders. As a reporter who has covered countless protests at home and here in America, I can confidently say this one in Los Angeles feels different. ADVERTISEMENT It's a city that has birthed protest movements that have swept the nation, and this feels just like that.
