logo
Asylum seeker can be deported after cheating in English test

Asylum seeker can be deported after cheating in English test

Yahoo02-05-2025

A Bangladeshi immigrant could finally be deported from the UK 13 years after he cheated in an English language test.
Md Adbur Rahim, 37, was accused by the Home Office of using a proxy to take the English test for him in 2012 which resulted in his application for indefinite leave to remain in the UK being rejected.
His deception was uncovered after a BBC Panorama documentary found widespread cheating at test centres and led to thousands of results including Mr Rahim's being declared invalid.
He appealed the refusal of his application, insisting he had taken the test himself, beginning a legal saga which went all the way to the Court of Appeal.
Now, Upper Tribunal Judge Bulpitt has ruled that it was 'highly probable' Mr Rahim used a proxy for the test and the Home Office was right to refuse his application.
Mr Rahim's claim highlights the lengthy legal battles by illegal migrants that has seen the backlog of immigration appeals rise to a record 41,987 outstanding cases. The Government has pledged to clear it by halving the time it takes for them to come to court to just 24 days.
Mr Rahim first came to the UK in 2007 as a student and was able to extend his leave until October 2014, when an application to extend was refused. While waiting for the appeal in that case to be heard, he launched a fresh application for indefinite leave to remain in October 2017 on the basis that he had been in the UK for a decade.
That application was denied by the Home Office a month later on the basis Mr Rahim had previously used 'deception' to obtain leave to remain by getting a proxy to take an English language test required for his October 2012 application to extend his leave.
This refusal then kickstarted a seven-year legal battle between Mr Rahim and the Home Office which went to the Court of Appeal.
It started in the first-tier tribunal in December 2018 where the court was told he had taken a Test of English for International Communication administered by the Educational Testing Service (ETS) in 2012. But the Home Office produced evidence to show Mr Rahim's test had likely been taken by a proxy and was therefore invalid.
The tribunal concluded the burden of proof was on Mr Rahim to show he had taken the test himself but they found no 'cogent' evidence this was the case and upheld the refusal. Rahim was not allowed to appeal and then applied twice, unsuccessfully, to take his case to the upper tribunal.
When his second application was denied he sought a judicial review in the Court of Appeal. This was initially refused but he he was then allowed to appeal that decision and it was decided that the first-tier tribunal had made an error of law concerning the burden of proof.
In January this year, the case was heard by Judge Bulpitt to determine whether the decision needed to be remade by the upper tribunal. He concluded that it did.
In April, Judge Bulpitt heard the full case including that in February 2014 a BBC Panorama programme had exposed widespread cheating at centres run by ETS which sparked a Home Office investigation.
Officials used 'voice biometric technology' to compare matching voices from different tests, a clear indicator that a proxy had been used.
On the day Mr Rahim supposedly took the test at the London College of Media and Technology in London. One hundred and thirty one tests were later found to be invalid, including his, and the rest of the 159 taken were recorded as questionable.
Mr Rahim told the court he had taken the test himself, relying on a witness statement from 2018 describing his journey to the test centre and the room itself. But he could not provide evidence from anyone who he claimed had recommended the centre to him.
Judge Bulpitt found his evidence to be 'wilfully vague' compared to the 'compelling' case offered by the Home Office that the Bangladeshi had used a proxy to conduct the test and therefore the Government was right to refuse his application.
He said: 'Overall, we found [Mr Rahim's] account to lack transparency, to be wilfully vague and to lack support in circumstances where supporting evidence especially from his partner could reasonably be expected.
'In contrast to that weak evidence we found the [Home Office's] evidence that [he] used a proxy for his test to be compelling, noting the high instances of fraud at the particular centre used by [Rahim], the appellant's exceptionally high score and the highly probable conclusion reached following the ETS testing that the voice records reveal that [he] used a proxy.'
Broaden your horizons with award-winning British journalism. Try The Telegraph free for 1 month with unlimited access to our award-winning website, exclusive app, money-saving offers and more.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Ministers to unveil 10-year plan to overhaul infrastructure
Ministers to unveil 10-year plan to overhaul infrastructure

Yahoo

timean hour ago

  • Yahoo

Ministers to unveil 10-year plan to overhaul infrastructure

Ministers are to unveil their plan to overhaul infrastructure over the next decade as Rachel Reeves said the country's schools and hospitals have been 'left to crumble'. The Treasury has promised hundreds of billions over the next decade for projects such as roads, railways and homes. According to the Treasury, the document will lay out Government plans on prioritised policy areas such as upgrading transport networks, building new homes, modernising public services such as hospitals, and assisting the transition to green energy. Ministers are pledging that at least £725 billion will be spent on infrastructure over the next 10 years. Ms Reeves said: 'The British people voted for change – and this is how we deliver it. For too long, our infrastructure – our schools and hospitals, or our roads and bridges – have been left to crumble, holding back communities and stunting economic growth. 'This was a dereliction of duty by previous governments overseeing an era of managed decline, but it ends with this one. 'We are investing in Britain's future, brick by brick, road by road and track by track. 'The strategy will rebuild people's pride in their homes, while growing the economy and putting more money in people's pockets as we deliver our Plan for Change.' The Chancellor outlined a raft of infrastructure investment as part of last week's spending review. According to Wednesday's announcement, there will be £39 billion over the next 10 years to build affordable and social housing, and spending is due to reach £4 billion a year in 2029/30. There was also a £30 billion commitment to nuclear power, including £14.2 billion to build the Sizewell C plant in Suffolk and £2.5 billion in small modular reactors, as well as £15 billion for public transport projects in England's city regions and a four-year settlement for Transport for London worth £2.2 billion. Shadow chancellor Sir Mel Stride said that the Chancellor is 'desperately trying to paper over the damage she's done to the public finances'. Sir Mel added: 'With inflation up, growth down, and unemployment rising, the economy is heading in one direction and that is backwards.'

What caused Air India Flight AI171 to crash? The key information we know so far
What caused Air India Flight AI171 to crash? The key information we know so far

Yahoo

time2 hours ago

  • Yahoo

What caused Air India Flight AI171 to crash? The key information we know so far

The Indian government is reportedly looking at a number of factors that may explain why Air India flight AI 171 crashed shortly after take-off from Ahmedabad Airport on Thursday, killing all but one of its 242 passengers. The London Gatwick-bound plane - which was carrying 53 British passengers, 169 Indian nationals, seven Portuguese and one Canadian - crashed into a medical college and erupted in a huge fireball on Thursday. The sole survivor was Briton Vishwash Kumar Ramesh, 40. At least 24 more people on the ground died. One of two black boxes has reportedly been found in a bid to help piece together vital clues that could shed light on the cause of the accident. On Friday, it was reported that Air India and the Indian government were looking at several aspects of the crash, including issues with the jet's engine thrust, its flaps, and why its landing gear remained open. The government is also looking at whether Air India was at fault, including looking at maintenance issues, a source told Reuters. Experts have also raised questions about the plane's landing gear, which was down when it should have been up, as well as the wing flaps. Some have raised the possibility of a power failure or bird strike. Here, Yahoo News UK looks at what investigators are likely to be considering. The Reuters news agency has reported two police sources as saying one of two black boxes from the plane has been found. They did not say whether it was the flight data recorder or the cockpit voice recorder that had been recovered. The black boxes, which are coloured orange to make them easier to find in the event of a crash, will be critical in establishing what happened. There are normally two recorders: a Cockpit Voice Recorder (CVR) for pilot voices or cockpit sounds, and a separate Flight Data Recorder (FDR). They are mandatory on civil flights, but their aim is not to determine any wrongdoing or fault - they are designed to preserve clues from cockpit sounds and data to help prevent future accidents. According to Reuters, investigators say the FDR helps them analyse what happened, and the CVR can start to explain why, though no two investigations are the same. According to Airbus: "Flight recorders store data (aircraft parameters) and sound (pilot, copilot, radio communications and the cockpit ambient noise). The recording device is crash-protected up to a certain level. It is resistant to fire, explosion, impact and water immersion." Video of the plane before the crash has shown its landing gear was down. Usually, this folds back into the aircraft immediately after it becomes airborne. Former British Airways pilot Alastair Rosenschein told Sky News: "It's clearly got its [landing] gear down and that is not correct... it should have been up." Watch: Moment Air India flight crashes after take-off He added: "I cannot understand why the [landing] gear would have been down... [and] left down. That would suggest, perhaps, a hydraulic problem because it's hydraulics that raise the gear." However, he made clear this was speculation. US aerospace safety consultant Anthony Brickhouse also said of the landing gear being down: "If you didn't know what was happening, you would think that plane was on approach to a runway." Steve Scheibner, an American Airlines pilot, also suggested there were abnormalities with the plane's wing flaps and linked this to the landing gear being down. Pilot Sumeet Sabharwal and his co-pilot Clive Kundar cried 'mayday' as the plane lost altitude, saying the engine was 'losing power'. According to reports, Sabharwal, who had more than 8,000 hours of flying experience, said he had 'no thrust' and was 'unable to lift'. And the Wall Street Journal reported on Friday, citing unnamed sources, that an investigation into the crash was focusing on "whether the aircraft had a loss or reduction in engine thrust". Dr Jason Knight, a senior lecturer in fluid mechanics at the University of Portsmouth, told The Telegraph: 'It appears from the video there is a cloud of dust just after take-off. 'I'm not sure, but it appears as though the cloud of dust could be from the engines as they both fail.' A twin-engine failure is extremely rare. The BBC reported experts familiar with Ahmedabad Airport as saying it is "notorious for birds", which can cause engine failures. Dr Knight also said "the most likely [reason] is a bird strike in both engines". But Scheibner said he didn't think a bird strike is a "likely theory". "We don't see any birds in the picture. It would have to be a lot of birds to foul out both engines and we don't see any indications coming out of the back of the engine that that happened: you'd see flames, you'd see sparks." Who were the British victims of the Air India plane crash? (The Guardian) Heartbreaking final selfie of doctor's young family starting a new life in Britain (The Telegraph) 'She was a ray of sunshine': First British victims of Air India plane crash named after 241 killed (The Independent)

Israeli attacks leave Iranians fearful, hopeful
Israeli attacks leave Iranians fearful, hopeful

Washington Post

time3 hours ago

  • Washington Post

Israeli attacks leave Iranians fearful, hopeful

When Israel launched its sustained assault on Iran's nuclear program and military leaders early Friday, Sareh began cycling through a range of emotions. 'I felt happiness,' the Iranian woman said, at the deaths of leaders who had long repressed the country's people. 'Then disbelief,' she continued from her home in the northern city of Rasht. 'Then some worry for what would happen next. Then happiness again, for how much power these people felt they had over us, how many of us they killed.' Like others interviewed for this report, she spoke on the condition that her last name be withheld for fear of retaliation from the government.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store