C-SPAN wants to broadcast Supreme Court arguments for the first time in this Trump case
Public access TV provider C-SPAN is calling on the Supreme Court to televise oral arguments for the first time during upcoming hearings over the Trump administration 's attempt to end birthright citizenship.
'This case holds profound national significance,' C-SPAN CEO Sam Feist wrote the court in a letter dated April 23. 'Its implications — legal, political, and personal — will affect millions of Americans. In light of this, we believe the public interest is best served through live television coverage of the proceedings. The public deserves to witness—fully and directly—how such a consequential issue is argued before the highest court in the land.'
The non-profit argued that televising the hearings, which begin May 15, will 'strengthen our democracy and deepen public understanding and appreciation of the judicial process.'
C-SPAN has not received a response to the letter, it told The Independent.
The Independent has contacted the Supreme Court for comment.
Allowing TV cameras into the Supreme Court chambers would be the biggest development in public access to the high court since audio recordings of oral argument went live in 2020 during the height of the Covid pandemic.
The Trump administration has an emergency request before the court, asking the justices to narrow or end nationwide injunctions against the executive order attempting to end birthright citizenship.
Courts and most legal scholars have argued Trump's order, which he signed his first day in office, likely violates the citizenship guarantees of the 14th Amendment.
The Trump years have seen the intensely private court take on a more public-facing role.
Chief Justice John Roberts issued a rare public statement earlier this year after the Trump administration attacked and tried to remove a federal judge overseeing a case about its emergency deportation flights to El Salvador.
"For more than two centuries, it has been established that impeachment is not an appropriate response to disagreement concerning a judicial decision. The normal appellate review process exists for that purpose,' he said.
The court was also forced to launch an internal investigation after a draft version leaked of its 2022 order overturning the constitutional right to an abortion.
In January 2023, the court said it had been unable to discern who leaked the opinion.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
32 minutes ago
- The Guardian
Afternoon Update: critics call for Aukus exit; ‘no corruption' in Higgins' $2.4m settlement; and a strawberry moon
Good afternoon. A chorus of Aukus sceptics, including former prime ministers Paul Keating and Malcolm Turnbull, say a US review into the nuclear-powered submarine program is an 'opportunity' for Australia to escape a deal that would cost hundreds of billions of dollars and leave the country ultimately less able to defend itself. The Pentagon overnight announced it had launched a review of the Aukus agreement to make sure it is aligned with Donald Trump's 'America first' agenda, throwing the defence pact with Britain and Australia into doubt. The defence minister, Richard Marles, downplayed the development, saying it was 'natural' that the US would examine the project, but that he believed there was still strong support for the trilateral agreement in Washington DC. The shadow defence minister, Angus Taylor, said Anthony Albanese must seek to safeguard Aukus by meeting Trump as soon as possible. Turnbull, whose pre-existing submarine deal with French shipbuilder Naval was dramatically torn up in favour of Aukus in 2021, said Australia should 'wake up' and review the agreement as well, while Keating, a longtime critic of the program, said the review 'might very well be the moment Washington saves Australia from itself'. Watchdog finds 'no corruption' in $2.4m settlement to Brittany Higgins after alleged rape Monash IVF CEO resigns after second embryo bungle Erin Patterson says she didn't deliberately source death caps and serve to guests as murder trial evidence concludes Sydney Theatre Company books $10m revenue boost after Dorian Gray production becomes global hit Australian Human Rights Commission president calls for end to police investigating deaths in police custody University staff say Woodside-backed climate conference highlights concerns about energy giant partnership Israeli forces kill at least 60 Palestinians seeking food in Gaza, health officials say The 'strawberry moon', so named because it traditionally denoted the start of strawberry picking in the northern hemisphere, could be seen in skies around the world on the night of 10-11 June. From Dubai to the Parthenon, see our gallery of the best shots. 'World records are made to be broken. So by the time I leave this sport, I want to make sure that that record is as fast as possible.' – Summer McIntosh The 18-year-old from Toronto broke her third swimming world record in five days at the Canadian Swimming Trials, clocking 4:23.65 in the women's 400m individual medley. McIntosh becomes the first swimmer to break world records in three different individual events at one long course meet since Michael Phelps at the 2008 Beijing Olympics. Official data shows the rate of Aboriginal hanging deaths is at a 17-year high, a number which correlates with Australia's surging prisoner population. Guardian Australia has spent months investigating hanging deaths in every state and territory. The investigation has revealed a staggering death toll linked to inaction on known hanging points. Sign up to Afternoon Update Our Australian afternoon update breaks down the key stories of the day, telling you what's happening and why it matters after newsletter promotion Whether wistful or euphoric, Brian Wilson made pop's most overwhelmingly beautiful music He was the Beach Boys' resident genius, seeping melancholy into even peppy teenybopper hits. Beyond all the myths about his life, writes Alexis Petridis, that brilliance is still intoxicating Today's starter word is: BAND. You have five goes to get the longest word, including the starter word. Play Wordiply. Enjoying the Afternoon Update? Then you'll love our Morning Mail newsletter. Sign up here to start the day with a curated breakdown of the key stories you need to know, and complete your daily news roundup. And follow the latest in US politics by signing up for This Week in Trumpland.
.jpeg%3Ftrim%3D0%2C0%2C0%2C0%26width%3D1200%26height%3D800%26crop%3D1200%3A800&w=3840&q=100)
The Independent
39 minutes ago
- The Independent
Is Trump's America in the middle of a coup?
In conducting a coup in an impoverished undeveloped nation there is a basic to-do list. You capture the presidency, the courts, take over the international airport, emasculate the legislature, decapitate the military of potential opponents, storm the local TV station and declare a new dawn. Bigger countries require more effort, like the mass mobilization of xenophobia through false-flag attacks and terror scares, but from Moscow to Monrovia, the patterns are the same – an autocrat takes power in the name of national salvation. With Donald Trump in power for a little over four months, questions are swirling as to whether this process is happening to what was the most powerful democracy on earth. When he refused to accept he lost the 2020 elections and his supporters stormed the Capital, and later jailed, he pardoned them all. Now America's constitution is again under threat of what many critics are calling an internal coup d'etat. Driven, perhaps, because the president has openly considered a Trump 2028 campaign for a third, unconstitutional, term. While he was duly elected to his office for a second time last November, every check and balance to the power of the US presidency as enumerated in the Constitution has been, or is being, challenged.— a notion only heightened by the drumbeat of declarations from White House insiders of an 'insurrection' in Los Angeles. As protestors took to the streets against the mass arrest of alleged illegal immigrants, Trump lost little time in ordering 700 US Marines and thousands of National Guard onto the streets of Los Angeles. Californian governor Gavin Newsom described the move as 'deranged' which would only serve to inflame tensions on the west coast. The governor declared: 'Democracy is under assault. The moment we feared has arrived. 'Take time. Reflect on this perilous moment a president, bound by no law or constitution, perpetuating a unified assault on American traditions.' His words came only hours after Trump warned anyone contemplating protesting during his military parade on June 14 that they would be met with 'very heavy force'. Trump's to-do list in taking on - and taking down - the establishment has already been largely ticked off. First he moved against the military and intelligence services whom, during his first presidency, he blamed for holding back his agenda and for failing to back the 'protestors' who invaded the US Capital on January 6 2021. Mark Milley, chairman of the joint chief of staff during Trump 1.0, lost his security detail and the pre-emptive pardon he'd been given by outgoing president Joe Biden after he was threatened with prosecution by Trump. Trump then fired his successor Airforce general Charles Brown, and the head of the US Coastguards Linda Fagan. They were axed, the administration suggested, because they were DEI hires. Nothing in their backgrounds indicates they were anything but qualified for the top jobs, but the messaging was clear from the White House – we want our own people. But they must be loyal above all – so General Timothy Haugh, the head of the National Security Agency and US Cyber Command, has also gone along with the head of Naval operations admiral Lisa Franchetti. No reason was given for Haugh's dismissal in April. Trump told reporters on Air Force One at the time: 'We're always going to let go of people – people we don't like or people that take advantage of, or people that may have loyalties to someone else.' Moving on, the FBI boss Christopher Wray was replaced with Kash Patel, an avid Trump loyalist who has failed to produce a budget for his agency this year. The new deputy director Dan Bongino is a podcaster who peddled the lie that Trump won the 2020 presidential election. The director of National Intelligence is now Tulsi Gabbard, who has been an apologist for Vladimir Putin and Syria's Bashar al Assad. Pete Hegseth, a former Fox News contributor, is secretary of defence and famed for his attacks on Volodymyr Zelensky, Nato, and for using his personal phone to transmit state secrets. Incompetence among cabinet members and top officials means that Trump knows they owe their place in his orbit to him alone. Each of these leaders have purged their own departments and replaced professionals with apparatchiks. The federal bureaucracy has been hammered by Trump's re-definition of more than 50,000 civil servants and 'political hires', allowing for him to impose pre-vetted loyalists in the executive heart of the government. Opposition to a coup will often come from the judiciary and universities. Trump has moved to stifle both. Top academies like Harvard and Colombia have been threatened with or have lost federal funding worth billions for pushing back at Trump's attempts to control their intellectual life. Foreign students are being banned. Students and academics who have supported Palestinian rights have been accused of backing terror groups like Hamas and fired, expelled or deported. The issue here is focussed on Israel and alleged antisemitism but again, the message is clear – free speech is over. Of course, none of this could have been achieved without the active support of the US Congress and Senate which is supposed to check the worst of executive power. But with Republican majorities in both, Trump has been given a free reign. And Republicans who do not subscribe to Trump's vision in Congress are often living in fear of criticising him. Standout Republican opponent Alaskan Senator Lisa Murkowski said during a townhall last month: 'We're in a time and a place where I certainly have not been here before. I'm oftentimes very anxious myself about using my voice because retaliation is real… 'I have to figure out how to help the many and the anxious who are so afraid [in Congress]'. Many academics from Africa in particular, who have lived through civil wars for the last 30 years, have wondered how long it would be before Americans realized they could be living through their own form of coup. A professor at a prestigious east coast university who has a green card and is world renowned in their field said: 'I'm just wary about being quoted. We (academics non-nationals) have even been told not to leave the US in case we can't get back in. The administration is monitoring our social media accounts'. Speaking anonymously for fear of retribution they went on: 'Those of us who have grown up under authoritarian regimes have learned of the signs of incipient and growing authoritarianism. None of this is rocket science. 'There is a method: the control of the press and judiciary, co-option of the loyalty of the police and the army, rise of militias, manipulation of elections. Trump discredited the mainstream media, stacked the judiciary… He demanded the loyalty of the FBI.' America's judiciary has had patchy success in getting the administration to observe the constitution that the president, military, and intelligence services have sworn to uphold too. Trump's White House has ignored orders to stay deportations. In May, over 130 former state and federal judges demanded the government drop its charges against Milwaukee County Circuit Court Judge Hannah Dugan, dubbing her indictment for allegedly helping man evade immigration officials as an 'egregious overreach' by the executive branch. But ICE immigration officials have spread across the country arresting suspects without showing identification, frequently without warrants, and using force to impose meet Trump's mass deportation promises. This week, Trump has been concerned with the manufactured notion of an 'insurrection' in California. A conflict between protestors and the armed forces on the streets of LA could be the excuse any autocrat would use to declare a national emergency, and suspend constitutional law. 'The president is trying to manufacture chaos and crisis on the ground for his own political ends,' said Robert Bonta, California's attorney general after announcing that the state, led by Mr Newsom, was going to sue the Trump administration for violating the US Constitution. 'Federalizing the California National Guard is an abuse of the president's authority under the law – and not one we take lightly. We're asking a court to put a stop to the unlawful, unprecedented order.' With decades of experience in West Africa and having published widely on the war that tore Yugoslavia apart, the anonymous east coast professor added a dire warning: 'I think, eventually, a state will consider seceding. Maybe California. Then it will be war, I think Yugoslavia is a good model for the US'.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Protest curfews spread to Washington as LA moves to arrest 'bad actors' and unrest continues in NYC and Chicago
Massive anti-ICE riots have spread from coast to coast as Los Angeles tries to crack down on 'bad actors' at fiery protests that continued for a sixth consecutive day on Wednesday. The City of Angels has been reeling since Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents first conducted raids in the city on Friday, sparking viral clashes between officers in riot gear and protesters who set vehicles on fire. Some have even taken advantage of the chaos as they looted more than 20 stores. But in cities across the nation, residents are rallying to show their support for the people of Los Angeles as they hold their own anti-ICE demonstrations - prompting Republicans to investigate who may be behind the uprising. Protests have popped up in cities like New York City and Chicago, and in Spokane, Washington, Mayor Lisa Brown was forced to impose a curfew after large groups of protesters took to the streets and blocked off roads. Officers who responded to the scene were then seen donning gas masks and deploying a device that released smoke into the crowd, causing them to disperse and begin shouting at police, CNN reports. A total of 30 people have since been arrested in the Washington city. It comes just one day after Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass issued her own lockdown from 8pm to 6am, saying she was trying to 'stop bad actors who are taking advantage of the President's chaotic escalation' after President Donald Trump deployed the National Guard and Marines to the city. But protesters have remained on the scene, with 17 people arrested on Tuesday for violating the curfew, according to the Los Angeles Times. Even more arrests were made Wednesday, as curfew went into effect for a second consecutive and police quickly drove rioters out. Officers were seen on horseback charging into a crowd at City Hall, causing several demonstrators to fall to the ground. Cops then pushed hundreds of protesters into Gloria Molina Grand Park, where they gathered and began chanting 'Shame.' Yet they seemed to be aware of their situation, as they wrote the number for bail support on their arms. Meanwhile, Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman announced criminal charges against eight people who allegedly attacked police, vandalized building and looted stores since the unrest began. 'If people want to hurl insults, we will protect that,' he said at a news conference Wednesday. 'If people want to engage in crimes, we will prosecute that.' His office said three people were charged with using fireworks and motorcycles to hurt officers, after two were caught on camera slamming their bikes into a police skirmish line. Hochman also announced charges against two people who allegedly joined a break in at a downtown Los Angeles Nike store and felony vandalism charges against people accused of tagging the downtown Hall of Justice - which houses the headquarters for the District Attorney's Office and the Sheriff's Department. More unruly rioters may also find themselves criminally charged in the coming days, LA County Sheriff Robert Luna said. He explained that officers are continuing to review footage from the riots. 'If you didn't get caught in the last couple of nights, there's a lot of evidence,' Luna said. 'You're probably going to have a detective knocking at your door.' Yet detectives are also trying to figure out how to work with members of the National Guard and the Marines, who arrived in the city on Wednesday. 'The role is still not clear, to us, the Marines or the National Guard, other than they're a support entity to protect federal employees and facilities,' Los Angeles Police Chief Jim McDonnell told CNN's Kaitlan Collins. 'This is unprecedented,' he continued. 'As far as the scope of their responsibilities or their abilities relative to arrest or dealing in a municipal environment, that's not something that they do certainly. 'What their training is, we're not sure of that - either on the Army or the Marines as it relates to crowd management, crowd control in an urban environment.' Attorneys representing President Donald Trump, though, argued in court documents on Wednesday that the military forces in Los Angles were not engaging directly in policing as they hit out at California Gov. Gavin Newsom's lawsuit. The governor and Attorney General Rob Bonta filed a suit over the president's deployment of the National Guard and the Marines earlier this week, arguing it was unconstitutional because it violates state sovereignty and federal laws that limit the use of military forces for policing. In a desperate attempt to get the forces out of Los Angeles, Newsom also asked a judge on Tuesday for a temporary restraining order on Trump's deployment - which the judge denied. Lawyers for the Trump administration have since filed a response calling California's request for the restraining order a 'crass political stunt endangering American lives.' If it were to be granted, they said, it would prevent the president 'from exercising his lawful statutory and constitutional power' to ensure federal facilities and personnel are protected and that the nation's immigration laws are adequately enforced. A hearing on the matter is now scheduled for Thursday afternoon. In the meantime, local and federal officials have vowed to investigate who may be funding the massive cross country riots. LA County Sheriff Robert Luna on Wednesday said he found 'evidence' outside agitators or an organized group is behind the riots in the city, and said authorities were 'looking to see if there is a conspiracy of some kind or organization,' Newsweek reports. At the federal level, FBI Director Kash Patel also said the bureau 'is investigating any and all monetary connections responsible for these riots' as reports emerged that Chinese influence could be behind the chaos, according to The Signal. The US-based Party for Socialism and Liberation (PSL) organized some of last week's protests in response to the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) raids that snowballed into violence over the weekend. The Marxist revolutionaries also played a role in last year's anti-Israel protests that roiled Columbia University. PLS has ties to the Chinese Communist Party (CCP) through Neville Roy Singham, a Connecticut-born tech entrepreneur who operates from Shanghai. Singham, together with his wife, Jodie Evans, the founder of antiwar group Code Pink, have been investigated by House Republicans for promoting protests, dissent and unrest in the US for their bosses in Beijing. Yet even though there may be financial links between Singham, PSL and the peaceful demonstrations against Trump's immigration crackdown, there is nothing to suggest that those protestors are involved in any of the violence or looting in LA. Meanwhile, Republican Sen. Josh Hawley has turned the blame on a Los Angeles immigration organization, Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights, which he said is 'bankrolling' the unrest. In a letter to Angelica Salas, the head of the organization, Hawley wrote that it should 'cease and desist any further involvement in the organization, funding or promotion of these unlawful activities.' 'Credible reporting now suggests that your organization has provided logistical support and financial resources to individuals engaged in these disruptive actions,' wrote Hawley, who chairs the Judiciary Subcommittee on Crime and Counterterrorism. 'Let me be clear: bankrolling civil unrest is not protected speech. It is aiding and abetting criminal conduct.' Salas, though, has denied the accusations. 'This is trying to take away the spotlight from the pain and suffering that this administration is causing,' she told the LA Times. 'I refuse to make it about anybody else but them.'
