
Astrology's credibility crisis: The dangers of unrealistic promises
Dr Soham D Bhaduri is an eminent public health physician turned Vedic astrologer and inner change life coach. His works spanning healthcare to spirituality have appeared in several prestigious peer-reviewed journals and national dailies. He has served as Chief Editor of The Indian Practitioner for over six years. An exponent of Existential Monism, his no-nonsense attitude towards astrology stems from years of philosophical self-exploration, which taught him that the cornerstone of spirituality is to felicitously balance both reason and intuition. He sees astrology as rooted in the science of 'complex systems', which must be embraced as an invaluable tool for mapping and steering life instead of being dismissed as mystical fortune-telling. LESS ... MORE
A few days ago, I stumbled upon two impassioned conversations on a popular social media platform which bore testament to the wildly unrealistic proportions an average client's expectations from astrology have assumed. Even worse is how such expectations continue to be indulged and abetted by some astrologers who make promises that are way out of line.
In one instance, an enthusiast claimed that the true hallmark of an astrologer was the ability to make pinpoint predictions from the Lagna chart (the basic chart in Vedic astrology) alone, without bothering to even glance through any of the divisional charts. To this, respondent astrologers thought it fit to nod their heads in agreement. One of them even went so far as to propose that divine faculty is indispensable for astrological prediction. In yet another instance, one astrologer confidently expressed that astrologers must not enquire clients about their problems and questions. Instead, they should be able to perfectly predict what questions their clients must be having on their minds. No one bothered to communicate the true purpose that divisional charts serve in astrology, or the fact that at any point of time, one's horoscope can suggest several problems, many of which may not even be perceived by them as problems to begin with.
Put forthright, as I've discussed in my preceding blogs, the epithet 'cheap, quick, and sensational' characterizes much of astrological practice today. An average client seeks otherworldly levels of accuracy while offering piffling or no money and a truckload of ridicule at the same time. But the decisive nail in the coffin, that which perpetually inflates this dangerous trend, is the way astrologers respond to such demands. Very often, the average astrologer, in a desperate scramble to impress and hook clients, does everything that erodes the credibility and disregards the sanctity of true Jyotish – from being a grovelling Yes-Man to employing sleights of mind and making lofty promises in return for no apparent money. These then go on to fortify the popular public impression that it is only 'fair and normal' to expect astrologers not to ask for rightful remuneration and vilify those who don't oblige. The consequence is unmistakable – little value given translates to little value received, and in the process, credibility of the profession takes the severest blow.
The most important trait for an astrologer to imbibe today, apart from learning not to pander to every unrightful taste of their clientele – is honest, upright acceptance, more so in public dealings. While this might entail some short-term pains, ignoring it guarantees much worse long-term repercussions. As wonderful as astrology is, there exist limitations therein just like everywhere, and it is hence that astrology at bottom is more of a tool to 'guide' than to 'predict'. And astrologers failing to acknowledge these limitations has already dealt irrevocable levels of damage to the field. Drawing connections with ethereal and divine stuff only rubs salt on the wounds by further distancing astrology from accepted notions of what is 'credible'. Those who've followed my previous blogs will appreciate that astrology is embedded in complexity science and deals with arguably the most complex system there is – one which is rarely conducive to anything that is perfectly predictive. While this makes Jyotish a highly useful and one-of-a-kind tool to guide and navigate life, it introduces a prominent, ineluctable element of uncertainty and unpredictability which has to be embraced with an open mind.
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email Disclaimer
Views expressed above are the author's own.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


New Indian Express
11 hours ago
- New Indian Express
Nimhans takes yoga to rural Karnataka for patients with mental disorders
BENGALURU: While the government is working on improving the health of people in rural areas, the National Institute of Mental Health and Neurosciences (Nimhans) is working on strengthening their mental health through community-based yoga programmes. Under the Yoga-based Extension Services (YES) programme, experts from Nimhans will help patients with severe mental health disorders. The three-year YES programme was launched on Tuesday in two taluks -- Thirthahalli in Shivamogga and Turuvekere in Tumakuru. Dr Aarti Jagannathan, principal investigator, YES project, and Additional Professor of Psychiatric Social Work, Nimhans, said that based on the outcome after three years, it will be implemented across the state. Parallel to the YES programme, workshops will also be held with stakeholders to understand if any changes need to be made in the models and how it is being implemented in the community.

The Hindu
a day ago
- The Hindu
SVIMS to offer AI-based medical services soon, says TTD chairman
Sri Venkateswara Institute of Medical Sciences (SVIMS) will soon offer Artificial Intelligence based medical services and perform a higher share of surgeries through robotic arms, announced Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanams (TTD) chairman B.R. Naidu on Wednesday (June 11). He was speaking at the 13th convocation of the TTD-run medical university held here. He recalled the institute's meteoric rise right from it was conceived by the then Chief Minister the late N.T. Rama Rao in 1993 to getting on the verge of becoming an Institute of National Importance. The institute has been reaching out to the poor and needy patients from Rayalaseema for the past three decades, offering services to 1,500 out patients and 750 in patients everyday. 'SVIMS is only the second in the public sector in the country to run an all-women medical college, which is a matter of pride,' Mr. Naidu added. The college produces 175 female doctors every year in the specialties of cardiology, cardiac surgery, neurology, neurosurgery, nephrology, urology and oncology. Executive Officer J. Shyamala Rao congratulated the 501 young doctors graduating from the institute and hailed SVIMS for becoming the first public sector medical institute in India to perform triple transplantation surgery of heart, liver and kidney. Recalling the TTD's spending in medical infrastructure, Mr. Naidu listed out the new buildings under construction, viz., the cancer block, cardio neuro blocks, specialties block, central kitchen, central warehouse, staff quarters and accommodation for the patients' attendants. All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS-Madurai) director M. Hanumantha Rao, who delivered the convocation address, wanted SVIMS to become an institute of national importance soon. He said such institutes always have an edge in funding support, autonomy in decision making, curricular design, resource allocation, global recognition and scope for collaboration with other reputable institutions. 'SVIMS has all the requisites to become an INI', he remarked. SVIMS director and vice-chancellor R.V. Kumar read out the annual report and thanked the TTD trust board for taking up developmental works at the hospital. Scholars led by SVIMS dean Alladi Mohan showered Vedic hymns (Vedasirvachanams) on the graduates. Director of medical education (Academic) G. Raghunandan and SVIMS registrar Aparna R. Bitla also took part.


The Hindu
2 days ago
- The Hindu
NIMHANS launches Yoga-based Extension Services in community intervention programmes
To enhance rural mental health care through yoga interventions, NIMHANS on Tuesday launched Yoga-based Extension Services (YES) in its ongoing community intervention programmes at Thirthahalli and Turuvekere in Shivamogga and Tumakuru districts respectively. YES, will be a six-session, once a month face-to-face programme whenever a patient comes to the Primary Health Centre/hospital for a follow-up, for a 30-45 minute duration. Brochures/videos depicting yoga practice with instructions in the local language will be provided to encourage daily practice at home. Indian Council of Medical Research director-general Rajiv Bahl, NIMHANS director Pratima Murthy and National Medical Commission chairperson B.N. Gangadhar launched the YES programme on Tuesday. 'We expect to observe improvement in symptom severity, disability, social cognition, socio-occupational functioning, and well-being over six months, along with delivery and fidelity (support and challenges) of YES,' said Aarti Jagannathan, principal investigator of YES project and additional professor of Psychiatric Social Work at NIMHANS. Schizophrenia patients The Community Intervention Psychotic Disorders programme in Thirthahalli was started in June 2005 with research grants under the National Mental Health Programme. Since then, NIMHANS team has been examining clinically relevant research questions among these representative, community-dwelling schizophrenia patients. In addition to studying this cohort scientifically, the team has also been providing regular clinical services to these underserved patients. 'Nearly two-thirds of these patients were out-of-treatment, and our team has provided services to them at their doorsteps – while most receive follow-up care in their nearest primary health centres, a substantial proportion of patients are seen in their homes,' she said. Till date, 400 schizophrenia patients have been identified and are being treated and followed up regularly. Apart from these, thousands of patients with other neuropsychiatric and neurodevelopmental conditions are being treated. The Turuvekere intervention programme was started in December 2009. 'Like in Thirthahalli, our team aimed to identify and treat all patients with schizophrenia in the taluk. Till date, 325 patients with schizophrenia have been identified, treated, and are being followed up. The total number of patients with other psychiatric disorders is over 2,000,' the doctor explained. 'Yoga as a culturally appropriate intervention is found to be effective in improving the physical, mental health and well-being of persons with mental disorders in India. We wish to address this important clinical, public health and research gap through YES,' she said. The event also marked the International Yoga Day 2025 month, as well as for celebrating over 15 years of community mental health service at Tirthahalli and Turuvekere, she added.