Queensland university apologises for ‘hurt' and ‘offence' caused at anti-racism event
The head of the Queensland University of Technology (QUT) has issued an 'unreserved apology' for events at an anti-racism symposium last month that caused offence, adding the institute behind it would 'not be holding events like this in the future'.
Appearing before a federal parliamentary inquiry into antisemitism on university campuses on Wednesday, the vice-chancellor of QUT, Prof Margaret Sheil, was grilled over why the event went ahead despite concerns from community members about alleged 'anti-Jewish' speakers.
The university's Carumba Institute held the national symposium on unifying antiracist research at the Brisbane Convention and Exhibition Centre on 23 and 24 January.
Related: Billionaire's record $100m donation to University of Sydney aims to increase diversity in Stem sector
Sheil began her opening statement acknowledging that: 'At the debate, external speakers showed slides that caused offence to a number of people.'
Sheil said she 'unreservedly' apologised for the 'hurt and concern' the events caused to QUT staff, students and the community.
At a comedy event advertised as 'the greatest race debate' and as the official 'pre-event' to the symposium, a cartoon image of a character dubbed 'Dutton's Jew' was shown as part of one speaker's presentation.
The slide, presented by the head of the Jewish Council of Australia, Sarah Schwartz, criticised what she described as stereotyping of the Jewish community by the Coalition. It has been the subject of widespread critical coverage in some media.
Sheil did not name the speakers she was referring to, or identify the slides.
On Tuesday, QUT commissioned the former judge John Middleton KC to conduct an independent review into the symposium. Sheil told the inquiry she intended to accept the recommendations in full and would share the findings with the public.The chair of the parliamentary committee, Labor MP Josh Burns, pointed to correspondence to Sheil on 17 January from the Australian Academic Alliance Against Antisemitism, 'raising concerns about the upcoming conference'.
'Some of the concerns … [were] around the speakers at the conference who have a demonstrated history of engaging in anti-Jewish racism, including the spreading of disinformation, disparaging stereotypes about Jews, the doxing of Jewish individuals … and calls for the elimination of the Jewish state,' he said.
'How did you respond to that?'
Sheil said she 'became aware' of the correspondence when she returned from leave on 20 January. She said the university advised the organisers to shut down any form of hate speech should it occur, while also bolstering security. She told the inquiry no speakers were uninvited.
'Unfortunately, they didn't adhere to that,' Burns alleged, adding an award had been given at the symposium to the artist and editor Matt Chun, who Burns alleged had been involved in the doxing of Jewish creatives last year.
The inquiry also heard the deputy chair, Coalition MP Henry Pike, name Chelsea Watego, the head of the Carumba Institute.
He alleged that she said a leaked WhatsApp group of Jewish creatives was 'worth a read' and led a 'shame chant' at the symposium after someone leaked Schwartz's slide to Murdoch newspapers.
Sheil said she 'greatly value[d]' Watego's scholarship and work to address and eliminate racism and the alleged chant needed to be 'verified and assessed'.
But she said she was not in a position to comment on allegations about individuals and would provide all relevant material to the review.
'There are many, many things about this that I feel very sad about and I personally find unacceptable,' Sheil said.
'I am sadder and disappointed that these events overshadowed an important academic symposium on a very serious issue, especially as it relates to the lived experience of racism of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people,' she said.
'It is critical we learn from what happened to ensure that such a similar incident doesn't happen again … the Carumba Institute will not be holding events like this in the future.'
Senator Lidia Thorpe told the inquiry she had attended the symposium, which she described as 'terrific' and 'amazing'.
She asked Sheil whether she considered that 'conflating anti-Zionism with antisemitism undermines genuine efforts to combat racial and religious discrimination'.
The vice-chancellor said she sought to respond to how people 'interpret and receive criticism'.
'It's not my area of expertise,' she replied. 'I'm a chemist.'
Sheil said from 7 October 2023 until the end of last year, the university had received no formal complaints relating to antisemitism. There had been 11 complaints about racial discrimination in the same period.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
20 minutes ago
The Dutch government has collapsed. What happens next?
THE HAGUE, Netherlands -- Dutch opposition parties called Wednesday for fresh elections as soon as possible, a day after anti-Islam lawmaker Geert Wilders sparked the collapse of the country's four-party coalition government. Prime Minister Dick Schoof's 11-month-old administration fell apart when Wilders withdrew his Party for Freedom ministers. Schoof and the ministers of three remaining parties remain in power as a caretaker Cabinet. The government, with limited powers, now has to lead the country for months before new elections and during what could — again — be protracted talks to cobble together a new coalition in the fragmented Dutch political landscape after the vote. Lawmakers can declare some policy areas 'controversial' during the caretaker period. That restricts the government from taking concrete action on those issues. The Dutch electoral commission will schedule a general election for all 150 seats in the Second Chamber of parliament. It is very unlikely to happen before the fall because of a parliamentary recess that starts July 4 and runs to Sept. 1 and that will be followed by several weeks of campaigning. In a statement to lawmakers, Schoof said he wants to keep control, even in caretaker mode, of vital policies over the coming months. 'As far as I'm concerned, it's about security, both nationally and internationally, including support for Ukraine and everything that's needed for defense," he said. He also wants to be able to act on the economy, including the global trade war unleashed since the start of U.S. President Donald Trump's second term, "because that can have a direct effect on the Dutch economy and on our business community.' But Schoof acknowledged that some other policies will be put on ice until there is a new coalition. 'The last thing we want now is postponement, but it is unavoidable in some cases,' he said. They want to go to the polls. 'I hope we can organize elections as quickly as possible, in the shortest possible time,' said Frans Timmermans, the former European Commissioner who now leads a two-party, center-left bloc. Timmerman's bloc of the Labor Party and Green Left is challenging Wilders' party for top spot in Dutch polls. Wilders won the last elections in November 2023. Lawmakers used Wednesday's debate to attack Wilders for failing to make good while in office on his 2023 election pledges — in what sounded like a proxy electoral debate. 'You turned your back on these people,' Jimmy Dijk of the Socialist Party said, suggesting that Wilders apologize to his voters. And it's not just the opposition that wants elections. Wilders also is looking forward to campaigning. 'Let's go back to the voter,' he said. The government remains committed to hosting the meeting of government leaders from the NATO alliance in The Hague later this month. Foreign Minister Caspar Veldkamp took to X soon after the administration's collapse to stress that the meeting will go ahead despite the political turmoil. 'We remain fully committed to organising the #NATOsummit in The Hague. We look forward to welcoming all NATO Allies on 24 June,' he wrote. He also said the Netherlands will continue to support Ukraine in its war against Russian aggression. The Netherlands has provided key arms to Kyiv, including F-16 fighter jets. 'We remain committed to European cooperation and security. Dutch support for Ukraine is a key part of that,' he wrote.
San Francisco Chronicle
26 minutes ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
2 more attacks on Jews heighten concerns about security in and around US synagogues
For the leaders of U.S. Jewish institutions, the recent attacks in Boulder, Colorado, and Washington, D.C., are stark reminders of their responsibility to remain vigilant despite years of hardening their security measures and trying to keep their people safe. Now, they're sounding the alarm for more help after a dozen people were injured in Boulder while demonstrating for the release of Israeli hostages in Gaza on Sunday. And just over a week earlier, two Israeli Embassy staffers were fatally shot outside a Jewish museum in Washington. After that shooting, 43 Jewish organizations issued a joint statement requesting more support from the U.S. government for enhanced security measures. Specifically, they asked Congress to increase funding to the Nonprofit Security Grant Program to $1 billion. 'Every Jewish organization has been serious about security for years. We have to be,' said Rabbi Rick Jacobs, president of the Union for Reform Judaism. 'The grants are to harden the buildings, for things like cameras and glass, and some kind of blockage so they can't drive a truck into the building." 'These are the everyday realities of Jewish life in the 21st century in America. It's a sad reality, but it is an essential responsibility of leadership to make sure that people are first and foremost safe.' Shira Hutt, executive vice president at The Jewish Federations of North America, said existing federal funds were inadequate, with only 43% of last year's applicants to the grant program receiving funding. Citing the attack in Boulder, she said increased funding for local law enforcement is also crucial. 'Thankfully, the attack was stopped before even further damage could have been done,' she said. 'This is really now a full-blown crisis, and we need to make sure that we have all the support necessary." One of the Jewish Federation's state-based affiliates, JEWISHcolorado, on Tuesday launched an emergency fund to raise $160,000 in support of the Boulder community. Its goals include enhancing safety and security measures for Jewish institutions and events. Strengthening alliances and pushing for results Leaders of Jewish Federation Los Angeles urged government, business and philanthropic groups to 'supercharge an alliance so we can build mutual understanding, dispel conspiracy theories, and provide rapid response when any group is under threat.' 'Jews here in Los Angeles are terrified but determined,' said the federation's president, Rabbi Noah Farkas. 'We do not need more community meetings, we need results and we are counting on our local government and our law enforcement partners to do more.' The security costs at 63 Jewish day schools have risen on average 84% since the Israel-Hamas war began on Oct, 7, 2023, according to the Teach Coalition, the education advocacy arm of the Orthodox Union, an umbrella group for Orthodox Judaism. The coalition is advocating for more state and federal security funding for Jewish schools and camps, as well as synagogues. The attacks in Washington and Boulder only heighten the urgency, said its national director Sydney Altfield. 'Some people see this as an isolated instance, whether it is in Colorado, whether it's in D.C.,' she said. 'But we have to step up and realize that it could happen anywhere. … It is so important that our most vulnerable, our children, are secure to the highest extent.' In Florida, Rabbi Jason Rosenberg of Congregation Beth Am said members of the Reform synagogue in the Tampa Bay area 'are feeling very nervous right now and having some additional security might make people a little bit more comfortable.' He said that 'there's a definite sense that these attacks are not isolated events, that these attacks are, in part, the result of a lot of the antisemitic rhetoric that we've been hearing in society for years now.' However, he said part of his message as a faith leader in such a climate has been to encourage resilience. 'We can't let this define us. … We can't stop doing what we do; we can't stop coming to synagogue; we can't stop having our activities,' he said. 'Our job is to add holiness to our lives and to the world, and we can't let this stop us from focusing on sacred work.' Security concerns inside and outside Jacobs, the Reform Judaism leader, said the latest attacks in Washington and Boulder signaled that new security strategies were needed. 'Yaron Lischinsky and Sarah Milgrim were murdered outside of the event at the D.C. Jewish Museum,' he said. 'And that presented a whole additional sort of challenges for law enforcement and for each of our institutions doing security, which is: you can't just worry about who comes in; you actually have to worry about who's lurking outside, and so, that is part now of our protocols." The attack in Boulder, he said, took place during a 'peaceful protest' where demonstrators were calling for the release of Israeli hostages in Gaza. 'We have to worry about what happens inside our institutions. … We also have to be thinking and working with law enforcement about what happens outside.' Jacobs recalled that when a Christian leader recently visited a Reform synagogue, he was 'stunned by the security protocols,' which included procedures that Jacobs likened to passengers passing through airport security. 'I said, 'Well, what do you do in your churches?' and he said, 'Well, we like to be welcoming.' And I said: 'We don't have that luxury. We want to make sure our people feel safe, otherwise people will stop coming.'" ___
Yahoo
34 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Amid ongoing attacks, Jewish people are afraid. Is anyone listening?
This week, in Colorado, a Molotov cocktail was thrown at a group of Jews marching peacefully on behalf of hostages held by Hamas. The attacker shouted, 'How many children have you killed?' and 'We need to end Zionists' as he hurled fire at Holocaust survivors and Jewish children. In Washington, D.C., two Israeli embassy staff members were gunned down in cold blood. In Paris, the Holocaust museum was defaced. In London, a Jewish business was vandalized with red paint and smashed windows. Each attack happened in a different country. The perpetrators didn't know each other. And yet, every Jew I know understands how deeply they're connected. This is what Jewish anxiety looks like in 2025. Not just fear of a lone extremist – but fear of a global pattern no one wants to name. A time when violence against Jews isn't just ignored, but politically inconvenient to acknowledge. The attacker in Colorado wasn't reacting to silence. He was reacting to noise. To slogans. To lies. To the viral fabrication that 14,000 Palestinian babies would be starved in 48 hours – a claim with no evidence, pushed by some of the most trusted news outlets in the world. By the time fact-checkers caught up, the lie had triggered an already radicalized man, preparing firebombs in America. That's where the anxiety begins. Not with the fire – but with the match. Because we've seen this before. Words become slogans. Slogans become an ideology. And ideology, left unchecked, becomes violence. Not long ago, we were told to 'believe all victims.' But today, Jewish victims are asked to justify their pain. Were you wearing an Israeli flag? Were you near a protest? Are you a Zionist? Are you a European colonizer? As if our humanity is conditional. As if the firebomb wasn't about us – we just happened to be standing in the way. I come from the political left. My parents were Iraqi and North African Jewish refugees. My relatives were murdered, raped and tortured. From that pain, I learned not to hate, but to seek peace. I've stood for coexistence. I've criticized Israeli leaders when they fail our Jewish values. But today, that's not enough. Because if you are Jewish and visible, you are a target. And if you're attacked, you're met with silence – or worse, moral gymnastics. In case you missed it: Ye's antisemitic rant, that $20 swastika shirt and why we need to talk about it Mainstream media repeated Hamas' invented casualty statistics with barely a pause. Days later, the numbers were quietly revised. But those burned by the flamethrower will attest: It was a blood libel. Moreover, words matter. 'Globalize the intifada.' 'End Zionists.' 'By any means necessary.' These are not abstract ideas. They are instructions. They are adrenaline for the unstable. They justify horrific violence. What's most painful isn't just the attacks – it's the shrug. The way the Colorado firebomb wasn't covered until hours later. The way Jewish blood doesn't trend. The way those who claim to fight hate won't name this one. We're told: this isn't antisemitism; it's anti-Zionism. And yet, somehow, the flames always find the flesh of Jews. Why is it never OK to target people for a government's actions unless the people are Jewish? Does the 88-year-old Holocaust survivor lying in agony in a hospital bed deserve it? Does anyone? What world are we in where I have to explain that setting people on fire is evil and does no good? Deep dive: How a father of 5 morphed into a terror suspect with Boulder's Jews in his crosshairs The truth is, we are afraid. Not in a viral-post kind of way, but in the quiet way you hesitate before entering a synagogue. The way you scan a crowd before speaking Hebrew. The way you wonder if your accent or your name might be the thing that puts you in someone's crosshairs. And what we're asking is simple: to be seen. Fully. Not as a proxy. Not as a debate. But as human beings – hurting, vulnerable and real. The shooting in D.C., the firebomb in Colorado – these weren't the beginning. They were the result. And if we still can't name what led us here, we'll be even less prepared for what's coming next. Hen Mazzig is an Israeli-born writer, speaker, and digital influencer known for his powerful advocacy for Jewish identity and his fight against antisemitism. He is the co-founder of the Tel Aviv Institute, a nonprofit that launched in 2019 to counter online antisemitism through strategic, data-driven social media campaigns. In 2022, he published his debut book, The Wrong Kind of Jew. Hen Mazzig continues to inspire a new generation to embrace advocacy. Most recently he created his series "And They're Jewish" which celebrates Jewish diversity and builds bridges rooted in tolerance and peace. This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Boulder Colorado attack: How Jews feel amid antisemitism
