Brothers behind Irish franchises of Starbucks and TGI Fridays banned from acting as company directors
Two brothers behind various Irish franchises, including several Starbucks cafes, TGI Fridays, Mao and Hard Rock Cafe, have been banned from acting as company directors of any company for five years.
A High Court judge imposed the restriction after finding Colm and Ciaran Butler failed to prove they acted responsibly in their operation of one of their companies, Downtul Ltd, which leased a premises at St Stephen's Green, Dublin, that operated as a Starbucks.
In a judgment published on Wednesday, Ms Justice Nessa Cahill noted the brothers were directors of more than 130 companies each.
'It is plain from this fact – and from the vigour with which this application was opposed – that the declarations of restriction sought in the particular circumstances of this case would have significant implications for them, beyond the symbolic or reputational,' she said.
READ MORE
Her orders followed an application from the liquidator of Downtul, Patrick O'Connell. Downtul was placed into voluntary liquidation in November 2022.
Mr O'Connell later raised concerns that the brothers did not act honestly and responsibly 'with regard to their duties, responsibilities and actions' as directors of Downtul.
Arising from this, Mr O'Connell sought an order for the brothers to be restricted from acting as company directors or secretaries for five years unless the company meets certain requirements set out in the Companies Act 2014.
The Butlers opposed Mr O'Connell's application.
A hearing of the case lasted five days, with both sides calling expert witnesses.
Acceding to the liquidator's request, Ms Justice Cahill said she was not satisfied the brothers acted responsibly in relation to Downtul's affairs, but they showed they acted honestly.
Ms Justice Cahill said her findings arose primarily from the brothers' operation of Downtul and a related company they controlled, Atercin Liffey Unlimited Company.
Downtul's function was to lease a premises at Stephen Court, St Stephen's Green, and it did not trade or carry on a business. It entered into a lease agreement for the premise in December 2013, its sole transaction.
Atercin operated a Starbucks cafe out of the Stephen's Green premises. The judge noted that Atercin operated from the premises rent-free for 2½ years and obtained Government supports to deal with the impacts of the Covid-19 pandemic.
In effect, Downtul bore the liability and cost of the lease, while Atercin occupied the leased premises and earned revenue from its trade there.
The judge said Downtul received no contribution from Atercin towards rent due on the Stephen Court premises 'and, consequently, was unable to pay its debts as they fell due'.
'In allowing the company to enter and maintain these arrangements, and in failing to ensure an enforceable mechanism by which the company could obtain the funds necessary to discharge its liabilities as they fell due or otherwise protect its position, the respondents [the Butlers] failed to demonstrate responsible conduct with regard to the interests of the company,' the judge said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
More than 100 complaints of excessive legal costs upheld by regulator
More than 100 complaints of excessive legal costs, most relating to family law and litigation costs, were upheld by the legal services regulator last year. A 14 per cent rise in complaints about legal practitioners to the regulator last year was largely due to a high volume of complaints by banks alleging failures by solicitors to comply with undertakings, the report of the Legal Services Regulatory Authority (LSRA) for 2024 also disclosed. Published on Thursday, the report said 143 of the more than 1,400 complaints finalised against legal practitioners last year were upheld, while more than 40 per cent were inadmissible. Of the complaints upheld by the regulator's complaints committee, 107 related to legal services and excessive costs, of which more than 60 per cent related to costs of litigation and family law. The remaining 36 of those upheld related to alleged misconduct. READ MORE Fifty-seven complaints of alleged misconduct were referred by the committee to the separate Legal Practitioners Disciplinary Tribunal because the authority cannot itself make findings of misconduct against legal practitioners. The LSRA has since 2020 received and investigated three types of complaints about solicitors and barristers – relating to alleged misconduct, inadequate legal services and excessive costs (overcharging). Some are mixed complaints and the vast number are against solicitors, reflecting the higher number of solicitors and their greater level of contact with clients. [ Judge criticises 'millionaire' legal costs and says losing litigants should be told lawyers' hourly rates Opens in new window ] It received 1,476 complaints last year, up 14 per cent on the 2023 figure, of which 1,410 related to solicitors and 66 to barristers. More than half, 762 (52 per cent), alleged misconduct only, 350 (24 per cent) alleged inadequate standards of legal services, mostly relating to litigation and conveyancing, and 23 (1 per cent) were from clients relating to excessive costs (overcharging). The remaining 341 complaints (23 per cent) were complaints on mixed grounds, of which 262 included an allegation of misconduct, 328 of inadequate services and 147 of excessive costs. Most complaints, 600 (41 per cent) concerned legal professionals practising in Co Dublin, 146 (10 per cent) related to Cork-based legal practitioners, 66 to Limerick and 53 to Kerry. Multiple complaints may be brought against an individual practitioner. Of the 1,474 complaints closed last year, 621 (41 per cent) were closed on inadmissibility grounds. A total of 143 complaints (10 per cent) were upheld and 182 (12 per cent) were not upheld. A further 324 complaints were resolved between the parties, including 62 with assistance of the LSRA's mediators. The LSRA made 18 successful applications to the High Court for orders to enforce its directions in complaints against legal practitioners. [ Inside the childcare courts: 'Making money from the misery of children - that's distasteful' Opens in new window ] The authority's chief executive Dr Brian Doherty said it was 'encouraging' more than one in five of all closed complaints were resolved between the parties, including with assistance of the regulator's complaints staff and trained mediators. While informal resolution may not be appropriate in every type of complaint, the evidence is that informal resolution 'can be a very effective and efficient way for both parties to work through their issues or disputes', he said. The report noted continued growth in 2024 in partnerships of solicitors seeking to operate as Limited Liability Partnerships (LLPs). A total of 26 LLPs were authorised by the LSRA during the year, bringing to 509 the number authorised since November 2019 when LLPs were introduced. The number of barristers continues to increase. A total of 3,071 barristers were on the Roll of Practising Barristers by the end of 2024, up 20 on the previous year. Of these, 2,134 were members of the Law Library and 937 were practising outside of the Law Library.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
VAT rate for small businesses will be reduced permanently, Tánaiste tells party colleagues
The next Budget will be an 'expansionary package' with plans to permanently reduce the VAT rate for small businesses, the Tánaiste has said. Simon Harris told the Fine Gael parliamentary party meeting on Wednesday that Budget 2026 would be 'responsible and responsive', according to a source present. The Tánaiste is understood to have told those present that he and his party colleagues remembered 'very well' what the party canvassed on in the lead up to the general election. Among the measures discussed was a permanent reduction in the VAT rate for small businesses. READ MORE This was alongside remarks by Mr Harris that childcare fees for many families are 'like a second mortgage'. He told colleagues these costs must be 'permanently reduced' over the lifetime of the Government. He added that the cost of education, across all levels, must be reduced alongside healthcare costs, while 'significant progress' must be made in children's disability services and special education. Separately, the Fine Gael leader said he supported calls for post offices to receive €15 million per year in funding for the next five years. A report earlier this year from Grant Thornton found that the post office network requires this level of funding per year until 2030, without which the State faces the prospect of 'rapid, unrestrained closures', which would risk 'irreparable financial, economic and social harm'. Direct funding of €10 million annually from the State is due to expire at the end of this year. An Oireachtas committee on Wednesday heard that up to 400 post offices could close if the State does not increase aid.
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
GoCar reduces rental service in Limerick following ‘constant significant damage' to vehicles
One of the State's leading car-sharing operators says it has been forced to reduce its services in Limerick after months of anti-social behaviour targeting its vehicles in the city. GoCar, which is owned by French car rental group Europcar, allows users to rent cars for short periods of time, with fees starting from €9 an hour. It has proved popular with Irish motorists over recent years with many using it and similar car-sharing services as an alternative to owning a car. The company has invested heavily in its service over the last decade and has expanded its nationwide fleet to more than 1,000 since it first arrived in Ireland in 2008. READ MORE It expanded into Limerick in 2017 and has widened its service there in recent years, with 10 stations dotted around the city at one point. However, in a statement sent to its members this week, the company said it had been left with no option but to curtail service in the city, As of Wednesday afternoon, there were only four GoCar locations around the city offering short-term rental cars. The company said it was 'proud to be a part of the Limerick community' and said it valued the support of people who use the service in the city. 'We've worked hard to continue providing a reliable service, because we know how important it is to your daily life,' the company said. 'Unfortunately, months of persistent incidents of antisocial behaviour have caused constant significant damage to our vehicles and placed an unsustainable strain on our operations.' The statement added that 'as a result, we've had to make the very difficult decision to temporarily reduce the number of GoCars available in Limerick.' GoCar said it was aware the move would cause disruption to those that use its cars correctly and it apologised to those who would be impacted by the curtailment. 'Please rest assured that this is not a decision we've taken lightly,' the statement continued, adding that the company was 'working closely with local authorities and An Garda Siochana to address the issues and are doing everything we can to restore full service as soon as possible.'
