Victim of IRA attack allegedly involving British agent loses legal claim over probe ‘delay'
A man shot in an
IRA
attack that allegedly involved a British agent has lost a
High Court
battle against the police for temporarily diverting all available legacy-related resources to the
Omagh bombing inquiry
.
Desmond McCabe claimed the
Police Service of Northern Ireland
(PSNI) decision to put other sensitive research work on hold for six months unlawfully breached an entitlement to have his claim for damages against Peter Keeley determined within a reasonable time.
But a judge dismissed the challenge mounted on an alleged violation of Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights.
Mr Justice Humphreys ruled on Friday: 'The uncontroverted evidence in this case is that no delay at all, let alone unreasonable delay ... has been caused by the impugned decision.'
READ MORE
Mr McCabe survived an attempted murder bid carried out by the IRA in the Newry area in November 1990.
The shooting was among a series of attacks allegedly linked to Mr Keeley, a former British spy who infiltrated the Provisionals and who uses the pseudonym Kevin Fulton.
Damages are being sought against the one-time agent, along with the police and ministry of defence, in a claim for negligence, misfeasance in public office, conspiracy, assault, battery and trespass.
In March this year it was announced that all qualified PSNI researchers were being assigned to sensitive work on behalf of the public inquiry into the Real IRA bombing of Omagh in August 1998 which claimed the lives of 29 people, including a woman pregnant with twins.
The request for material on 32 other dissident republican attacks in the 1990s led to the PSNI pausing all other sensitive legacy-related casework for six months due to underfunding and resources.
Mr McCabe's lawyers claimed the decision was irrational and unlawfully breached Article 6 rights to have his civil action dealt with.
Judicial review proceedings were brought against the chief constable, and also the Department of Justice for an alleged failure to provide the necessary resources to progress legacy litigation.
But police insisted they have already provided sensitive discovery in a lead case among the series of actions related to the alleged activities of Mr Keely.
Correspondence on behalf of the PSNI contended that the temporary redirection of sensitive research resources was not affecting the civil action.
'No delay has been occasioned to the lead case, or Desmond McCabe's case, as a result of the Omagh bombing inquiry related reallocation of resources,' it stated.
Based on those assertions, Mr Justice Humphreys ruled that the challenge had no legal merit and must be dismissed.
He confirmed: 'The applicant has not established any arguable case with realistic prospects of success.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
6 hours ago
- The Journal
Ballymena to host first ever Pride Parade weeks after headline grabbing riots
THE ORGANISER OF the first ever Pride Parade in Ballymena has said he never considered cancelling the event, despite wide-scale rioting in the Co Antrim town earlier this month. Ballymena made headlines around the world after three nights of rioting earlier this month in which over 40 PSNI officers were injured. PSNI said the rioting erupted after a vigil to protest the alleged sexual assault in the town was 'hijacked' by 'racist thuggery'. Curtis Lee, the organiser of the first ever Pride Parade in Ballymena which will take place tomorrow, told The Journal: 'The committee's opinion was that, no matter what, we're going ahead with this because to cancel would be to give into fear. 'The theme of our event is 'love over fear' so to give into fear would have went against everything that Pride stands for.' He added that it 'didn't make any sense to us to cancel it because of the actions of a few individuals' and said that 'a lot of the people that caused damage were actually bused in to Ballymena'. During a visit to Ballymena by The Journal in the aftermath of the rioting, a member of a 'local regeneration group' remarked that there were 'definitely elements of the protest on Monday night that weren't local'. Lee told The Journal that while 'there is definitely racism in the town, to tarnish the whole town with the same brush is unfair'. He added that 'Pride will exist here to present an alternative vision of Ballymena'. Advertisement There will, however, be protests tomorrow from four evangelical Christian groups and Lee said this was something they expected would happen. 'Ballymena is the birthplace of Ian Paisley so it was always to be expected that there was going to be counter protests.' One of the four groups protesting is United Christian Witness, and the other three are local church groups. Lee said he is 'disappointed but not surprised' by the planned protests. Meanwhile, in one social media thread on the upcoming parade, someone commented that as a gay person, they 'couldn't wait to leave Ballymena'. 'I never thought I'd see the day there would be a Pride event there,' they added. Lee said that messages like these are 'the entire reason of why we're doing this'. 'Just that one day of visibility in the town can be life saving,' said Lee. 'I've had messages from parents of young people fearful for child's safety and who struggle with their mental health and they're excluded. 'To give a platform to make them feel welcome and to be seen is so important.' Lee added that he has spoke to many older people who said they never could have imagined that a Pride Parade could take place in Ballymena. Related Reads 'Bricks instead of beer': Stark images from NI photographer tell story of the Ballymena riots I went to talk to people in Ballymena, and was told to make myself 'scarce' or there'd be trouble 'Racist thuggery': How a peaceful vigil in Ballymena turned into anti-immigration violence 'As much as Pride has taken off around the world,' said Lee, 'I think there was always the expectation of, 'oh, that'll never happen here'.' But while there have been many messages of support, Lee acknowledged that some of the responses have taken him by 'surprise' and have been 'incredibly toxic'. Lee said he has been informed of an individual who is 'putting leaflets into local shops and businesses, asking them not to support Pride'. 'He's telling them that if they support pride, he will encourage local Christians to boycott their business.' Lee said many local business owners 'have been fearful of publicly supporting what we're doing'. 'We would never judge any business, because there is some uncertainty of what the response will be and things could escalate, especially after the riots,' said Lee. 'I would never expect any business to put themselves at risk. 'As much as I would like every business in the town to have rainbow flags, I can't expect everyone to scream from the rooftops about it. 'I hope we can get to that place down the line, but with this being our first parade, we expected this.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
11 hours ago
- Irish Times
Oisin Murphy can continue riding while under charges for drink-driving
Oisin Murphy will be able to continue riding until at least his court appearance on drink-driving charges next week. The four-time champion jockey was in action at Doncaster on Friday and has six booked rides at York on Saturday, the most high-profile meeting since he was charged while at Royal Ascot last week. Murphy (29) has been charged with one count of driving a motor vehicle while over the prescribed level of alcohol and one count of failing to co-operate with a preliminary test at the roadside after a collision in the early hours of Sunday, April 27th this year. He is due to appear at Reading magistrates court next Thursday. READ MORE It is understood the racing authorities, while monitoring developments, feel that nothing prevents Murphy from riding at present and the judicial process should be allowed to play out in the appropriate way. – Guardian
Irish Times
12 hours ago
- Irish Times
‘Are you staying or going?': The question all Irish emigrants eventually face
Ireland's long-standing history of emigration is reflected in a piece by Mark Paul , London Correspondent, in which he says, 'Over the decades the area had been a magnet for Irish immigrants, but the community aged. Younger London Irish now favour Hackney or Clapham. Meanwhile, Archway's green army went grey.' While Mark's piece centres around Martin Fallon, an 'old boy from Ireland' who died in May, he speaks to locals in the traditional London-Irish community about how things have evolved. It's interesting to consider the changing face of the Irish community in London, especially since – for the most part – the whys of leaving their homeland are generally the same after all this time. For Peter Flanagan, he says that when he first moved to the UK, he expected to stay about six months. Now, after six years, however, he's wondering will he ever leave. Having bought his first home in the English capital, though, he feels that's probably an indication – and not a conscious decision – that he's here for good. Despite this, Flanagan says: 'My real fear is staying in the UK so long that I go full Pierce Brosnan. So far removed from my place of origin that I become an awkward facsimile of myself. Half-remembered visions of my childhood blurring with drunken fever dreams. Perched on a barstool in a silk cravat, waxing lyrical about the old country to anyone who will listen. 'I do miss Éire,' I'd slur. 'My father built our family home from clay and sticks on the banks of the river Liffey. I often wonder if it's still standing.'' Something students considering a move to the US should bear in mind are new visa requirements introduced this week. In a statement on Monday, the US embassy in Dublin said the US State Department is 'committed to protecting our nation and our citizens by upholding the highest standards of national security and public safety through our visa process'. READ MORE The embassy said visa applicants will be required to list all social media usernames or handles for every platform they have used from the last five years on their visa application form so these accounts can be vetted. Taoiseach Micheál Martin condemned the new requirements as 'excessive' and said that they will cause 'fear and anxiety' among young people. Read more about the changes here . Columnist Laura Kennedy says there is always one question she is asked as an emigrant in Australia: 'Are you staying or going?' And while it may be a nudge from loved ones to get you home, it eventually becomes a real question in need of a serious answer. This month, she also looked at what Irish people are good at – digesting dairy, drinking and, of course, emigration. Our shortcoming? Pollen. And, by God, her allergies are not holding back in the hay fever capital of Canberra. As autumn hits down under, it's not letting up either. She writes: 'It does make me miss Limerick a bit, though, and its chaste plant-life that has the decency to die – or to play dead – once autumn shuffles in.' Adrian O'Sullivan, from Cork, has no plans to leave Berlin, which he first visited in 1988 as an 18-year-old. Speaking to Frank Dillon, he says he's noticed subtle changes over the years. 'When I came here first, what I often remarked upon was that, for Germans, everything is absolutely forbidden unless it is allowed whereas, for the Irish, everything is allowed unless it is absolutely forbidden. Sometimes Irish people have come here thinking they can do things the same was as they can in Cahersiveen, but that doesn't work.' Wicklow woman Orla McLaughlin lives in Venice and says she felt connected to the city from early on. She misses friends and family in Ireland, however, and returns once or twice a year, 'though it was easier when the children were younger. You inevitably miss out on some milestones and sharing some of your own too.' Finally, if, when you ask yourself should you stay or go, you decide a return to Ireland is on the cards, you may want to check out our guide on how to go about buying property in Ireland from abroad. Thanks for reading.
