US Judge Sides With Meta In AI Training Copyright Case
A US judge on Wednesday handed Meta a victory over authors who accused the tech giant of violating copyright law by training Llama artificial intelligence on their creations without permission.
District Court Judge Vince Chhabria in San Francisco ruled that Meta's use of the works to train its AI model was "transformative" enough to constitute "fair use" under copyright law, in the second such courtroom triumph for AI firms this week.
However, it came with a caveat that the authors could have pitched a winning argument that by training powerful generative AI with copyrighted works, tech firms are creating a tool that could let a sea of users compete with them in the literary marketplace.
"No matter how transformative (generative AI) training may be, it's hard to imagine that it can be fair use to use copyrighted books to develop a tool to make billions or trillions of dollars while enabling the creation of a potentially endless stream of competing works that could significantly harm the market for those books," Chhabria said in his ruling.
Tremendous amounts of data are needed to train large language models powering generative AI.
Musicians, book authors, visual artists and news publications have sued various AI companies that used their data without permission or payment.
AI companies generally defend their practices by claiming fair use, arguing that training AI on large datasets fundamentally transforms the original content and is necessary for innovation.
"We appreciate today's decision from the court," a Meta spokesperson said in response to an AFP inquiry.
"Open-source AI models are powering transformative innovations, productivity and creativity for individuals and companies, and fair use of copyright material is a vital legal framework for building this transformative technology."
In the case before Chhabria, a group of authors sued Meta for downloading pirated copies of their works and using them to train the open-source Llama generative AI, according to court documents.
Books involved in the suit include Sarah Silverman's comic memoir "The Bedwetter" and Junot Diaz's Pulitzer Prize-winning novel "The Brief Wondrous Life of Oscar Wao," the documents showed.
"This ruling does not stand for the proposition that Meta's use of copyrighted materials to train its language models is lawful," the judge stated.
"It stands only for the proposition that these plaintiffs made the wrong arguments and failed to develop a record in support of the right one."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Int'l Business Times
an hour ago
- Int'l Business Times
Syria's Wheat War: Drought Fuels Food Crisis For 16 Million
Rival Syrian and Kurdish producers are scrambling for shrinking wheat harvests as the worst drought in decades follows a devastating war, pushing more than 16 million people toward food insecurity. "The country has not seen such bad climate conditions in 60 years," said Haya Abu Assaf, assistant to the United Nations Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) representative in Syria. Syria's water levels have seen "a very significant drop compared to previous years, which is very worrying", Abu Assaf told AFP, as a relatively short winter rainy season and decreased rainfall take their toll. "A gap of between 2.5 to 2.7 million tonnes in the wheat crop is expected, meaning that the wheat quantity will not be sufficient to meet local needs," Abu Assaf said, putting "around 16.3 million people at risk of food insecurity in Syria this year". Before the civil war erupted in 2011, Syria was self-sufficient in wheat, producing an average of 4.1 million tonnes annually. Nearly 14 years of conflict have since crippled production and devastated the economy. The FAO estimates that harsh weather has impacted nearly 2.5 million hectares of wheat-growing land. "Around 75 percent of the cultivated areas" have been affected, as well as "natural pastures for livestock production", said Abu Assaf. To bridge the wheat gap, imports would be essential in a country where around 90 percent of the population lives in poverty. Before his ouster in an Islamist-led offensive in December, Syria's longtime ruler Bashar al-Assad used to rely on ally Russia for wheat. In April, new authorities reported the first wheat shipment since his removal arrived in Latakia port, with more Russian shipments following. Iraq also donated more than 220,000 tonnes of wheat to Syria. During the war, Damascus competed with the semi-autonomous Kurdish administration in the northeast to buy wheat from farmers across fertile lands. Last year, Assad's government priced wheat at $350 per tonne, and the Kurds at $310. After Assad's ouster, Damascus and the Kurds agreed in March to integrate Kurdish-led institutions into the new Syrian state, with negotiations ongoing on implementation. Damascus set wheat prices this month at between $290 and $320 per tonne, depending on the quality, plus a $130 bonus. The Kurdish-led administration offered $420 per tonne including a $70 bonus. Damascus' agriculture ministry expects a harvest of 300,000 to 350,000 tonnes in government-controlled areas this year. Hassan Othman, director of the Syrian Grain Establishment, acknowledged Syria was not self-sufficient, in comments on state television. But he said authorities were working "to ensure food security by importing wheat from abroad and milling it in our mills". In northeast Syria's Amuda, farmer Jamshid Hassu, 65, inspected the tiny wheat grains from his fields, which cover around 200 hectares (around 500 acres). Despite heavy irrigation efforts to offset scarce rainfall, he said, production has halved. The FAO's Abu Assaf said indicators showed that "about 95 percent of rain-fed wheat has been damaged and affected", while irrigated wheat yields were down 30 to 40 percent. Hassu, who has been farming for four decades, said he had to pump water from depths of more than 160 metres (525 feet) to sustain his crops as groundwater levels plunge. Agriculture remains a vital income source in rural Syria, but without urgent support, farmers face ruin. "Without support, we will not be able to continue," Hassu warned. "People will suffer from poverty and hunger." Before the war, Syria was self-sufficient in wheat, producing an average of 4.1 million tonnes annually, but 14 years of conflict crippled production AFP A flock of sheep grazes in a field on the outskirts of Qamishli AFP The FAO estimates that harsh weather has impacted nearly 2.5 million hectares of wheat-growing land AFP
Int'l Business Times
8 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
The DSP-Agnostic Approach That Gives AI Digital an Edge in Fragmented Media Buying
The digital advertising ecosystem has become fragmented. Major platforms like Google, Meta, and Amazon have built what industry insiders call "walled gardens", closed ecosystems where advertisers must play by the platform's rules, often with limited transparency into how their campaigns perform. AI Digital 's response was to develop an "Open Garden" philosophy, a DSP-agnostic approach (demand-side platform) that allows advertisers to work across multiple platforms while maintaining central coordination. This neutrality is rare in an industry where many service providers are incentivized to push specific platforms. "We designed our model to be agile and partnership-friendly," says Magli, CEO. "There are no rigid commitments, no minimum spend or lock-in periods, so teams can scale with us at their own pace." This flexibility has proven particularly valuable for small and medium-sized agencies that previously could not access premium programmatic inventory due to budget constraints. Human Intelligence, Enhanced by AI As artificial intelligence (AI) has become a buzzword across industries, AI Digital's approach is unique for its emphasis on human expertise. With over 300 digital media professionals, including planners, optimizers, and strategists, the company iterates that technology should complement rather than replace human judgment. Its slogan, "Built on human intelligence, enhanced by AI," Is the outlook. It is a stand that distinguishes it in a market where many competitors promote full automation as the ultimate goal. The company's newest offering, the Elevate platform, launched in April 2025, symbolizes this balanced approach. Elevate provides AI-powered media planning that can generate complete campaign blueprints in as little as 30 seconds based on inputs like budget, target audience, geography, and campaign goals. Beyond Traditional Metrics One of AI Digital 's most significant deviations from industry norms is its focus on business outcomes rather than traditional advertising metrics. "Besides the traditional metrics like CPMs, impressions, CPCs, we provide business outcomes. For example, how the campaign affected your revenue," explains Stephen. This switch from measuring impressions and clicks to tracking actual business impact represents a maturation in how digital advertising effectiveness is evaluated. By connecting advertising spend directly to revenue generation, AI Digital helps clients justify their marketing investments to finance departments and C-suite executives who care more about bottom-line results than awareness metrics. The Smart Supply Advantage For enterprise clients with in-house marketing teams, AI Digital offers a service called Smart Supply, a highly optimized premium traffic for targeted campaigns. "We provide these audiences to you in an ID format, in a code format. If you insert it within your campaign manager, it shows to them," Stephen explains. "We do not have any access to their campaign managers. We do not change anything, but we optimize the traffic on an ongoing basis." This approach allows large agencies to maintain control of their campaigns while benefiting from AI Digital's expertise in audience targeting—a crucial capability as third-party cookies phase out and targeting becomes more challenging. Growing Against the Odds AI Digital has established a niche in the industry. The company has expanded from approximately 100 employees in 2024 to over 300 today, with offices worldwide, though it remains primarily remote-first with headquarters in Miami. April 2025 marked two significant milestones: the launch of the Elevate platform and the opening of the company's first Canadian office in Montréal, focusing particularly on the unique Québec market. This growth comes despite, or perhaps because of, increasing challenges in the digital advertising landscape. As privacy regulations tighten and third-party cookies disappear, advertisers need partners who can navigate these changes while still delivering results. The Transparency Imperative Perhaps the most consistent theme across AI Digital's offerings is transparency, which shows clients exactly how their advertising dollars are spent and what results they generate. This transparency extends to the company's use of artificial intelligence. While many AI systems operate as "black boxes," making decisions that even their creators cannot fully explain, AI Digital has prioritized explainability in its Elevate platform. The system provides clear rationales for its recommendations, projecting how changes might improve campaign performance. For example, rather than simply suggesting a budget reallocation, Elevate might explain that shifting 20 percent of spend from one channel to another could increase conversion rates by an estimated 15 percent. This approach addresses what AI Digital calls "the biggest blind spot in advertising today", the fact that advertisers increasingly depend on AI-driven systems they don't understand.
Int'l Business Times
10 hours ago
- Int'l Business Times
G20 President S.Africa Warns Global Turmoil Hurts Poorer Nations
Global fragmentation is fuelling unprecedented turmoil and disproportionately harming poorer nations, South Africa's foreign minister warned Thursday, urging a united G20 response for peace. Ronald Lamola made the remarks to dozens of diplomats from the G20 group of the world's leading economies meeting to prepare for its summit in November under South Africa's presidency. "State rivalries are fuelling fragmentation, with economic decoupling, and proxy conflicts undermining global stability," the foreign minister said, referring to multiple major conflicts and humanitarian crises under way. This was "exacerbating fragility in vulnerable regions while also weakening multilateral institutions that underpin the rules-based international order," he said. South Africa is the first African nation to hold the rotating year-long presidency of the group made up of 19 countries plus the European Union and the African Union that together represent around two-thirds of the world's population and 80 percent of its GDP. Pretoria wants to use its presidency to champion Global South priorities, including boosting climate resilience and tackling poor countries' debt, before handing the baton to the United States next year. Speaking to AFP, Lamola said he was hopeful that the talks at the Sun City resort 185 kilometres (115 miles) northwest of Johannesburg "will persuade and help to encourage the message of peace, good friendly neighbours and the language of de-escalation." Resolutions taken by the bloc are non-binding in nature and the diverse grouping has often failed to reach a consensus. However, many members hold seats on the UN Security Council or are involved in conflict resolution efforts, making the G20 "an important platform" and "very persuasive", Lamola told reporters. Lamola said he was not concerned that the United States -- the bloc's richest member -- did not send a representative to Sun City. "We have received their letter of apology, in which they stated their reasons," he said. "We believe that the G20 can proceed with or without the US, but they are important in terms of participation." Relations between South Africa and the United States plummeted this year over a range of international and domestic policies and US Secretary of State Marco Rubio skipped the G20 foreign ministers' meeting in Cape Town in February. Keen to salvage his summit, South African President Cyril Ramaphosa tried at talks with Donald Trump in May to have the US leader commit to attend the Johannesburg meeting. The Russian representative at the Sun City, Svetlana Lukash, was non-committal about the attendance of President Vladimir Putin, saying only he will take part "in some way". Putin missed the previous G20 summits in India and Brazil, avoiding possible political opprobrium and any risk of criminal detention under an International Criminal Court (ICC) warrant. Lukash said G20 members remained divided over Russia's war in Ukraine but were less fixated on the conflict than they were when it started in 2022. The war has split the G20, with Western countries condemning the invasion and pouring military and financial aid into Ukraine, while Russia has courted support from emerging powers such as Brazil, China and India. "Most of the world closed their eyes on numerous conflicts around the world due to dominance of Western views," she said. But more countries now recognised the "double standards", Lukash said.
