logo
Perspective: Abuse in our prisons is killing our humanity

Perspective: Abuse in our prisons is killing our humanity

Yahoo23-03-2025

'Don't tell anyone,' said a prison guard, lowering his voice, 'but I'm not here to be violent.'
We wore protective vests and carried handcuffs, pepper spray and a radio with a button to press if attacked. I had been hired as the first Latter-day Saint chaplain in the federal prison system and the first female chaplain at that particular penitentiary.
By the time the officer confided in me, I was hearing rumors of abuse in our isolation unit: officers withholding food; verbally and sexually harassing incarcerated men; physically assaulting them. I reported these rumors to my supervisor but saw no response.
Advocacy groups have long raised alarms about abuse in prisons beyond the view of cameras. Numerous incidents highlight the severity and pervasiveness of this issue.
Nearly a year into my time in the prison, one guard bragged that he and other guards punished incarcerated men beyond what the courts assigned. They did this in the isolation unit, where cameras were scarce. When I told my supervisor, he said the guard might be joking. I wrote a report to a special investigations team, but I had no evidence to corroborate the claim. I do not know the outcome of my report, because I resigned shortly after filing it.
My worries about violence within prison walls have resurfaced due to recent events. Ten former New York state prison guards have been charged for their role in the fatal beating of Robert Brooks on Dec. 9. Body camera footage shows officers pummeling Brooks while handcuffed on a medical examination table at Marcy Correctional Facility. If the officers had not been wearing body cameras — which they seemingly didn't realize were recording — the true cause of Brooks' death might have never come to light.
During the trial of the officers implicated in Brooks' death, thousands of New York State correctional officers went on a strike that lasted 22 days and cost the state millions of dollars daily. During this period, at least seven prisoners in New York facilities lost their lives. One of them, 22-year-old Messiah Nantwi — imprisoned at a facility just across the street from where Brooks was killed — may have been assaulted by officers. Nine incarcerated men alleged that he had been beaten by staff.
The protesting officers demanded safer working conditions, fewer mandated shifts and the repeal of the Halt Act, which limits solitary confinement. New York Gov. Kathy Hochul and the New York State Correctional Officers and Police Benevolent Association reached a tentative agreement outlining key provisions to address these concerns.
More state and federal policy makers should consider similar provisions. Correctional officers in facilities across the nation face burnout under extreme conditions. Mandatory overtime shifts lead to chronic sleep deprivation, impaired cognitive function and compromised safety. Overworked staff navigate violent conditions where it is easier to maintain control when prisoners are seen as objects rather than people. Incarcerated individuals, already scarred by systemic injustice, are further exposed to violence, deepening the cycle of harm and survival rooted in trauma.
In my year serving inside the prison in 2021, I witnessed the consequences of this cycle. One officer recounted how a prisoner murdered a fellow officer. Every day, he wondered who might be next. All of us — incarcerated men and staff — constantly scanned our surroundings in a life-threatening environment where the fear of death was a matter of course.
We need a rethinking of policies that created today's mass incarceration system. Not only is the system unjust; it's unsustainable. But addressing systemic issues and creating policy change takes time — time that officers and incarcerated people don't have when their lives are at risk daily.
Deaths continue to occur beyond the reach of surveillance. A 2024 Justice Department report examining deaths in Federal Bureau of Prisons facilities from fiscal years 2014 to 2021 found that in at least 64 cases, cameras were either absent, inoperative or failed to provide sufficient coverage. Of those cases, 18 deaths were classified as homicides. More recently, on Dec. 30, in the isolation unit at a federal prison in Pennsylvania, Terry Flowers died after being 'placed in a holding cell where he continued to spit at and kick employees until he became unresponsive,' according to a local news report. It remains unclear whether this was a standard medical emergency or if other factors contributed to his death. Flowers' family and the public may never know.
As a chaplain, I communicated with families whose loved ones had died, whether from a medical emergency or assault. I witnessed the pain of families questioning what had happened. The uncertainty of not knowing the cause of a loved one's death behind bars deepens an already painful situation. I recall a particularly emotional conversation with a father who kept saying, 'I'm just trying to bury my son.'
For everyone's sake — incarcerated individuals, staff and families — we need to immediately increase surveillance in all prisons, as Hochul proposed in New York. This not only deters abuse of those incarcerated but provides legal protection for officers when prisoners file false claims against them.
Understanding the mental toll of isolation, the high rate of suicides in isolation units and the impact of these units on officers, we should limit the time incarcerated individuals spend in isolation and the time officers work in isolation units. Prioritizing adequate rest after standard shifts rather than imposing overtime is essential to maintaining safety and well-being in high-security settings.
Finally, independent reviews, in addition to those of the Department of Justice, should be conducted to help prevent systemic abuse and increase accountability. Their results must be made public for transparency and accountability.
Reforming our prison system requires a fundamental shift in how we view punishment, accountability and human worth. The call for reform is not just about preventing death. It's about seeing our shared humanity and reclaiming our responsibility to one another.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

State lawmakers will vote on prison reform package in last days of session
State lawmakers will vote on prison reform package in last days of session

Yahoo

time7 hours ago

  • Yahoo

State lawmakers will vote on prison reform package in last days of session

Jun. 10—ALBANY — State lawmakers will consider, and most likely pass, a legislative package meant to overhaul parts of the state prisons and county jails — the culmination of months of debate in the face of serious problems in the state corrections system. On Monday afternoon, one bill with language from 10 smaller pieces of legislation was drawn up and introduced in the Senate and Assembly. In about 20 pages, it lays out new rules regarding body cameras, death notifications for incarcerated people, autopsy reports for people who die in state custody, expands and gives more power to the state oversight committee and the independent prison monitor, and extends the statute of limitations to sue the state for emotional or physical injury that resulted from negligence in state or county facilities. The packages were introduced as a result of negotiations among the Democratic majorities in both the state Assembly and Senate — those negotiations resulted in this deal which both majority conferences have agreed to vote to pass. Altogether, the package would require the release of video footage related to the death of an incarcerated person involving security staff to the Attorney General's Office of Special Investigations within 72 hours in most cases; empower the Attorney General to address conflicts of interest within that office to limit instances where the AG has to appoint a special prosecutor; require the installation of a fixed-camera surveillance system in all state prisons and local jails, requires that when someone dies in prison that DOCCS report the death publicly and inform the next of kin within 24 hours; expands the state Commission on Corrections; orders a study on deaths in the prison system to develop a plan to reduce those deaths; requires quarterly reports from the DOCCS special investigations office; mandates more information including x-rays and photographs be included in autopsy reports done on people who die in prison; and permits that the independent Correctional Association of New York can access public records without submitting a FOIL request and can tour a prison with only 24 hours notice. The package doesn't include everything that lawmakers have been considering for reform this year. Some more progressive lawmakers had advanced a larger package, which they called the Robert Brooks Blueprint for Justice Reform — named after the man who was killed by corrections officers in a brutal attack, caught on body cameras, in December. The Brooks package included 22 bills that would have addressed many aspects of the state prisons, expanding the Department of Corrections power to discipline its security staff, creating an ombudsman's office for the prisons, requiring both professional and security staff to intervene in incidents of violence, as well as expanding parole, good behavior time credits, medical care and rights for incarcerated people and specifically pregnant people in jails and prisons, among other bills. The package introduced Monday doesn't include the bills to address parole or earned time, it doesn't address medical care in the prisons or expand rehabilitative programming or alternative court programs. Some lawmakers aren't satisfied with the lack of parole or good-time reforms in this package, arguing that the state prisons have gotten significant attention and are in a serious crisis now and that lawmakers should have used that attention and clear problem to make more significant reforms. But others acknowledged that changing the entrenched practices of the corrections system will take time. Assemblymember Emily Gallagher, D-Brooklyn, is a leading sponsor for one bill in the package, the bill to add more members to the state Commission on Corrections. Gallagher's bill, carried by Senator Julia Salazar, D-Brooklyn, would add six members to the existing three that sit on the SCOC, three appointed by the Senate and three appointed by the Assembly, coupled with the existing three members appointed by the Governor. Gallagher said that she hopes, with a larger SCOC and more specific requirements that members of the commission represent backgrounds in psychiatry, social work, corrections or have experience as an incarcerated person, the oversight group will take a more active role in reforming and holding the state prisons accountable. Gallagher and other lawmakers have criticized the SCOC for failing to effectively operate for years now — the group hasn't held a public meeting longer than 14 minutes in at least three years. Despite the ongoing staffing crisis in the state prisons, the two high-profile murders of incarcerated people by COs within the last year, and the estimated 70-plus other deaths of incarcerated people just this year, the SCOC has not held a public meeting longer than 3 minutes this year. On Tuesday, Gallagher and a group of supporters rallied in support of her bill and the omnibus prison reform package — acknowledging that it's a step along the way to what they want, and not the full package. "The package as a whole will increase oversight and provide an essential layer of protection, accountability and transparency," Gallagher said. "It's not enough, but it's certainly a first step. It is an essential first step if we are to meaningfully move the needle for our incarcerated community members." The state Legislature has just a few days to advance this package if it's to pass this year; the Senate will leave town on Thursday, not scheduled to return until January, while the Assembly will leave town for the year on June 17. It's not clear what the Governor's position on the bill is either, as she doesn't comment on legislation before it's delivered to her desk for final approval. If the package passes the legislature, Hochul can choose to sign it as-is, veto it entirely or make significant amendments for the legislature to review next year.

Plastic surgeon jailed for trying to kill colleague
Plastic surgeon jailed for trying to kill colleague

Yahoo

time2 days ago

  • Yahoo

Plastic surgeon jailed for trying to kill colleague

A plastic surgeon has been jailed for life for attempting to murder a colleague he wanted "out of the way" because he was a witness against him in disciplinary proceedings. Jonathan Peter Brooks broke into Graeme Perks's home in Halam, Nottinghamshire, in the early hours of 14 January 2021, wearing camouflage gear and armed with a crowbar, cans of petrol, matches and a knife. A trial in Loughborough heard Mr Perks had a "95% chance of dying" after being stabbed by Brooks. Brooks, who was convicted of attempted murder, attempted arson with intent to endanger life and possession of a bladed article, was told he would serve at least 22 years in prison. On the night of the attack, Brooks smashed conservatory doors and doused the ground floor of the house with petrol, intending to set it on fire. Mr Perks, a consultant plastic surgeon who had recently retired, was woken by the break-in and initially mistook the defendant for his son, before Brooks stabbed him in the abdomen. The trial previously heard Mr Perks's injuries were "of the most serious type", and included a bleeding liver, injuries to the pancreas and bowel, and an "extremely life-threatening injury" to the back of the abdomen. Brooks appeared via video-link from HMP Norwich after refusing to attend the court in person, having claimed he had a bedsore that meant he would be unable to sit for long periods. The judge said he was informed Brooks was physically fit to attend, and there was no reason he could not. Throughout the hearing, Brooks moved around in his room, occasionally standing from his wheelchair. He was sitting looking towards the camera as his sentence was handed down. This breaking news story is being updated and more details will be published shortly. Please refresh the page for the fullest version. You can receive Breaking News on a smartphone or tablet via the BBC News App. You can also follow @BBCBreaking on X to get the latest alerts.

2 Tacoma officers who saved man from burning car awarded Medal of Valor
2 Tacoma officers who saved man from burning car awarded Medal of Valor

Yahoo

time5 days ago

  • Yahoo

2 Tacoma officers who saved man from burning car awarded Medal of Valor

Officers Victor Celis and Cory Correia did not think twice before they rescued David Brooks from his burning car two months ago. For that, they've received a prestigious award Thursday. Celis and Correia were dispatched April 29 to the 900 block of South 96th Street for a single-car crash. A car had struck a pole and fence, with its engine compartment fully engulfed in flames, according to the Tacoma Police Department. Brooks had been driving the vehicle and was still inside when the officers arrived. 'The only thing I remember at that point was I came back to senses, or whatever it might have been, noticing that my airbag had deployed, my car's on fire and I pressed my panic alarm,' Brooks told The News Tribune at a ceremony held to honor Celis and Correia. 'The operator comes on and I said, 'My car's on fire, and I don't think I can get up.'' Celis and Correia pulled Brooks out of the car and had to navigate the smoke, flames and downed wires to move him to a safe distance from the fire. 'Once I was basically at safety, the only thing else I heard was, boom. The car had exploded,' Brooks said. The incident left Brooks with a crushed heel and several fractured bones in his body. Brooks said he was in the ICU and eventually taken to a general room at a hospital. Now, he is going through rehabilitation and recovery. Celis told The News Tribune that saving Brooks was just instinct. 'You don't think about what you're doing. You just go in and you get it done,' Celis said, 'You gotta help him, that's the whole point.' For the rescue, Celis and Correia were awarded the Medal of Valor at the police headquarters. This medal is the highest honor given to police officers in the country for acts of bravery and heroism that went beyond what is normally expected. Both officers told The News Tribune they had learned they were being awarded the Medal of Valor once the ceremony began. 'It feels great,' Correia said when he was asked how receiving the honor felt. 'I think the chief made a good point saying that any one of these other officers would do the exact same thing.' Correia has been with TPD since 2019, while Celis joined the department in 2022. Celis has been in law enforcement for 28 years, and will be joining the Fircrest Police Department in July as their newest chief of police. Interim Police Chief Patti Jackson awarded Celis and Correia their medals during the ceremony as members of the department watched. City manager Elizabeth Pauli, family members of the officers, Brooks and his family also were in attendance. 'Despite the spreading fire, both officers put themselves in harm's way to save the driver's life without waiting for assistance from the Fire Department,' Lt. Shawn Mallot said at the ceremony. Brooks' brother, Steven, thanked the officers in his remarks during the ceremony. He said he had written a letter to Jackson in May, which summarized how grateful his family was. 'These officers are a very good example of what being an unselfish hero is all about,' he said.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store