Supreme Court of Canada agrees to weigh in on B.C. First Nations' title dispute
The Supreme Court of Canada has agreed to weigh in on a dispute between First Nations that have overlapping land title claims in British Columbia.
The overlapping claims involve the Gitanyow Nation, the Nisga'a Nation and the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation, and Canada's high court on Thursday agreed to hear appeals of decisions by lower courts in B.C.
The Gitanyow Nation's title claims overlap with the Nisga'a Nation's claims, which are covered by a treaty, and both the B.C. Supreme Court and Court of Appeal denied the Nisga'a's bid to be added as a defendant in the Gitanyow's case, which is scheduled for trial in B.C. Supreme Court next month.
The Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation also has overlapping claims with the Gitanyow, and the Supreme Court of Canada is now poised to decide how courts will handle complex title disputes between First Nations.
Lawyer Ryan Beaton, a member of the Tsetsaut Skii km Lax Ha Nation's legal team, says hearing the cases separately would have been 'inefficient' and the high court now has 'an opportunity to speak to how these overlapping cases should be litigated.'
Beaton says the top court has yet to address how courts should deal with overlapping title claims, and its decision will set down guidelines and principles 'for how these types of overlaps will be litigated' in the future.
'In B.C., especially with most First Nations not having treaties with the Crown, there are many title claims and many potential title cases that will involve overlapping claims,' he said.
During Elections
Get campaign news, insight, analysis and commentary delivered to your inbox during Canada's 2025 election.
'We said to the Supreme Court and, urging them to take this appeal, that there needs to be some guidance from the country's highest court on how the courts, lower courts, should deal with these cases as they start to come now.'
This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 24, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBC
6 hours ago
- CBC
Manitoba premier hints at using emergency powers to open up hotel rooms for wildfire evacuees
Manitoba's premier says his government could use emergency powers to free up hotel rooms for people who escaped the wildfires still raging in the province's north. Premier Wab Kinew told reporters Thursday the province along with partners in the hotel industry have opened thousands of rooms for the more than 21,000 people who've fled the fires — but that there's still many families sleeping on cots weeks after the government declared a provincewide state of emergency. "We have emergency powers. We've been very restrained in how we're using them and we don't want to use them," he said, calling on hotel operators sitting on rooms to voluntarily open them up for evacuees. "For those operators of hotels who aren't stepping up, we need to see more," he said. "We all know that there's more rooms out there that we could be tapping into." The premier made the remarks after landing in Winnipeg following a trip to the front lines of the battle against the largest wildfire currently raging in the province. For his final stop, Kinew toured the congregate shelter that's been set up to welcome evacuees in Thompson, about 400 kilometres north of Winnipeg as the crow flies. It's "pulling at the heartstrings when we see families with kids sleeping on cots in a hockey rink," he said. "There's rooms in Thompson people could be accessing and I'd like to see those opened up. There's rooms in other parts of the province.… We're not talking about forever here." Some First Nations leadership have been urging the province to free up the hotel rooms for evacuees. WATCH | Province takes over security at Winnipeg evacuee shelter amid safety concerns: Province takes over shelter security after wildfire evacuee safety concerns 5 hours ago Duration 2:38 Safety concerns have prompted the Manitoba government to take over security at a congregate shelter in Winnipeg for people fleeing from the 21 active wildfires in the province. Meanwhile, officials say rain and cooler weather have helped to fight the fires, but hotter, drier weather is raising the fire danger. Last week, Pimicikamak Cree Nation Chief David Monias wrote a letter calling on the government to use emergency measures to make the rooms available. Kinew said he hasn't heard feedback from any hotels declining to host evacuees, but that the province has "a lot of data" about the rooms that are currently occupied. "I feel confident saying we know that there's more that some in the hotel sector can do," he said. Flin Flon 'like a scene out of a movie': premier The premier started Thursday's tour in Bakers Narrows — where firefighters are staging their response to the fire threatening the City of Flin Flon and other communities. The province's largest fire was 307,780 hectares as of the latest fire bulletin Thursday afternoon. "What really strikes me is that we're in a helicopter there with somebody who's been in the Manitoba Wildfire Service for decades and they say you'd have a big fire, you know, once every eight years or so," Kinew said. "Now, it's every single year we're getting these massive blazes and they're happening earlier and its going later into the year." After Bakers Narrows, the premier went into Flin Flon, where roughly 5,000 people have been forced out of their homes. The city is about 630 kilometres northwest of Winnipeg. "If you've ever been to Flin Flon, it's a city like many others in Manitoba," Kinew said, noting the usually busy streets are now deserted. "You go there right, now, it's like a scene out of a movie." Kinew said he met firefighters from all over the province in Flin Flon, including volunteers using their vacation time to help out as well as recently trained First Nations firefighters. He also said he met people coming from the U.S. and thanked them for stepping up. The crews have "held this huge, massive wildfire at bay. The biggest wildfire that we can recall being on their doorstep, and they've done it by working together," he said. "It's amazing just to see the co-operation to protect such an iconic city."
CBC
13 hours ago
- CBC
N.W.T. ministers press feds to maintain Jordan's Principle funding through 2026
Northwest Territories politicians are lobbying federal officials to extend Jordan's Principle funding through 2026. Earlier this year, Indigenous Services Canada (ISC), announced it would be narrowing the range of eligible requests under the program that was created to ensure First Nations children don't face gaps or service denials because of their identities. The announcement has created uncertainty in N.W.T. schools, where many education assistant positions (EAs) are funded with money from Jordan's Principle. In Yellowknife Education District No. 1 (YK1) alone, schools are bracing to lose 79 EAs. On a trip to Ottawa earlier this month, N.W.T. Education Minister Caitlin Cleveland said she and other N.W.T. cabinet ministers stressed the urgency of the funding, in as many meetings as they could. "If you want more tradespeople, if you want to be able to really focus on Arctic sovereignty, if you want to build healthy communities together and be able to focus on economic development as a country, as one economy, it really does rely on children having access to education," Cleveland told CBC News. "And that's what Jordan's Principle is about." The changes in Jordan's Principle come after some reportedly used the funding for things like home renovations, gaming consoles and, in one case, a zip line kit. Cleveland acknowledged those abuses of the program but said that's not what's happening with education bodies using Jordan's Principle funds for EAs. "We are seeing education bodies really work hard to ensure that they are carrying the spirit and intent of the policy … and addressing the needs of Indigenous children," she said. The changes would also mean that every Jordan's Principle funding application must come from a referral by a health-care professional. N.W.T. Health Minister Lesa Semmler said that will further strain a system already stretched thin. "When we look at the amount of children that are going to need assessments and referrals, that is going to put a huge burden," Semmler said. "And many of our small communities where these children are getting supports don't have a health professional." Cleveland said their federal counterparts seemed to understand their concerns when they met in Ottawa this month. But she says the N.W.T. officials didn't hear an answer, or a timeline for when they might know whether the funding will be extended. "We simply don't have those answers, but we're going to continue to pull the levers that we have," she said. Cleveland said they're also in the process of coming up with a contingency plan in case the federal government does not extend the funding. "This is one of the things that certainly does keep us up at night because of the dire impacts that it could have. We have a fragile system," she said.
Global News
20 hours ago
- Global News
Continued failure to consult on uranium exploration a harmful mistake: Mi'kmaw Chiefs
Nova Scotia's continued failure to consult with First Nations on uranium exploration is a mistake that will further erode the province's relationship with Mi'kmaq communities, says the Assembly of Nova Scotia Mi'kmaw Chiefs and a lawyer from Sipekne'katik First Nation. Pictou Landing First Nation Chief Tamara Young said the Mi'kmaq people were neither consulted nor notified when Nova Scotia introduced then passed a bill that opens the province up to potential uranium mining and fracking. 'The lack of consultation is unacceptable and goes against the UNDRIP (United Nations Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples),' Young said in a statement to The Canadian Press on Wednesday. The assembly has said they will continue to oppose both uranium exploration and hydraulic fracturing until their environmental concerns have been addressed. The provincial government added uranium to its list of priority critical minerals May 14, and it issued a request for exploration proposals for three sites with known deposits of the heavy metal. Interested companies had until Wednesday to submit their proposals. Story continues below advertisement Premier Tim Houston has said the legislative changes are needed to help the province withstand economic challenges from American tariffs. 'We recognize there are international pressures and influences affecting our economy, but any resource development in Mi'kma'ki must include our consent and participation as we are the rightful owners of these lands, waters and resources,' Young said in the statement, speaking as co-lead of the environment, energy and mines portfolio on behalf of the Assembly of Nova Scotia Mi'kmaw Chiefs. Rosalie Francis, a Mi'kmaq lawyer whose firm is based out of Sipekne'katik First Nation, said the province risks further damaging their relationship with Mi'kmaq communities and sabotaging the potential uranium industry by failing to consult adequately and early. 'By choosing not to consult, it scares away investors, destroys the relationship and gets us back to starting at zero,' Francis said in an interview Tuesday. 'It all comes down to trust, and this completely diminishes any kind of trust.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Meanwhile, four municipalities have recently called on the government to slow down its push for uranium exploration, CBC News reports. Pictou County was the first to do so, followed by the West Hants Regional Municipality, the Municipality of the District of Lunenburg and the Municipality of the County of Annapolis. Each council is asking the province for an indefinite delay to allow for consultations and information sessions. Story continues below advertisement Nova Scotia has opened up three plots of land for uranium project proposals: an 80-hectare site in Louisville in Pictou County; a 64-hectare site in East Dalhousie in Annapolis County; and a 2,300-hectare site in Millet Brook in Hants County. Much of this is on private land. The government has previously said companies selected by the province would have to seek permission from landowners to explore. However, Section 26 of the province's Mineral Resources Act allows the natural resources minister to intervene if there is a stalemate. A spokesperson with the Department of Natural Resources said if a company decides it wants to develop a mine on one of these sites, then there is duty to consult with Mi'kmaq communities. 1:57 Concerns raised about N.S. move to allow fracking and uranium mining Francis said that position is backwards, and is not in line with case law on the matter. Story continues below advertisement 'It's been clear that duty to consult begins when, in the minds of government, they're anticipating activity that will affect rights,' Francis said, adding that should happen before a company has made a decision on the site. The lawyer said it would appear the province has not learned from the fallout of the Alton Gas cavern project, which was officially scrapped in fall 2021. The Alberta energy company abandoned its plan to create huge salt caverns north of Halifax to store natural gas more than 13 years after starting construction. The company said at the time the project experienced challenges and delays, referring to opposition the project faced from Indigenous protesters and allies who opposed the company's plan to remove large, underground salt deposits by flushing them out with water from the nearby Shubenacadie River. The plan also called for dumping the leftover brine into the tidal river, where it would flow into the Bay of Fundy. In March 2020, a decision by the Nova Scotia Supreme Court ordered the province to resume consultations with Sipekne'katik First Nation on the matter and determined the former environment minister was wrong when she concluded the province had adequately consulted with the First Nation about the project. 'The province should have walked away from that decision and said, 'OK, lesson learned.' The project never went forward. All the gas investors looked at it and said, 'This is just a mess now. Let's just walk away,'' Francis said. Story continues below advertisement The lawyer said it will be telling in the coming weeks if the province chooses to engage with Mi'kmaq communities or 'if the province will march along in the same way it did before.' 'Either we'll have a success story or we'll have another Alton Gas play out,' she said. Shiri Pasternak, a criminology professor at Toronto Metropolitan University and co-investigator of a research project called Infrastructure Beyond Extractivism, said the situation in Nova Scotia mirrors the expedited extraction movement that's happening across the country. 'What's happening to the Mi'kmaq in Nova Scotia is really proliferating as an attack on Indigenous and environmental rights across the country right now,' she said in an interview Tuesday. Pasternak said Nova Scotia is one of several provinces working to speed up extraction and development projects — moves that are supported by the federal government. 'We have this sweep of fast-tracked legislation and policy changes to the Environment Assessment Act, both provincially in Nova Scotia and in other places, but also federally in terms of the Impact Assessment Act in order to expedite development and extraction — most of which will be against the desires and the consent of Indigenous people across the country.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 12, 2025.
