Runcorn and Helsby debate: Five things we learned
With the Runcorn and Helsby by-election around the corner, the candidates from the five biggest parties in the constituency at the last election were invited to take part in a live debate on BBC Radio Merseyside, with contributions from other candidates played out during the programme.But what did we learn from those who took part?
1. Call for 'fair playing field' for town centres
Runcorn Shopping City came up - with one listener describing it looking like something from 28 Days Later.Liberal Democrat Paul Duffy said he thought there was a national issue with town centres. He said there should be higher taxes on global corporations."Yes, everybody uses Amazon, but when you use Amazon you're not using a town centre, so we need to give them a fair playing field to get people back in to town centres.Green Party candidate Chris Copeman said he would like to see living/working spaces considered - although when asked if he would live in Runcorn Shopping City he said it would "need quite a lot of work to make it good".Conservative Sean Houlston said there needed to be a vision for the area and that he would use his business skills to attract investment, Sarah Pochin of Reform UK said she would want to put money into people's pockets so they could spend in town centres.Labour's Karen Shore said that Shopping City, which is in private ownership, "has had its day" but she said there needed to be someone to talk to the owners, "bring heads together and bring in investment".
2. For whom the bridge tolls
The ever controversial tolls on the two bridges in the constituency - the Mersey Gateway and the Silver Jubilee - were brought up by listeners.Currently, residents living in the part of the constituency covered by Halton Borough Council - that includes Runcorn - get unlimited free trips across the bridge after paying an annual admin fee. But those who live in other areas which fall into Cheshire West and Chester Council's area are not eligible for this.Green candidate Chris Copeman said he wouldn't want the tolls scrapped - instead he said he'd want more investment in public transport, although he also said there were circumstances for businesses where he would like a special rate.Reform's Sarah Pochin said she would campaign for the tolls to be scrapped, and Conservative Sean Houlston said he wasn't in favour of any further increases.Paul Duffy of the Liberal Democrats said he would want all parts of the constituency to be involved in the local discount scheme which is currently only for residents of Halton, while Labour's Karen Shore said she was a "pragmatist" and would put a case to the Labour Metro Mayor Steve Rotheram for the middle ground.
3. What's your first priority?
One listener asked what was the first thing that the candidates would do to improve the lives of their constituents if elected.Labour's Karen Shore said her priority was investing in public services.Sarah Pochin of Reform UK said her priority would be to tackle illegal immigration.Meanwhile, Paul Duffy said as a Liberal Democrat he would be a voice of influence on the current government, and added that the Labour government had listened to some of the ideas of the party.Conservative Sean Houlston said he would bring together a local team of residents and people who wanted change and "get them talking and I'd listen to what they want to do", and also "spread the message" on investment opportunities.Chris Copeman of the Green Party said he would push for regeneration in the area, highlighting that he would like to see more social and affordable housing projects.
4. Disagreements over HMOs, immigration and campaign messages
One listener spoke about claims during the campaign about the number and nature HMOs (houses of multiple occupation) which he said was "not the reflection of the experience of many local residents", and asked how the candidates would ensure their actions and campaigns were "based on facts rather than fear?'Conservative Sean Houlston said he had a "positive message" about Runcorn and Helsby."When people raise concerns, we get to the bottom of facts and we address them."Meanwhile Sarah Pochin of Reform UK said she had been speaking about concerns over HMOs after hearing from local residents and being shown CCTV of issues including drug dealing, and said she believed some of the people were illegal immigrants.She was asked if she had called the police to report these issues, and she said that some of those who had gone to her did not want to be identified.Paul Duffy of the Liberal Democrats criticised her for not calling the police and said residents had been in touch about HMOs asking for people to "stop trashing our area".Labour's Karen Shore said she agreed with Paul Duffy and that she felt it "wasn't a true reflection of the area".Meanwhile, Green Party candidate Chris Copeman said he believed the issue was a "distraction" and that the "politics of fear" was emerging.
5. 'This is not a general election'
As this is the first by-election since Labour won the general election, it is being seen by some as the first mayor electoral test for Sir Keir Starmer. But Conservative Sean Houlston said this election was about "who is going to be the next strong, local MP"."It's not a general election, it's not an opinion poll," he said.And he added that he did not want the area to be "a headline for a day and forgotten about for years to come".Other candidates also said throughout that they would want to be a strong voice if elected to stand up for the area nationally. Local links were highlighted as well as candidates' passion for the area throughout the hour-long debate.
The Runcorn and Helsby by-election takes place on 1 May and you can see minute manifestos from the candidates here.
Who are the candidates?
A total of 15 candidates are standing in the by-electionListed alphabetically, they are as follows:Catherine Anne Blaiklock (English Democrats)Dan Clarke (Liberal Party)Chris Copeman (Green Party)Paul Duffy (Liberal Democrats)Peter Ford (Workers Party)Howling Laud Hope (Monster Raving Loony Party)Sean Houlston (Conservatives)Jason Philip Hughes (Volt UK)Alan McKie (independent)Graham Harry Moore (English Constitution Party)Paul Andrew Murphy (Social Democratic Party)Sarah Pochin (Reform)Karen Shore (Labour)John Stevens (Rejoin EU)Michael Williams (independent)
Read more stories from Cheshire on the BBC and follow BBC North West on X. For more local politics coverage, BBC Politics North West is on BBC One on Sunday at 10:00am and on BBC iPlayer.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ITV News
44 minutes ago
- ITV News
PM announces national inquiry into grooming gangs scandal
Sir Keir Starmer has announced the government will launch a national inquiry into the grooming gangs scandal, despite resisting calls for one for months. It comes after the government commissioned a review into the scandal by Baroness Louise Casey, which has recommended a national inquiry and is due to be published in full next week. The prime minister told reporters as he travelled to the G7 summit in Canada: 'I have read every single word of her report and I am going to accept her recommendation. That is the right thing to do.' Since the scandal became a point of fierce political discussion earlier this year, the government has repeatedly insisted there was no need for a national inquiry, instead launching five locally-led investigations. The prime minister had previously argued another inquiry would delay justice for the victims of the scandal, saying the government wanted to get on with implementing the recommendations of a 2022 inquiry into child sexual exploitation. 'From the start I have always said that we should implement the recommendations we have got,' the PM told reporters.'I have never said we should not look again at any issue - I had wanted to be assured that on the question of any inquiry, that's why I asked Louise Casey, who I hugely respect, to do an audit.' Pressed on the detail of the inquiry, the PM said: "It will be statutory under the inquiries act, that will take a bit of time to sort out exactly how that works and we will set that out in an orderly way." Debate around tackling grooming gangs raged earlier this year after tech billionaire and X owner Elon Musk began attacking Sir Keir Starmer and his government, accusing them of being "complicit" in the scandal. Both the Conservatives and Reform UK have repeatedly called for a national inquiry into the previously accused Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch of 'jumping on the bandwagon', by calling for a national investigation. The Conservatives had tabled an amendment to the Crime and Policing Bill that was due to be voted on in Parliament next week, calling for the government to set up a national statutory inquiry within three months. In response to the announcement on a statutory inquiry Badenoch said: 'Keir Starmer doesn't know what he thinks unless an official report has told him so. 'Just like he dismissed concerns about the winter fuel payment and then had to u-turn, just like he needed the Supreme Court to tell him what a woman is, he had to be led by the nose to make this correct decision here. 'I've been repeatedly calling for a full national inquiry since January. It's about time he recognised he made a mistake and apologise for six wasted months.' The government had previously argued that there had already been a national inquiry into the grooming gangs, referring to the 2022 Jay Inquiry into child sex abuse. The Jay inquiry described the sexual abuse of children as an "epidemic that leaves tens of thousands of victims in its poisonous wake". It looked into abuse by organised groups following multiple convictions of sexual offences against children across the UK between 2010-2014, including in Rotherham, Cornwall, Derbyshire, Rochdale and Bristol. In November last year, Professor Jay said she felt "frustrated" that none of the probe's 20 recommendations had been implemented more than two years after its conclusion. Reports in The Times newspaper suggest the Casey review will say that white British girls who were targeted by grooming gangs were 'institutionally ignored for fear of racism'. The Casey audit was originally due to take three months from when it was announced in January.
The Herald Scotland
an hour ago
- The Herald Scotland
Community visibly emotional during candlelit vigil for Air India crash victims
One of the most emotional moments of the vigil came when Harrow Mayor, Councillor Anjana Patel, shared that two young girls had lost their father in the crash, just weeks after their mother died from cancer. People attend a multi-faith vigil at the Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow, London, for the victims of the Air India crash (James Manning/PA) Their father, Arjun Patoliya, had flown to Gujarat to scatter his wife Bharti's ashes following her death. He was returning home to his daughters, aged four and eight, when the plane went down. 'The saddest incident we have got here in Harrow is one parent had already died here because of cancer,' Cllr Patel said, as the crowd audibly gasped. 'The husband went to do the rituals in India and coming back, he was on board. He has left two little girls behind and the girls are now orphans. 'I really hope that those girls will be looked after by all of us.' She added: 'Caring is the most that we can do at this hour. 'We don't have any words to describe how the families and friends must be feeling, so what we can do is pray for them.' Bob Blackman, Conservative MP for Harrow East speaking during the vigil (James Manning/PA) She also revealed how her sister-in-law's cousin had been killed in the crash. Local councillors, a local MP and residents packed into the temple for the ceremony, which included emotional tributes, candle lighting, and a message of condolence from the King. Bob Blackman, MP for Harrow East, said it was believed to be the highest number of British deaths ever recorded in a plane crash, with 53 UK nationals on board. 'When someone dies in illness or old age, we celebrate their lives,' he said. 'But when an air crash happens – completely unpredictable – people are taken away from us immediately, just like that.' 'We think of all those families sitting by the telephone, wondering if their loved ones were actually on the plane.' People attend a multi-faith vigil at the Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow, London, for the victims of the Air India crash (James Manning/PA) He said the Gujarati community in the UK was deeply affected, with victims having links to Harrow, Leicester, Birmingham and beyond. 'The difficulty the authorities have already got is: who are they visiting? Which family members were they coming to see in the UK?' he said. Councillor Hitesh Karia, who represents Pinner South ward and is a member of the temple's congregation, also shared the impact of the tragedy. Speaking to the PA news agency, he said: 'It's nice that the local community can come together – the local support means a lot. 'Twenty devotees that come here have sadly lost their lives.' 'It shows there is a solidarity, and despite the high amount of diversity, we can come together when appropriate.' People attend a multi-faith vigil at the Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow, London, for the victims of the Air India crash (James Manning/PA) The vigil was held at the temple led by Shri Rajrajeshwar Guruji, who previously told PA he knew 20 of the victims personally. Many in the hall quietly wept as candles were lit by representatives of all four faiths. 'The only feeling left is sadness – we can't do any more,' Mr Guruji said.
South Wales Argus
an hour ago
- South Wales Argus
Community visibly emotional during candlelit vigil for Air India crash victims
Faith leaders from the Hindu, Muslim, Christian and Jewish communities led the service on Saturday at the Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow, north-west London, where 20 of the victims are thought to have previously worshipped. One of the most emotional moments of the vigil came when Harrow Mayor, Councillor Anjana Patel, shared that two young girls had lost their father in the crash, just weeks after their mother died from cancer. People attend a multi-faith vigil at the Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow, London, for the victims of the Air India crash (James Manning/PA) Their father, Arjun Patoliya, had flown to Gujarat to scatter his wife Bharti's ashes following her death. He was returning home to his daughters, aged four and eight, when the plane went down. 'The saddest incident we have got here in Harrow is one parent had already died here because of cancer,' Cllr Patel said, as the crowd audibly gasped. 'The husband went to do the rituals in India and coming back, he was on board. He has left two little girls behind and the girls are now orphans. 'I really hope that those girls will be looked after by all of us.' She added: 'Caring is the most that we can do at this hour. 'We don't have any words to describe how the families and friends must be feeling, so what we can do is pray for them.' Bob Blackman, Conservative MP for Harrow East speaking during the vigil (James Manning/PA) She also revealed how her sister-in-law's cousin had been killed in the crash. Local councillors, a local MP and residents packed into the temple for the ceremony, which included emotional tributes, candle lighting, and a message of condolence from the King. Bob Blackman, MP for Harrow East, said it was believed to be the highest number of British deaths ever recorded in a plane crash, with 53 UK nationals on board. 'When someone dies in illness or old age, we celebrate their lives,' he said. 'But when an air crash happens – completely unpredictable – people are taken away from us immediately, just like that.' 'We think of all those families sitting by the telephone, wondering if their loved ones were actually on the plane.' People attend a multi-faith vigil at the Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow, London, for the victims of the Air India crash (James Manning/PA) He said the Gujarati community in the UK was deeply affected, with victims having links to Harrow, Leicester, Birmingham and beyond. 'The difficulty the authorities have already got is: who are they visiting? Which family members were they coming to see in the UK?' he said. Councillor Hitesh Karia, who represents Pinner South ward and is a member of the temple's congregation, also shared the impact of the tragedy. Speaking to the PA news agency, he said: 'It's nice that the local community can come together – the local support means a lot. 'Twenty devotees that come here have sadly lost their lives.' 'It shows there is a solidarity, and despite the high amount of diversity, we can come together when appropriate.' People attend a multi-faith vigil at the Siddhashram Shakti Centre in Harrow, London, for the victims of the Air India crash (James Manning/PA) The vigil was held at the temple led by Shri Rajrajeshwar Guruji, who previously told PA he knew 20 of the victims personally. Many in the hall quietly wept as candles were lit by representatives of all four faiths. 'The only feeling left is sadness – we can't do any more,' Mr Guruji said.
