logo
Why school can be the best medicine for children in hospital

Why school can be the best medicine for children in hospital

Irish Examiner13-05-2025

Every morning across Ireland there are parents contemplating whether their child really is 'too sick' to go to school.
Meanwhile, the pupils of Temple Street Hospital School, at CHI at Temple Street, are attending classes from their hospital beds and even isolation units to avoid missing out on the childhood experience. All the while, its teachers are doing everything in their power to help children thrive, despite inadequate staff numbers and limited resources.
The principal of the hospital school is calling for an end to staffing shortages at the facility amid struggles to provide one-to-one classes for its young patients.
Ann Higgins was speaking as HOPE congress 2025 takes place this week in Dublin. Hosted by HOPE — the hospital teachers of Ireland — the event includes everything from panel discussions to testimonials from former patients, and the staffing challenges facing hospital teachers across Ireland.
Ms Higgins said her school currently has 18 school-going patients. While the hospital classroom can facilitate small groups, many of the children are unable to leave their hospital beds. This poses obvious challenges for the team, which is made up of two secondary and three primary school teachers.
Despite their limited numbers, staff members including deputy principal Ciara Jenkins have been doing everything they can to ensure kids don't miss out on important educational milestones including school tours.
The Gate Theatre and Dublin Zoo were among the locations visited by some hospital school students who have been well enough to enjoy temporary leave from hospital.
Teachers also take a proactive approach by individualising lesson plans to cater to the child's interests. Ms Higgins is keen to see the team expand to ensure more children suffering from illnesses and physical trauma receive individual attention.
She said urgent action is needed in response to staffing issues.
'It is groundbreaking what is happening here at the moment because we're going to have the National Council for Special Education reviewing our staffing allocation. This is really important because we don't have enough staff here. The first thing any hospital school will tell you is that we are pretty much predominantly understaffed. This is because our staffing allocation hasn't been reviewed by the Department of Education for years.
'For example, today our deputy principal had 18 children on two wards. These are not like the children you have in your run-of-the-mill classrooms. Students are in wards. They are in beds after surgery. Some of them can't get out of their beds. Teachers come to kids in isolation with PPE equipment. We are talking about every type of need. These children, generally speaking, need one-to-one support but this is just not possible.'
Temple Street Hospital School principal Ann Higgins. Picture: Gareth Chaney
She expressed hope that their concerns over staffing levels will be listened to and heard.
'We had our first visit from the NCSE and we've been told that there will be a second visit looking at our staffing. Obviously time is of the essence. We are fighting to have our voices heard.
'The recently-formed National Association of Special School Principals are supporting us too and have written to the NCSE to try and ensure that we have our staffing review done in a timely way. This will help us look at what staffing we're going to have on site for September. It will enable us to do recruitment in line with every other school in the country instead of always being on the back foot.
'It's really difficult because we are presented in here every day with a different number of children. For us, every single day is like the first day of September.
'We have a database and we upload our enrolment for the day and every day that's different. It's very challenging for teachers because they might have children who are here for a longer stay. Those children would always be prioritised for the teacher. However, we also have a cohort of children that is changing literally on a daily basis. Hospital schools are categorised by the Department of Education as special schools. However, up until recently we weren't supported by the NCSE.
'It's a huge development to think we will be supported by them. This is also a huge milestone for hospital schools.'
The principal spoke about what sets hospital teachers apart.
'The teachers have to be thinking on their feet constantly. They are the most creative and intuitive teachers because they need to be.
'Other teachers in schools can plan for their whole year in advance. Our teachers have to plan every day. They may even make a plan for the following day. However, that can go belly up for all kinds of reasons.'
She described the positive impact their school has on its pupils' social and emotional development.
'There was a little boy here who was due to start junior infants last September. When the time came for his first day of school he just wasn't well enough. It was an awful shame he was missing out on meeting all his classmates. His teacher and our teacher worked together and they organised for him to have a zoom call every single morning he came to the hospital classroom. They clicked into his classroom down the country and watched all his little pals. Every one of them could see him and they made sure he was doing the same activities as his classmates in the school at the same time. It meant that when the time came for him to go back to school they all knew him.
'The teacher often came on screen and chatted to him so that when he was eventually well enough to attend school for the first time they were all familiar to him.'
Teachers at the school often liaise with other frontline workers to establish the best way forward for the children.
'We don't work in isolation. We're part of a multidisciplinary team where there will be a lot of discussion with people involved in all of the disciplines including speech and language therapy, physiotherapy, and occupational therapy. This is never a teacher going off on a solo run. It's always a team decision when deciding if a child is well enough to do their exams.'
She lauded the determination of her students.
'Children are often sitting their junior search exams here. They can be children who are here for a long period of time. Some think they have missed out on the opportunity until we explain that we can set ourselves up as an exam centre and collect the papers from a nearby school. The children and their determination is the most important part for me. We had a young man who did his junior cert here last year who started his exams in the hospital classroom only to find he was in too much pain to sit in the chair for long periods. He continued the rest of his exams from his bedside and was facilitated in doing his exams there. We will do everything we can to be as adaptable as possible.'
Deputy principal Ciara Jenkins said the school experience can normalise hospital for many children.
Temple Street Hospital School vice principal Ciara Jenkins at CHI at Temple Street. Picture: Gareth Chaney
'It mimics the school experience for them in a way that normalises hospital,' Ms Jenkins explained.
'The kids are used to coming and learning with other children in the classroom setting, so it certainly helps with that kind of thing.
'They also make little pals as well. The kids often ask about their friends and are keen to catch up with them.
'They know what's expected of them in a school setting whereas the hospital can be an uncertain environment for them. It's scary sometimes. When it comes to their health you know that the children don't have a choice but in school we try and offer lots of choice to make them feel that little bit of control. They want to be able to experience normality.'
A Department of Education spokesperson said the department 'provides funding and staffing for schools attached to seven hospitals where children are treated as inpatients'.
'The department also funds education provision in a small number of on-site schools attached to Camhs inpatient units.
'As part of the annual special school staffing review, the staffing arrangements for hospital schools and schools attached to Camhs units are currently being reviewed.
'The National Council for Special Education is leading on this work and engaging directly with these schools. The outcome of the review process will be communicated directly to each of the schools concerned.'

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Letters to the Editor, June 10th: On clinical governance, alcohol tax and gardening leave
Letters to the Editor, June 10th: On clinical governance, alcohol tax and gardening leave

Irish Times

time21 hours ago

  • Irish Times

Letters to the Editor, June 10th: On clinical governance, alcohol tax and gardening leave

Sir, – I write as both a mother and a scientist. In 2023, when my daughter was just four years old, she was recommended for hip surgery to treat developmental dysplasia of the hip (DDH) under the care of Children's Health Ireland (CHI). We were deeply concerned about whether the procedure was truly necessary and ultimately chose to decline it. We sought a second expert opinion who reviewed her medical records and imaging, confirming what we had feared: our daughter no longer had DDH and had never needed surgery in the first place. We were lucky. Too many families were not. The revelations about unnecessary hip surgeries are just one part of a far wider institutional collapse. From the use of non-medical grade spring devices in spinal surgeries, to the misappropriation of National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) resources, what's becoming clear is that these failures are not isolated – they are systemic. Clinical governance, patient safety, and ethical standards were compromised across CHI. Children with complex needs were not treated with dignity or respect, but as burdens to be managed. READ MORE As a scientist, I am appalled. I cannot comprehend how invasive surgeries were conducted without solid clinical evidence, peer oversight, or proper audit. This betrays the most basic principles of evidence-based medicine. As a parent, I am devastated. The very system meant to care for our children ignored parental concerns, dismissed expert warnings, and placed vulnerable lives at risk. This crisis did not emerge in silence. Since 2017, advocacy groups – many led by parents – have raised alarms about systemic dysfunction within CHI. Their warnings were persistent, informed, and largely ignored. Had they been taken seriously; my daughter would never have faced this decision – and countless other children might have been spared real harm. We cannot accept vague apologies or bureaucratic delay. What is needed is a full public enquiry, criminal investigations where warranted and accountability at every level of CHI and the HSE, and binding reforms to ensure this never happens again. The lives and the futures of children depend on it. Ireland's children deserve care that is safe, ethical, and humane. Nothing less. – Yours, etc, DR THERESE MURPHY, Lecturer in Molecular Diagnostics and Bioinformatics, School of Biological, Health and Sports Science, Technological University Dublin, Dublin. Alcohol consumption and tax Sir, – The recent report showing a 4.5 per cent drop in alcohol consumption in Ireland last year ( 'Alcohol consumption falls 4.5 per cent, putting Irish at European average,' June 9th ), is welcome news, reflecting healthier public attitudes and the success of evidence-based policy, including minimum unit pricing. However, the suggestion from the Drinks Industry Group of Ireland (DIGI) that this progress should now justify a cut in alcohol excise duty is deeply misguided. Alcohol continues to cause enormous harm in Irish society, with thousands of lives lost or devastated every year through liver and heart disease, dementia, breast cancer, domestic abuse and more. Each year, alcohol costs the Irish State billions in healthcare, policing and lost productivity. Alcohol taxation remains one of the few public tools that reduces consumption while raising vital revenue to offset just a small fraction of the costs alcohol imposes on society. If anything, our alcohol excise rates urgently need revision as despite rising costs and inflation, they have remained essentially unchanged since 2014. Most Irish citizens do not know or understand the risks of alcohol consumption. The dangers of alcohol, particularly its links to cancer, cardiovascular disease and cognitive decline, remain hugely under-recognised. The unambiguous position of the World Health Organisation needs to be better known: no level of alcohol consumption is safe for our health. – Yours, etc, DR RALPH HURLEY O'DWYER, Specialist Registrar in Public Health Medicine, Dublin. Gaza and food aid Sir, – I'm delighted by the international impact of the Madleen, due to the presence of Greta Thunberg and other international activists. I wonder have your readers forgotten the 2010 Irish endeavour to respond to the tragedy of an earlier Palestinian Nakba. Together with Malaysian support, we purchased a ship which carried 60 tonnes of cement for rebuilding essential humanitarian infrastructure in Gaza. And significantly, onboard was Mairead Maguire, winner of the Nobel Peace Prize. The ship we named the Rachel Corrie after a young Jewish girl who gave her life in trying to stop the bulldozing of a Palestinian home. As in the case of the Madleen, we were intercepted by Israeli forces in international waters. The Rachel Corrie was boarded from two Israeli gunships and we were taken into Ashdod. There were seven Irish and seven Malaysian activists onboard. Malaysia had assembled the funding for the purchase of the ship, which was fitted out in Dundalk, and where a retired Scottish captain was hired. The then minister for foreign affairs, Micheál Martin, contacted me via satellite phone to express his concern for the safety of Irish nationals, and to inform me that he had been in touch with the Israelis. I explained that, in addition to delivering cement to Gaza, we intended to enter Gaza, just as our friends onboard the Madleen had intended. In both cases, the attempt was to break the stranglehold over Gaza and the people of Gaza by Israel. Micheál Martin understood the situation, and arranged for the Irish ambassador to meet me in Ashdod after our arrival at the detention centre. At his request the ambassador met me, and together with his Thai counterpart, he agreed to get the Filipino crew, the Cuban engineer, and the Malaysian activists out of the Israeli prison as soon as possible. These were all citizens of countries that did not recognise Israel. We Irish had agreed we would not leave detention until the other shipmates including the Scottish captain had been freed and flown home. Our opportunity to prosecute Israel for military action in international waters was not taken up by Ireland or Malaysia, regrettably, and now we see the same violation of international law taking place. – Yours, etc, DENIS J. HALLIDAY, Former UN assistant secretary general (1994-98) Ranelagh, Dublin 6. Sir, – In light of the Gaza genocide can we stop pretending there is such a thing as international law. Countries only talk about it when it is broken by another. It is only enforced when it is opportunistic for wealthy powerful countries. Instant action occurs when container ships are threatened, but none when humanitarian aid is in international waters under a British flag. – Yours, etc, JANE JACKSON , Greystones, Co Wicklow. Sir, – How ironic to see Israeli defence soldiers handing out food and water to protestors who themselves were trying to force Israel to hand out food and water to starving Gazans. – Yours, etc, DAVID CURRAN, Knocknacarra, Galway. Gardening leave and the HSE Sir, – The two HSE employees who have been on gardening leave for 11 years must have very fine specimens by now. ( 'Two staff on gardening leave for 11 years,' June 9th). In this other world 'gardening leave' is a term used to describe a short-term paid absence from work between two employments. But in the public sphere it means being paid indefinitely (eleven years and counting) to do nothing. Why would the gardener even contemplate the possibility of alternative employment in these circumstances? Martin Wall reports the HSE as saying that it endeavours to carry out all investigations 'as expediently as possible'. I think 'expeditiously' may have been intended but 'expediently' fits the bill beautifully. – Yours, etc, PAT O'BRIEN, Rathmines, Dublin 6. Sir, – Two HSE staff on gardening leave for 11 years . Clearly, they are creating something spectacular for Bloom. -– Yours, etc, FRANK J BYRNE, Glasnevin, Dublin 9. Sir , – I see that two HSE employees have been on 'gardening leave ' for 11 years. With such experience perhaps a transfer to the Botanic Gardens would be in order. – Yours, etc, HUGH PIERCE, Co Kildare. Some guides to St Stephen's Green Sir, – Your interesting recent supplement on St Stephen's Green (' A guide to who owns St Stephen's Green ', June 7th) reminded me how 21 years ago, when the shiny new Luas first pulled into Stephen's Green West, I suggested by letter to your paper that the four very functionally named thoroughfares surrounding the Green revert to their historical more attractively sounding monikers: ie. Stephens Green East – Monk's Walk, West – French Walk, South – Leesons Walk and North – Beaux Walk (as shown on Rocque's Map 1757). All this time later 'You are now approaching French Walk' would still sound so much more sublime as you glide in on the Luas or stroll on to Beaux Walk towards the Shelbourne. Ah let it be done, a little renaming enhancement to uplift further this famous old marshy Square! – Yours, etc, HELEN KEHOE, Stoneybatter, Dublin 7. Sir, – The headline 'A guide to who owns St Stephen's Green,' caught my attention. I was afraid the ownership of the public park had moved to the private sector and I'd be reading how the bandstand could now be rented for €3,000 per month. So it was delightful to discover it only referred to the property around the rectangular Green. – Yours, etc, DERMOT O'ROURKE, Lucan, Dublin. Some pointers for the GAA Sir, – I could not agree more with Nicky English's analysis of Saturdays Munster final in Limerick at 18.00hrs on a Saturday evening. (' Weary Limerick's errors allowed Cork's confidence to flourish,' June 9th). I was one of the spectators who because I had to walk (my running days are over!) left the stadium at half time in extra time to catch the 21.00hrs train back to Dublin. Let me declare an interest, I am a Corkman who loves the game of hurling and obviously delighted with the result. The performance by both sets of amateur players on Saturday was up there with the best I have been privileged to witness over the years. I'll leave it to your columnists and others to describe the passion, excitement etc. of the game but would add some observations, which are meant to be constructive. The core issue with the scheduling of games in both codes is the contraction of the season. It is an issue needing immediate attention to be sorted for the 2026 season. There are so many reasons why it should, all of which have been well articulated, and I can honestly say I have yet to meet a supporter of either code who agrees with the short season for our inter county championships. I fully agree with Nicky's comments on refereeing. I have been arguing for a long time that the game is too fast and hectic now for one referee and in my opinion we should have two, each in full control of their own half, at least for major championship games. I also agree the new football rules in relation to the clock and hooter should be implemented as should some disciplinary measures on dissent and gamesmanship. Not so sure about revaluing the goal to four points! When I entered the Gaelic grounds at 17.40 hrs on Saturday and Croke Park at 15.30 hrs on Sunday there were no programmes for sale. Why? and please don't tell me they were all sold out!! Another issue which I don't like bringing up is the toilet facilities at our stadiums. The scene under the Mick Mackey stand during the intervals on Saturday can only be described as appalling, disgraceful, third world. Whatever about men jamming the entrances/ exits trying to get in and out , the sight of our women supporters, who are growing in such numbers, lining up in orderly lengthy queues is so so embarrassing and must be so demeaning for them. I don't accept there is no solution to this problem in this age of mobile units which we see deployed in other venues throughout the country. – Yours etc. JOE WALSH, Sutton, Dublin. Gulf stream and climate change Sir, – A recent letter from Richard Herriott (my first cousin as it happens) queried why the Environmental Protection Agency's (EPA)latest report did not mention the possible collapse of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation – more popularly known as the Gulf Stream. While the concern is valid, the omission is understandable. The EPA's focus is on Ireland's emissions and our domestic climate action. The destabilisation of the Gulf Stream is indeed one of the most alarming global climate tipping points, but it is also largely beyond our direct influence. In contrast, the report highlights the many areas where we can make a difference – reducing emissions from transport, agriculture, buildings, and energy. These are spheres where policy and behavioural change can yield real and measurable results. The real scandal is not what the report left out, but what we continue to leave undone. We are failing to act even where action is clearly within our grasp. It would be tragic if, in the face of potential planetary upheaval, we chose to focus on the immovable rather than the urgent and fixable. Or we could do a Nero and pull out a fiddle. – Yours, etc, JAMES CANDON, Woluwe St. Pierre, Brussels. Season's Greetings Sir, – At 9.20 am on Monday June 9th, an out-of-service bus passed me on Kevin Street, Dublin 8, bearing the greeting, 'Merry Christmas from Dublin Bus' on its display screen. Is this a record? – Yours, etc, MARK HARKIN, New Bride Street, Dublin 8.

CHI failure to deliver international best practice 'harmed' children, among findings of report
CHI failure to deliver international best practice 'harmed' children, among findings of report

Irish Examiner

timea day ago

  • Irish Examiner

CHI failure to deliver international best practice 'harmed' children, among findings of report

The unpublished report, seen by the Irish Examiner, into concerns at Children's Health Ireland hospital identified: • An unknown number of children — between five and 80 — with the same health condition receive 'suboptimal' care at this hospital compared to how patients with the same condition are treated in another CHI hospital. They were known as 'orphans' internally, with one staff member interviewed saying: 'How can you have patients that aren't someone's responsibility?' • Some of the children may develop cancer or be infertile due to delays related to a procedure which should be done by 18 months old. • The review quotes another unpublished report from 2017, which warned of similar problems for these patients. It says by 2021 they found 'lack of clarity' about actions taken on that older report. • National Treatment Purchase Fund monies given for 'insourcing' to run extra clinics for 179 children is questioned. Some 95% of children seen could have been seen in another service during regular hours without extra funding. Some could have been seen sooner. Some of the children were referred to an inpatient waiting list which was longer than at another service which could have treated them. The review found this was 'potentially negligent'. • Risk assessment in 2021 for one national service said children being treated 'have a poor experience or are harmed due to the inability of CHI to deliver international best practice standards of [this care]'. It was given a risk score of 20 out of 25 • A 'toxic culture' was identified, with three specialist nurses leaving one service between 2013 and 2021. Comments show one person had panic attacks at work. Trainee doctors faced a 'psychologically unsafe environment' in one department reviewed. • Some 89% of people interviewed described 'a culture where change was slow, which lacked governance and robust processes' across CHI as a whole, while 43% said 'they wanted to see real change across CHI'. • A defamation case is on-going between two consultants, which the report linked to 'fraught relationships' between two services in which they work.

Children's health crisis will roll on until there is transparency about how public money is spent
Children's health crisis will roll on until there is transparency about how public money is spent

Irish Times

time2 days ago

  • Irish Times

Children's health crisis will roll on until there is transparency about how public money is spent

The fallout concerning the use of funding from the National Treatment Purchase Fund (NTPF) in a Children's Health Ireland (CHI) hospital continues. The story that emerged in the media over a week ago painted a picture of a rolling crisis, after a confidential internal report raised concerns about abuse of waiting lists and a toxic work culture . That report will now be referred to gardaí by the HSE. The report in question focused on five special weekend outpatient clinics for 179 children carried out by a consultant at a public hospital. These clinics were funded by the NTPF and the consultant received €35,800 for seeing the patients. However, the report questions whether the young patients could have been seen during the consultant's HSE contracted hours or referred to his colleagues. There were also concerns about potential clinical failures regarding vulnerable children, who may have been left waiting longer than they should have been for important treatment. READ MORE And yet again, the report raises serious questions about professional ethics, conduct and clinical care in CHI, coming hot on the heels of the publication of two separate damning reports on children's orthopaedic surgery failures. We still know don't exactly what actions were taken to address the alleged potential misuse of NTPF funds and whether there may be further similar cases in CHI. The news that the report has been referred to gardaí – amid temporary pausing of NTPF funding, which is now due to be lifted 'imminently' – and promises of action and reviews, as well as the 'ongoing' roll-out of a new central referral management system for all services in CHI, suggests that there is much more to come. Whatever happens, it is unacceptable if the Department of Health , the Minister, the NTPF and the HSE were left in the dark about the whole affair until it was reported in the media, as has been suggested. We are expected to accept promises that it won't happen again, that action is being taken, and – well, you know the drill. But what about the bigger picture – oversight and transparency on how we are spending our healthcare budget, and, crucially, if it is being best used to provide care for patients? This year the HSE has a record €26.9 billion in funding , and staffing levels have increased by 23 per cent in the last five years. There are many new services, and bed numbers are continuing to grow to meet escalating demand. Our population is now 5.3 million. The Irish health system seems inexplicably reluctant to carry out routine audits and set standardised targets, as the continued large variations in productivity between services, gaps in basic performance data, and resistance to many oversight initiatives shows The question is whether we are getting the best value for money and access to services commensurate with these increases in resources. And where does the NTPF fit into all this? It was set up over 20 years ago to help relieve waiting list pressure in the public system, and was regarded by some as a sort of pressure safety valve to get public patients seen, diagnosed and treated faster; and by others as a sticking plaster for inadequate public capacity. Its budget for this year is an increased €230 million. Last year it facilitated outpatient appointments, diagnostic scans and procedures for approximately 251,000 public patients. It initially purchased appointments in the private sector for patients waiting too long on public waiting lists – known as outsourcing – but in recent years it has moved towards increased use of 'insourcing'. This is essentially overtime: using spare capacity in public hospitals over and above core activity. All governance for insourcing remains with the treating hospital, the NTPF took pains to point out last week. So it, and by extension the HSE itself, claims no responsibility for how its – or rather public – money is spent, once the forms are filled in. The NTPF does publish data on how many procedures and appointments it has paid for, which is more information than many of our health services publicly provide. And now it has written to all public hospitals with whom it funds insourcing work to obtain further confirmation that all work is carried out in line with agreed terms. There has always been the potential for abuse of NTPF funding as consultants can refer their own public patients to their private clinics, or public overtime. There is supposed to be data collection on how often this occurs, with the appropriate governance applied. And in cases where there are only one or two consultants in a highly specialised disease or geographic area, it makes sense to allow them to see these patients in a private/public overtime capacity if they are on a very long waiting list, to ensure timely access where needed and longer-term continuity of care. But surely audit and inspections of the use of NTPF funding in individual institutions should be routine? Each hospital should always be able to fully account for the need for insourcing funds, proving that its own resources, and staffing time, have been maximised under allocated HSE funding. Newer contracts for various healthcare staff allow for longer core weekday working hours and weekend work as normal, but implementation has been piecemeal in some specialities and services, despite the increased cost and staffing numbers. [ 'Fear and distrust': why children's healthcare is in crisis Opens in new window ] In this case, was the CHI hospital paying attention to how many patients were on individual consultant lists? How many they were seeing, and how long were individuals waiting before signing off the NTPF funding applications? The Irish health system seems inexplicably reluctant to carry out routine audits and set standardised targets, as the continued large variations in productivity between services, gaps in basic performance data, and resistance to many oversight initiatives shows. Last year, then-Minister for Health Stephen Donnelly presented data to the HSE board showing a significant drop in the average number of patients seen per consultant, with obvious ramifications for our long waiting lists. And in correspondence on the 2025 HSE budget, he asked the HSE to apply a standardised approach to maximising productivity through agreeing outpatient clinic targets for individual consultants, departments and specialities, and sharing data on outpatient numbers between consultants. A health minister should not have to specifically request what should be done as a matter of course. Our complicated public healthcare system, comprising public, voluntary and private overlapping services – and a combination of old and new working contracts – continues to muddy the waters of accountability and transparency. A key underpinning element of Sláintecare is the unpicking of the various conflicts and competing interests within our health service, increased governance and standardisation. Until its full implementation, whenever that is, far more oversight of all publicly funded services must be applied.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store