Report urges city to accept federal funding for short-term rental rules enforcement
A year after the city imposed a licensing regime for short-term rental units, such as those listed on Airbnb and VRBO, new federal funding is poised to help crack down on anyone breaking the rules.
A new report seeks city council approval to accept a grant of just under $770,000 over the next two years, which would boost enforcement of the units the city began licensing on April 1, 2024.
But some neighbours of such properties say enforcement is falling short, so far.
Craig, who asked that his last name not be used, said city rules haven't solved issues in his downtown building, where about one-quarter of all units are short-term rentals.
'Our quality of life is adversely impacted on a regular basis by these units,' he said.
While wild parties are the most common problem, others include include domestic violence, hallway fights and at least one case of human trafficking, said Craig.
'There (are) people who are afraid to leave.… You don't want to leave your suite when there's people causing issues in the hallway. You're kind of trapped,' he said.
The city's rules allow owners to operate one short-term rental unit, which must be their primary residence. However, permanent residents of Winnipeg, and corporations wholly owned by Winnipeggers, are permitted to rent out one primary residence and up to three short-term rental units they don't live at via a grandfather clause, as long as they owned the properties before Feb. 23, 2023.
Craig said that means incidents can pile up at units with off-site owners and city bylaw officers often can't immediately respond.
'The bylaw needs to be enforceable to actually mean anything,' he said.
Downtown resident Mike Diehl agreed.
'We (typically) don't know where the owners live, exactly, or how far away they are when something needs to be addressed. This is ghost hotel style,' said Diehl. 'You kind of wish there would be some… upper limit (in terms) of the number of short-term rentals that can exist in a building.'
He welcomed the city's plan to add enforcement but said condo boards also need more power to prevent short-term rental operators from buying housing units.
According to the city report, the federal government believes cracking down on non-compliant short-term rentals could help boost the country's supply of long-term housing.
Coun. Vivian Santos, chairwoman of council's community services committee, said she hasn't personally received complaints about short-term rentals since city licensing took effect, though other councillors have.
'I think the enforcement part would really help. I know there have been complaints about some illicit, illegal activity,' said Santos (Point Douglas).
The city plans to use the funding to identify any gaps in its bylaws, ramp up enforcement and better use technology to monitor the industry.
Steps would include: adding an enforcement and policy analyst, a licensing enforcement inspector and an information technology programmer analyst; using new technology to detect bookings for unlicensed properties; and creating a new scheduling system to streamline inspections.
'I think it would be very helpful for the community bylaw enforcement team to have some temporary additional help,' said Santos.
In Winnipeg, there are 679 active short-term rental licences in effect, while two licences have been removed for breaking the rules and 64 complaints have been made through 311 since licensing began, said city spokeswoman Pam McKenzie, in an email.
The city's licensing program also imposed an accommodation tax on short-term rentals, which is currently set at six per cent.
A full city report on short-term rentals is expected in June, said Santos.
A spokeswoman for the short-term rental industry said she hopes more enforcement can help crack down on what she believes to be a small portion of operators breaking city rules.
'It only benefits us if the bad hosts are weeded out. The quicker, the better in my opinion,' said Melanie Mitchell, president of the Manitoba Association of Short Term Rental Owners.
Mitchell said the industry provides jobs and needed accommodations.
And while the federal government blames short-term rentals for taking up scarce housing units, Mitchell believes they have little impact on the overall supply.
'You could put them all out of business in one day and still have a huge housing supply issue in Winnipeg,' she said.
Mitchell said it would be unfair for the city to rescind its decision to allow some existing short-term rentals to continue operating even though owners don't live on site.
'People made their business decisions based on being grandfathered (in), so that should be the end of that discussion. And the grandfathering criteria was so strict that cut out probably half of the short-term rentals in Winnipeg already,' she said.
Council is expected to vote next month on accepting the federal enforcement funding and the proposed plan to spend it.
joyanne.pursaga@freepress.mb.ca
X: @joyanne_pursaga
Joyanne PursagaReporter
Joyanne is city hall reporter for the Winnipeg Free Press. A reporter since 2004, she began covering politics exclusively in 2012, writing on city hall and the Manitoba Legislature for the Winnipeg Sun before joining the Free Press in early 2020. Read more about Joyanne.
Every piece of reporting Joyanne produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber.
Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
3 days ago
- Global News
Despite pushback, Montreal forges ahead with strict new short-term rental rules
Montreal is forging ahead with new rules banning many short-term rentals for nine months a year, hoping to alleviate a housing crunch and strike a blow in a lengthy battle against unauthorized listings. City council in March passed a new bylaw that will allow people to rent their principal residences for periods of 31 days or less only during peak tourist season, between June 10 and Sept. 10. They must also obtain a $300 permit from the city and meet previous requirements to register with the province. Full-time Airbnb units run by commercial enterprises are still allowed in parts of the city, but are restricted to a few streets and areas. Despina Sourias, a city councillor in charge of housing, said previous rules were hard to enforce because they allowed some property owners to avoid getting fined by stating a rental property was their main residence. The new rules, she said, will shift the burden of proof onto listing owners instead of inspectors. Story continues below advertisement 'Before it was like, we have to go out and catch people, we've got to roam the streets,' she said in a phone interview. Banning short-term rentals in principal residences for nine months a year makes issuing fines much easier, Sourias said. 'You don't have your permit, you get a ticket,' she said. 'If you're doing it outside the time that you're allowed to do it, you get a ticket.' The new rules are the next step in a progressive crackdown across the province that began after seven people died in a fire in an Old Montreal building in March 2023. Six of the victims had been staying in Airbnb rentals, which the mayor confirmed were not allowed in that part of the city. After the fire, the provincial government tabled new legislation requiring platforms like Airbnb to only display ads that include a tourism licence number and expiry date. The city also hired a squad of inspectors to try to crack down. Get daily National news Get the day's top news, political, economic, and current affairs headlines, delivered to your inbox once a day. Sign up for daily National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy Before the new bylaw, it was easier for people to rent their main residences for short periods, such as during a vacation. That led some people to use different schemes to falsely declare a full-time rental as a principal residence, and forcing inspectors into lengthy investigations to prove otherwise, the city said. Montreal's mayor said in January that despite the provincial law, more than half of the 4,000 units on short-term rental platforms did not comply with the rules. Story continues below advertisement The new rules have received pushback from the province's tourism department, as well as from platforms such as Airbnb, who claim that they will hurt the city's economy and do little to improve housing affordability. Alex Howell, Airbnb's policy lead from Canada, called on the city to reverse what she called an 'extreme and short-sighted' rule change. 'This poorly thought-out decision will drive up hotel prices and make travel more expensive for Quebecers – nearly 140,000 of whom stayed in an Airbnb in Montreal last year – and weakens Montreal's ability to attract visitors for major events that fuel tourism throughout the year,' she said in a statement. Saif Yousif, a property manager for Park Place Properties, believes the new rules are overly restrictive. Yousif manages about 80 short-term rentals in the Montreal and Mont-Tremblant areas, including many owned by clients want to rent their homes when they're travelling. Yousif feels the existing rules were already strict enough to prevent people from falsely claiming an investment property as a principal residence. The regulation, he said 'makes it difficult for (homeowners) to take vacations or take some time off and leave the city' and is unlikely to result in units being returned to the long-term rental pool. The best way to keep rental prices down would be to build more housing, he added. Likewise, the province's tourism department said the new rules would not put an end illegal rentals or the housing crisis. Story continues below advertisement 'On the contrary, they could even worsen the situation by pushing more operators into illegality, returning Montreal to the Wild Web of before our reforms,' it said in a statement to The Canadian Press. But David Wachsmuth, the Canada Research Chair in urban governance at McGill University, believes Montreal may succeed where other cities have failed at cracking down on illegal rentals. He said platforms leave it up to cities to track down rule-breakers, which forces municipal officials to 'play detective' and figure out who's actually a principal resident and who isn't. He said enforcement will be easier under these rules, because anyone running an Airbnb outside the designated full-time rental areas can be automatically fined outside the summer season. 'Anybody who's running an Airbnb in March, if you're not on one of those very small number of corridors where you're allowed to do this (legally), it's just guaranteed that you're breaking the law,' he said. 'So that's just a really fundamental shift in how the overall process of being a short term rental host is going to interact with the laws here in Montreal.' He said most Montrealers who want to rent their principal residence would likely be doing so mostly in the summer anyways. Therefore, the rules will only inconvenience legitimate homesharers while making it much harder for full-time unauthorized rentals to turn a profit. Wachsmuth also dismisses any claims that limiting short-term rentals won't help alleviate housing pressures, saying the research shows 'beyond any possible shred of a doubt' that communities that put short-term rental rules in place see their rents rise at a slower rate than those who don't. Story continues below advertisement This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 2, 2025. This is a corrected story. A previous version incorrectly summarized comments by David Wachsmuth on the impact of short-term rental rules on rent prices.
CTV News
3 days ago
- CTV News
Despite pushback, Montreal forges ahead with strict new short-term rental rules
Fog hangs over the skyline of Montreal on Jan. 1, 2025. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Graham Hughes.) Montreal is forging ahead with new rules banning many short-term rentals for nine months a year, hoping to alleviate a housing crunch and strike a blow in a lengthy battle against unauthorized listings. City council in March passed a new bylaw that will allow people to rent their principal residences for periods of 31 days or less only during peak tourist season, between June 10 and Sept. 10. They must also obtain a $300 permit from the city and meet previous requirements to register with the province. Full-time Airbnb units run by commercial enterprises are still allowed in parts of the city, but are restricted to a few streets and areas. Despina Sourias, a city councillor in charge of housing, said previous rules were hard to enforce because they allowed some property owners to avoid getting fined by stating a rental property was their main residence. The new rules, she said, will shift the burden of proof onto listing owners instead of inspectors. 'Before it was like, we have to go out and catch people, we've got to roam the streets,' she said in a phone interview. Banning short-term rentals in principal residences for nine months a year makes issuing fines much easier, Sourias said. 'You don't have your permit, you get a ticket,' she said. 'If you're doing it outside the time that you're allowed to do it, you get a ticket.' The new rules are the next step in a progressive crackdown across the province that began after seven people died in a fire in an Old Montreal building in March 2023. Six of the victims had been staying in Airbnb rentals, which the mayor confirmed were not allowed in that part of the city. After the fire, the provincial government tabled new legislation requiring platforms like Airbnb to only display ads that include a tourism licence number and expiry date. The city also hired a squad of inspectors to try to crack down. Before the new bylaw, it was easier for people to rent their main residences for short periods, such as during a vacation. That led some people to use different schemes to falsely declare a full-time rental as a principal residence, forcing inspectors into lengthy investigations to prove otherwise, the city said. Montreal's mayor said in January that despite the provincial law, more than half of the 4,000 units on short-term rental platforms did not comply with the rules. The new rules have received pushback from the province's tourism department, as well as from platforms such as Airbnb, which claim that they will hurt the city's economy and do little to improve housing affordability. Alex Howell, Airbnb's policy lead from Canada, called on the city to reverse what she called an 'extreme and short-sighted' rule change. 'This poorly thought-out decision will drive up hotel prices and make travel more expensive for Quebecers – nearly 140,000 of whom stayed in an Airbnb in Montreal last year – and weaken Montreal's ability to attract visitors for major events that fuel tourism throughout the year,' she said in a statement. Saif Yousif, a property manager for Park Place Properties, believes the new rules are overly restrictive. Yousif manages about 80 short-term rentals in the Montreal and Mont-Tremblant areas, including many owned by clients who want to rent their homes when they're travelling. Yousif feels the existing rules were already strict enough to prevent people from falsely claiming an investment property as a principal residence. The regulation, he said, 'makes it difficult for (homeowners) to take vacations or take some time off and leave the city' and is unlikely to result in units being returned to the long-term rental pool. The best way to keep rental prices down would be to build more housing, he added. Likewise, the province's tourism department said the new rules would not put an end to illegal rentals or the housing crisis. 'On the contrary, they could even worsen the situation by pushing more operators into illegality, returning Montreal to the Wild Web of before our reforms,' it said in a statement to The Canadian Press. But David Wachsmuth, the Canada Research Chair in urban governance at McGill University, believes Montreal may succeed where other cities have failed at cracking down on illegal rentals. He said platforms leave it up to cities to track down rule-breakers, which forces municipal officials to 'play detective' and figure out who's actually a principal resident and who isn't. He said enforcement will be easier under these rules, because anyone running an Airbnb outside the designated full-time rental areas can be automatically fined outside the summer season. 'Anybody who's running an Airbnb in March, if you're not on one of those very small number of corridors where you're allowed to do this (legally), it's just guaranteed that you're breaking the law,' he said. 'So that's just a really fundamental shift in how the overall process of being a short-term rental host is going to interact with the laws here in Montreal.' He said that most Montrealers who want to rent out their principal residence would likely do so mostly in the summer anyway. Therefore, the rules will only inconvenience legitimate home sharers while making it much harder for full-time unauthorized rentals to turn a profit. Wachsmuth also dismisses any claims that limiting short-term rentals won't help alleviate housing pressures, saying the research shows 'beyond any possible shred of a doubt' that communities that put short-term rental rules in place see their rents rise less slowly than those who don't. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 2, 2025.
Globe and Mail
3 days ago
- Globe and Mail
Montreal pushes on with new short-term rental rules despite pushback
Montreal is forging ahead with new rules banning many short-term rentals for nine months a year, hoping to alleviate a housing crunch and strike a blow in a lengthy battle against unauthorized listings. City council in March passed a new bylaw that will allow people to rent their principal residences for periods of 31 days or less only during peak tourist season, between June 10 and Sept. 10. They must also obtain a $300 permit from the city and meet previous requirements to register with the province. Full-time Airbnb units run by commercial enterprises are still allowed in parts of the city, but are restricted to a few streets and areas. Two years after fatal fire, Montreal tightens rules on short-term rentals including Airbnb Despina Sourias, a city councillor in charge of housing, said previous rules were hard to enforce because they allowed some property owners to avoid getting fined by stating a rental property was their main residence. The new rules, she said, will shift the burden of proof onto listing owners instead of inspectors. 'Before it was like, we have to go out and catch people, we've got to roam the streets,' she said in a phone interview. Banning short-term rentals in principal residences for nine months a year makes issuing fines much easier, Sourias said. 'You don't have your permit, you get a ticket,' she said. 'If you're doing it outside the time that you're allowed to do it, you get a ticket.' The new rules are the next step in a progressive crackdown across the province that began after seven people died in a fire in an Old Montreal building in March 2023. Six of the victims had been staying in Airbnb rentals, which the mayor confirmed were not allowed in that part of the city. After the fire, the provincial government tabled new legislation requiring platforms like Airbnb to only display ads that include a tourism licence number and expiry date. The city also hired a squad of inspectors to try to crack down. Before the new bylaw, it was easier for people to rent their main residences for short periods, such as during a vacation. That led some people to use different schemes to falsely declare a full-time rental as a principal residence, and forcing inspectors into lengthy investigations to prove otherwise, the city said. Montreal's mayor said in January that despite the provincial law, more than half of the 4,000 units on short-term rental platforms did not comply with the rules. The new rules have received pushback from the province's tourism department, as well as from platforms such as Airbnb, who claim that they will hurt the city's economy and do little to improve housing affordability. Alex Howell, Airbnb's policy lead from Canada, called on the city to reverse what she called an 'extreme and short-sighted' rule change. 'This poorly thought-out decision will drive up hotel prices and make travel more expensive for Quebecers – nearly 140,000 of whom stayed in an Airbnb in Montreal last year – and weakens Montreal's ability to attract visitors for major events that fuel tourism throughout the year,' she said in a statement. The province's tourism department said the new rules would not put an end illegal rentals or the housing crisis. 'On the contrary, they could even worsen the situation by pushing more operators into illegality, returning Montreal to the Wild Web of before our reforms,' it said in a statement to The Canadian Press. But David Wachsmuth, the Canada Research Chair in urban governance at McGill University, believes Montreal may succeed where other cities have failed at cracking down on illegal rentals. He said platforms leave it up to cities to track down rule-breakers, which forces municipal officials to 'play detective' and figure out who's actually a principal resident and who isn't. He said enforcement will be easier under these rules, because anyone running an Airbnb outside the designated full-time rental areas can be automatically fined outside the summer season.
