Manitoba, Ottawa say $4.8-B lawsuit over Lake Winnipeg should be tossed
The Manitoba and federal governments denied any wrongdoing as they asked a court to reject a lawsuit filed by First Nations over the effect of sewage spills and pollution on Lake Winnipeg.
In separate statements of defence, the two levels of government say their conduct didn't harm the First Nations.
The First Nations claim in the lawsuit, launched a year ago, that decades of pollution that ended up into the Red and Assiniboine rivers, which flow into Lake Winnipeg, have caused physical, psychological, social and cultural harms to their communities.
JOHN WOODS / FREE PRESS FILES
The lawsuit was launched after more than 200 million litres of raw sewage got into the Red River when a municipal sewer pipe broke in February 2024.
The suit was launched after more than 200 million litres of raw sewage got into the Red River when a municipal sewer pipe broke in February 2024.
The $4.8-billion lawsuit, filed in the Manitoba Court of King's Bench by eight First Nations, names the municipal, provincial and federal governments as defendants.
The plaintiffs were Black River, Berens River, Brokenhead, Hollow Water, Kinonjeoshtegon (Jackhead), Misipawistik (Grand Rapids), Sagkeeng and Poplar River. Bloodvein, Dauphin River and Fisher River Cree First Nations have since signed on as plaintiffs.
In its submission, the province says the nutrient load in Lake Winnipeg — increased nitrogen and phosphorous, which contribute to increasingly frequent algae blooms — can be blamed on various sources, including climate change, agriculture, urban and industrial development as well as wastewater, and it would be 'challenging' to attribute it to one source.
Manitoba argues, on top of its environment and water legislation, it has various programs to monitor the lake and surrounding communities. It said it isn't responsible for promises made in treaties that were signed by the federal Crown.
The province asserts it exercises due diligence and takes appropriate regulatory action to deal with the City of Winnipeg's sewage spill infractions, including by pursuing charges under the Environment Act, as it did in response to the February 2024 spill.
The province argues the City of Winnipeg is responsible for its wastewater system and must inform affected communities when there's a sewage spill.
The province notes that water quality in First Nations is a federal responsibility.
Further, the province says, parts of the claim are barred under the Limitations Act. It filed a cross claim against the city.
The federal government, in its statement of defence, acknowledges the effect of sewage on the lake, but says other sources in the watershed have also polluted the water.
It argues it has gone to considerable lengths to study and improve the health of the lake as a matter of public policy.
Ottawa says the city must adhere to federal regulations on pollution and the senior level of government investigates and pursues regulatory actions when rules aren't followed.
Winnipeg Free Press | Newsletter
Winnipeg Jets Game Days
On Winnipeg Jets game days, hockey writers Mike McIntyre and Ken Wiebe send news, notes and quotes from the morning skate, as well as injury updates and lineup decisions. Arrives a few hours prior to puck drop. Sign up for The Warm-Up
Last month, Ottawa slapped the city with a federal Fisheries Act charge in connection with the 2024 spill.
The City of Winnipeg, in court filings last week, argued the 2024 incident and other sewage spills have little effect on pollution in Lake Winnipeg, while the blame for water-quality issues falls to the province and Ottawa for not providing enough money to upgrade Winnipeg's sewer system.
The city argued other sources predominantly affect the lake and that reducing or eliminating contributions from the municipal sewer system would not restore Lake Winnipeg to its natural condition or eliminate the issues, as the First Nations alleged in their lawsuit.
The city argued the other two governments have jurisdiction to regulate effects to Lake Winnipeg. It launched cross claims against the two senior governments.
erik.pindera@freepress.mb.ca
Erik Pindera
Reporter
Erik Pindera is a reporter for the Free Press , mostly focusing on crime and justice. The born-and-bred Winnipegger attended Red River College Polytechnic, wrote for the community newspaper in Kenora, Ont. and reported on television and radio in Winnipeg before joining the Free Press in 2020. Read more about Erik.
Every piece of reporting Erik produces is reviewed by an editing team before it is posted online or published in print — part of the Free Press 's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press 's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Toronto Star
an hour ago
- Toronto Star
Doug Ford pushes through rapid development law despite objections of First Nations
Amid warnings of highway blockades and other civil disobedience from First Nations, Premier Doug Ford's government passed its controversial Bill 5 to fast-track development of mines and infrastructure in the fight against U.S. tariffs. 'We need to get moving, folks,' Ford said Wednesday before the vote on the Protect Ontario By Unleashing Our Economy Act, which creates 'special economic zones' where local and provincial rules can be bypassed — and which opposition parties dub 'no-law' zones.
CTV News
5 hours ago
- CTV News
‘Diplomacy ends today': First Nations warn of protests over Ontario mining law
Protesters and community members chant and wave signs, as they listen to speakers during a demonstration opposing Bill 5, outside the Ontario legislature at Queen's Park in Toronto, Monday, June 2, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Cole Burston Ontario Premier Doug Ford's government has given itself the power to suspend provincial and municipal laws for chosen projects in areas it deems to have economic importance, citing the need to speed up development of mines, but First Nations warn confrontation is brewing. Known as Bill 5, the legislation sparked a firestorm of anger among First Nations communities, who say it tramples their rights and ignores their concerns. It may have passed in the legislature Wednesday, but Indigenous leaders say the fight is just beginning. 'Our diplomacy ends today,' said NDP deputy leader Sol Mamakwa, who represents the northern Ontario riding of Kiiwetinoong that is home to many First Nations and the mineral-rich Ring of Fire region. 'You cannot trample on the rights of the people that live on these homelands and get away with it.' Ford has said the bill is needed to speed up large projects, particularly mines, in the face of U.S. President Donald Trump's trade war. Jeers from dozens of First Nations members echoed in the legislature as the bill was passed into law. Ford was not there for the final vote. Nishnawbe Aski Nation Grand Chief Alvin Fiddler called the premier a 'coward.' 'This fight is not over, but we will meet you on the ground,' Fiddler said. 'He did not even have the guts to show up for the vote.' Ford was on a call with a Republican congressman during the vote, his office said. Lake Huron Regional Chief Scott McLeod said that shows where the premier's priorities lie. 'His priorities are not with the Indigenous people in this province,' he said. 'They're with business people, and he wants the resources that are in our territories. He's selling our minerals and our resources to Americans, to the world, without our permission and that is what we're not going to stand for.' The government had tried to amend the bill to explicitly include duty to consult provisions, but delay tactics at the committee stage by the Liberals meant that the Progressive Conservatives passed the legislation without that. Ford said earlier in the day that they would consult with First Nations over the summer, but that may now be in question. From now on, Fiddler said, Nishnawbe Aski Nation will not take him or his government seriously, nor will they engage with Indigenous Affairs Minister Greg Rickford. Fiddler called for his resignation. 'He is supposed to be representing Indigenous affairs for our nation, but he failed at every turn, and we will not work with him,' Fiddler said. 'We will not engage with him at all moving forward.' The legislation will create so-called 'special economic zones,' where the province could suspend laws in order to speed up projects such as mines, and the government has said the Ring of Fire would be the first such zone. Chris Moonias, the former chief of Neskantaga First Nation, suggested action will begin by preventing mining companies and others' access to their lands. 'We're going to shut down the Ring of Fire,' he said. 'Whatever that means, whatever we can do, we're going to shut it down. I promise you that.' Earlier in the day, Ford said blockades wouldn't be 'very wise.' 'You can't break the law,' Ford said. 'Simple as that. ... They need to move on or they'll be dealt with appropriately.' When asked to clarify his comments, Ford said he doesn't direct the police and any enforcement would be up to the Ontario Provincial Police or local police services. The premier wouldn't say if he would use the notwithstanding clause to save Bill 5 if it ends up being challenged and found unconstitutional in court. But he said that he would 'cross that bridge' when he comes to it. Civil liberty groups are livid at the prospect of effectively lawless zones, and unions have warned that labour laws would be under threat. The measure is part of an omnibus bill that makes a slew of other changes, including stripping protections for endangered and threatened species. Environmental groups and the Toronto Zoo have warned this will lead to extinctions. Farmers, who largely support the Progressive Conservative government, have also spoken out against the bill. The Ontario Federation of Agriculture said the broad powers 'could override vital protections for farmland and agricultural systems.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 4, 2025. Liam Casey and Allison Jones, The Canadian Press
CTV News
5 hours ago
- CTV News
Ontario passes controversial mining law as Doug Ford warns against blockades
Protesters and community members chant and wave signs, as they listen to speakers during a demonstration opposing Bill 5, outside the Ontario legislature at Queen's Park in Toronto, Monday, June 2, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Cole Burston Ontario Premier Doug Ford's government has given itself the power to suspend provincial and municipal laws for chosen projects in areas it deems to have economic importance. On Wednesday afternoon, the province passed Bill 5, the so-called Protect Ontario by Unleashing Our Economy Act, which has sparked a firestorm of anger among First Nations. The province has said the bill is needed to speed up large projects, particularly mines, in the face of U.S. President Donald Trump's trade war. Jeers from dozens of First Nations members echoed in the legislature as the bill was passed into law. Ford did not show up for the final vote. Earlier in the day, Ford wouldn't say if he would use the notwithstanding clause to save Bill 5 if it ends up being challenged and found unconstitutional in court. But he said that he would 'cross that bridge' when he comes to it. First Nations say the bill tramples their rights and ignores their concerns and they have warned they may blockade roads, railways and mines in protest. But Ford said Wednesday that wouldn't be 'very wise.' 'You can't break the law,' Ford said. 'Simple as that. ... They need to move on or they'll be dealt with appropriately.' When asked to clarify his comments, Ford said he doesn't direct the police and any enforcement would be up to the Ontario Provincial Police or local police services. The legislation will create so-called 'special economic zones,' where the government could suspend laws in order to speed up projects such as mines. Ford has cited the need to move more quickly on mining places such as the Ring of Fire in northern Ontario in order to strengthen the province's economy while it is under Trump's attack. Civil liberty groups are livid at the prospect of effectively lawless zones, and unions have warned that labour laws would be under threat. The measure is part of an omnibus bill that makes a slew of other changes, including stripping protections for endangered and threatened species. Environmental groups and the Toronto Zoo have warned this will lead to extinctions. Farmers, who largely support the Progressive Conservative government, have also spoken out against the bill. The Ontario Federation of Agriculture said the broad powers 'could override vital protections for farmland and agricultural systems.' Several First Nation leaders said Wednesday there was nothing the government could do to rectify the bill. 'I believe it is too late,' said deputy Grand Chief Anna Betty Achneepineskum of Nishnawbe Aski Nation, which represents 49 First Nations including those in the Ring of Fire. 'They have not acknowledged our request, our demands and our position to start over again so that we can be there as the rightful treaty people of Ontario.' NDP deputy leader Sol Mamakwa, who represents the northern Ontario riding of Kiiwetinoong that is home to many First Nations and the Ring of Fire, said that Ford is not listening to their concerns. 'This is not the wild, wild west,' he said, surrounded by several people who flew in from various communities in his riding. 'We are the ones that live in these communities on these lands. He does not live in those lands. ... You cannot vote, legislatively bulldoze your way. These are the people that will stop that bulldozer coming north.' Ford's government fast-tracked the bill and limited third-reading debate, and while the opposition parties tried to stall the bill at the committee stage, it returned to the legislature Wednesday afternoon for the third reading and final vote. In response to the growing backlash, Indigenous Affairs Minister Greg Rickford and Mining Minister Stephen Lecce said late last month that the province would amend Bill 5 to explicitly include duty to consult provisions throughout the legislation. That amendment did not end up making it in the bill due to the tactics the Liberals used in committee. Ford said it's unfortunate that opposition parties wanted to 'drag this out,' but his government will consult with First Nations over the coming months. 'When it comes to duty to consult, which is very important, and we are going to do it, if they have an equity partnership it moves like greased lightning,' he said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 4, 2025. Liam Casey and Allison Jones, The Canadian Press
