State government fails to extend man's sentence it deemed 'manifestly inadequate'
A state government has failed to prove a man accused of using a rope to drag a woman to a car was handed a 'manifestly inadequate' sentence.
The Queensland government had sought to increase Brock Andrew McDonald's sentence after he was jailed for assaulting and depriving the liberty of a young woman in October 2023.
He was sentenced to two-and-a-half years on parole in December, with 413 days as time served.
Attorney-General Deb Frecklington said in January that in her view, the sentence did not meet community standards and was 'manifestly inadequate'.
McDonald, 44, is alleged to have put a rope around a young woman's neck before dragging her into a car in the early hours of the morning.
He placed the screaming woman in the back seat while repeatedly telling her not to look at his face.
She eventually escaped the car and hid in a nearby bush before calling for help.
McDonald had pleaded guilty to charges of deprivation of liberty and assault occasioning bodily harm.
In the appeal, the attorney-general had sought McDonald's sentence to be increased to no less than three years for the deprivation of liberty charge.
The attorney-general's counsel submitted that the Court of Appeal should conclude the sentence was 'unreasonable and plainly unjust' and was so far outside the range of sentences that an error must have occurred.
But the Court of Appeal on Friday dismissed the case, finding the attorney-general could not demonstrate the sentence was manifestly inadequate or that an error had occurred.
The judges said the prosecution launched the appeal with the 'fundamental misconception' that sentences for kidnapping offences were comparable in McDonald's case on a deprivation of liberty charge.
The appeal court referenced the sentencing judge's ruling on the basis that the prosecution had not sought to prove intent that is required for a charge of kidnapping.
The prosecution instead pursued deprivation of liberty, which holds a lesser maximum sentence.
The appeal judges said the attorney general 'ignored the consequences' of the prosecution's choices in framing the charges of deprivation of liberty instead of kidnapping, which McDonald pleaded guilty to.
'The argument presented on behalf of the attorney-general fails to demonstrate that the sentence was manifestly inadequate,' the appeal judges ruled.
Ms Frecklington expressed her disappointment over the outcome.
'This sentence was appealed because I did not believe it met community expectations,' she said in a statement.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
5 hours ago
- The Independent
Police officer hospitalised after being crushed between two cars
A 41-year-old man has been arrested on suspicion of assault, dangerous driving, and failure to stop after a Greater Manchester Police sergeant was injured in an alleged hit-and-run incident in Rusholme. The incident occurred on Frodsham Street at 6pm on Friday, where a car reportedly "reversed into the officer several times" before fleeing the scene. The injured sergeant is currently receiving hospital treatment for his injuries, which are not believed to be life-threatening or life-changing. Assistant Chief Constable Steph Parker has condemned the assault, emphasising the risks faced by frontline officers and assuring that an investigation is underway to bring the perpetrator to justice. Police are appealing to the public for any CCTV or dash cam footage of the incident or the moments leading up to and following it, urging them to call 101 and quote log 2828 of 30/05/25.
Daily Mail
5 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Inside the tragic downfall of former Sydney society 'It' girl as she hits a new low - after she was accused of shocking forgery scam
The glamorous life of a former celebrity stylist and one-time 'It' girl of the 2000s has potentially unravelled after she was arrested for allegedly forging prescriptions. New Zealand-born Kelly Smythe, 47, was charged earlier this month at Surry Hills Police Station in Sydney 's inner east. She spent the night in custody before appearing before Downing Centre Local Court via video link last week, when she made a release application while being held on remand. Smythe, who lives on Australia's most expensive street in Point Piper, was charged with two counts of using a false document to obtain property and two counts of obtaining or attempting to get a prohibited drug by false representation. A charge sheet showed Ms Smythe allegedly used a false letter and two fraudulent scripts to get dexamphetamine and lisdexamfetamine from the Paddington Compounding Pharmacy on Oxford street in February 21 and May 15. Dexamphetamine medication is used in attention-deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and narcolepsy (sleep disorder) while Lisdexamfetamine treats moderate-to-severe binge eating disorder in adults. Smythe's barrister Charles Alexander lodged a release application on his client's behalf. 'She knows she needs to stay on the straight and narrow,' he told the court. Magistrate Sharon Freund said the police facts indicated there may be further charges pending, but no fresh charges had been laid. The magistrate granted bail but addded: 'I suspect your client may have an issue with the drugs she has been self-prescribing.' Smythe, who wore gold-rimmed sunglasses during her video-linked court appearance, said: 'Thank you so much, ma'am.' The case will be back before the court next month. At the height of her career she was a Seven Network stylist and the go-to fashion adviser to Sydney's elite, styling Miranda Kerr, Jennifer Hawkins, Jodi Gordon and Sonia Kruger. But after five years at the helm of the wardrobe styling department, Seven cut ties with her. With the local fashion industry teetering on the brink of collapse, Smythe struggled with freelance work and former friends say she vanished from the limelight. She tied the knot in 2011 with Alex Nikolaidis, ten years younger than her, at St Mark's Church, in the ritzy eastern suburbs enclave of Darling Point, in front of clients and Sydney's society set including Roxy Jacenko, Holly Brisley and Chris Bath. She was known for living life in the fast lane before take a step away form the limelight several years ago The couple welcomed a son, who is now 14, a year before saying 'I do'. They are now divorced. On Wednesday the petite stylist was seen stranded on New South Head Road in Sydney's east after her car ran out of fuel and required NRMA roadside assistance. She was dressed in low-rise jeans, furry flats and designer sunglasses.
BBC News
5 hours ago
- BBC News
Australia Kelpies win Test series against England Thorns
Australia's men's netball team won the Aurora Series after dominating England Thorns in a 62-30 victory at the Motorpoint Arena in Nottingham to take a 2-0 series, which is the first Australia have contested in England, consists of three lost the opener 63-34 at the Copper Box Arena in London on 25 May and were well beaten in Saturday's second encounter.A dominant last two quarters by Australia sealed the success and the series, although the hosts were competitive at the first-quarter score was 12-9 in favour of the visitors and it was a similar story in the second quarter as good work by James Firminger kept England within touching distance. But Australia's Kelpies stretched their lead to 27-15 at the break and took command in the third quarter to move 47-21 men only played their first international match in 2022, while their opponents have been competing on the international stage since the that experience and quality showed as the Kelpies, led by the impressive Josh Byron, extended their lead in the fourth third and final Test will take place on Sunday at the Copper Box Arena.
