Toronto City Council passes ‘bubble zone' bylaw to limit protests around vulnerable institutions
Toronto City Council has voted to create a bylaw that would limit protests outside places of worship and other vulnerable institutions on a case-by-case basis.
The motion would create a 50-metre buffer around the spaces following an application from the property owner and would be in effect for a year, subject to renewal.
The motion passed 16-9, with a slew of amendments, following several hours of debate.
The original bylaw proposal written by the city manager called for a buffer of 20 metres to be created for a period of about six months, if an institution attested that it had been subject to a protest that 'impeded' access to the property in the previous 90 days.
Council rejected a proposal to increase the buffer to 100 metres, but did pass a motion from Coun. James Pasternak to increase it to 50 metres.
Council also passed a slew of motions from Coun. Rachel Chernos-Lin to increase the initial coverage time from six months to a year; to drop the requirement of having been previously targeted; and to request police support for bylaw officers charged with enforcing the rules.
The bylaw will limit protests outside places of worship and other places like hospitals, schools, daycares and libraries if requested by the owners of those facilities.
The city said it would need to spend $1.6 million for 12 bylaw officers to enforce the rules. Another $200,000 would go towards public education. Those who break the bylaw could face a fine of up to $5,000.
The bylaw will go into effect on July 2.
Council sees passionate debate
The city manager was asked to craft the bylaw, in consultation with the city solicitor, in Dec. 2024. Since then, a number of public consultations were held to gather input for the proposal. Sixty-three per cent of respondents said they were either strongly unsupportive or somewhat unsupportive of the law.
Speaking before council on Wednesday, Mayor Olivia Chow acknowledged that the city has to balance competing priorities.
'On one hand, there are community concerns around attending places of worship and a lot of fear for their safety. On the other hand, we have to protect the Charter rights to freely assemble and expression,' she said.
Protests in the city have increased in the wake of the Israel-Hamas war and Toronto police said earlier this year that they responded to 2,000 'unplanned events' in 2024. It's unclear how many of those protests took place outside of the institutions described in the bylaw.
Coun. James Pasternak, speaking at city hall, said he believes the law would not impact freedom of speech.
'It doesn't take any rights away. It doesn't take away the right to protest, the right to picket, or the right to free speech. And all it's doing is extending rights to those who want to walk into vulnerable institutions,' he said Wednesday.
Coun. Brad Bradford echoed those remarks, calling the bylaw an 'additional tool' that could help 'clear out and protect' places of worship that he says have been targeted with hate, harassment, intimidation and violence.
Several councillors said they had heard from constituents who said they no longer feel safe in some parts of the city because of some of the protests.
Meanwhile, Coun. Gord Perks argued that 'everybody has the right to express themselves.'
'If we don't encourage the right to protest, we lose all the democratic rights that have been built up in Canada over time,' he said.
Coun. Chris Moise said he was 'concerned' the bylaw could violate people's Charter rights. As such, he put forward his own motion to defer a vote on the proposed bylaw until Ottawa introduces a federal bill related to accessing places of worship, something Prime Minister Mark Carney said he would table in the run up to last month's election. The motion was defeated.
Similar bylaws have been passed in Vaughan and Brampton, after large-scale, and in some cases violent, protests broke out near synagogues and temples, respectively, last year. Those bylaws limit protests to 100 metres from a place of worship and owners of those institutions do not need to apply for an access area to be established.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CTV News
21 minutes ago
- CTV News
Body of Israeli-Canadian Judih Weinstein held by Hamas recovered
This undated photo provided by Hostage's Family Forum shows Israeli hostage Judih Weinstein and Gad Haggai, whose bodies have been recovered from Gaza by Israeli security forces. (Hostage's Family Forum via AP) OTTAWA -- Israel has recovered the bodies of two hostages taken in Hamas' Oct. 7, 2023 attack that ignited the war in the Gaza Strip, including one Canadian citizen. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu said the remains of Judih Weinstein and Gad Haggai were recovered and returned to Israel in a special operation by the army and the Shin Bet internal security agency. 'Together with all the citizens of Israel, my wife and I extend our heartfelt condolences to the dear families. Our hearts ache for the most terrible loss. May their memory be blessed,' he said in a media statement. Kibbutz Nir Oz, a small community near the Gaza border, announced in December 2023 the deaths of Weinstein, 70, and Haggai, 72, both of whom had Israeli and U.S. citizenship. Weinstein was also a Canadian citizen. Iddo Moed, Israel's ambassador to Canada, said in a social media statement that this is a 'painful moment that brings closure to the family.' 'We will not rest until all remaining 56 hostage are back home,' Moed said. Noah Shack, interim president of the Canadian Jewish advocacy organization CIJA, said their hearts are with Weinstein and Haggai's children and grandchildren. 'Judih embodied the very best of Canada and Israel. An educator for children with special needs and a passionate peacebuilder, she dedicated her life to coexistence -- teaching meditation to both Palestinian and Israeli children. She didn't just believe in peace; she lived it,' Shack said in a media statement. The military said the two were killed in the Oct. 7 attack and taken into Gaza by the Mujahideen Brigades, the small armed group the military said also abducted and killed Shiri Bibas and her two small children. The army said it recovered the remains of Weinstein and Haggai overnight into Thursday from the southern Gaza city of Khan Younis. The couple were taking an early morning walk near their home in Kibbutz Nir Oz on the morning of Oct. 7 when Hamas militants stormed across the border and rampaged through several army bases and farming communities. In the early hours of the morning, Weinstein was able to call emergency services to let them know that both she and her husband had been shot, and to send a message to her family. Weinstein was born in New York and taught English to children with special needs at Kibbutz Nir Oz. The kibbutz said she also taught meditation techniques to children and teenagers who suffered from anxiety as a result of rocket fire from Gaza. Haggai was a retired chef and jazz musician. 'My beautiful parents have been freed. We have certainty,' their daughter, Iris Haggai Liniado, wrote in a Facebook post. She thanked the Israeli military, the FBI and the Israeli and U.S. governments and called for the release of all the remaining hostages. The couple were survived by two sons and two daughters and seven grandchildren, the kibbutz said. At least 10 Palestinians were killed in Israeli strikes in Khan Younis overnight, according to Nasser Hospital, which received the bodies. It was not immediately clear if the strikes were related to the recovery mission. In Gaza City, three local reporters were killed and six people were wounded in a strike on the courtyard of the al-Ahli Hospital, according to Gaza's Health Ministry. It did not immediately identify the journalists or say which outlets they worked for. The Israeli military said it was looking into reports on the strike at al-Ahli. The army says it only targets militants and blames civilian deaths on Hamas because it is embedded in populated areas. Hamas-led militants killed some 1,200 people, mostly civilians, in the Oct. 7 attack and abducted 251 hostages. They are still holding 56 hostages -- around a third of them believed to be alive -- after most of the rest were released in ceasefire agreements or other deals. Israeli forces have rescued eight living hostages from Gaza and recovered dozens of bodies. Israel's military campaign has killed more than 54,000 Palestinians, mostly women and children, according to the Gaza Health Ministry, which does not say how many of the dead were civilians or combatants. The offensive has destroyed large parts of Gaza and displaced around 90 per cent of its population of roughly 2 million Palestinians. The United States, Egypt and Qatar have been trying to broker another ceasefire and hostage release after Israel ended an earlier truce in March and imposed a blockade that has raised fears of famine, despite being eased in recent weeks. But the talks appear to be deadlocked. Hamas says it will only release the remaining hostages in return for more Palestinian prisoners, a lasting ceasefire and an Israeli withdrawal from Gaza. It has offered to hand over power to a politically independent Palestinian committee. Netanyahu has rejected those terms, saying Israel will only agree to temporary ceasefires to facilitate the return of hostages. He has vowed to continue the war until all the hostages are returned and Hamas is defeated or disarmed and sent into exile. He has said Israel will maintain control over Gaza indefinitely and will facilitate what he refers to as the voluntary emigration of much of its population to other countries. The Palestinians and much of the international community have rejected such plans, viewing them as forcible expulsion that could violate international law. -- With files from The Associated Press David Baxter, The Canadian Press This report by The Canadian Press was first published June 5, 2025.
CTV News
30 minutes ago
- CTV News
Muskoka to welcome Canada's premiers in July
Premier Doug Ford is hosting Canada's premiers in Muskoka this summer. In an invite to all 13 members of the Council of the Federation (COF), Ford is requesting their presence to shore up their commitment to work together to build a stronger, more united country. 'With President Trump taking direct aim at our economy, we need to build and we need to build fast,' said Premier Ford. 'Together, premiers are seizing the momentum coming out of the recent First Ministers' Meeting in Saskatoon to move the projects that will unleash the full potential of Canada's economy forward. There's never been a more important time for all of us from coast to coast to coast to work together to build the most competitive economy in the G7.' The meeting July 21 to 23 will focus on encouraging premiers to move forward with nation-building projects, how to navigate Canada-U.S. relations, as well as working toward making Canadian communities safer. Once in Muskoka, Canada's provincial leaders will sit with national Indigenous organizations to discuss economic development and reconciliation. During his time as chairperson of the Council of the Federation, Ford has coordinated a Team Canada approach to fight tariffs, all the while helping Canada remain on equal footing with the U.S., which included a visit to Washington D.C. with the complete cadre of premiers. Quick Facts
CTV News
an hour ago
- CTV News
New York transit executive selected to be new head of TTC
A New York City transit executive has been tapped to take over as the head of the Toronto Transit Commission, Mayor Olivia Chow announced Thursday. Mandeep Lali, who was previously in charge of subway operations at New York's Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA), will replace former TTC CEO Rick Leary, who resigned last summer. 'Mr. Lali has over two decades of global experience in transit,' Chow said during Thursday's news conference in Scarborough. 'He deeply understands public transit in a big, busy city. Mandeep Lali's depth of experience managing the most complex subway system in the world is exactly what we need to get Toronto moving.' TTC Chair Jamaal Myers called the hiring process an 'extensive international search' that lasted nearly nine months. He noted that Lali has 'immense experience' in both the private and public sector and has held senior roles at 'two of the world's most iconic transit system.' In addition to his experience at the MTA, Myers said Lali spent 13 years in 'progressively senior roles' at Transport for London. 'What made Mandeep stand out among all of the outstanding candidates that we considered was his clarity of vision,' Myers said. 'When we asked him what his goal for the TTC was he said, without missing a beat, 'To make the TTC the most reliable transit system in north American.' As a lifelong ttc rider, this was music to my ears.' More details to come...
