logo
Iran's history has been blighted by interference from foreign powers

Iran's history has been blighted by interference from foreign powers

Yahoo5 hours ago

Israel's recent surprise attack on Iran was ostensibly aimed at neutralising Iran's nuclear programme, but it didn't just damage nuclear installations. It killed scientists, engineers and senior military personnel.
Meanwhile, citizens with no ties to the government or military, became 'collateral damage'. For 11 days, Israel's attacks intensified across Tehran and other major cities.
When the US joined the attack, dropping its bunker-buster bombs on sites in central Iran on June 21, it threatened to push the region closer to large-scale conflict. Israel's calls for regime change in Iran were joined by the US president, Donald Trump, who took to social media on June 22 with the message: 'if the current Iranian Regime is unable to MAKE IRAN GREAT AGAIN, why wouldn't there be a Regime change??? MIGA!!!'
Trump's remarks are reminders of past US interventions. The threat of regime change by the most powerful state in the world carries particular weight in Iran, where memories of foreign-imposed coups and covert operations remain vivid and painful.
Get your news from actual experts, straight to your inbox. Sign up to our daily newsletter to receive all The Conversation UK's latest coverage of news and research, from politics and business to the arts and sciences.
In the early 1890s, Iran was rocked by a popular uprising after the shah granted a British company exclusive rights to the country's tobacco industry. The decision was greeted with anger and in 1891 the country's senior cleric, Grand Ayatollah Mirza Shirazi, issued a fatwa against tobacco use.
A mass boycott ensued – even the shah's wives reportedly gave up the habit. When it became clear that the boycott was going to hold, the shah cancelled the concession in January 1892. It was a clear demonstration of people power.
This event is thought to have played a significant role in the development of the revolutionary movement that led to the Constitutional Revolution that took place between 1905 and 1911 and the establishment of a constitution and parliament in Iran.
Reza Shah, who founded the Pahlavi dynasty – which would be overthrown in the 1979 revolution and replaced by the Islamic Republic – rose to power following a British-supported coup in 1921.
During the first world war, foreign interference weakened Iran and the ruling Qajar dynasty. In 1921, with British support, army officer Reza Khan and politician Seyyed Ziaeddin Tabatabaee led a coup in Tehran. Claiming to be acting to save the monarchy, they arrested key opponents. By 1923, Reza Khan had become prime minister.
In 1925, Reza Khan unseated the Qajars and founded the Pahlavi dynasty, becoming Reza Shah Pahlavi. This was a turning point in Iran's history, marking the start of British dominance. The shah's authoritarian rule focused on centralisation, modernisation and secularisation. It set the stage for the factors that would that eventually lead to the 1979 Revolution.
In 1941, concerned at the close relationship Pahlavi had developed with Nazi Germany, Britain and its allies once again intervened in Iranian politics, forcing Pahlavi to abdicate. He was exiled to South Africa and his 22-year-old son, Mohammad Reza, was named shah in his place.
Mohammad Mosaddegh became Iran's first democratically elected prime minister in 1951. He quickly began to introduce reforms and challenge the authority of the shah. Despite a sustained campaign of destabilisation, Mossadegh retained a high level of popular support, which he used to push through his radical programme. This included the nationalisation of Iran's oil industry, which was effectively controlled by the Anglo-Persian Oil Company – later British Petroleum (BP).
In 1953, he was ousted in a CIA and MI6-backed coup and placed under house arrest. The shah, who had fled to Italy during the unrest, returned to power with western support.
Within a short time, Mohammad Reza Shah Pahlavi established an authoritarian regime that governed through repression and intimidation. He outlawed all opposition parties, and numerous activists involved in the oil nationalisation movement were either imprisoned or forced into exile.
Read more:
The shah's rule became increasingly authoritarian and was also marked by the lavish lifestyles of the ruling elite and increasing poverty of the mass of the Iranian people. Pahlavi increasingly relied on his secret police, the Bureau for Intelligence and Security of the State.
Meanwhile, a scholar and Islamic cleric named Ruhollah Khomeini, had been rising in prominence especially after 1963, when Pahlavi's unpopular land reforms mobilised a large section of society against his rule. His growing prominence brought him into confrontation with the government and in 1964 he was sent into exile. He remained abroad, living in Turkey, Iraq and France.
By 1978 a diverse alliance primarily made up of urban working and middle-class citizens had paralysed the country. While united in their resistance to the monarchy, participants were driven by a variety of ideological beliefs, including socialism, communism, liberalism, secularism, Islamism and nationalism. The shah fled into exile on January 16 1979 and Khomeini returned to Iran, which in March became an Islamic Republic with Khomeini at its head.
But the US was not finished in its attempts to destabilise Iran. In 1980, Washington backed Saddam Hussein in initiating a brutal eight-year war, which claimed hundreds of thousands of Iranian lives and severely disrupted the country's efforts at political and economic reconstruction.
Iran and the US have remained bitter foes. Over the years ordinary Iranians have suffered tremendously under rounds of US-imposed sanctions, which have all but destroyed the economy in recent years.
This new wave of foreign aggression has arrived at a time of significant domestic unrest within Iran. Since the Woman, Life, Freedom protests, which began in September 2022 after the death of Mahsa Amini at the hands of the morality police, there has been a general groundswell of demand for social justice and democracy.
But the convergence of external aggression and internal demands has brought national sovereignty and self-determination to the forefront, as it did during previous major struggles. While world powers gamble with Iran's future, it is the Iranian people through their struggles and unwavering push for justice and democracy who must determine the country's future.
This article is republished from The Conversation under a Creative Commons license. Read the original article.
Simin Fadaee does not work for, consult, own shares in or receive funding from any company or organisation that would benefit from this article, and has disclosed no relevant affiliations beyond their academic appointment.

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Playbook PM: Trump tallies wins as he leaves NATO summit
Playbook PM: Trump tallies wins as he leaves NATO summit

Politico

time20 minutes ago

  • Politico

Playbook PM: Trump tallies wins as he leaves NATO summit

Presented by THE CATCH-UP THE VICTORY LAP CONTINUES: President Donald Trump took center stage at the NATO summit in the Netherlands today, touting his brokered ceasefire between Iran and Israel that seems to be holding, as well as the defense spending commitment that he secured from NATO allies — a 'monumental win for the United States' as Trump called it. What Trump said: The president spent a large portion of a nearly hourlong news conference blasting the intel assessment reported yesterday that found Iran's nuclear capabilities had only been set back by months. 'We think we hit 'em so hard and so fast, they didn't get to move,' Trump said, while slamming the NYT and CNN for their reporting. 'We destroyed the nuclear. It's blown up … to kingdom come.' He even compared the attack to the nuclear bombs detonated in Hiroshima and Nagasaki in 1945, Reuters' Jeff Mason and Gram Slattery report. 'This ended a war in a different way,' he said. Especially upset: Secretary of Defense Pete Hegseth, who's ordered a Pentagon investigation into the initial assessment leak per POLITICO's Paul McLeary. Hegseth said at the news conference there was 'low confidence' in the initial report on the damage, adding: 'If you want to make an assessment at what happened at Fordo, get a big shovel and go deep, because Iran's nuclear program is obliterated.' The damage: Iran's Foreign Ministry said today that their nuclear installations were 'badly damaged' but didn't provide many more details, Bloomberg's Dana Khraiche reports. Trump said in a Truth Social post that Israel backed up his 'OBLITERATED' claim. What comes next: Trump said he'll be talking with Iran next week, and he will 'probably' ask for a written statement that Iran won't pursue a nuclear weapon again. 'But they're not going to be doing it anyway,' adding that it's a possibility Iran signs an agreement. Asked whether the two sides could resume fighting, Trump said 'I think they're very much finished.' WORD PLAY: NATO allies cemented their agreement today to boost defense spending to 5 percent — but not all the allies, thanks to the language in the group's comminqué, NYT's Lara Jakes writes. 'The difference lies in a bit of mushy diplomatic language that lets the NATO secretary general, Mark Rutte, claim that he delivered on President Trump's spending demand. The brief and unanimously approved communiqué that NATO issued after leaders wrapped up their annual summit says that 'allies' — not 'all allies' — had agreed to the 5 percent figure.' Striking back: Trump lashed out at Spain, which didn't agree to the 5 percent bump, and signaled he's ready to retaliate for what he views as an ally not stepping up to the plate — threatening Madrid will pay 'twice as much' in tariffs in a renegotiated trade deal, POLITICO's Eli Stokols and Felicia Schwartz report. And yet, Trump 'declared outright that NATO allies' 'passion' for their collective defense had erased much of his long-held skepticism about the alliance,' Eli and Felicia write. ME AND Z: Trump also met with Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy on the sidelines of the summit, who 'couldn't have been nicer,' Trump said. Zelenskyy called the meeting 'long and substantive,' and it prompted Trump to consider sending more Patriot air-defense batteries to the war-torn country, per Bloomberg's Daryna Krasnolutska and Andrea Dudik. After talking with Zelenskyy, Trump told reporters that Russian President 'Vladimir Putin really has to end that war.' Mixed signals: Secretary of State Marco Rubio signaled that the U.S. likely wouldn't slap more sanctions on Russia, Eli reports with more of our POLITICO colleagues. But that softer stance from Rubio 'came as a surprise to the NATO foreign ministers Rubio met the night before,' who he told that the Senate would likely take up sanctions legislation soon. MOOD MUSIC: Rutte appears to have 'cracked the code for a successful leaders' summit involving President Donald Trump: Call him 'daddy,'' POLITICO's Felicia Schwartz and colleagues write from The Hague. 'Add to that a significantly slimmed-down schedule that was long on praise for the president — Rutte's 'daddy' was intended as a compliment for intervening in the fighting between Israel and Iran — and short on existential questions like how alliance members will fund their most significant spending increase since the end of the Cold War.' IN THE AIR: Trump is on his way back to the U.S., per the pool. He's leaving what was surely nicer weather and will return to swampy humidity once he's back (stay inside, folks). Good Wednesday afternoon. Thanks for reading Playbook PM. Spot something? Send it my way at abianco@ 7 THINGS YOU NEED TO KNOW 1. IN THE HOT SEAT: Emil Bove, a top Justice Department official, and federal appeals court nominee testified before the Senate Judiciary Committee this morning for a confirmation hearing for his appointment to a federal appeals court. Sen. Dick Durbin, the top Democrat on the panel, said Bove was in a 'category all of his own' in terms of controversial Trump judicial nominees, POLITICO's Hailey Fuchs and Erica Orden report. On the controversies: Bove said he 'never advised a Department of Justice attorney to violate a court order,' as a whistleblower complaint alleged. He also defended DOJ's controversial decision to squash the corruption prosecution of NYC Mayor Eric Adams and denied that there was any quid pro quo to get Adams' cooperation on immigration enforcement — though he did say 'policy reasons made it appropriate to dismiss the charges.' More from Hailey and Erica 2. THE VIEW FROM 1600 PENN: The White House is on a messaging push as the self-imposed July 4 deadline to deliver the megabill rapidly approaches. Stephen Miran, the White House's chief economist, said Trump's policies will reduce the budget deficit by up to $11 trillion over the next decade, Bloomberg's Skylar Woodhouse reports. Half the savings would come from economic growth and another part would come from tariff revenue, Miran said. Report card: It's part of an analysis by the Council of Economic Advisers sent to Congress today as the administration ramps up its efforts to sell the sprawling reconciliation bill, per POLITICO's Jordain Carney. 'The analysis is significantly rosier than projections from most other economists, who doubt that the Republican plan will do much for growth,' Jordain writes. Read the full report Clamping down: NEC Director Kevin Hassett is urging trade partners to get a deal done before the megabill, which could make the bill's controversial 'revenge tax,' which raises taxes on foreign companies and investors in retaliation, a moot point, Bloomberg's Emily Birnbaum and Lauren Vella report. Clicker: 'How much will you save or lose with Trump's 'big' tax bill?' by WaPo 3. MAMDANI MANIA: Just hours after Zohran Mamdani claimed the Democratic nomination in the NYC mayoral contest, Republicans are racing to turn the 33-year-old democratic socialist into their new boogeyman ahead of next year's midterms, POLITICO's Jacob Wendler reports. A host of prominent MAGA-aligned commentators 'launched xenophobic attacks' against the Mamdani's Muslim religion, POLITICO's Nicole Markus writes. But Mamdani's ascension marks a 'watershed moment for Muslim New Yorkers,' roughly one million of whom call NYC home and played a critical role in expanding the electorate that delivered for Mamdani, NYT's Maya King reports. Calls from Congress: In a pair of posts on X this morning, Chuck Schumer and Hakeem Jeffries — Democrats' top two congressional leaders who both hail from New York — offered guarded praise for Mamdani. Schumer congratulated Mamdani on an 'impressive campaign,' while Jeffries lauded it as a 'strong campaign.' Both applauded his focus on the economy and each said they had spoken to Mamdani this morning and planned to meet in person soon. But absent from both messages was a full-throated endorsement. Welcome to the general election: Eric Adams, who is now set to face off against Mamdani in November, went on Fox News this morning to preview his attack line. 'He's a snake oil salesman, he will say and do anything to get elected,' Adams said on 'Fox and Friends.' 4. THE REAL-WORLD IMPACT: Speaker Mike Johnson's state of Louisiana is 'uniquely vulnerable' to cuts to Medicaid and food assistance programs included in the 'big, beautiful bill,' POLITICO's Liz Crampton reports in a must read from Shreveport in Johnson's district. 'Louisiana is poorer, sicker and hungrier than most states, and the deep cuts to Medicaid have a growing number of Republicans in Louisiana worried that Congress and the White House are going too far,' Liz writes. 'More than 1.6 million Louisianans — roughly 35 percent of the state's population — count on it for health care.' 5. HOLD YOUR FIRE: Rep. Thomas Massie (R-Ky.) — the bullseye for many a Trump Truth Social post — wants a truce, WSJ's Olivia Beavers and colleagues report. The consistent attacks are 'not about changing my vote' on the megabill, adding that they are 'flogging me to keep the other horses in the barn,' Massie said. But he still wants to cool things down: 'I want a cease-fire. I survived the bunker busters. Let's call it even.' More on Massie: The Kentucky Republican has been a consistent thorn in Trump's side, and Trump-aligned GOP groups have already drawn up plans to oust him in 2026, POLITICO's Brakkton Booker and colleagues write. Things could get expensive, fast: 'Some Republican strategists estimate combined spending could reach as high as $45 million, an unheard of total for a primary contest in the 4th Congressional District.' Says Chris LaCivita in a text message to POLITICO: 'He has established himself as a contrarian for contrarian sake … He should be a man and switch parties instead of posing as a Republican.' 6. IMMIGRATION FILES: The Trump administration has promised to target the 'worst of the worst immigrants,' but so far only 6% of known immigrant offenders have been arrested, NBC's Julia Ainsley and Laura Strickler scooped. Almost half those in ICE custody have no charges or criminal convictions at all. And exclusive reporting from CNN's Priscilla Alvarez reveals the Trump administration is preparing to dismiss hundreds of thousands of asylum claims to speed the deportations of migrants. Behind the curtain: 'Inside the Global Deal-Making Behind Trump's Mass Deportations,' by NYT's Edward Wong and colleagues: 'U.S. officials have approached Angola, Mongolia and embattled Ukraine. … The U.S. government paid Rwanda $100,000 to take an Iraqi man and is discussing sending more deportees there. Peru has said no so far, despite having been pressed repeatedly. … The Trump administration has spoken to at least 29 nations in Europe, Latin America, Africa and Asia … Beyond that, the State Department has asked diplomats overseas to approach at least another 29 countries, most of them in Africa, for a total of at least 58.' 7. 2026 WATCH: Scott Brown, the former ambassador to New Zealand and Samoa and Massachusetts senator, is making another play for the Senate, hoping to replace retiring Democrat Jeanne Shaheen in New Hampshire, WMUR's Adam Sexton scooped. Brown becomes the highest-profile Republican to enter the race, which the GOP believes it can flip next fall. Asked if he has assurances of Trump's support, Brown said: 'There's no assurances in anything in life at all. I live every day as if it's my last — and certainly I would love the president's endorsement.' TALK OF THE TOWN SPOTTED: CMS Administrator Mehmet Oz dining at the Occidental last night. MEDIAWATCH — WaPo is launching a new program that will allow sources quoted in its articles to annotate or add additional information, NYT's Ben Mullin scooped. 'The program will allow only people identified by name in an article to comment on it, and the articles included for now are only those published by The Post's climate team.' OUT AND ABOUT — SPOTTED at a reelection fundraiser for Rep. Jim Clyburn (D-S.C.) hosted by Lyndon Boozer, Fred Humphries, Steve Hartell, Laurie Knight and James Assey at Cafe Fiorello last night: Mignon Clyburn, Shashrina Thomas, Ashley Hayes, Katreice Banks, Lance Mangum, Jamie Gillespie, Erik Huey, Gerry Harrington, De'Ana Dow, Larry Duncan and G.K. Butterfield. — Thailand hosted a reception for the House Chiefs of Staff Association yesterday evening in Georgetown, where representatives from 10 Southeast Asian countries joined 70 chiefs of staff for karaoke and Asian food. Thai Ambassador Suriya Chindawongse sang 'Apt.' by Rosé and Bruno Mars as the first song. SPOTTED: Singaporean Ambassador Lui Tuck Yew, Philippine Ambassador Jose Manuel Romualdez, Mitchell Rivard, Heather Swift, Michelle Dorothy, Zach Weidlich, Mark Dreiling, Nikki Wallace, Mary Rosado, Jaryn Emhof, Rick Jakious, Tasia Jackson, Jeremy Marcus, Chloe Hunt, Drew Ross, Jo Stiles, Marcus Garza, Blake Nolan and Liz Amster. — SPOTTED at a 'YouTube in Session' event at Union Station bringing together policymakers and YouTube creators for discussions: Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-Iowa), Rep. Josh Riley (D-N.Y.), Emily Jashinsky, Hannah Akey, Nathan Brand, Cooper Reves, Michael Comer, Earnestine Dawson, Hunter Koski, Zachari Levy, Billy McLaughlin, Tizzy Brown, Stephanie Chambless, J.P. Freire and Hannah Eddins. — SPOTTED at a launch party for Alex Swoyer's new book, 'Lawless Lawfare: Tipping the Scales of Justice to Get Trump and Destroy MAGA' ($18.04), at Butterworth's last night, also hosted by Post Hill Press publisher Anthony Ziccardi: Mike Davis (who wrote the foreword), Harmeet Dhillon, Kenny Cunningham, Raheem Kassam, Jesse Binnall, Curt Levey, Chris Dolan, Stephen Dinan, Bradley Jaye, Matt Boyle, Charlie Spiering, Otto Heck, Dante Swallow, Brigid Mary McDonnell, Eric Branstad, James Rockas and Julia Pollak. TRANSITIONS — Hale Diamond is now creative director for Rep. Joaquin Castro (D-Texas). She previously was comms director for Rep. Tim Kennedy (D-N.Y.) and is a House Transportation and Infrastructure Dems alum. … Robert Shapiro is now a partner in Dechert's financial services practice group. He was previously assistant chief counsel in the division of investment management at the SEC. … Eric Lipka is now speechwriter for Senate Minority Whip Dick Durbin (D-Ill.). He previously was Pennsylvania deputy press secretary on the Harris campaign and is an Elizabeth Warren alum. … … Jonas Edwards-Jenks is now a VP with BerlinRosen's impact practice. He was previously comms director at End Citizens United. … Ariel Hayes is joining the Democratic Association of Secretaries of State as executive director. She previously ran the national political department at the Sierra Club. … Will Boyington is now associate administrator for comms at NASA. He previously was director of external comms at Blue Origin. Send Playbookers tips to playbook@ or text us on Signal here. Playbook couldn't happen without our editor Zack Stanton, deputy editor Garrett Ross and Playbook Podcast producer Callan Tansill-Suddath.

UN's atomic agency's Iran policy gets mixed reviews from experts after US-Israel 'obliterate' nuclear sites
UN's atomic agency's Iran policy gets mixed reviews from experts after US-Israel 'obliterate' nuclear sites

Fox News

time23 minutes ago

  • Fox News

UN's atomic agency's Iran policy gets mixed reviews from experts after US-Israel 'obliterate' nuclear sites

JERUSALEM - After 12 days of fighting, President Donald Trump and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu declared victory against Iran's nuclear program. Trump declared three nuclear sites had been obliterated, as Netanyahu announced that Israel had "removed an immediate dual existential threat: both in the nuclear domain and in the area of ballistic missiles" – achievements the U.N.'s International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) failed to reach throughout some 20 years of monitoring Iran's nuclear activities. Dr. Or Rabinowitz, a nuclear proliferation scholar from the Hebrew University of Jerusalem and a visiting associate professor at Stanford University, told Fox News Digital that the IAEA "cannot, by itself, stop a country that wants to divert nuclear material and technology from its civilian program to its military program." "It can warn, and that's what it has been doing," she said. "Sometimes these warnings led to United Nations Security Council resolutions, and sometimes they didn't, but the IAEA by itself, can't do more than that – it is only as strong as the board members and the countries that participate in it." Days before Israel launched its military assault on Iran with the aim of removing the nuclear – and conventional – weapons threat, the global nuclear watchdog reported that Iran had an estimated 408.6 kilograms (nearly 901 pounds) of uranium enriched to 60%, enough to make some nine nuclear bombs. The report, which also criticized Iran's lack of cooperation with the IAEA, prompted the agency's board of governors, for the first time in 20 years, to declare that the Islamic Republic was in breach of its non-proliferation obligations. "We shouldn't be surprised by this failure, and we should add to this failure, the failure of the United Nations," said Dr. Yoel Guzansky, a senior fellow at the Institute for National Security Studies at Tel Aviv University. Guzansky highlighted the fact that just a week ago, in the midst of launching hundreds of ballistic missiles into Israeli towns and cities, Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi addressed the U.N. Human Rights Council in Geneva. "Iran was welcomed there, and Israel was bashed," he noted. "It just shows that the U.N. system has long failed, and is long in need of remodeling, remaking, rebuilding," Guzansky continued, adding that compared to other U.N. bodies, "the IAEA is fairly okay." "It's not black and white, it has had some achievements, but it depends on what your expectations are," he continued. "I don't think anyone expected that the IAEA would entirely prevent Iran." Guzansky said that two decades of inspections and such reports had actually allowed Israel, and the U.S., to "gather intelligence and an understanding of Iran's nuclear program" – a fact that was tested over the past week and a half. Iran has consistently maintained that all its nuclear activities were entirely peaceful and that it would never seek to develop or acquire nuclear weapons. "The real problem here isn't necessarily the IAEA, it's that Iran has been cheating for 20 years and has not been playing a straight bat," said Alan Mendoza, Executive Director of the Henry Jackson Society. "Iran has been confusing and tricking and secretly developing programs, which the IAEA has not been able to access," he said, adding, "so, in many ways, it's not the IAEA fault, per se, it doesn't have any enforcement capabilities -- its job is just to monitor." Mendoza also said that Iran's ability to advance its nuclear ambitions and enrich uranium to weapons grade level was "really the fault of the international community, rather than an agency." "This could have been cracked down upon years ago, as we have now seen, whether by military or other means, to actually force Iran into compliance," he said. "What this ultimately shows you is that when you have an international malefactor who continues to want to game the system, the only way to deal with them is to blow up the system and say, 'Okay, you want to play it that way,' well, here's our response." Despite the U.S. and Israel's successful use of force, the IAEA has held back from commending their actions. At an emergency session of the agency's board members on Monday, Rafael Grossi, the IAEA's Director General, was still urging diplomacy and warning that fighting risked "collapsing the global nuclear Non Proliferation regime." "There is still a path for diplomacy, we must take it, otherwise violence and destruction could reach unimaginable levels, and the global Non-Proliferation regime that has underpinned international security for more than half a century could crumble and fall," he said, without a word about Iran's lack of transparency and its clear violation of international agreements over more than two decades. But on Tuesday, two days after the U.S. military carried out massive precision strikes on three key nuclear sites in Iran, Grossi told Fox News' Martha MacCallum that his agency did not know where nearly 900 pounds of potentially enriched uranium is now located, after Iranian officials said it had been removed for protective measures ahead of the US strikes on nuclear facilities in Iran. "Like all the international bodies who have been condemning US and Israeli action, these organizations exist for the purpose solely of diplomacy," Mendoza said, adding, "The agency doesn't have any military function. It has no recourse to it. It can't call for it, so, if you think about it, all they're doing is merely protecting their position within the international system." Requests for a response from the IAEA were not immediately answered on Wednesday.

War Powers Resolution From House Democratic Leaders May Not Limit Trump's War Powers
War Powers Resolution From House Democratic Leaders May Not Limit Trump's War Powers

The Intercept

time27 minutes ago

  • The Intercept

War Powers Resolution From House Democratic Leaders May Not Limit Trump's War Powers

As Democrats try to push forward legislation that would block further strikes on Iran, one measure advanced by House leadership could actually strengthen the Trump administration's justification for subsequent attacks, anti-war advocates warn. House progressives on Wednesday were trying to reach a compromise with Democratic leaders that would curb further U.S. military involvement in Iran while satisfying concerns from pro-Israel members about American support for Israel's missile defense. There are three different war powers resolutions in play in Washington. In the Senate, a resolution from Tim Kaine, D-Va., appears to be on track for a vote on Friday. In the House, however, Democrats remain sharply divided between two resolutions. 'There's no upside to advancing a competing War Powers Resolution. It's not just unnecessary — it's actively counterproductive,' Cavan Kharrazian, a senior policy adviser at Demand Progress, said in a statement. 'There's still time to reconcile this on the House side, and we hope an agreement can be reached to enable a strong vote with the best possible language.' The resolutions in both chambers face long odds, thanks to near-unanimous support from the majority Republicans for President Donald Trump's strikes. Congressional Democrats are responding to Trump's strikes by pursuing a vote under the War Powers Act, the Vietnam War-era law designed to limit presidents' ability to launch military action abroad without congressional approval. Kaine's initial resolution introduced last week directs Trump to halt hostilities against Iran, while making clear that the president can still defend the U.S. from imminent attack. Kaine's resolution has drawn support from Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, D-N.Y. It is expected to come to a voter later this week. Amid concerns from pro-Israel Democrats, Kaine said Tuesday that he was co-sponsoring an amendment to his resolution with Sens. Adam Schiff, D-Calif., and Andy Kim, D-N.J. The amendment is intended to continue to allow the U.S. to participate in Israeli missile defense. Pentagon officials said last April that the U.S. — not Israel — shot down most Iranian drones and missiles during an Iranian attack. 'This amendment would leave no doubt that Senator Kaine's resolution would ensure that President Trump has to make the case to the American people for further action against Iran without constraining our ability to help defend the Israeli people from Iranian attacks,' Kim said in a statement. While most Senate Democrats appeared to have coalesced around Kaine's resolution, House Democrats remained split on Wednesday over how to respond to Trump's strikes. Advocates last week said they were frustrated that Democratic leaders were not moving forward with a resolution as Trump publicly mulled attacking Iran. Rep. Ro Khanna, D-Calif., teamed up with Rep. Thomas Massie, R-Ky., to introduce a resolution. After the strikes were launched, three House Democratic committee ranking members introduced an alternative resolution that its authors claim would also force Trump to cease hostilities with Iran. The sponsors are Reps. Jim Himes of Connecticut, Adam Smith of Washington, and Gregory Meeks of New York. Anti-war advocates worry that the House leadership measure could actually wind up strengthening Trump's justification for launching further strikes on Iran. In an apparent nod to Israel, the leaders' resolution would give the president the power to 'defend the United States or an ally or partner of the United States from imminent attack.' Trump has already justified his strike on Iran as an act of 'collective self-defense of our ally, Israel,' according to a letter he sent Congress, despite the assessment of U.S intelligence agencies that Iran was not building a nuclear weapon. Critics say the House Democratic leadership resolution mirrors the language of Trump's justification far too closely. 'We think if it passes, it would be worse than not having a war powers resolution.' 'We think if it passes, it would be worse than not having a war powers resolution,' said Yasmine Taeb, the legislative and political director for the Muslim advocacy group MPower Change. 'This war powers resolution gives the impression that the president has broad authority to be able to engage in military offensive action with respect to Iran — if Israel is asking us to.' Spokespersons for Himes, Meeks, and Smith's offices did not immediately comment. Khanna has said that his resolution is intended to preserve the U.S. military's ability to participate in Israeli missile defense. Advocates said they understood there were ongoing discussions about a compromise. The two sides have ample time: A vote on the measure is not expected to come to the floor before mid- to late-July. Whether or not the two sides come to an accord, however, the push to respond to Trump's strikes could face serious pushback from Republican House Speaker Mike Johnson. Johnson said Tuesday that he thought the War Powers Act itself was unconstitutional and signaled that he may use a procedural move to prevent it from coming to the floor. The War Powers Act states that resolutions brought under its auspices must be fast-tracked to the House floor within 15 working days. Johnson, however, could try to block the resolution from receiving such a 'privileged' status — although that would likely force a vote on the procedural maneuver itself. Massie's co-sponsorship of the resolution gave it bipartisan support, but it's unclear whether he will continue to push its passage in the face of intense pressure from the White House and the ceasefire announced by Trump on Monday. Massie has said he is taking a 'wait and see' approach. As a shaky ceasefire between Israel and Iran continued to hold Wednesday morning, progressives in the House said they were pursuing a vote on their preferred resolution despite the opposition from Johnson. Khanna said at a Capitol press conference that blocking the vote with a procedural maneuver would be an 'unprecedented abrogation of congressional power.' 'The fundamental point here is that we don't know what the strikes accomplished, but we do know a lot of the harm,' Khanna said. 'It has hardened the resolve in Iran to now race towards a nuclear weapon.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store