Brahms: Ein Deutsches Requiem album review
Edward Gardner and his Bergen Philharmonic forces offer a detailed, considered performance of Brahms's humanist masterpiece. Tempos are steady and sombre, the playing full of warmth, and there are heartfelt vocal solos from Johanna Wallroth and Brian Mulligan. The tone in the first movement is beautifully dark, the lower strings (the violins are silent in this movement) taking the music down into a velvety blackness, the wind soloists lavishing care on every line. It's a highly promising start. Yet while the attention to detail continues, so does the carefulness, and the latter is perhaps too dominant. The work's sense of consolation is captured more convincingly than its suggestion of release: the culmination of the penultimate movement loses its joyous momentum and remains earthbound.
That said, there's much to enjoy. Mulligan's baritone solo in the third movement conveys tension and desperation while still sounding beautiful, and is answered by choral singing that's impressively agile and secure of pitch. However, although the large choral forces comprise three massed choirs, one isn't often struck by their power: there's not much space in the recorded sound between voices and orchestra, leaving the chorus feeling a little far back in the mix. The result is that, Mulligan excepted, the words don't leap out quite as they should in this of all Requiems.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Western Telegraph
29-05-2025
- Western Telegraph
Carey Mulligan and cast 'freeze' in Pembrokeshire film shoot
The British actress stars in the upcoming comedy drama, The Ballad Of Wallis Island, which was filmed in coastal Wales during the summer. Director James Griffiths said: "Tom especially was going blue through most of the takes. "I think there was a medic going in, and you too, right (Carey)? We had a medic sort of checking your temperature for the cold stuff. "It was freezing." When asked if it was filmed during the summer, Oscar-nominated actress Mulligan said "it's Wales". The film sees Mulligan, who is married to singer Marcus Mumford, play one half of a disbanded folk band opposite Plebs star Tom Basden as her ex-boyfriend. The movie sees a fan and lottery winner – portrayed by comedian Tim Key – pay for them to reunite and perform a gig on an island, called Wallis. Mr Basden said the rural location, believed to be in and around Pembrokeshire, was "beautiful and it was unpredictable, weather wise, and it was challenging". Mr Key added: "We shot the short film (version) 18 years ago, and we're kind of very eager to get back to Wales. "Feels like it's a big part of the film. Ms Mulligan, 40, also recalled that the filming over a few weeks felt like a "summer camp together". Ms Mulligan, whose mother is from Llandeilo, Wales, also said: "I had such a little baby when we were filming, it's just attached to all these, like, gorgeous memories of my baby being little. "And you guys were all around, and everyone was cuddling her, and we were all sort of together for a bit. "So it's very precious to me." The original short film, The One And Only Herb McGwyer Plays Wallis Island, was nominated for a 2008 Bafta short film prize, and saw Mr Key and Mr Basden in the main roles. Ms Mulligan has been nominated three times for a best actress Oscar, for projects including coming-of-age hit An Education, revenge thriller Promising Young Woman, and biopic Maestro. The Ballad Of Wallis Island will come to UK cinemas on Friday.
North Wales Live
29-05-2025
- North Wales Live
Carey Mulligan 'checked by medic' during freezing Welsh summer filming
A medic was called on-set to assess if British actress Carey Mulligan and the cast were not getting too cold while they filmed a movie in coastal Wales during the summer, the director has said. In the upcoming comedy drama, The Ballad Of Wallis Island, Mulligan – who is married to singer Marcus Mumford – plays one half of a disbanded folk band opposite Plebs star Tom Basden as her ex-boyfriend. The movie, which has had critical acclaim in the US, sees a fan and lottery winner – portrayed by comedian Tim Key – pay for them to reunite and perform a gig on an island, called Wallis. At the gala screening at the Ham Yard Hotel, London, on Wednesday, director James Griffiths told the PA news agency: "Tom especially was going blue through most of the takes. 'It's Wales' "I think there was a medic going in, and you too, right (Carey)? We had a medic sort of checking your temperature for the cold stuff. It was freezing." When asked if it was filmed during the summer, Oscar-nominated actress Mulligan said "it's Wales". Basden said the rural location, believed to be in and around Pembrokeshire, was "beautiful and it was unpredictable, weather wise, and it was challenging". Key said: "We shot the short film (version) 18 years ago, and we're kind of very eager to get back to Wales. Feels like it's a big part of the film. Weirdly." Mulligan, 40, also recalled that the filming over a few weeks felt like a "summer camp together". London-born Mulligan, whose mother is originally from Llandeilo, Wales, also said: "I had such a little baby when we were filming, it's just attached to all these, like, gorgeous memories of my baby being little. "And you guys were all around, and everyone was cuddling her, and we were all sort of together for a bit. So it's very precious to me." The original short film, The One And Only Herb McGwyer Plays Wallis Island, was nominated for a 2008 Bafta short film prize, and saw Key and Basden in the main roles. Mulligan has been nominated three times for a best actress Oscar, for projects including coming-of-age hit An Education, revenge thriller Promising Young Woman, and biopic Maestro. In April 2012, Mulligan married Mumford – lead singer of Mumford & Sons – and the couple now have three children. She has previously appeared on soundtracks released for movies she has been in, including Maestro, Inside Llewyn Davis, about a fictional folk singer, and period drama Far From The Madding Crowd. The Ballad Of Wallis Island will come to UK cinemas on Friday.
Powys County Times
29-05-2025
- Powys County Times
Carey Mulligan ‘checked by medic' during freezing Welsh summer filming
A medic was called on-set to assess if British actress Carey Mulligan and the cast were not getting too cold while they filmed a movie in coastal Wales during the summer, the director has said. In the upcoming comedy drama, The Ballad Of Wallis Island, Mulligan – who is married to singer Marcus Mumford – plays one half of a disbanded folk band opposite Plebs star Tom Basden as her ex-boyfriend. The movie, which has had critical acclaim in the US, sees a fan and lottery winner – portrayed by comedian Tim Key – pay for them to reunite and perform a gig on an island, called Wallis. At the gala screening at the Ham Yard Hotel, London, on Wednesday, director James Griffiths told the PA news agency: 'Tom especially was going blue through most of the takes. 'I think there was a medic going in, and you too, right (Carey)? We had a medic sort of checking your temperature for the cold stuff. It was freezing.' When asked if it was filmed during the summer, Oscar-nominated actress Mulligan said 'it's Wales'. Basden said the rural location, believed to be in and around Pembrokeshire, was 'beautiful and it was unpredictable, weather wise, and it was challenging'. Key said: 'We shot the short film (version) 18 years ago, and we're kind of very eager to get back to Wales. Feels like it's a big part of the film. Weirdly.' Mulligan, 40, also recalled that the filming over a few weeks felt like a 'summer camp together'. London-born Mulligan, whose mother is originally from Llandeilo, Wales, also said: 'I had such a little baby when we were filming, it's just attached to all these, like, gorgeous memories of my baby being little. 'And you guys were all around, and everyone was cuddling her, and we were all sort of together for a bit. So it's very precious to me.' The original short film, The One And Only Herb McGwyer Plays Wallis Island, was nominated for a 2008 Bafta short film prize, and saw Key and Basden in the main roles. Mulligan has been nominated three times for a best actress Oscar, for projects including coming-of-age hit An Education, revenge thriller Promising Young Woman, and biopic Maestro. In April 2012, Mulligan married Mumford – lead singer of Mumford & Sons – and the couple now have three children. She has previously appeared on soundtracks released for movies she has been in, including Maestro, Inside Llewyn Davis, about a fictional folk singer, and period drama Far From The Madding Crowd.
