Bates says Post Office scandal compensation schemes are ‘quasi-kangaroo courts'
The former subpostmaster, who has campaigned for justice for colleagues, added that he has been offered compensation which he said amounts to less than half of his original claim.
Writing in the Sunday Times, the 70-year-old said: 'The subpostmaster compensation schemes have been turned into quasi-kangaroo courts in which the Department for Business and Trade sits in judgement of the claims and alters the goal posts as and when it chooses.
Sir Alan Bates is calling for an independent body to be created to administer compensation schemes (Yui Mok/PA)
'Claims are, and have been, knocked back on the basis that legally you would not be able to make them, or that the parameters of the scheme do not extend to certain items.'
More than 900 subpostmasters were prosecuted between 1999 and 2015 after faulty Horizon accounting software made it look as though money was missing from their accounts.
Many are still awaiting compensation despite the previous government announcing that those who have had convictions quashed are eligible for £600,000 payouts.
The group litigation order (GLO) scheme was set up to achieve redress for the 555 claimants who took the Post Office to the High Court between 2017 and 2019.
But Sir Alan, who was portrayed by actor Toby Jones in ITV drama Mr Bates Vs The Post Office, said promises that compensation schemes would be 'non-legalistic' had turned out to be 'worthless'.
He has also called for an independent body to be created to deliver compensation schemes for this and similar public sector scandals.
Under the GLO, claimants can take a fixed sum of £75,000 or seek their own settlement.
If there are disputes in individual cases, they are referred to an independent panel for review.
Postmasters can also seek a final view from Sir Ross Cranston, a former High Court judge, if they believe the panel has got it wrong.
Sir Alan was knighted last year for his services to justice, having founded the Justice for Subpostmasters Alliance (JFSA).
Last month, he sent an email to members of his group, calling on victims to take the Government to court over delays to financial redress, adding that a judicial review would 'probably be the quickest way to ensure fairness for all'.
It is understood that 80% of postmasters in Sir Alan's group have accepted a full and final redress or been paid most of their offer.
A Department for Business and Trade spokesman said: 'We pay tribute to all the postmasters who've suffered from this scandal, including Sir Alan for his tireless campaign for justice, and we have quadrupled the total amount paid to postmasters since entering government.
'We recognise there will be an absence of evidence given the length of time which has passed, and we therefore aim to give the benefit of the doubt to postmasters as far as possible. Anyone unhappy with their offer can have their case reviewed by a panel of experts, which is independent of the Government.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
35 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Navarro responds to Musk-Trump feud
By Published: | Updated: Trump trade advisor Peter Navarro brushed off the exploding feud between President Trump and Elon Musk by comparing the world's richest man to something a consumer might forget about in the back of the fridge. Navarro, a Trump loyalist who served four months in prison for refusing to comply with a congressional subpoena, was among the first Trump Administration officials on camera after the Trump-Musk clash went into meltdown mode. The two men were completely at odds over Trump's tariffs, which prompted a reporter to ask Navarro at the White House whether he was glad to see Musk out of the fray. 'No, I'm not glad. Whatever,' Navarro replied. 'It's – people come and go from the White House. He was a Special Government Employee with an expiration date,' Navarro said. Musk served in government as a 'Special Government Employee,' and the administration cited the 130-day limit when explaining his departure, although Trump had the power to renew it. Trump himself used language Thursday that gave the impression he fired Musk. 'Elon was 'wearing thin,' I asked him to leave,' Trump wrote in just one of his slams on his former first buddy. Later, Navarro, 75, had something nice to say about Musk's team of programmers and aides who got access to agency computer systems and searched for contracts. 'I work with the DOGE folks a lot here, and I've got a very special project, which at some point I'll come out here and talk about with them,' Navarro said. He claimed to have identified a government computer program that 'is run like a 1950s IBM punch card operation at great expense.' 'We're going to turn that from a Model T into a Ferrari,' he said. But he refused to divulge specifics on an extraordinary intervention. 'Stay tuned,' he said. Navarro has been a key proponent of Trump's tariffs, during both the first and second term, helping promote Trump's 'Liberation Day' tariffs that the administration calls 'reciprocal' to hit back at countries running a trade surplus with the U.S. In his stunning clash with Trump Thursday, Musk wrote that 'The Trump Tariffs will cause a recession in the second half of this year.' That put him at odds with Trump's cherished policy – and Trump's 'favorite word' in the dictionary – even while taking on Trump's 'big, beautiful bill,' which is Trump's top legislative priority. Navarro tried to smooth over the policy differences.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
How much Elon Musk stands to lose in Trump spat as his staggering government contracts are revealed
Elon Musk 's revenge war against Donald Trump has seen the Tesla billionaire savage his former boss with toxic insults on his platform X. But it might be the president who gets the last laugh - as the fallout threatens to lose the SpaceX founder billions of dollars. Trump has threatened to cut off huge federal loans and subsidies to Musk's companies after they fell out over the 'Big Beautiful Bill'. In the last twenty or so years, the tech guru's firms have received some $38billion in government contracts, according to The Washington Post. 'The easiest way to save money in our Budget, Billions and Billions of Dollars, is to terminate Elon's Governmental Subsidies and Contracts,' Trump wrote on Thursday. 'I was always surprised that Biden didn't do it!' The threat came after the world's richest man, worth over $330billion, torched Trump's 'Big Beautiful Bill' as a ' disgusting abomination,' largely because it's projected to add trillions of dollars to the deficit. Tesla and SpaceX - Musk's biggest companies - have received by far the most help from the government over the years. SpaceX President and COO Gwynne Shotwell estimates that SpaceX has gotten $22billion in federal spending. And last year alone, at least a quarter of the rocket designer's revenue came directly from federal contracts valued at $3.8billion. Tesla has already had $11.4billion in regulatory credits from environmentally-focused federal and state programs looking to boost the number of zero-emission vehicles. At least $2.1billion of that total has been to help Tesla develop new cars and improve upon its battery technology, according to advocacy group Good Jobs First. Trump hasn't yet said he wants to get rid of these regulatory credits, which is good for Musk because his companies get these credits for free and can sell them for virtually 100 percent profit. Though these credits make up a relatively small percentage of Tesla's revenue, they represent a staggering 32 percent of the company's profits since 2014, according to E&E News. What could be worrying to Musk is that there are 52 ongoing contracts with seven different government agencies that are set to pay his companies an additional $11.8 billion over the next few years, according an analysis from The Post. If Musk as DOGE chief was able to cancel government contracts he felt were wasteful, there's no reason to believe Trump as president wouldn't be able to do the same to Tesla, SpaceX and others. Starlink, a satellite internet service, is one of Musk's smaller companies and is far less reliant on government assistance. While Tesla and SpaceX have received billions, Starlink has only gotten about $6 million from various federal agencies in 2022 and 2023. That includes a pledge from the Department of Defense back in 2022 to buy $1.9million worth of Starlink technology. Though Starlink may be able to weather a potential boycott from Trump, investors are worried about Tesla's fortunes given its large reliance on the federal government. Shares of Tesla plummeted nearly 12 percent on Thursday, when the worst of the jabs between Trump and Musk were happening. It's stark reversal from just several months ago, when Trump was helping Musk sell Tesla cars on the South Lawn of White House. Before markets closed on Thursday, Musk dramatically claimed that Trump is in the Epstein files, which he said explained why they haven't been released in full by the Justice Department. Trump didn't directly respond to the Epstein accusation, instead posting what amounted to a shrug on Truth Social. He also shifted the focus back to the 'big, beautiful bill,' which he continues to vehemently support despite Musk's qualms. 'I don't mind Elon turning against me, but he should have done so months ago,' Trump wrote. 'This is one of the Greatest Bills ever presented to Congress.' Musk's attacks on the bill further complicates its passage in the Senate, where the 53 GOP senators already weren't in lockstep on certain provisions.
The Guardian
an hour ago
- The Guardian
Trump-Musk meltdown: key moments in the billionaires' spectacular split
Breaking up is hard to do, and even harder if you are a billionaire who decides to break up with another billionaire on the two social media platforms you own, while the world watches in real time. Here are the key moments as the relationship between the US president, Donald Trump, and his former senior adviser Elon Musk unravelled in spectacular fashion, precipitated by a dispute over a colossal spending bill that could have major consequences for years to come. CBS previewed an interview, scheduled for that weekend, in which Musk said Trump's proposed tax and spending bill 'undermines' the cost-cutting efforts of the 'department of government efficiency' (Doge), which he led. Musk announced on social media that he was leaving his role in the Trump administration, a departure that the White House confirmed was in process on the same evening. 'As my scheduled time as a Special Government Employee comes to an end, I would like to thank President @realDonaldTrump for the opportunity to reduce wasteful spending,' the billionaire wrote on X, his social media platform. As my scheduled time as a Special Government Employee comes to an end, I would like to thank President @realDonaldTrump for the opportunity to reduce wasteful spending. The @DOGE mission will only strengthen over time as it becomes a way of life throughout the government. In the Oval Office, Trump praised Musk for his service, presenting him with a golden key and lauding the 'colossal change' he brought through Doge – which in four months entered dozens of federal departments, accessed sensitive data and led to the elimination of thousands of jobs, though the ultimate savings were far, far less than Musk had promised. Standing alongside Trump in the Oval Office, Musk, who faced a 130-day limit in his tenure as a special government employee that had ended two days prior, vowed that his departure was 'not the end' of Doge, and that it would 'only strengthen over time'. Musk seemed to release a pent-up frustration on X. He said: 'I'm sorry, but I just can't stand it anymore', then derided the administration's One Big Beautiful Bill Act, calling it a 'massive, outrageous, pork-filled Congressional spending bill' that was 'a disgusting abomination'. I'm sorry, but I just can't stand it massive, outrageous, pork-filled Congressional spending bill is a disgusting on those who voted for it: you know you did wrong. You know it. Musk doubled down in the early hours, claiming the bill 'more than defeats all the cost savings achieved by the Doge team at great personal cost and risk'. It more than defeats all the cost savings achieved by the @DOGE team at great personal cost and risk While hosting the freshly appointed German chancellor, Friedrich Merz, Trump skimmed over the diplomatic niceties and instead used the opportunity to engage in a freewheeling discussion about Musk that started positively but got progressively less pleasant. He began by needling Musk for appearing in the Oval Office with a black eye. 'You saw a man who was very happy when he stood behind the Oval desk. And even with the black eye. I said: 'Do you want a little makeup? We'll get you a little makeup.' But he said: 'No, I don't think so.'' (Musk claimed last week that he got the black eye when his five-year-old son, X Æ A-12, punched him in the face.) Trump then said he had 'had' a great relationship with the Tesla boss, but 'I don't know if we will any more', adding: 'I'm very disappointed in Elon. I've helped Elon a lot.' He then accused Musk of being upset that the bill would take away subsidies for electric vehicles. It got worse. 'If you saw the statements he made about me, which I'm sure you can get very easily, it's very fresh on tape, he said the most beautiful things about me, and he hasn't said bad about me personally,' Trump said, but then added, presciently: 'But I'm sure that'll be next.' He went on to accuse Musk of missing the glamour of being in the Oval Office, saying that sometimes people leave his administration and become 'hostile' because of 'Trump derangement syndrome'. 'They leave and they wake up in the morning, and the glamour is gone. The whole world is different, and they become hostile, I don't know what it is,' the president added. Merz's face during all this was a picture. (.) Musk, who somehow despite running multiple companies never seems to be offline, was watching the Oval Office meeting and responding in real time. Trump's claim that Musk had known what was in the bill was false, Musk said. He wrote that it 'was passed in the dead of night so fast that almost no one in Congress could even read it'. False, this bill was never shown to me even once and was passed in the dead of night so fast that almost no one in Congress could even read it! But what appeared to really get under his skin was Trump saying on Thursday he would have won the presidential election without Musk's help or money. Replying to an X user, Musk said: 'Without me, Trump would have lost the election, Dems would control the House and the Republicans would be 51-49 in the Senate. Such ingratitude.' Without me, Trump would have lost the election, Dems would control the House and the Republicans would be 51-49 in the Senate. Such ingratitude Less than two hours after the White House event, Musk posted a poll on X, asking: 'Is it time to create a new political party in America that actually represents the 80% in the middle?' Is it time to create a new political party in America that actually represents the 80% in the middle? At the time of writing, 80% of X users who responded had said 'Yes'. He then gave us all something to chew on: 'Oh and some food for thought as they ponder this question: Trump has 3.5 years left as President, but I will be around for 40+ years …' Elon Musk is 53 years old. Oh and some food for thought as they ponder this question: Trump has 3.5 years left as President, but I will be around for 40+ years … Ashley St Clair, a rightwing influencer thought to have had a baby called Romulus with Musk, popped up to offer the president some counselling. hey @realDonaldTrump lmk if u need any breakup advice Trump was not having any of this: what billionaire narcissist would? He took to the social media platform he owns to claim that he had asked Musk to leave his work with the 'Doge' office because he was, Trump said, 'wearing thin'. 'I asked him to leave, I took away his EV Mandate that forced everyone to buy electric Cars that nobody else wanted … and he just went CRAZY!' Trump wrote, then brazenly suggested he would 'terminate Elon's governmental subsidies and contracts'. Musk immediately responded: 'Such an obvious lie. So sad.' Such an obvious lie. So sad. Then he upped the ante. 'Time to drop the really big bomb: Donald Trump is in the Epstein files,' referring to the convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein. 'That is the real reason they have not been made public,' Musk wrote, adding in a separate post: 'Mark this post for the future. The truth will come out.' Time to drop the really big bomb:@realDonaldTrump is in the Epstein files. That is the real reason they have not been made a nice day, DJT! Musk, of course, has himself been pictured with Epstein associate Ghislaine Maxwell, who was found guilty of sex-trafficking in 2021. Both men deny any wrongdoing. Ye, an erstwhile ally of both men – who has been dropped by sponsors and fans over his antisemitic outbursts – posts: 'Broooos please noooooo,' adding: 'We love you both so much.' Broooos please noooooo 🫂 We love you both so much Musk had earlier been reposting the House speaker, Mike Johnson, criticising the Joe Biden administration in 2023 for 'an endless cycle of out-of-control deficit spending'. 'Where is the Mike Johnson of 2023!?' Musk asked. Johnson took the bait. 'The Mike Johnson of 2023 is the SAME Mike Johnson who has always been a lifelong fiscal hawk,' he said in a lengthy post. X users were unimpressed and the post wound up with a community note disputing its accuracy. The Mike Johnson of 2023 is the SAME Mike Johnson who has always been a lifelong fiscal hawk - who now serves as Speaker and is implementing a multi-stage plan to get our country back to fiscal responsibility and extraordinary economic growth. It begins with the critically… Gnomically, the US president wrote: 'I don't mind Elon turning against me, but he should have done so months ago.' Musk then threatened to withhold the spacecraft that Nasa has used to travel to and from the International Space Station – which would leave astronauts dependent on Boeing or Russia to get them home. 'SpaceX will begin decommissioning its Dragon spacecraft immediately,' he wrote. As a reminder, Musk is 53. In light of the President's statement about cancellation of my government contracts, @SpaceX will begin decommissioning its Dragon spacecraft immediately Musk ratcheted things up even further when he amplified a tweet by Gamergater Ian Miles Cheong calling for Trump to be impeached. (If it happened, it would be for a record third time.) Yes Having backed the US president to the hilt during the election campaign, and joined his administration, Musk then declared: 'The Trump tariffs will cause a recession in the second half of this year.' The Trump tariffs will cause a recession in the second half of this year With an 'eyebrow raised' emoji, Musk posted a well-known NBC video of Trump with Epstein at a party in 1992, dancing, joking and making comments about women. 🤨 The White House press secretary, Karoline Leavitt, described the feud as 'an unfortunate episode from Elon'. Musk posted a meme referring to the persistent online suggestions that he uses ketamine and to his associating Trump with Epstein. In 2024, Musk said he uses the drug on prescription for medical reasons. 😂🎯 … but then shortly before 7am a reporter asked Trump about the supposed phone call he was going to have with Musk later in the day. 'You mean the man who has lost his mind?' Trump asked. Here we go again …
