Girl Awarded $800k After Taking McDonald's To Court Over Chicken Nuggets
A family received closure several years after a frightening incident that took place after a visit to a McDonald's in Tamarac, Florida. According to South Florida news station NBC6, the fast food chain was ordered to pay the family $800,000 in damages after their daughter was burned by an "unreasonably" hot Chicken McNugget.
Back in 2019, the child's mother, Philana Holmes, purchased Happy Meals for herself and her then four-year-old daughter, Olivia Caraballo. Upon receiving her drive-thru order, Holmes handed one of the meals to her daughter.
Shortly after, one of the McNuggets, which was said to be "unreasonably and dangerously" hot, became stuck in the child's car seat and burned her leg, causing second-degree burns.
In May 2023, a jury found that McDonald's and the franchise owners were at fault for the incident. And in July 2023, a jury was tasked with deciding how much they thought the family should receive in damages. Of the $15 million the family asked for, they were granted $800,000 by the jury.
Despite receiving far less than what they requested, Holmes revealed that she was pleased with the outcome.
"I honestly had no expectations, so this is more than fair for me. I'm actually just happy that they listened to Olivia's voice and the jury was able to decide a fair judgement. I'm happy with that," she said while speaking with NBC6.
Holmes also expressed her hope that McDonald's will eventually offer some kind of warning for parents when it comes to hot food.
"Hopefully they'll put warning signs on the nugget boxes so parents will know. And just in the future for parents to be more aware. Don't just take someone's word for it that it's warm. It could possibly be hot," Holmes said.In 1994, a 79-year-old woman spilled extraordinarily hot McDonald's coffee on herself and suffered third-degree burns. According to Vox, "She just wanted McDonald's to pay her medical expenses, estimated at $20,000. McDonald's only offered $800, leading her to file a lawsuit." She ended up settling for less than $600,000.
You Might Also Like
Insanely Easy Weeknight Dinners To Try This Week
29 Insanely Delicious Vodka Cocktails
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
2 hours ago
- Yahoo
Former owner of well-known venue admits VAT fraud
The ex-owner of a restaurant, bar and wedding venue has pleaded guilty to evading VAT and deliberately defrauding HM Revenue and Customs. Jack McDaid, 67, who previously ran Casa Brighouse in West Yorkshire under the company Casa Events, was due to stand trial at Leeds Crown Court along with business partner Samuel Revy-Holmes, 35, and accountant Robert Brook, 47, but changed his plea on Tuesday before the start of a trial. His Honour Judge Simon Phillips KC told McDaid he would be sentenced at the end of the trial, which was expected to last about two weeks. Mr Revy-Holmes and Mr Brook have both denied conspiracy to evade VAT and cheating the public revenue and their trial began on Tuesday. McDaid, Mr Revy-Holmes and Mr Brook have all been granted conditional bail. At the start of the trial, jurors at Leeds Crown Court heard the business's turnover had been almost £10m during the period when the alleged offences took place between October 2011 and June 2018. However, from November 2013 until May 2018, a total of 19 VAT returns were submitted which all showed no sales had taken place and no goods had been purchased, meaning no VAT was due. At that time, McDaid, of Sandal Magna, Halifax, owned Casa Events, while Mr Revy-Holmes, of Upper Marsh, Halifax, was registered as a company director. Mr Brook, of Orchid Grove, Netherton, was director of Yorkshire Accountancy Services and worked as the accountant for Casa Events, Mr Russell told jurors. Prosecutor Brian Russell told the court all three men were "jointly responsible for ensuring the company's tax liabilities and obligations were met". However, they "knowingly and deliberately conspired together to commit the criminal act of evading VAT", Mr Russell said. The court heard that the alleged offences came to light when HM Revenue and Customs began investigating another of McDaid's companies, Castelite Developments, in September 2017. That investigation got under way after no VAT returns were made for the business, despite it being registered for a period of about three years, jurors were told. The trial continues. Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
Trial opens for woman charged in drunken crash that killed man walking back to work release
A trial opened Monday for a woman accused of drunkenly hitting and killing a man walking in the middle of Taft Street back to work release in January 2020 after his McDonald's shift. Christian Megan Garza, 30, is charged with several felonies. She pleaded not guilty. The victim, Andreas Ramos, 27, of Chicago, was still lying on her hood when Garza's father arrived minutes later to help. She claimed she hit a deer. In opening statements, Deputy Prosecutor Shannon Philips told jurors that Garza had been drinking 'Don Julio' tequila with 'Squirt' at a Jan. 18, 2020, birthday party in St. John. She loaded her 4-year-old daughter into a car seat in her red Volkswagen. On a cold and icy night, Garza decided to take an alternate route to avoid the curvy and twisty 93rd Avenue back to her parents' Crown Point home — where she also lived. She got into the turn lane about 1,000 feet before the light, before hitting Ramos just after midnight. The crash happened near 91st and Taft Street in Merrillville. There was 'no attempt' to break or swerve, Philips said. Defense lawyer Susan Severtson clarified it was Garza's toddler niece's party. Her parents went home first. She didn't see Ramos. Ramos was wearing a black jacket with 'fur' trim, which is why Garza could have believed the man was an animal, the defense lawyer said. Garza consented to a blood draw, which showed she was above the legal limit, court documents show. 'No one could have avoided this accident,' Severtson said. 'That was the cause, not any…intoxication.' Ramos was 'violating the rules of the road' by walking in the middle of the turn lane, Severtson said. Court documents show Sgt. Jeff Bunnell told Merrillville Detective Jeff Rice that Ramos was an inmate in the Lake County Community Corrections Kimbrough Work Release Center. Men commonly seen walking in the middle turn lane on Taft Avenue in Merrillville – a busy street with long stretches without sidewalks – are typically returning from their jobs to work release while they serve their terms. Police estimated Garza drove 644 feet with Ramos still on her car, documents note. Officers also found an empty vodka bottle in her vehicle. On Monday, Lydia Ramos, the victim's mother, testified briefly. Armando Garza, the defendant's father, said the child's party started around 5:30 p.m. He admitted he had a couple beers, but said he was good to drive. He wasn't sure if his daughter was drinking before admitting he saw her with a red solo cup. He arrived home shortly before his daughter called. She pulled over in a former Ultra grocery store parking lot. It was immediately clear there was a man on her hood. 'It's not a deer you hit,' he said. 'It's a person.' She was 'shocked,' 'scared,' 'nervous' and 'crying.' The father called 911. When the dispatcher asked if she used drugs or alcohol that night, he said no. He told defense co-counsel Roy Dominguez that they were all traumatized – 'Nobody's seen anything like that.' Wouldn't it have made more sense to have his wife drive him, their daughter and granddaughter home, Philips later asked. I wasn't impaired, Armando replied. The woman is charged with seven felonies – two counts each of causing death when operating a motor vehicle with an ACE of .08 or more, causing death when operating a motor vehicle while intoxicated, operating a vehicle while intoxicated – endangering a person less than 18 yrs old. She's also charged with neglect of a dependent and five misdemeanors. The case is before Judge Natalie Bokota with Deputy Prosecutor Jacob Brandewie also assigned. Ramos is survived by two children, according to his obituary. A judge approved a $92,000 payout from Garza's sister's homeowner's insurance policy in October. Ramos was sentenced to two years of work release in December 2019 in a robbery case. 'Without having sidewalks on Taft, it does make it challenging,' Lake County Community Corrections Executive Director Kellie Bittorf said Tuesday. The program oversees the Kimbrough work release center. They give inmates safety vests to wear at night if they have to walk back from work, she said. They give out Gary bus passes and 'strongly encourage' them to use it. But, sometimes the scheduling or bus stops don't line up. They have had a bus stop put right in front of the center and are currently working to buy bus passes in bulk, she said. If approved, they also let inmates drive or have family members take them to work. 'We do our best to avoid having them to walk, to provide those resources,' she said. The trial continues this week. mcolias@
Yahoo
5 hours ago
- Yahoo
12 hurt in fight at Charlotte McDonald's
MEDIC says 12 people were hurt in an incident Tuesday morning at a McDonald's in southwest Charlotte. It happened just after 10:30 a.m. near the intersection of S. Tryon Boulevard and Pressley Road. MEDIC says they were called for an assault. Three people were taken to the hospital for their injuries, MEDIC said. None of the victims were immediately identified. Chopper 9 SkyZoom flew over the scene and spotted MEDIC's Mass Casualty bus in the parking lot. It's not clear what led to the assault. We're working on getting more details. This is a developing story, check back for updates. (VIDEO >> 'He tried to kill me': Arrest made in Uber assault case)
