Humanitarian groups, UN heavily criticize new aid distribution plan in Gaza
The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation began distributing aid this week despite criticism from the United Nations and some aid groups that have long been operating in Gaza. Photos and videos verified by ABC News show long lines of crowds waiting to get much-needed aid.
The controversy ramped up on Tuesday after a Palestinian was killed and 47 others were injured when shots were reportedly fired into the crowd of Palestinians who were trying to get food at an aid distribution site in Rafah, according to the U.N. It was unclear who fired the shots.
The Israel Defense Forces said it fired "warning shots" in the area of the distribution site as people flooded in, but not into the crowd. The cause of death for the person who was killed is unknown.
The Gaza Humanitarian Foundation declined ABC News' request for comment. The organization previously denied there were injuries or deaths at the Rafah site and said that all food was distributed at the site.
The GHF was first announced on May 19 -- three days after the Israeli government began its increased military operation in Gaza. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced that Israel, "with our American friends," was creating a "system with distribution centers" that would be "secured by the IDF, preventing Hamas from reaching the area," to allow more aid to reach people in Gaza, referring to the Israel Defense Forces.
After the end of an 11-week Israeli blockade on aid entering Gaza, GHF -- a private contractor backed by the U.S. and Israel -- would take over distributing aid in Gaza, Netanyahu said.
Palestinians in Gaza are facing extreme hunger and famine due to the lack of resources, the U.N. and aid groups have warned. The blockade was instituted to pressure Hamas to release the remaining 20 hostages taken during Hamas' surprise terror attack on southern Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, that killed 1,200 people and led to the capture of hundreds, Israel said.
"The level of need in Gaza right now is overwhelming, and aid needs to be allowed to enter immediately and without impediment. Aid must reach those who need it most, irrespective of where they are in Gaza, safely and with dignity," an International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC) spokesperson told ABC News in a statement.
While the GHF appears to have some level of U.S. backing, it is unclear what the U.S.'s exact role is in the organization.
The U.S. government has not publicly commented on the GHF or what role it plays in the organization. The GHF has no public website.
Jake Wood -- an American military veteran who has worked in international humanitarian operations -- was the head of the GHF until he abruptly resigned from the organization on Sunday, May 25, hours before aid distribution was set to begin in Gaza.
Wood said in his resignation statement that he was "approached" about two months ago to lead GHF because of his experience in "humanitarian operations."
"At the time, GHF was a loose constellation of various ideas and concepts among a wide range of stakeholders, and I sought to establish it as a truly independent humanitarian entity. I am proud of the work I oversaw, including developing a pragmatic plan that could feed hungry people, address security concerns about diversion, and complement the work of longstanding NGOs (non-governmental organizations) in Gaza," Wood said.
"However, it is clear that it is not possible to implement this plan while also strictly adhering to the humanitarian principles of humanity, neutrality, impartiality, and independence, which I will not abandon," Wood said.
John Acree was named as the interim executive director of the foundation the next day, on May 26, according to a release from GHF.
When ABC News requested an interview with someone from GHF, the group said no one would be available.
GHF said in a press release Friday it has distributed over 2.1 million meals in Gaza, and operations will continue scaling with plans to build additional sites, including in the northern region.
"Despite the emergency intensity and kinetic environment surrounding our operations, the fact is our assistance efforts are helping Gazans," a statement from Acree said. "But this is just the beginning. Our commitment to safely and effectively supplying food directly to a large, hungry population is unwavering, and we look forward to continuing to scale and strengthen on our initial undertakings to help meet the basic food security needs of the people in Gaza."
Critics have warned GHF's plan will not meet the needs of Palestinians.
MORE: Gazan children wait for food in long lines as starvation looms
"I walked for kilometers, I got tired and only came home with a can of peas," Mazen Yunis, a Palestinian from Khan Younis, told an ABC News producer in Gaza outside the distribution site in Rafah. "The quantity was limited, and the people swarmed it; barely anyone got some, only a few people got boxes, around 2,000 people went there, maybe a 100 got some."
"I have a 10-member family and only came back with a can of peas," Yunis said.
Netanyahu said earlier this month that the new aid scheme under GHF would distribute food to Palestinian families to last them a week. He also said that it will be "very hard for Hamas to steal it, especially because we guard these positions."
Amnesty International said only experienced groups should coordinate the relief needed by the over 2 million Palestinians in Gaza, "who are facing catastrophic levels of food insecurity due to the weaponisation of starvation," in a statement Thursday.
"The United Nations and global aid organizations have universally condemned the GHF for undermining established aid distribution networks and violating core international humanitarian principles," Amnesty International said. "Alarmingly, the scheme puts military personnel in charge of aid delivery, an approach fundamentally at odds with international humanitarian standards."
U.N. officials also said humanitarian law must be respected.
MORE: IDF announces start of 'Operation Gideon's Chariots' Gaza ground offensive
"We continue to stress that a meaningful scale-up of humanitarian operations is essential to stave off famine and meet the needs of all civilians wherever they are," U.N. spokesman Stephane Dujarric said on Tuesday.
"We and our humanitarian partners stand ready to deliver at scale, which is something we've repeated over and over and again," Dujarric said.
Aid groups also criticized the limited number of distribution points.
"Even if implemented, the plan's proposed aid volumes fall short of the immense scale of needs in Gaza. The level of need right now is overwhelming, and aid needs to be allowed to enter immediately and without impediment," the ICRC said in a separate statement on Tuesday.
The ICRC said it is not involved in the GHF aid distribution, saying it "cannot work under any mechanism that doesn't allow us to uphold those principles and our modalities of work."
MORE: Aid trucks looted in southern Gaza as famine looms due to blockade: UN
"Humanitarian aid should not be politicized nor militarized. This erodes the neutrality required to ensure assistance is delivered based solely on need, not political or military agendas," the ICRC said in a statement.
Gabor Rona, a professor at Cardozo School of Law who specializes in international humanitarian law, agreed with the criticism of GHF.
"The GHF operation is a violation of humanitarian principles of independence, neutrality, and impartiality, but most importantly, the principle of humanity, given the program's inadequacy and consistency with Israeli and U.S. interests in displacement of the civilian population under occupation (a war crime and crime against humanity)," Rona said in an email to ABC News.
The World Food Programme, which is part of the U.N., said it "cannot safely operate under a distribution system that limits the number of bakeries and sites where Gaza's population can access food."
"WFP and its partners must also be allowed to distribute food parcels directly to families -- the most effective way to prevent widespread starvation," the organization said in a statement.
GHF said in a press release on Friday that it is "actively testing and adapting its distribution model to safely deliver the maximum amount of aid to the greatest number of people."
The organization added, "We will continue to adapt based on conditions on the ground, including access, crowd pressure, and safety considerations."
Humanitarian groups, UN heavily criticize new aid distribution plan in Gaza originally appeared on abcnews.go.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
24 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Boulder illegal immigrant terror suspect's 'possible radicalization' probed by authorities: retired FBI agent
In the wake of a violent firebombing at a pro-Israel rally in Boulder, Colorado, a retired FBI agent said that authorities are probing the Egyptian suspect's "possible radicalization," an expert said. "Authorities are currently conducting a forensic search of the scene, collecting device remnants, fingerprints, and possible surveillance footage," Jason Pack, a retired FBI special agent, told Fox News Digital. "Background investigations are underway—both locally and internationally, likely with Egyptian authorities through the U.S. Embassy in Cairo, into the suspect's history, affiliations, and possible radicalization." Authorities identified the suspect as 45-year-old Egyptian national Mohamed Sabry Soliman, who had overstayed his visa. "He came armed with Molotov cocktails and a homemade flamethrower. He shouted 'Free Palestine' and other slogans during the assault. This wasn't random. It was personal and likely politically or ideologically driven," he said. Boulder, Colorado Suspected Terror Attack Suspect Mohamed Sabry Soliman Faces Murder, Assault, Other Charges Investigators are now determining whether the incident meets the federal legal definition of domestic terrorism. Read On The Fox News App "Authorities are actively investigating whether the attack where the suspect used Molotov cocktails and a makeshift flamethrower while shouting 'Free Palestine,' meets the legal definition of a domestic terror incident under U.S. law," Pack explained. He cited U.S. Code § 2331, which outlines domestic terrorism as acts that violate criminal law, are intended to intimidate or influence, and occur within the United States. Soliman, 45, is charged with violating 18 U.S.C. §§ 249(a)(1) and (a)(2), federal hate crime statutes involving acts motivated by race, religion, or national origin. "Investigators will likely examine whether the suspect's actions, targeting a public gathering with incendiary devices, were ideologically motivated and intended to instill fear or make a political statement," he said. According to Pack, the public details already suggest several qualifying elements. He said that prosecutors will need "more than just ideology." "However, federal prosecutors will need more than just ideology; they'll have to prove intent to intimidate or coerce," he said. "Key evidence could include statements, writings, digital communications, or planning behavior." The suspect's behavioral red flags are also under scrutiny, he said. "According to sources familiar with the case, the attacker was reportedly shirtless, highly agitated, and made no attempt to escape after launching the assault," Pack said. "From a behavioral and psychological profiling perspective, this suggests impulsive extremism or a desire for martyrdom rather than escape or survival. These traits are often associated with ideologically driven lone actors." "This kind of attacker typically operates without a support network but may be influenced by online propaganda or perceived injustices," he said. "The erratic behavior, crude weaponry, and politically charged language point to a disorganized, emotionally unstable individual whose radicalization—if confirmed—could place the case within the growing trend of unpredictable, lone-wolf-style domestic attacks." Us Politicians, Jewish Groups Condemn 'Horrifying' Boulder Terror Attack: 'Vile, Antisemitic Act Of Terror' The retired Supervisory Special Agent from the FBI with 21 years of service said that he has investigated cases "just like this." "It's rare, but not unheard of, for someone to act out violently in support of a cause, especially when that person feels isolated, powerless, or desperate. Based on the information we know now, Soliman appears to fit the profile of a lone actor, someone with a grievance, who may have felt unheard and decided to lash out. They will also have to assess his mental health." "The homemade weapons show planning. The target, a group rallying on behalf of Israeli hostages, was clearly chosen on purpose. That suggests a level of intent and maybe radicalization, though there's no public evidence yet tying him to any organized group," Pack said. The affidavit paints a detailed picture of Soliman's planning. In an interview with investigators, Soliman said that he researched on YouTube how to make Moltov Cocktails, purchased the ingredients and constructed them. He told investigators that he wanted to kill the "Zionist group" and wished they were all dead after searching for the gathering online. He also stated that he would carry out the attack again if given the chance. He referenced "our land," which he identified as Palestine, and his desire to stop supporters of Israel from "taking over" that land, according to the affidavit. Pack said that the FBI and local authorities are digging into "everything," noting Soliman's online history, phone, travel records and any international connections. "That includes whether he downloaded bomb-making materials or had contact with foreign actors," he said. "Agents are also talking to people who knew him in Colorado Springs, where he lived. They'll want to know if he talked about violence, politics, or anything that might have raised red flags. Investigators will look for any signs this could have been prevented." Suspect In Boulder Terror Attack Determined To Be Egyptian Man In Us Illegally: Fbi On the scene, forensics will remain a top priority for federal investigators, Pack said. "The forensic work at the scene is just as important. They're collecting every piece of evidence, from bottle shards to accelerant residue. That'll help piece together exactly what he used, how he built it, and where he might have tested it," said Pack. "This kind of violence shakes communities—and it's not something law enforcement takes lightly. One man with homemade firebombs injured nearly a dozen people. That's why police around the country will be taking a second look at security plans for similar events, especially ones tied to Israel, Gaza, or other politically charged issues." Despite the gravity of the attack, Pack believes there's no indication of a broader conspiracy. "From what I've seen, there's no broader plot here. But that doesn't mean it ends in Boulder. Investigators are thinking long term—looking for signs this kind of thing could happen again somewhere else." "These kinds of lone-wolf attacks are tough to predict, but they're not impossible to stop," he said. "The key is sharing intel, watching for behavioral warning signs, and not ignoring threats when they surface." "For now, law enforcement is doing what it does best: following the evidence, interviewing witnesses, and staying focused on keeping the public safe."Original article source: Boulder illegal immigrant terror suspect's 'possible radicalization' probed by authorities: retired FBI agent
The Hill
24 minutes ago
- The Hill
Trump team emphasizes immigration in Boulder response
President Trump and his administration are leaning into immigration more than antisemitism in the wake of an attack in Boulder, Colo., that targeted a pro-Israel gathering. The administration has made it its mission to usher in tough immigration policies, and it has also gone after universities for antisemitism over campus protests related to the Gaza war. The attack on the group demonstrating in Boulder for the release of hostages held by Hamas fits into several arguments the administration is making about what needs to change in the country, particularly since the suspect behind the attack was living in the U.S. on an expired visa. So far, the response from the administration has been much more focused on highlighting that immigration status. Trump's response to the attack a day later began by ripping his predecessor President Biden for what he deems a 'ridiculous open border policy.' The Department of Homeland Security, meanwhile, was 'revamping' the Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) tip line to 'report suspicious criminal activity by illegal aliens including terrorist activity, gang related crimes, and suspected sex trafficking' in its response to the event in Boulder. 'For four years, the Biden Administration allowed millions of unvetted illegal aliens—including terrorists, gang members, and other violent criminals—to pour into our country. Yesterday's terrorist attack by a suspect illegally in our country, underscores the importance of getting these illegal aliens out of our country,' assistant secretary Tricia McLaughlin said in a statement. DHS' response to the attack on Sunday involved immediately highlighting that the suspect had been in the U.S. illegally. Similarly, Secretary of State Marco Rubio warned about deporting criminals in response to the attack. 'In light of yesterday's horrific attack, all terrorists, their family members, and terrorist sympathizers here on a visa should know that under the Trump Administration we will find you, revoke your visa, and deport you,' he said on X. The suspect, Mohamed Soliman, has been charged with a federal hate crime after he allegedly yelled 'Free Palestine' as he was attacking the group, injuring multiple people with Molotov cocktails. Soliman had entered the U.S. on a tourist visa in August 2022. That visa expired in early 2023 but Soliman stayed in the country since and he had applied for asylum during that time. DHS said he had also applied for a work permit once the tourist visa was up, but that had also expired. Soliman used a 'makeshift flamethrower' and incendiary devices Sunday to attack people demonstrating for the release of hostages held in Gaza by Hamas. The victims of the attack range in age from 52 to 88, The Associated Press reported. Deputy chief of staff Stephen Miller, one of the administration's chief immigration hawks, quickly called out Soliman's immigration status late Sunday just after the attack, calling him 'an illegal alien.' 'He was granted a tourist visa by the Biden Administration and then he illegally overstayed that visa. In response, the Biden Administration gave him a work permit. Suicidal migration must be fully reversed,' Miller said. Press secretary Karoline Leavitt, meanwhile, did highlight that Jewish Americans should 'rest assure' that 'this president has your back.' She also directed her response towards the work of the administration to crack down on border crossings and also blamed the Biden. 'I'd also like to point out that this administration has done more than any administration to curb this violence and to curb illegal immigration,' she said. 'We know that this individual, this terrorist, was allowed into this country by the previous administration… was given a tourism visa and then was illegallyl allowed to stay.' The incident in Boulder comes just a week after another antisemitic attack in Washington, D.C. A man who shouted 'free, free Palestine' while being detained fatally shot two Israeli Embassy staffers, Yaron Lischinsky and Sarah Milgrim, at a reception at the Capital Jewish Museum. Following that attack in Washington, attorney general Pam Bondi said the threat level has been increased for all Americans, telling people that 'whether you are Jewish or not, be vigilant.' Some Democrats on Monday said the administration wasn't doing enough to call out antisemitism. 'It was an obviously antisemitic attack and the latest in a series of antisemitic attacks. We had that attack on that couple exiting the Jewish community center in Washington a couple of weeks ago… and the Jewish community is very on edge. And we want the federal government to do more,' Rep. Jerry Nadler (D-N.Y.) said on CNN. Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer (D-N.Y.), meanwhile, called out the dangers of unchecked antisemitism but opted not to address the administration's response. 'Because of their Jewish identity, they were targeted by hate. When antisemitism is allowed to fester in more corners of society, it historically leads to more terrorism and violence,' Schumer said on the Senate floor.
CNN
40 minutes ago
- CNN
Boulder suspect plotted attack for a year over hatred of ‘Zionists,' federal authorities say
For a full year, Mohamed Sabry Soliman planned a violent assault driven by his simmering anger toward Israel and hatred of 'Zionists,' he told federal authorities. That plot culminated on Sunday, when the 45-year-old Egyptian national left an iPhone with messages to his wife and five children in his house, drove to downtown Boulder with a homemade flamethrower and Molotov cocktails and attacked demonstrators at a peaceful Jewish event to support hostages in Gaza, according to federal hate crime charging documents. Twelve people were injured in the attack, during which Soliman yelled 'Free Palestine,' according to the FBI. He later told authorities that 'he wanted to kill all Zionist people and wished they were all dead,' an affidavit said. Only one thing held Soliman back from attacking sooner, he told authorities: Waiting for his daughter to graduate high school. A Colorado Springs Gazette article published in April profiled a student matching his daughter's description as a recipient of a scholarship. According to the article, she described in her scholarship application how her family had immigrated to the US after living in Kuwait, noting that her father had undergone a 'difficult surgery' when she was young 'that restored his ability to walk.' The girl said the incident inspired her to pursue medical school – a dream that would have been impossible in Kuwait but within reach in America. Now, Mohamed Sabry Soliman faces a federal hate crime charge and state charges of attempted murder. Soliman was born in Egypt and lived in Kuwait for 17 years before moving to Colorado, according to a state arrest affidavit. CNN reviewed a Facebook account matching his name and date of birth. On the account's page, which was last updated about 10 years ago, Soliman said he attended high school and college in Egypt and later moved to Kuwait, where he had an accounting job, according to the page. That account featured photos of Mohamed Morsi, the Muslim Brotherhood leader who served as Egypt's president from 2012 to 2013, when he was ousted in a military coup that triggered mass protests and sit-ins in Cairo. Posts on the Facebook page expressed support for the Muslim Brotherhood protests against the removal of Morsi. One post from August 2013 featured a four-finger salute with a yellow background, a symbol supportive of the Rabaa al-Adawiya Square encampment, which was violently dispersed by Egyptian security forces loyal to Egypt's then-defense minister and current president, Abdel Fattah al-Sisi. According to the newspaper article on the student whose identifying details match those of Soliman's daughter, her father at one point underwent a serious medical procedure on his legs – one she described in her scholarship application as 'nothing short of 'magic.'' When the family lived in Kuwait, the daughter stated, the success of the procedure inspired her to study medicine – but 'the prospect of attending medical school there was not an option' as a non-Kuwaiti. 'The move to the United States provides a chance to fulfill her dream,' the article said. 'Coming to the USA has fundamentally changed me,' she wrote. 'Most importantly, I came to appreciate that family is the unchanging support.' Mohamed Sabry Soliman first tried to come to the US in 2005 but was denied a visa, law enforcement sources told CNN. He entered the US in August 2022 as a non-immigrant visitor and in 2023 received a two-year work authorization that expired in March, a Homeland Security official said Monday. With his wife and children, he moved into a two-story home on the far eastern edge of Colorado Springs and he found work, at least briefly, as an accountant. The health care company Veros Health said in a statement he was an employee starting in May 2023 but left three months later. The company did not respond to questions about his departure. Soliman had also worked as an Uber driver, according to the company, which noted all drivers must pass a criminal and driving history background check and hold a valid Social Security number. The company said his account has now been banned. Neighbors who briefly spoke with CNN said they saw Soliman's children playing near his house but were not familiar with the family. One neighbor said she had no direct interactions with Soliman but described his wife as friendly. As he began plotting an attack, Soliman told authorities, he researched how to make Molotov cocktails on YouTube. He also learned online about the group that eventually became his target – a weekly demonstration in Boulder urging Hamas to return the remaining hostages from Gaza. Soliman said he took a concealed-carry class and learned to shoot a gun but as a non-citizen was blocked from purchasing a gun, so he turned to Molotov cocktails, according to a state affidavit. Soliman told authorities that he purchased ingredients for the cocktails – including 'glass wine carafe bottles or Ball jars,' according to the federal complaint – constructed them and purchased gas at a gas station on the way to Boulder. He also filled up a backpack weed sprayer with gasoline. Before leaving for the attack, Soliman said, he left an iPhone hidden in a desk drawer at home with messages for his family as well as a journal. As the group marched with signs on Sunday, Soliman waited nearby with a utility vest over his shirt; some witnesses thought he looked like a gardener, multiple law enforcement sources said. The state affidavit notes that he bought flowers from Home Depot. According to authorities, he attacked and severely burned multiple marchers. Soliman was captured on video by bystanders standing shirtless and yelling phrases including 'Palestine is Free!' and 'end Zionists!' before police arrived and arrested him. Police found a nearby plastic container holding at least 14 unlit Molotov cocktails, the federal complaint said. After his arrest, Soliman's wife brought an iPhone 14 she said belonged to him to the Colorado Springs police office, the affidavit said. Local and federal authorities said at a press conference Monday that Soliman was not previously on their radar. Soliman does not appear to have a prior criminal record in Colorado, according to a search of state records. The sheriff of El Paso County, Colorado, said that aside from some traffic stops, his office had received three calls from an address linked to Soliman since late 2022, which the sheriff described as 'non-criminal' calls involving a 'juvenile contact' and two 911 hang-up calls. Soliman also interacted with Colorado Springs police in connection with two minor traffic infractions in 2023, a department spokesperson said. Throughout his interview with law enforcement, Soliman said he 'hated the Zionist group and did this because he hated this group and needed to stop them from taking over 'our land,' which he explained to be Palestine.' The complaint states Soliman was charged with a 'hate crime involving actual or perceived race, religion, or national origin.' Jewish community leaders have called for action following rising antisemitic violence. Two Israeli Embassy staff members were killed last month by a gunman who authorities said later yelled 'Free Palestine!' The Islamic Center of Boulder condemned the 'targeted violence' of Sunday's attack. Blake Ellis, Em Steck, Robert Kuznia, Holmes Lybrand, and Audrey Ash contributed to this story.
