Detroit Animal Welfare Group director faces criminal charges over "friendly" fawns
Kelley Labonty, the director of Detroit Animal Welfare Group, is facing criminal charges over "friendly" fawns.
The allegations are being made by conservation officers with the Michigan Department of Natural Resources, and it's caused a lot of controversy on social media.
Labonty will face off against Macomb County Prosecutor Peter Lucido in court on Tuesday.
Labony says the Detroit Animal Welfare Group is a dream that became a reality for her several years ago. She says now it's being threatened.
"We are putting hundreds of animals' lives at risk for a very frivolous case," Labonty said.
Conservation officers with the DNR allege that the Detroit Animal Welfare Group had four habituated fawns in a field across from its farm in Romeo, Michigan.
Labonty says that's not true.
"They're normal, healthy fawns that were released from rehabilitation, and I haven't seen them. They're not on the property. They weren't even on our property. They were on a 500-acre open field across from us," Labonty said.
Celeste Dunn, Labonty's attorney, says her client has spent tens of thousands of dollars on state-of-the-art facilities to prevent habituation, like bottle feeders, to avoid human interaction.
"Every taxpayer should be outraged that this has continued to go on because of a personal vendetta against my client," Dunn said. "Looking at a video for a few minutes is not sufficient to determine if an animal is habituated."
She says this all stems from a long history of animosity between the government agency and Labonty.
"We obtained internal emails that then say, 'Let's go after her,'" Dunn said.
Lucido has spoken out about the case.
In a post on Facebook, he says, "It is important for the public to understand that the DNR brought this case to the Macomb County Prosecutor's Office (MCPO), and recommended prosecution for alleged violations of State law. This action was not initiated by my office."
He claims the nonprofit is misleading the public with false information.
"The MCPO is in the process of prosecuting the charges brought by the DNR as we are required to do by State law when dictated by evidence," the statement continues. "The MCPO is seeking to resolve this case and has given the individual charged with options that protect wildlife in an appropriate way. DAWG is completely wrong to claim that the MCPO is seeking to penalize anyone who is helping wildlife in a manner consistent with state law."
A plea deal was offered, but Labonty says it could still lead to her wildlife permit being taken away.
"He (Lucido) had the opportunity not to charge and chose not to," Labonty said. "Why would we take a plea deal when we did absolutely nothing wrong? These are criminal charges. We are not criminals."
Labonty says if her permit is revoked, the animals in her care could be euthanized.
"People are at my door, 24/7, in the middle of the night. I'm up feeding babies. People are dropping animals off. It's a huge service that we provide," Labonty said. "If, in fact, we were found guilty in a jury trial, that would give the DNR permission to come in and take all the animals in our care, all the wildlife in our care, and euthanize them."
A preliminary hearing is scheduled at 9 a.m. Tuesday in Romeo.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
4 hours ago
- Yahoo
Swimmer seriously injured in boating incident on GA lake
A man is hospitalized after a boating incident over the weekend, according to the Georgia Department of Natural Resources. [DOWNLOAD: Free WSB-TV News app for alerts as news breaks] Just before 4 p.m. on Saturday, game wardens were notified of a boating incident that happened at the north end of Jackson Lake near Conley Ditch Road. The DNR said the swimmer was hanging onto a swim platform of a wake boat when the throttle shifted into reverse, causing the swimmer's leg to be caught by the propeller. Officials said this caused severe injuries to his leg. The victim was airlifted to Grady Memorial Hospital. His current condition was not released. The DNR Critical Incident Reconstruction Team is conducting an investigation. TRENDING STORIES: Plane crashes into Pacific Ocean near San Diego 2 accused of stealing vehicle left on I-75 Georgia tax revenues up 9.1% in May, a $224 million increase [SIGN UP: WSB-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter]
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Man runs from drug deal, jumps into GA pond to escape deputies, officials say
Georgia officials said a man went to great lengths to avoid an arrest. [DOWNLOAD: Free WSB-TV News app for alerts as news breaks] On Sunday, Cpl. Johnny Robinette and Game Warden Aaron Powell were called to help Cook County deputies and Adel police. According to the Georgia Department of Natural Resources, officers were chasing a suspect who ran away from a drug deal. The DNR said the suspect stole a bike to help in his escape, and then jumped into a pond and swam to a nearby island to avoid being arrested. TRENDING STORIES: Man installed recording device in metro Atlanta Burlington Coat Factory, police say Nearly 2 dozen arrested for stealing thousands from Mall of Georgia Hall Co. escaped inmate steals motorcycle, leads deputies on multi-state chase, officials say When game wardens arrived, they launched a boat to access the island. They later found the suspect and took him into custody. The suspect, whose age and identity were not released, was turned over to local agencies and charged with multiple drug-related offenses. [SIGN UP: WSB-TV Daily Headlines Newsletter]
Yahoo
6 days ago
- Yahoo
Grace Schara's wrongful death trial against Ascension St. Elizabeth begins
APPLETON - The jury trial involving the death of Grace Schara, 19, at an Ascension hospital during the COVID-19 pandemic got underway June 3 in Outagamie County Circuit Court. The Freedom teen died Oct. 13, 2021, seven days after she was admitted to Ascension NE Wisconsin-St. Elizabeth Hospital in Appleton for symptoms of COVID-19 infection. Scott Schara, her dad, sued the hospital a year and a half later in a wrongful death case that includes claims of medical negligence, violation of informed consent and battery. Dr. Gavin Shokar, who was the primary doctor in charge of Grace's care, and Hollee McInnis, a registered nurse who provided medications to Grace while she was a patient in the intensive care unit, are also named as defendants in the case. In an approximately 30-minute opening statement, Warner Mendenhall, one of Schara's attorneys, said Grace's stay at St. Elizabeth was a precautionary measure to provide her with supplementary oxygen and steroids. But she quickly began facing issues. On two occasions shortly after she was admitted, on Oct. 7 and Oct. 8, Grace was given Precedex, which "dangerously lowered her blood pressure and pulse," Mendenhall claimed. On both occasions, Grace's condition improved after medical staff stopped or turned down her dose of the medication, he said. Scott Schara stayed with his daughter at the hospital for several days, until staff asked him to leave, and he was escorted out of the hospital by security guards on Oct. 10. He was persistent with asking questions of medical staff, but was "doing exactly what he was supposed to do as a dad and power of attorney for health care,' Mendenhall said. The family had lawyers negotiate with the hospital to allow older sister Jessica Vander Heiden to be with Grace. On the morning of Oct. 13, Shokar spoke with Grace's family over the phone saying Grace was stable and they should focus on nutrition and movement so Grace could soon go home. 'Oddly though, despite Grace's improving condition, Shokar requested Scott authorize a ventilator, even though there was no need for a ventilator at that time,' Mendenhall said. Mendenhall said Scott Schara did not want his daughter to be placed on a ventilator. But as a result of this conversation, Shokar not only documented that Grace had a Do Not Intubate order, known as a DNI, but also a Do Not Resuscitate Order, known as DNR. The Schara family did not learn Grace has been labeled DNR until Grace was in respiratory distress shortly before she died later that night. 'Dr. Shokar watched this 19-year-old girl breathing fast, and instead of assessing why, without talking to the family before, and Nurse McInnis, injected Grace Schara with morphine, a powerful opioid drug that suppresses breathing,' Mendenhall said. Scott and Cindy Schara, Grace's mother, then had to watch their daughter die over FaceTime, with their cries for medical staff to save their daughter ignored, Mendenhall said. 'At this trial, we will show that Grace Schara, a beautiful, gifted 19-year-old girl with Down syndrome, was killed by a deadly injection while dozens of medical personnel stood aside and did nothing,' Mendenhall said. Attorneys for the defendants painted a very different picture of Grace's hospital stay and the events leading up to her death. Two attorneys delivered opening statements for the defense: Jason Franckowiak, who represents defendants Ascension Health and McInnis; and Randall Guse, who represents Ascension Medical Group – Fox Valley Wisconsin, Inc. and Shokar. Grace did not die of any injection she was given by hospital staff, the attorneys argued. She died of a COVID-19 infection, which worsened during her days at the hospital, despite medical staff's best attempts to save her. Additionally, attorneys said Grace's family had consented during a conversation with Shokar to both a "Do Not Intubate" and a "Do Not Resuscitate" order. Franckowiak said evidence presented at trial will dispute multiple claims made by the plaintiffs, including that the medications and dosages provided to Grace were standard in the intensive care unit. Specifically, Precedex and lorazepam, both sedatives, were used in an effort reduce her rapid breathing and allow her to take deeper breaths and take in more oxygen. After administration of those drugs did little for her vitals, Shokar ordered McInnis, one of Grace's nurses, to administer a small dose of morphine. That drug, Franckowiak said, helped temporarily improve Grace's oxygenation, from around 50% to 98%. "Dr. Shokar reached a reasonable conclusion that the morphine had done exactly what he had intended it to do: it had lowered Grace's rate of breathing sufficient to allow her take deeper breaths, therefore increasing her oxygenation level,' Franckowiak said. Grace was stable for about an hour, but then her lungs gave out, Franckowiak said. He said experts will testify that without the ability to intubate Grace, chest compressions would not have been effective. And a reversal agent like naloxone would not have been effective, as the plaintiffs asserted. "The only potential way for Grace's emergent pulmonary condition to have been adequately addressed at the point of her arrest would have been mechanical ventilation, but doctors and nurses had been explicitly forbidden by Mr. Schara (from) intubating Grace," Franckowiak said. Franckowiak also said Scott Schara will be asked to testify about some of his beliefs, which have 'shaped the allegations' he is making. Among them are a belief that the COVID-19 pandemic was planned to create fear and a general distrust of medical personnel. Cindy Schara, Grace's mom, was the first witness to testify for the plaintiffs. She detailed how Grace began to show symptoms of COVID-19, which she describes as similar to allergy symptoms, after the family attended a concert in Oshkosh on Sept. 25. Grace was not vaccinated, and on Oct. 1 she tested positive for the virus. Cindy said she had the same symptoms, which is why she was never able to go to the hospital to be with Grace. Cindy Schara also confirmed she and Scott Schara had been researching how to treat COVID-19 prior to seeking medical help for Grace on Oct. 6. Cindy Schara said they were researching protocols provided by Front Line COVID-19 Critical Care Alliance. The group, now known as the Independent Medical Alliance, was formed in April 2020 by physicians and former journalists who advocated for unapproved treatments, such as ivermectin, for COVID-19. Both its founders have since had their medical board certifications revoked. She said the organization advised taking supplements, which they did, and to seek medical help if blood-oxygen saturation levels dropped below 94%, which they also did. Cindy Schara said the family would never made a decision on a DNR order on its own. If they were, they would want other family members, their pastor, primary care physician and a lawyer to be involved in the conversation. "It would be a terrible thing to have to decide," she said, indicating she and her husband never made that decision during two separate phone calls with Shokar. She was questioned at length about her and her husband's views on the medical professional after Grace's death. She acknowledged she believes the COVID-19 vaccine is a bioweapon and young vaccinated men, once vaccinated, became sterile, among other things. None of these theories are supported by research or the scientific community. The trial is expected to last up to four weeks. Jessica Van Egeren is a health care reporter and assistant breaking news editor with the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel. She can be reached at jvanegeren@ This article originally appeared on Milwaukee Journal Sentinel: Trial begins against Ascension hospital in Appleton over Grace Schara's death
