Decorated Australian veteran loses defamation appeal over Afghanistan killings
Three federal court judges unanimously rejected his appeal of a judge's ruling in 2023 that Roberts-Smith was not defamed by newspaper articles published in 2018 that accused him of a range of war crimes.
Justice Anthony Besanko had ruled that the accusations were substantially true to a civil standard and Roberts-Smith was responsible for four of the six unlawful deaths he had been accused of.
Roberts-Smith has never faced criminal charges, which must be proven to the higher standard of beyond reasonable doubt.
He was not in the Sydney court on Friday to hear the ruling and his lawyers refused to comment. They have a final option of appealing to the High Court.
Roberts-Smith, 46, is a former Special Air Service (SAS) Regiment corporal who was awarded the Victoria Cross and Medal for Gallantry for his service in Afghanistan. Around 39,000 Australians soldiers served in Afghanistan and 41 were killed.
His SAS colleagues are among those calling for him to become the first of Australia's Victoria Cross winners to be stripped of the highest award for gallantry in battle.
Roberts-Smith has been financially supported by Australian billionaire Kerry Stokes whose media business Seven West Media is a rival of Nine Entertainment that published the articles that Roberts-Smith argued defamed him.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Powys County Times
8 hours ago
- Powys County Times
Councillor's fury as Powys cabinet members miss school vote
Residents of a village whose school is set to close feel 'betrayed' by the council's cabinet, an opposition leader has said. At a meeting of on Tuesday, June 10, cabinet members received an objections report on the proposal to close the 25 pupil Ysgol Bro Cynllaith in Llansilin near Oswestry. It means the closure will now go ahead at the end of August. Conservative group leader, Cllr Aled Davies who represents Llansilin said: 'At the last meeting to discuss Ysgol Bro Cynllaith a third of the cabinet was missing. 'Today is the final meeting to discuss the future of Bro Cynllaith and half the cabinet including the leader are missing.' Cllr Davies continued: 'There were a number of opportunities to meet with the community, the school governors and headteacher and only one of the 10 cabinet members could be bothered to come. 'It's not acceptable – it's important that cabinet are seen to reach out to the community. 'They are feeling betrayed and clearly the cabinet has no interest in the north of Powys.' He pointed out that the Cllr Berriman (Liberal Democrat) lives 51 miles away and other cabinet members live well over 100 miles away from Llansilin. Cllr Davies said: 'There's one member of the cabinet from Montgomeryshire (Cllr Richard Church) when it has 40 per cent of the Powys population.' Cllr Davies added that 'serious alternative proposals' to closure had not been considered. Cabinet member for education, Cllr Pete Roberts (Liberal Democrat) explained that on the day of a meeting arranged by Cllr Davies, for the whole village he had been down at a meeting with the minister for education in Cardiff. Cllr Roberts said: 'You arranged that without actually informing cabinet members you wanted there that it was happening. 'The travel time for me to Cardiff is an hour and 50 minutes, the travel time from Cardiff to Llansilin is between three-and-a-half and four hours. 'The civil service guidance is that anyone attending a meeting should not be driving for more than six hours in that day. 'If you had shown the courtesy of inviting me I would have made every attempt to be there, but you chose not to, so I will not be lectured by you.' Cllr Roberts added: 'This proposal has been enacted in exactly the same way as has been done on previous closure proposals that have been through judicial review.'
Daily Mail
10 hours ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE SAS soldiers dramatically cleared of murdering Syria jihadist in battle after two-year legal nightmare
Five SAS soldiers facing murder charges over the death of a known Islamic terrorist in Syria have had their names cleared, the Mail can reveal. After a two-year legal nightmare, the elite troops have been told they will not face a court martial. In a case that provoked fury within the regiment, the 'Blades' as SAS soldiers are known, were accused of using excessive force on the battlefield three years ago. They had pursued the jihadist at night in a rural area after watching a video of him in which he vowed to 'blow up infidels'. In the footage he was seen wearing a suicide vest, which was found near where he was shot dead in pitch darkness. For security reasons, the location and date of the operation cannot be disclosed. Given the circumstances, the troops were shocked to learn later that they were being investigated by the Royal Military Police (RMP). One told colleagues he felt like a 'tethered goat' as RMPs, top brass and lawyers used the incident as a test case. A friend said: 'It takes some believing but the guys have been staring down the barrel of murder trials for shooting a confirmed jihadist in a live battlefield situation. 'How on earth anyone could accuse them of using excessive force in that situation was beyond everyone. 'These guys were put through the wringer so the generals, the Defence Serious Crime Unit and the Service Prosecuting Authority could prove how rigorously they can pursue a prosecution. 'That's fine and dandy for them, but for the soldiers who risked their lives that night to be accused – and to wait so long for justice – that was appalling.' The RMP investigation coincided with a High Court inquiry into allegations of SAS war crimes in Afghanistan. With the judge in that inquiry expected to publish a damning report later this year, there was a rigorous investigation of the Syria case. Files were sent to prosecutors recommending murder charges against the five soldiers. The Service Prosecuting Authority – the military equivalent of the Crown Prosecution Service – then spent 18 months reviewing the case before finally agreeing to clear the soldiers. The saga led rank and file SAS soldiers to accuse their chain of command of 'putting their careers before protecting their soldiers'. The five SAS soldiers involved were part of a cordon around a jihadist compound when the shooting took place. Suspects escaped and the five broke from the cordon and gave chase. They caught the likely suicide bombers, one of whom was seen hiding in a bush. They opened fire in the darkness because they believed the jihadist posed an immediate threat to their lives. But a search of his body confirmed he was not wearing his suicide belt, which was later found in the compound he had bolted from. Today, the Ministry of Defence said: 'Our personnel are respected worldwide and make extraordinary sacrifices in defence of the nation. It's right that we hold them to the highest standards and action is taken where anyone fails to meet them. 'Following thorough investigations and assessments, we can confirm that no charges have been brought forward in these cases.' Tory armed forces spokesman Mark Francois said: 'It is imperative we continue to recognise the outstanding contribution of our Special Forces to UK security and the incredible risks they take. This case highlighted the dangers they face and the difficult split-second decisions they are forced to make against ruthless enemies.'
Telegraph
10 hours ago
- Telegraph
Afghanistan inquiry threatening Army recruitment, claims former commander
The inquiry into the conduct of special forces in Afghanistan is affecting the Army's recruitment drive, a retired SAS commander has warned. Ed Butler, the former commanding officer of 22 SAS, said recent allegations about the SAS and Special Boat Service (SBS) made by the BBC were 'sensationalist' and risked exacerbating the recruitment and retention problem plaguing the military. Writing for The Telegraph on Wednesday, Brig Butler said: 'Current members of the SAS and Special Boat Service (SBS), along with other service personnel, are now worried every time they pull the trigger that a lawyer or journalist is going to come after them 10 or 20 years after the event. This is not only hugely corrosive to morale, but also affects recruitment and retention.' He added that the Government 'risks failure' if it does not support the Armed Forces. Government aims to recruit 3,000 troops 'Serving and retired members of the Armed Forces want to know that the MoD and ministers have their backs on the battlefield and in the courts,' he wrote. 'The Government cannot have it both ways. Either it supports its Armed Forces from cradle to grave, or it risks failure.' In recent years, the Ministry of Defence (MoD) has suffered from a recruitment and retention crisis across all three services. Last week, the Government committed to delivering the Strategic Defence Review's recommendation of recruiting around 3,000 additional regular troops in the next Parliament. The review had revealed the number of UK regular troops and reservists had been in 'persistent decline', and had fallen eight per cent since 2022.
