End Gaza's aid debacle by letting humanitarians do their jobs
'Why do they tell us to go to the aid sites, why? And when we go there, we get killed. What they're doing to us is wrong, they're lying to us.' In three short phrases, Arafat Essaim – whose younger brother was killed by Israeli gunfire on Sunday – summed up the murderous chaos into which humanitarian relief efforts in Gaza have descended.
Since then, distressing scenes of desperate and hungry Palestinian civilians jostling for aid and running from gunfire have been repeated several times. Dozens of people are reported to have been killed or injured by Israeli forces. This pandemonium is not the result of a well-meaning aid effort that is trying but failing – it is the consequence of the destruction and exclusion of the humanitarian networks that supported Gaza's people before the war.
UNRWA, the UN agency for Palestinian refugees, is an organisation that developed considerable expertise owing to its work with generations of displaced Palestinian communities. Since the Hamas attacks of October 7, 2023, the agency has literally and metaphorically been in Israel's firing line, losing more than 300 team members in the war and facing criminalisation inside Israel itself. Many other international aid agencies, as well as most journalists, have been shut out of Gaza and prevented from doing their jobs.
Following May's lifting by Israel of its 11-week aid blockade, the resulting vacuum was filled by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, a US and Israeli-backed relief provider created on the fly. Some good-faith observers argued, with reservations, that this body be given a chance to work because of the sheer level of starvation stalking Gaza. A week of disorder and death at aid sites has made it clear that the GHF model – that is, privitised and militarised relief work during a full-blown war – had failure hardwired into it.
Fatally flawed strategies, such as gathering huge numbers of hungry people at a single aid distribution point, have proved disastrous. The menacing presence of unidentified private soldiers and Israel's labelling of roads to the aid sites as ' combat zones ' have only exacerbated the aid crisis. There is a reason why many humanitarian professionals are heavily trained and often stay in the same field for years to get the right experience and skills – relief work is an incredibly difficult, complex job. The ad-hoc aid effort taking place in Gaza is doing more harm than good. The American consulting company, Boston Consulting Group, has now pulled out of the GHF's work. However, the GHF continues to insist that the aid delivery is a conducted in an orderly way and denies reports of killings.
Israel's political and military leadership may feel their deny-and-deflect approach to reports about civilians being shot dead at aid sites will help the country weather growing criticism. On the contrary, its growing estrangement from international partners and allies reveals the solipsism at the heart of this strategy. Israel's overreliance on the US for support – such as Wednesday's veto by America of a UN Security Council resolution calling for a ceasefire and full aid access in Gaza – is not cast-iron. A much more transactional US administration is in the White House now.
There is a reason why many humanitarian professionals are heavily trained and often stay in the same field for years to get the right experience and skills – relief work is an incredibly difficult, complex job
The real way to deal with this criticism is to finally perceive the reality of this mess and enable international access to Gaza while maintaining a ceasefire. Instead of amassing myriad legal, political, diplomatic and security problems for the future, as well as a collection of broken relationships with erstwhile partners, a truly strategic Israeli government would let the UN and other professionals do their job.
The alternative is yet more suffering, guaranteeing that the Palestinian resistance narrative lasts much longer than this current phase of the conflict. On Wednesday, President Sheikh Mohamed bin Zayed and Egyptian leader Abdel Fattah El Sisi issued a renewed call for a permanent ceasefire during high-level talks in Abu Dhabi, as well as a "just and comprehensive peace" based on a two-state solution. All the deflection in the world cannot refute the hard logic of that position.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Middle East Eye
9 minutes ago
- Middle East Eye
Syria closes controversial Rukban refugee camp near Jordanian border
Syrian authorities have shut down a controversial refugee camp near the Jordanian border that has long faced criticism over dire conditions for its residents. A spokesperson for the Syrian Emergency Task Force, which coordinated activity related to Rukban camp, said all those previously hosted there had returned home and the camp is now 'closed and empty'. Information Minister Hamza al-Mustafa said on X on Saturday that the closure of the camp, established in the early years of the Syrian civil war in 2011, marked the end of "a tragic and sorrowful chapter of displacement stories created by the bygone regime's war machine". At its height, the camp hosted as many as 100,000 inhabitants. But over time, many left due to the poor conditions, returning either to government-held areas or other parts of Syria with the help of smugglers. Numbers also dwindled after Jordan closed its border and stopped regular aid deliveries in 2016. New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters With little to no aid coming in, residents lacked access to food staples, basic medical supplies and health infrastructure. They were forced to live in makeshift dwellings without access to running water or basic sanitation, while the school system was all but nonexistent. "Rukban was not just a camp, it was the triangle of death that bore witness to the cruelty of siege and starvation, where the regime left people to face their painful fate in the barren desert," added Mustafa. Armed groups led by Hay'at Tahrir al-Sham overthrew the government of President Bashar al-Assad in December 2024. Since then, many Syrians living in exile or in camps have begun returning to their original homes, no longer fearing reprisals from Assad's government. The International Organization for Migration (IOM) says around 1.87 million Syrians have returned to their places of origin since December. However, the IOM says the "lack of economic opportunities and essential services" still poses a challenge for returnees.
The National
3 hours ago
- The National
Syria receives major wave of investments in six months since Assad's fall
Syria has attracted growing international investment and aid commitments in the six months since the fall of the regime of former president Bashar Al Assad, as the country seeks to rebuild its shattered economy. This rapid influx of investment marks a stark contrast to the years of economic decline and isolation that defined the country's post-2011 era. Since Mr Al Assad's departure last December, investors from across the region and beyond have started to take a stake in Syria's post-conflict recovery. Qatar, Saudi Arabia and the UAE were among the first nations to endorse the country's new leadership, with President Ahmad Al Shara invited to visit all three countries a handful of times since he took office in a bid to secure economic support. Major commitments include a $7 billion energy infrastructure deal led by Qatar's UCC Holding, a $6.5 billion aid pledge from international donors and an $800 million port development agreement with Dubai-based DP World. Half a century of recovery Despite the momentum, Syria's reconstruction needs range between $400 billion, according to the World Bank, and $1 trillion, as estimated by Mohammad Al-Shaar, Syria's Minister of Economy and Industry, last month. In February 2025, the UNDP published a report in which it estimated that Syria's economy could take half a century to recover to prewar levels. Before the 2011 uprising, Syria's economy was valued at $67.5 billion, ranking 68th globally and comparable to economies like Paraguay and Slovenia according to the World Bank. By 2023, however, years of conflict and sanctions had reduced the country's gross domestic product by 85 per cent to just $9 billion, placing it 129th in the global rankings. Between 2000 and 2010, Syria enjoyed steady economic growth averaging 4.5 per cent annually, with inflation below 5 per cent. At its peak, nominal GDP reached $60 billion, and the average income per member of the population approached $3,000. People power Despite the investments and interest, a key challenge will be getting the country workforce-ready. The prolonged war in Syria has displaced millions, with more than 6.2 million Syrians registered as refugees, and an additional 7.2 million internally displaced. This mass displacement has resulted in a substantial reduction in the available labour force, particularly in critical sectors such as construction and health care. A significant portion of the population has also experienced disruptions in education and vocational training, leading to a skills gap that hampers reconstruction efforts. To address these challenges, new initiatives like cash-for-work programmes have been introduced. These programmes aim to provide immediate employment opportunities while simultaneously rebuilding essential infrastructure. They also offer on-the-job training, helping to bridge the skills gap and empower communities to participate actively in the nation's recovery.
Middle East Eye
4 hours ago
- Middle East Eye
Cambridge students hit out at injunctions 'criminalising' Palestine encampment
Activists have hit out at a number of University of Cambridge colleges after they obtained court injunctions "criminalising" pro-Palestine encampments on campus. Interim injunctions were obtained by Trinity College and St John's College earlier this week after campaigners re-established encampments in protest at what they said was a failure by the university to divest from Israeli companies. A lawyer for the colleges has asked for the injunctions to be made final and to last 12 months, arguing that the protests have been disruptive to students taking exams and that the colleges are "concerned about the environment of fear and intimidation created by masked protesters". Cambridge for Palestine (C4P) said the move amounts to "criminalising" protests on campus. The group posted footage on their Instagram page appearing to show police earlier this week threatening protesters with imprisonment. Speaking to Middle East Eye on Saturday, a spokesperson for C4P, who preferred to remain anonymous, said the university was aiming to obscure a consensus among the student body that "rejects the university's long-standing partnership in genocide". New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters "Just months ago, when Cambridge enacted its first anti-protest injunction, over a thousand students, faculty and staff members united to condemn the university's repressive and racist action," they said. "Our university is isolating itself with its blatant defence of Zionist violence, and we will not allow it to go unchecked as it bankrolls scholasticide and mass murder." 'Our university is isolating itself with its blatant defence of Zionist violence' - C4P activist MEE contacted the University of Cambridge for comment, but had received no response at the time of publication. C4P says Trinity College holds investments in companies such as Elbit Systems, Caterpillar, L3Harris Technologies, and Barclays despite the university's previous commitment to review its 'responsible investment' policy following a similar months-long encampment last year. The group said the renewed protest last week came after months of student, faculty and community "frustration" over the university's failure to honour those pledges. The group has outlined four core demands, including full disclosure of financial ties to companies implicated in Israeli violations of international law, full divestment from them and reinvestment in Palestinian communities. In March, the university was granted a High Court order barring pro-Palestine actions from three locations on its campus until the end of July 2025 - a reduced version of its original bid to secure a five-year ban, which was rejected in court on 27 February. The University of Cambridge is made up of 31 self-governing colleges that operate autonomously, including in their financial investments. Many of them have faced protests over their investments since the launch of Israel's war on Gaza in October 2023. On 20 May, King's College announced it would divest millions from the arms industry and companies complicit in "the occupation of Ukraine and Palestinian territories", becoming the first Oxford or Cambridge college to take such measures. Since the beginning of Israel's war on Gaza in October 2023, pro-Palestinian students around the world have launched encampments in support of Gaza and in opposition to university links to Israel. The actions have been met with a fierce crackdown by security and police on several campuses.
