German immigration clampdown ruled illegal by federal court
Germany
's tough new migration approach, which involves turning asylum seekers back at the border, has been described as unlawful by Berlin's federal administrative court.
The ruling, which cannot be appealed, undercuts a pledge by Chancellor
Friedrich Merz
and his government, sworn in last month, to cut immigration numbers.
Monday's case was taken by three Somali nationals, two men and a woman, turned back on May 9th by German border police at the railway station in Frankfurt an der Oder to Poland.
The police, acting under a new regulation passed by the federal interior ministry, refused to allow the three to file for asylum in Germany and returned them to Poland the same day. The police sent them back, the government ruled in court, because they were coming from a safe third country.
READ MORE
On Tuesday the court said the border police actions, and the regulation they were following, ignored necessary legal steps and violated asylum provisions.
[
EU warns Poland for suspending Dublin migrant regulation
Opens in new window
]
'Persons who express the wish to seek asylum while at a border check on German territory may not be sent back,' the court ruled. At least, it added, until it is known which European country has frontline responsibility for their asylum application under the EU's Dublin system.
Until Monday the interior ministry had cited emergency provisions and a danger to public order as its justifications for setting aside EU law. In court it argued that one quarter of the 230,000 asylum applications filed last year in Europe were filed in Germany.
The court dismissed this argument, saying 'it remains open what these numbers mean for public order or security'. It also criticised the unilateral nature of Berlin's new policy as contradicting the 'loyal co-operation' required of EU member states 'to look, in a serious way, for common solutions'.
The opposition Green Party called the ruling as a 'severe defeat' for Chancellor Merz and his interior minister,
Alexander Dobrindt
.
[
Germany increases border checks: Alexander Dobrindt oversees radical policy shift
Opens in new window
]
'Merz and Dobrindt ignored the warnings and broke EU law, and have now run into a brick wall,' said Katharina Dröge, Green co-leader.
Green Bundestag parliamentary floor leader Irene Mihalic called the ruling a warning to the government 'to abide by the law in the future and not to knowingly exceed its own powers for populist purposes'.
Germany's police union also welcomed the ruling, saying 'the approach was legally iffy from the start'.
Immigration lobby group Pro Asyl said an 'unlawful practice of national unilateral action in asylum policy has failed, this nonsense must now come to an end'.
Mr Dobrindt insisted on Monday evening he would stick to his policy.
'There is a legal basis for it, regardless of individual case rulings,' he said, adding that the three plaintiffs had sought to enter Germany three times previously.
.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Journal
4 hours ago
- The Journal
There'll soon be another country where you'll be able to use euro
THERE'LL SOON BE another country where you'll be able to travel without needing to exchange your euro for a different currency. The European Commission has given approval for Bulgaria to adopt the euro from next year, putting it on course to become the 21st member of the eurozone. The commission said Bulgaria had fulfilled the strict criteria 'intended to ensure that a country is ready to adopt the euro and that its economy is sufficiently prepared to do so'. The European Central Bank also gave a positive opinion, hailing Bulgaria's 'tremendous dedication to making the adjustments needed'. Bulgarian Prime Minister Rossen Jeliazkov hailed 'a remarkable day' that followed 'years of reforms, commitment and alignment with our European partners'. The push has, however, sparked a backlash from some Bulgarians, with protests and recent surveys showing nearly half of those questioned opposed adopting the euro — fearing painful economic consequences. About 1,000 people demonstrated today in front of the National Assembly building in the centre of Sofia. The gathering was organised by the opposition pro-Russian Vazrazhdane party. Others, though, have welcomed the move towards the euro. 'It will give us greater freedom and make traveling abroad easier,' a 36-year-old software developer in Sofia told AFP, though she added feeling 'a bit of nostalgia'. 'We are losing a bit of our identity, our lev,' she said. Advertisement 'Whether it's in euros, dollars, or levs, I just want to live well,' Svilen Manavski, 61, a construction worker said. Bulgaria has had a rocky road to joining the eurozone: the nation has been plagued by political turmoil with seven elections in three years, the most recent in October 2024. The approval comes 18 years after Bulgaria joined the EU. With a population of 6.4 million, Bulgaria has spent several years preparing its economy to join the eurozone. It still needs the approval of the EU's finance ministers, who are expected to give their full backing in July, before it formally adopts the euro from 1 January 2026. 'Today's report is a historic moment for Bulgaria, the euro area and the European Union,' said EU economy chief Valdis Dombrovskis. 'Of course, the euro is more than a currency. Following on from Bulgaria becoming a full member of the Schengen area earlier this year, it brings Bulgaria ever closer to the heart of Europe,' he added. When the first euro bank notes and coins were rolled out on 1 January 2002, Ireland was one of 12 countries to become part of the single-currency area. It has since grown to 20, with Slovenia joining in 2007, Cyprus and Malta in 2008, Slovakia in 2009, Estonia in 2011, Latvia in 2014 and Lithuania in 2015. Croatia was the most recent country to join in 2023. Bulgaria wanted to adopt the currency sooner but in the past few years the EU had concluded its inflation was too high to meet the necessary requirements. To join the single currency area, member states must show that their economy has converged with other eurozone countries and that they have a handle on their finances. © AFP 2025
Irish Times
4 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on ECB interest rates: getting near to their floor
The European Central Bank (ECB) is widely expected to cut interest rates again at today's meeting, encouraged by figures earlier this week showing euro zone inflation at 1.9 per cent, just below its 2 per cent target. A quarter point cut in its key deposit rate is expected by the financial markets and any other outcome would be a big surprise. However, what will be particularly closely watched are new forecasts for inflation from the ECB and any comments from its president, Christine Lagarde, about the outlook. Another cut in interest rates looks justified at a time when inflationary pressures and the euro zone economy both appear weak and investment sentiment is hit by uncertainty, mainly related to the policies of US president Donald Trump. But indications from the ECB of what happens next may be limited, with Lagarde likely to stick to the line that it all depends on the data in the months ahead. While pointing to limited inflationary pressures, the ECB's forecasts are also likely to caution about the difficulties of forecasting and remaining price pressures in some areas. Were the EU to respond to Trump's tariffs with similar moves of its own on US imports, this could also push up inflation in the euro zone. The rapid fall in ECB interest rates since they peaked at 4 per cent also means there may not be much further to go in terms of reductions. Borrowing costs may now be around what is called a neutral level, in other words one which neither stimulates nor restricts economic activity. More hawkish members of the policy-making governing council had already been cautioning about reducing interest rates further, even before today's meeting. Their real target was probably to underline that after the deposit rate reaches 2 per cent, convincing reasons would be needed to reduce it further. READ MORE The financial markets continue to anticipate further gradual reductions, albeit limited in scale. In a volatile economic environment, it is impossible to be certain, but ECB interest rates may now be coming close to their floor.
Agriland
4 hours ago
- Agriland
Livestock ‘essential' to meeting climate targets
A paper published by an EU body of agri-food research organisations – including Teagasc – has said that livestock systems are essential to meeting climate and biodiversity targets, when they are designed with 'circularity and multifunctionality in mind'. The paper, described as a policy brief, was published this week by the Animal Task Force (ATF), an EU public-private partnership entity that brings together organisations in several EU member states that work in the areas of livestock research and science. Teagasc is one such organisation, and Teagasc director Prof. Frank O' Mara is the president of the ATF. The paper, titled Livestock are more than food, said that livestock systems in Europe 'are at a crossroads'. 'In the middle of growing calls to reduce meat consumption, livestock numbers, and agricultural emissions, the broader contributions of livestock are often overlooked by both the general public and policymakers. 'Yet, when managed sustainably, livestock plays a key role in delivering climate resilience, resource efficiency, rural development, and ecosystem services,' the paper added. According to the report, the benefits of livestock, apart from food production, include: manure as a renewable fertiliser; use of certain products in pharmaceuticals, textiles and construction; biodiversity and landscape management; rural livelihoods; health and nutrition; renewable energy through biogas production; and companionship and therapeutics for humans. The report said that these functions 'align closely' with the EU's sustainability agenda, while being 'unrecognised' in many of the EU's policy frameworks. The ATF cited the Common Agricultural Policy (CAP), saying the policy offers eco-schemes and agri-environmental supports 'but often lacks the tools to reward livestock systems for their ecosystem services or circular contributions'. The paper said that animals are 'sentient beings', citing concerns over animal welfare. However, the paper also said that it is 'of vital importance for the livestock industry as well as European citizens' that arguments used to enhance welfare-related regulations 'are based on solid scientific evidence'. According to the ATF, there are a number of policy challenges to the livestock sector in the EU. These include what the ATF claimed were 'misaligned' environmental metrics which undervalue the ecosystem services of extensive livestock systems. The ATF also said that there are regulatory barriers which 'often block the circular use of materials'. The ATF went on the claim that there are 'biased narratives' in which public and policy debates are polarised, 'making it harder to build nuanced, sustainable strategies'. As well as that, there is insufficient investment in farmers' roles, with farmers poorly represented in funding decisions, and weak support for new entrants or mixed systems, the ATF said. However, the paper said there are also 'policy opportunities', including: supporting circular livestock systems; integrating livestock into broader sustainability metrics; fostering innovation; reframing public communication; and creating 'enabling conditions' for diverse farming models.
