Musclebound trans swimmer Ana Caldas wins all 5 races at women's swim nationals
Unmatched Performance at National Meet
Ana Caldas
, a 47-year-old
transgender swimmer
, won all five races she entered at the us. Masters Swimming Spring National Championship last weekend in San Antonio, Texas. Competing in the women's 45-49 age group, Caldas took gold in the 50- and 100-yard breaststroke, the 100-yard freestyle, and the 100-yard individual medley. She won some events by margins rarely seen at this level, such as over four seconds in the breaststroke and three seconds in the freestyle.
Footage circulating online showed her leading far ahead of other swimmers, drawing both applause and outrage. Critics quickly drew parallels to Lia Thomas, the first openly transgender athlete to win an NCAA Division I swimming title in 2022, sparking renewed debate over fairness and inclusion in women's sports.
— hecheateddotorg (@hecheateddotorg)
A Familiar Debate Reignites
Lia Thomas's collegiate victories once marked a significant moment for trans athletes but also triggered nationwide controversy. Her 2022 NCAA win in the women's 500-yard freestyle led to a federal investigation. The us. Department of Education found that the University of Pennsylvania violated Title IX by allowing her to compete in the women's division, ordering the school to strip her records and honors from that season.
This ruling raised significant questions about how athletic bodies should balance fairness and inclusion, questions now resurfacing with Ana Caldas's dominance. Some supporters view her success as a display of determination and resilience. Others, however, see it as another example of transgender athletes potentially holding physiological advantages over cisgender women, particularly in short-distance events where milliseconds usually separate winners.
Public Backlash and Athlete Reactions
The reaction online has been swift and polarizing. Prominent women's sports advocate Riley Gaines, a former collegiate swimmer, dismissed Caldas's gender identity and tweeted, 'He won them all.' Another critic, Beth Bourne, likened the situation to a 'real-life South Park episode,' a reference that quickly went viral on social media as viewers expressed disbelief at the race footage showing Caldas outpacing competitors by multiple body lengths.
Bourne, who is an outspoken advocate for women's rights in sports, also called the results 'insanity,' noting, 'Anyone who competes in swimming at the national level knows this is unheard of in a 50-yard race where wins are often measured in a tenth or a hundredth of a second' at national-level events, not in multiple seconds.
A spokesperson for the
Independent Council on Women's Sports
(ICONS) told Reduxx, 'He's just laughing at these women,' referring to Caldas's performances. ICONS also sent a letter to us. Masters Swimming (USMS), warning that allowing her to compete might violate fair competition principles.
Governing Policies and a Complex Legacy
Under USMS policy, transgender women may compete in women's events if they meet specific
hormone-level criteria
. Caldas was allowed to compete under these rules. But critics argue those standards do not adequately offset physiological advantages carried over from male puberty. Her athletic history adds further fuel to the debate: before transitioning, Caldas, born Hugo Caldas, competed in men's sports and even made three appearances at the CrossFit Games, narrowly missing a spot in the 2012 London Olympics.
This background, combined with her recent dominance, has intensified calls for sporting bodies to revisit their policies. Supporters of transgender inclusion maintain that exclusion based on gender identity is discriminatory. However, critics insist that fairness for female athletes must remain a top priority.
As Ana Caldas becomes the latest flashpoint in a growing cultural and legal debate, sports organizations are being pushed to clarify how best to respect identity while preserving the integrity of competition.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
8 hours ago
- First Post
Trans athlete defies US President Trump's criticism to win two golds and silver at California state athletics meet
High-schooler AB Hernandez cleared 5 feet, 7 inches in high jump with no failed attempts and also won triple jump and finished second in long jump, sharing the first position with other athletes in the first two events. read more AB Hernandez, a transgender student at Jurupa Valley High School, won two gold and a silver medal at the California high school track-and-field championships in Clovis, California. AP A transgender high school athlete won two gold and a silver and shared the medals with rivals under new rules aimed at tamping down controversy over her participation in the California State Track & Field Championships on Saturday. AB Hernandez, 16, cleared 5 feet, 7 inches (1.70m) in the high jump with no failed attempts and shared first place with Jillene Wetteland and Lelani Laruelle – who each cleared the same height with one failed attempt. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD They topped the podium together at the championships held in Clovis, outside of Fresno, under new rules announced this week by the California Interscholastic Federation in response to criticism of the policy that allows transgender athletes to compete in girls' events. CIF first modified their championship entry rules so that biological females were not excluded from competition due to the participation of trans athletes. They then issued a rule change targeting events in which Hernandez had qualified to compete – high jump, long jump and triple jump – saying any 'biological female student-athlete who would have earned a specific placement on the podium will also be awarded the medal for that place' in those events. AB Hernandez, center, flashes a sign as she shares the first-place spot on the podium with Jillene Wetteland, left, and Lelani Laruelle during a medal ceremony for the high jump at the California high school track-and-field championships in Clovis, California. AP The changes came after days of controversy that included a social media post from US President Donald Trump, who threatened to withhold future federal funding from California if Hernandez was allowed to compete. 'As a female, this transitioned person is practically unbeatable. THIS IS NOT FAIR, AND TOTALLY DEMEANING TO WOMEN AND GIRLS,' Trump wrote. 'Please be hereby advised that large scale Federal Funding will be held back, maybe permanently, if the Executive Order on this subject matter is not adhered to…This is a totally ridiculous situation!!!' STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD The US Department of Justice has also launched an investigation into whether California has violated Title IX, the law that prohibits sex discrimination in educational programs that receive federal funding. On Thursday, Clovis mayor Diane Pearce also called for CIF to block Hernandez's participation. During preliminary competition on Friday, a small plane circled the stadium pulling a banner that read: 'No boys in girls sports!' Plane flies 'No Boys in Girls' Sports' banner at California track and field state championship. AB Hernandez, a boy, will compete in the girls' high jump, triple jump, and long jump finals tomorrow. Great work by @WomenAreReals and @icons_women 🙌🏼 — Riley Gaines (@Riley_Gaines_) May 31, 2025 About a dozen protesters outside the venue sported T-shirts and signs reading 'Save girls sports.' Hernandez shrugged off the controversy, also winning the triple jump and finishing second in the long jump. In the triple jump, Hernandez leapt 42 feet 2.75 inches (12.87m) and shared gold with Kira Gant Hatcher, who jumped 40 feet five inches. Loren Webster won the long jump with a jump of 21 feet 0.25 inches (6.40m). Hernandez was second with 20 feet 8.75 inches and shared silver with Brooke White, who jumped 19 feet 4.25 inches.
Time of India
4 days ago
- Time of India
Transgender Athlete Sparks National Debate: AB Hernandez's Journey in Track and Field
In a pivotal moment for high school athletics, 16-year-old AB Hernandez, a transgender athlete from Jurupa Valley High School, has become the center of a nationwide debate on gender identity and sports fairness. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Her qualification for California's state track and field championships in events like the triple jump, long jump, and high jump has ignited discussions that extend far beyond the track. Hernandez's participation, permitted under California's 2013 law allowing students to compete according to their gender identity, has faced criticism from various quarters. President Donald Trump publicly condemned her inclusion, labeling it "totally demeaning to women and girls," and threatened to withhold federal funding from California unless the state barred her from competing. This stance aligns with his Executive Order 14201, signed in February 2025, which seeks to ban transgender women from participating in women's sports teams across educational institutions. Trump threatens to revoke federal funding from California over transgender high school athlete In response to the escalating controversy, the California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) introduced a "pilot entry process" for the state championships. This initiative allows an additional cisgender female athlete, who narrowly missed qualification, to compete in events where a transgender athlete has qualified. The CIF emphasized that this measure aims to balance inclusivity with fairness, ensuring that no athlete is displaced. Governor Gavin Newsom supported the CIF's approach, describing it as a thoughtful resolution to a complex issue. He highlighted the importance of inclusivity and fairness in competition, especially amid rising anti-trans sentiments nationwide. However, critics argue that the policy creates a dual standard and may be discriminatory, while supporters believe it addresses concerns without compromising the rights of transgender athletes. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now 'Totally ridiculous situation!!!' Trump threatens California's funding over transgender athlete The U.S. Department of Justice has also entered the fray, launching a Title IX investigation into California's policies on transgender athletes. The probe examines whether allowing transgender athletes in girls' sports constitutes sex-based discrimination, focusing on the CIF and specific school districts involved. As the state championships approach, Hernandez remains focused on her performance, stating, "All I can do is go out there and compete and just do my best." Her resilience amid the controversy underscores the broader societal challenges at the intersection of sports, identity, and policy. This unfolding situation in California reflects a microcosm of the national debate on transgender rights and sports, highlighting the need for nuanced discussions and policies that respect both inclusivity and fairness.
Time of India
6 days ago
- Time of India
MLC: Aim is to get cricket in NCAA, says Seattle Orcas CEO Hemant Dua
Seattle Orcas finished runners-up in the first season of the Major League Cricket and sixth in the second season. (Image: X/SeattleOrcas) New Delhi: Seattle Orcas CEO Hemant Dua believes USA's win over Pakistan in the 2024 T20 World Cup has played a pivotal role in helping cricket get its first foot in the door. The win helped USA cricket take a significant initial step towards achieving a goal, which, in the bigger picture, is to make the sport popular in a country where it is in unchartered territory. "Cricket has grown overall. It was always on the straps for very long here, but it was more at the amateur level in the USA. The cricket board has gone through a lot of challenges. I think off late, ICC started investing in it and seeing cricket in the USA as the frontier they want to conquer," Dua told "The 2024 World Cup came, it did really well and had a huge impact from an economic point of view. It helped cricket to a certain extent definitely because USA beating Pakistan was like a dream come true for the USA guys; it helped the growth of cricket," he said. Dua says with Major League Cricket (MLC) successfully entering its third season, the next goal is to get cricket into the National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA) so that the sport will be in the mainstream. "Largely, cricket is played by South Asians and a little bit of the Commonwealth population like the English, South Africans, and all those. It hasn't really gone into the mainstream as yet, and the challenge remains: how do you make it a growing mainstream sport, especially focused on youth and colleges," he said. "In the US, unlike other parts of the world, if you're not part of the college system, the sport really doesn't grow. You know, because college sport is the base of growth here for everything, right? So that's how all sports kind of grow in that direction. Once you become part of the NCAA, you grow automatically; that is how sports grow. "Ideally, this should be the next step, but it's a combination where everyone will have to come on the same platform. When I say everyone, I mean USA Cricket, MLC, Minor League Cricket, all have to come on the same platform, and one of the biggest challenges for becoming part of college sports is Title IX. Title IX means you've got to have equivalent or some form of women's cricket playing, right? Without women's sport, you don't get recognition. "In my region, which is the Pacific Northwest, there are girls playing regularly, so we're trying to grow. I mean, there are various leagues that have come up at U-19 and U-16 levels for boys and girls both. The boys' sport is growing, but it's small numbers," he said. With cricket finding a place at the 2028 Los Angeles Olympics, Dua is hopeful that most of the MLC franchises will have their own cricket stadium, and it will take cricket to the next level. "What will make a huge impact is now when all six teams will have their own stadium ready. It is part of the contract with MLC that each team will build their stadium by 2028. With the Olympics happening in 2028, there is going to be some noise where people will get to know about the sport more," he said. For the expansion of cricket in the USA, the franchises are also banking on targetting the Indian population. "If you look at the population, approximately 20 million South Asians live in the USA. It is a pretty significant number. Indians have the highest net worth individuals. The Indian income group is much higher compared to the average income group in the USA, so there's a spending capacity there. So can we tap into that, can we tap into that dream?" he said. Dua, who has been part of the Delhi Daredevils (now Delhi Capitals) for ten years since the inception of the Indian Premier League (IPL) in 2008, admitted that all six franchises are currently making losses, but he strongly believes that the MLC as a product is sustainable in the larger scheme of things. "Everyone's making losses in the MLC now. Even in the IPL, for 10 years, everybody made losses until the 11th year broadcast contract came on the floor," he said. The Indian income group is much higher compared to the average income group in the USA, so there's a spending capacity there Hemant Dua "I strongly believe that MLC is sustainable. As I said, everything depends largely on the media contracts. Right now, we are on Willow, which is a streaming platform, so we're opening up new markets. In each region, I have tied up with a regional sport network along with Willow. We've opened up with Root and Fox 13; we're going to relay our matches similarly in other regions. "These are obviously not going to help us make money, but the idea is to ensure that more people get to see the game. For the first time now, Amazon has also done a deal, so they'll broadcast the Sunday night games on Amazon. It's opening up, but I think the real test will come when the new broadcast contract comes in, and whoever takes it, whether it's Willow or whether it's another channel or whoever it is, takes up and depending on what value that generates, that will tell you in which direction we are actually moving. " Get IPL 2025 match schedules , squads , points table , and live scores for CSK , MI , RCB , KKR , SRH , LSG , DC , GT , PBKS , and RR . Check the latest IPL Orange Cap and Purple Cap standings.
