Historian blames post-war 'chaos' for Harvard Magna Carta 'copy' confusion
A British historian who discovered a copy of the Magna Carta was a genuine manuscript has shared his theory on why the document was misidentified.
Harvard Law Library bought a version of the royal charter at auction for just $27.50 in 1946, the equivalent of around $450 (£328) today.
The vellum document was described as a "copy made in 1327... somewhat rubbed and damp-stained" - but two historians last month discovered it was actually a rare original worth millions of pounds.
The document was just one of seven versions of the Magna Carta to survive from King Edward I's 1300 issue of the charter.
Professor David Carpenter, who made the discovery with Professor Nicholas Vincent, believes "post-war chaos" is to blame for the confusion.
Speaking at a meeting of the Pipe Roll Society at The National Archives in London, he said: "This was just after the war, there was still a measure of chaos, someone has misread the date on it.
"This is most likely how it happened."
Following the discovery, Prof Vincent traced the history of the document prior to Harvard buying it.
His research suggests that after it was issued by King Edward I to the former parliamentary borough of Appleby, it fell into the hands of a family before being passed to slavery abolitionist Thomas Clarkson.
Via his estate, it ended up in the hands of Forster Maynard, a World War One flying ace, who sold it to London book dealers Sweet & Maxwell for £42, which then sold it to Harvard.
Prof Carpenter, a medieval historian at King's College London, immediately realised the 'copy' looked a lot like the real Magna Carta when he spotted it in Harvard's online catalogue.
"I immediately sent the image to my colleague Nicholas Vincent asking him 'Is this what I think it is?'," he said.
Speaking at the same meeting, Prof Vincent said: "I told him immediately, you know what that is!"
The Magna Carta was originally established in 1215 under King John and outlined the rights of ordinary people under common law for the first time.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Hampstead ladies' pond swimmers accuse trans women of spying on them
Swimmers at the Hampstead ladies' pond have accusedtransgender women of spying on them naked. Women have complained of voyeuristic behaviour from some trans women, who were born male, using the Kenwood Ladies' Pond, which they say has made left them feeling 'violated'. One said she had been stared at in the shower, while another saw a biological man taking photographs of other bathers. Now a women's rights group has threatened the City of London Corporation, which owns the outdoor pond, with legal action unless it stops biological men from using it. The pond opened in 1925 and is the sole women-only freshwater swimming amenity in the country. Since 2019 it has been open to trans women. The Corporation has not changed its policy since the Supreme Court ruled in April that, under the Equality Act, sex means biological sex. This judgement means toilets and changing rooms should be segregated by biological sex and not self-identified gender. Women's rights campaigners Sex Matters have threatened to take the Corporation to court unless it changes its regulations to comply with the Supreme Court ruling. The group said it has examples of women who have felt uncomfortable using the ponds since trans women were allowed in. They have 'been subjected to trans-identifying men being naked in the changing area and showers' and experienced 'trans-identifying men taking photographs of women and girls and trans-identifying men topless in the meadow, both of which are not permitted'. Other women have complained about ' trans-identifying men staring at women and girls in the showers and changing facilities'; and 'felt violated in what they considered was a women-only safe space'. One pond user, who wishes to remain anonymous, complained: 'I was showering outside after my swim, when a big man with a long wig and a long coat came walking down the path to the pond area. 'This man came and lingered in the restricted area between the outdoor showers and the fence, where my towel was draped. He stood there turned at an angle, looking at me and evidently wanting me to know that he was looking at me. 'I was trapped, because I was naked, and my towel was on the fence behind him.' In 2019, the pond changed its rules to allow trans women - that is biological men - to use the facilities, claiming it was required under the Equality Act. When the change was being discussed, Charles Lord, from the City of London Corporation, said: 'It shouldn't be controversial. It shouldn't be a debate. Trans women are women, trans men are men.' Even after the Supreme Court judgement, the Corporation put out a statement indicating it would not change its policy, saying: 'Any unlawful discrimination will not be tolerated. Our gender identity policy is designed to ensure our services are welcoming to everyone, including all who use the bathing ponds.' Trans women have been allowed to use the pond since the judgement, even though the signs say 'women only' and 'no men beyond this point'. The changing hut at the ladies' pond contains open communal showers and an open changing area. There is also a mixed pond and a men's only pond. Last month, 30 women's rights campaigners stormed the male-only pond at Hampstead shouting 'no goolies in our poolies' in protest at the policy. Sex Matters said the Corporation was failing on human rights grounds, discrimination and harassment, and had made an error in law. A spokesman for the Corporation said: 'In line with other service providers, we are reviewing our access policies, including those at Hampstead Heath's bathing ponds. 'In doing so, we must consider the impact of current and potential future arrangements on all visitors, while ensuring we meet our legal duties and provide appropriate access. ' This summer we will engage with our service users and other stakeholders to ensure we understand their needs and can take properly informed decisions. 'In considering the way forward, we have taken, and will continue to take, specialist legal advice. The current arrangements remain in place during the review. 'Our priority is to provide a safe and respectful environment for everyone.'
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
Five ways to heat your garden and extend the summer evenings
Garden-party season is in full swing; but given the changeable UK climate, if you want your barbecue or cocktail soirée to extend long into the evening, you might want to invest in a heater for guests to gather around after dark. There are a number of ways you can add warmth and ambience to your garden: a quick-fix patio heater, an atmospheric fire pit, a compact chiminea, or a luxurious garden fireplace. But what to choose? Here are the pros and cons of some of the most popular garden-heating options to consider. Patio heaters A patio heater is a simple way to keep warm after the sun sets, and there are several different styles on the market. Electric heaters include tabletop options, which are ideal if your garden is small. A real space-saver is a wall-mounted or hanging pendant heater, which can be stored away if it's not needed over the winter months. Floor-standing heaters range from small, lantern-style models to the tall free-standing ones frequently seen in beer gardens. There are also more thoughtful designs that mimic industrial-look floor lamps, such as the Kettler Kalos copper free-standing patio heater (pictured; £379, Pros and cons Electric heaters are easy to use and quick to heat up, but require a power outlet, which could mean you have to contend with cables trailing across your patio or terrace. Gas alternatives are cord-free but require a supply of fuel. A 13kg propane gas bottle costs around £50, and will give you around 18 hours of burn time, though this can vary greatly according to the settings you choose. Cost Patio heaters start from as little as £35 for a basic tabletop heater and can reach £400-plus for more powerful, stylish designs. Tip: If you plan to place a patio heater in an exposed position, choose one with a heavy base, or one that fixes to the floor, to ensure a gust of wind won't blow it over. Fire pits A fire pit creates a welcoming environment for guests, and there are many shapes and sizes available, so you can tailor your selection to your space. Contemporary designs are available in a wide range of finishes, including coloured concretes and stainless or corten steel. If you have the space and would like a more permanent structure, you can build something yourself – perhaps out of brick or stone for a rustic look – or commission one to be built by a professional. Whatever you choose, it is important to consider the space around a fire pit and allow plenty of room to move around. If your garden is small with overhanging trees, you will need to make sure there's a safe enough clearance to use an open fire. A fire pit won't be for all – children and pets are a consideration. Pros and cons Steel fire-pits and bowls are mostly portable and don't require any installation. Some come with a removable grill so that you can barbecue on top. The downside of a wood-burning fire pit is that the smoke can blow directly into your face if the wind suddenly shifts; and you'll probably find your hair and clothes will smell of it after a night by the fire pit. The smoke might also not be welcomed by neighbours. Using kiln-dried wood which has a moisture content of less than 20 per cent is a more carbon-friendly fuel choice, as it ensures reduced smoke emissions. Some fire pits have built-in 'smokeless' technology, such as the smokeless large fire pit by Chesneys (£695, You'll pay a bit more, but it might be worth it for comfort. By choosing a fire pit powered by gas you can avoid smoke entirely – as well as ash and soot. They are quick and easy to operate, but you will need to spend a bit more and to buy gas to keep it burning. Bioethanol fire pits are becoming a popular option for outdoor fire pits as they are clean-burning and work from a renewable and sustainable fuel source. Bioethanol can be more expensive than wood, however. Cost A small portable fire pit or bowl can start at around £100, with larger models starting from around £300. A 16-litre bag of kiln-dried logs costs around £8 and could last a few days to a week or two, depending on how often you burn them and the size of your fire pit. A bespoke gas fire pit would reach into hundreds or even thousands of pounds. Chimineas A standalone chiminea is a good option if you prefer a smaller and more contained open fire. Traditional designs come in patterned terracotta, but there are also models in cast iron. The clay versions don't get as hot, which might help if you have pets or small children around, but the metal versions are more durable, as clay can be fragile. You can also cook with a chiminea, which could be helpful when entertaining larger groups and there's not enough space on the barbecue. Pros and cons Chimineas are preferable to fire pits for smaller gardens, as the fire is more contained, and the chimney also funnels the smoke up and away so that it's less likely to blow into your face. They don't produce as much heat as a fire pit however, so are not as well suited to larger spaces. Again, using kiln-dried wood minimises smoke and emissions. Cost Chimineas cost from around £65 from companies such as Argos and B&Q, but you can expect to pay upwards of £200 for a more premium model such as the Sarsden chiminea (pictured; £280, Fire pit tables A fire pit table offers the same compelling look of real flames, as well as a place to gather around and eat. Designs can be integrated into a coffee, dining or bar table, using gas for clean, smoke-free heat. Designs are typically contemporary, although you can find rustic-look versions. A fire pit table that requires propane gas normally comes with a cover to conceal the bottle. You might also find versions that can be connected to your gas supply at home with touchpad controls. Pros and cons Reilly Gray, the co-founder of garden furniture company Suns Lifestyle, says: 'Serving as a focal point, the fire pit will provide added warmth and encourage interaction around the table. The integral gas source and push-button ignition and controls mean you get instant heat with little effort.' You will need a professional gas engineer to install a dedicated gas line to the fire pit table. While there's an initial financial outlay, it can be more cost-effective in the long run than other heat sources. Cost Fire pit tables start from around £500 for cheaper versions and can reach into the thousands – for example, the director Guy Ritchie's £75,000 model, as used by David Beckham. You can buy a dining set with a built-in fire pit such as the Monte Vari fire pit and Nappa dining collection (pictured; £6,200, Garden fireplaces You can create a dramatic focal point in your garden all year round with a fireplace. 'A garden fireplace can come in a number of guises and is a real investment, usually created as part of an overall landscape project and integrated into the outdoor entertainment scheme,' says Tony Young of outdoor kitchen company Urban Outdoors. For the maximum convenience, choose a gas fire. You can have one built into a wall or enclosure, or buy a free-standing fireplace. Some models are designed to be barbecues too, so they can be fitted as part of an outdoor kitchen. A gas version is simple to use, especially if you choose one that can be operated by a handheld remote control, a smartphone app or your home automation system. Some of the more expensive bioethanol fireplaces use the same technology. For a traditional fireplace you will need a wall in your garden for the brickwork flue – and a plentiful supply of wood. Pros and cons A fireplace will give your garden wow factor, but it's a significant investment. Owen Pacey of Renaissance London, which specialises in antique fireplaces, says Italian or French stone fireplaces have proved popular for clients who want a rustic look. 'The benefit of a wood-burning outdoor fireplace is that you will get the classic, romantic experience,' he says. 'Unfortunately, there are local regulations about creating a nuisance with smoke and your fireplace will need a chimney, which your neighbours may not be so happy about. So many people will choose a gas fireplace, or perhaps a liquid-fuel bioethanol one, both of which are easier to install, especially in urban areas.' Gas and wood-burning fireplaces should be installed by a qualified and registered engineer. Your designer or supplier will recommend the best way to conceal a gas cylinder, but in a larger project, it may be best to connect to gas from the house. Cost A standalone all-in-one fireplace costs around £2,300 and for a custom-built model you will pay much more, starting from around £2,000 for the fireplace alone. Installation of the structure and fuel lines will be on top. An antique fireplace might start at £4,000.
BBC News
2 hours ago
- BBC News
'Lessons learned' by Leeds council after school closure U-turn
A council has said it will learn lessons after it was forced to reverse its plan to close a primary City Council had intended to shut Queensway Primary, in Yeadon, after saying a decline in pupil numbers and financial pressures had put its long-term sustainability at the authority was forced to shelve the plan after parents launched a legal challenge over the way a consultation was carried out ahead of the a set of recommendations to improve future school consultations have been published in a "lessons learned" report by the council. The report found that parents, school staff and councillors felt the consultation period was not long enough, although meetings were held in the run-up to the also said the plan had caused "stress and upset for children, their families and the wider community", particularly as they faced a similar closure threat in added that it had also caused concern over the welfare of children with special educational needs and disabilities (SEND), according to the Local Democracy Reporting Service. At a children and families meeting earlier, Otley & Yeadon councillor Ryk Downes said: "Parents were coming to me saying they couldn't find alternative places for their children based on their SEND needs."We have got to sort out the problem of pupil numbers in Aireborough but at the moment the solution isn't there."Councillors were told that a wider "area-based" approach to the decline in pupil numbers would be taken moving Mark Duce, who has been at the school for four years, announced last week he and other staff had taken the difficult decision to leave the school due to a "lack of clarity provided regarding the long-term future of Queensway". Listen to highlights from South Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North
