Florida execution stay request appealed to U.S. Supreme Court
1 of 2 | Thomas Gudinas, 51, is scheduled to die by lethal injection in Florida on Tuesday after he was convicted of raping and murdering Michelle McGrath, 27, outside an Orlando nightclub in 1994. A stay of execution petition was filed last week to the U.S. Supreme Court as attorneys questioned the state's "process for determining who lives and who dies." Photo by Florida Department of Corrections
June 23 (UPI) -- The scheduled execution of a Florida man on Tuesday is being appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court as attorneys question the state's "process for determining who lives and who dies."
Thomas Gudinas, 51, is scheduled to die by lethal injection after he was convicted of murdering and raping Michelle McGrath, 27, as she left an Orlando nightclub in 1994.
The "cause of death was a brain hemorrhage resulting from blunt force injuries to her head, probably inflicted by a stomping type blow from a boot," according to the medical examiner and restated in the opinion by the Florida Supreme Court.
While Gudinas' attorneys argue he should be spared because he is "severely mentally ill," they appealed last week to the U.S. Supreme Court for a stay of execution because they want Florida to release records related to Gov. Ron DeSantis' "unbridled discretion in determining who shall die and when."
"Florida's governor has no criteria, procedure or guidelines in place for selecting who lives and who dies," according to the petition filed by attorney Ali Shakoor on Wednesday. DeSantis signed Gudinas' death warrant last month.
"Granting the governor unfettered discretion has, in practice, led to a completely arbitrary process for determining who lives and who dies. There are no articulated limits to the executive discretion, there are no guidelines for the selection process and the entire process is cloaked in secrecy," the petition states.
Shakoor has argued that there are 111 men who have been on Florida's death row longer than Gudinas. He also claims that of the 61 lawyers practicing post conviction death penalty law in Florida, the governor's focus on him "is peculiar and concerning."
"It defies statistical probability for Thomas Gudinas to be Attorney Shakoor's fourth death warrant in less than one year," according to a recent editorial in The SunSentinal. If Gudinas is executed Tuesday, he would be the seventh Florida inmate put to death by lethal injection this year.
While the governor's office did not comment, the state Attorney General's Office urged the Supreme Court to reject the claims, arguing Gudinas is not entitled to death warrant records.
"Gudinas wants this court to order the Florida courts to release the requested records so he can then potentially challenge both the governor's selection of him for a death warrant and the broader Florida clemency structure for lacking criteria or procedures to determine whom to execute as violations of the Eighth and Fourteenth Amendments," according to the state's response.
"While he asserts that such claims would be meritorious, the Florida Supreme Court has repeatedly held that the clemency process and the governor's absolute discretion to issue death warrants are constitutional."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
UPI
an hour ago
- UPI
Watch: Bears escape park enclosure, eat a week's supply of honey
June 25 (UPI) -- A pair of European brown bears escaped from their enclosure at a British wildlife park and made their way to a food storage area, where they feasted on snacks including a week's worth of honey. Wildwood Devon confirmed on social media that 5-year-old bears Mish and Lucy escaped from their enclosure due to "an operational area" that allowed the bruins to access a behind-the-scenes area used for food storage. The park was closed as part of standard protocols and police were contacted, but zookeepers were able to "encourage both bears back into their enclosure without the need for any intervention," the post said. The park said the bears "posed no threat to the public at any point, enjoyed a selection of snacks -- including a week's worth of honey -- before being safely returned to their enclosure by the expert keeper team within the hour." Officials said both bears took long, food-induced naps upon returning to their habitat.
UPI
an hour ago
- UPI
Kenya bans live TV coverage as nationwide protests again erupt
A demonstrator displays a placard Wednesday during a protest in the central business district of Kenya's capital city of Nairobi. The protest marks the first anniversary of the Gen Z protests, which culminated with the storming of the national parliament which left dozens dead at the hands of Kenyan police forces. Photo by EPA. June 25 (UPI) -- Television stations were forced off air as thousands flooded the streets in Kenya across the African nation to demand President William Ruto's resignation a year after mass protests over a controversial tax bill left dozens dead after citizens stormed the Kenyan parliament. "Many of us are being killed with no reason," 24-year-old security guard Don Cliff Ochieng told The New York Times Wednesday, saying he was in Nairobi due to police brutality and lack of economic opportunity as banks, business and schools are closed due to fear of violence and major roads closed leading into Kenya's capital city. Unconfirmed reports by multiple news outlets indicated at least two people were shot dead Tuesday and Wednesday during protests in Mattu, about 65 miles from the Kenya's capitol Nairobi where at least 50 protesters reportedly were injured as nationwide protests erupted to mark the first anniversary of last year's deadly demonstrations. "It is our right to demonstrate," added Ochieng. Meanwhile, the Kenyan government has banned live protest television coverage with the privately owned NTV and KTN stations reporting that police officials raided its transmission center and "unconstitutionally" switched off broadcast signals. "This action has been taken without notice," NTV's parent company Nation Media Group stated Wednesday. "The shutdown of NTV is a direct interference of our editorial operations," the statement read in part. Kenyans hit the streets in June 2024 in oppositon to Ruto's tax bill proposal, which passed but Ruto backed off from, to raise an additional $2 billion in needed revenue, which sparked fears of cost of living increases on daily services and goods. Last year's bloody clampdown by Kenyan security forces left at least 65 people dead with thousands arrested and 89 reports of some still missing persons, according to Amnesty International. However, the Kenyan government claimed the death toll at 42 casualties. This week, Kenyan police utilized water canons and tear gas to disperse protests, which again started earlier this month spurred by the questionable death in police custody of teacher and blogger Albert Ojwang, in marches largely lead by angered Gen Z Kenyans fuled over Ruto's perceived arrogance, lack of accountability, economic hardship and string of failed campaign promises to help the poor. Kenyans "are not feeling heard and there's a sense that things have not really changed since the protests last year," Meron Elias, an East Africa analyst at the nonprofit group International Crisis Group, told NYT. "They want to remind the government that this is not a problem that will easily go away." Ruto became president in 2022 and since then salary taxes have spiked in addition to a doubled fuel tax with Kenyans now paying a housing levy and tax on health insurance. On Wednesday, protestors in Nairobi yelled "Ruto must go!" as some carried roses and photos of victims killed last year after a man last week was shot in the head in demonstration against police violence. Kenya's top law enforcement official, Douglas Kanja Kirocho, urged the public on Tuesday to "refrain from provocative acts directed at police officers in the execution of their duties," he said in a statement. In a television speech that day in Nairobi at his official residence, the beleaguered president retired his support for the police. Kenya's National Police Service Commissions stated its expectation that its officers will uphold the "highest standards of professionalism and restraint." "You cannot intimidate the police. You cannot use force against the police, or insult or threaten the police. You are threatening our nation," Ruto said in his speech to a group that included cabinet ministers. However, Kenyan news sources issued reports of people in civilian clothes with weapons accompanied by police as last week's protests were extinguished. On Tuesday, a joint statement by 12 nations, including the United States was critical of the use of "plainclothed officers in unmarked vehicles" and further stated disappointment over the "use of hired 'goons' to infiltrate or disrupt peaceful gatherings." "We are honoring them," Joann Nancy, a 21-year-old student, told the Times. "I am just hoping nobody gets killed."
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
NYC business leaders hope Cuomo drops out of mayoral race completely: sources
Prominent New York business leaders who supported Andrew Cuomo are hoping he will drop out of the race completely after his humiliating loss in the Dem mayoral primary, The Post has learned. As the former governor has emergency meetings about his political future, at least one prominent business executive and Cuomo supporter reached out to the former governor Wednesday morning and gently nudged him to reconsider staying in the race for the good of the city, The Post has learned. Other supporters from the city's business community plan to do so imminently, they say. 3 At least one prominent business executive and Andrew Cuomo supporter reached out to the former governor Wednesday morning and gently nudged him to reconsider staying in the race for the good of the city. John Angelillo/UPI/Shutterstock 'He got destroyed — our best shot is Adams,' said one prominent NYC business leader. 'He lost Harlem. How did that happen? 'He had his shot,' said another Cuomo business supporter. 'It is over.' After his humiliating loss to the socialist upstart Zohran Mamdani in the Democratic primary, Cuomo will be watching polling data to decide if he should run as an independent in the general election for New York City mayor, according to two people with direct knowledge of the matter. Cuomo's last hope to potentially resurrect his political career and remain in the race, these people say, is if polls show the current Mayor Eric Adams, also running as an independent, is 'unelectable,' and the city's business leaders demand that Adams withdraws from the race to prevent a Mamdani victory. Nevertheless, even Cuomo himself told one person who spoke to him after his defeat Tuesday night his fate depends on 'whatever the polls say' and that dropping out is a real possibility. Democratic consultant Hank Sheinkopf is predicting Cuomo will eventually concede rather than go down in history as the man who helped an antisemitic leftist get elected to run Gotham. If Cuomo remains in the race, he will further split the moderate vote between Adams and GOP candidate Curtis Sliwa. 3 After his humiliating loss to the socialist upstart Zohran Mamdani in the Democratic primary, Cuomo will be watching polling data to decide if he should run as an independent in the general election. AFP via Getty Images 'What choice does he have?' Sheinkopf told the Post. Cuomo, at least for now, is playing his cards close to the vest. On Wednesday morning, he was texting business community supporters telling them that he believes Adams is 'un-electable' to rally support, The Post has learned. The former governor is telling people that Adams, who had to face criminal bribery charges from the Trump DOJ before embracing the president's immigration deportation plans, could falter in the face of additional scrutiny over his ethical conduct. It would leave an opening for him to run and possibly defeat the prospect of a Mamdani mayoralty in a three-way race. 3 On Wednesday morning, Cuomo was texting business community supporters telling them that he believes Eric Adams is 'un-electable' to rally support, sources said. Andrew Schwartz / Cuomo is said to be banking on business community support to force Adams out; many business leaders say they will leave Big Apple if Mamdani is elected given his economic proposals and defund the police positions. Mamdani is also a fierce critic of Israel and had once vowed to globalize the intifada. But business community support is unlikely in the face of the complete drubbing he took Tuesday night. One thing is certain: GOP nominee and Guardian Angels founder Curtis Sliwa isn't dropping out. 'The Gambinos told me to shut my mouth in 1992 or else,' he said referring to a failed assassination attempt in 1992, adding that 'five hollow-point bullets later I took a licking and came back ticking. The only way I drop out is if I'm in a pine casket 6 feet under.'
