Trump wins rare court victory to use 1798 law in fast-tracking Venezuelan deportations
WASHINGTON, May 14 — A federal judge in Pennsylvania ruled on Tuesday that the United States can use the Alien Enemies Act to fast-track the deportation of accused Venezuelan gang members, in what appears to be the first court ruling that backs the Trump administration's interpretation of the 1798 law.
Judge Stephanie Haines, of the US District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, ruled that President Donald Trump has authority to declare the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua a foreign terrorist organisation and deport its members under the Alien Enemies Act, but she criticised the administration's practice of deporting people sometimes 'within a matter of hours.'
Haines, appointed by Trump during his first term, ruled that the administration must give potential deportees at least 21 days' notice and the opportunity to challenge their removals, to avoid the possibility that people who are not gang members 'may be errantly removed from this country.'
She made the ruling in court papers in the case of a Venezuelan man identified as A.S.R. Haines did not rule whether A.S.R. was a member of the gang, but she said people like him must be given more opportunity to challenge their deportations.
Haines required the government to provide notice in Spanish and English, and to provide interpreters when necessary.
Lee Gelernt, an attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union who is representing A.S.R., said he would appeal.
'We strongly disagree with the Court's decision to allow the government to continue using this wartime authority during peacetime, and will appeal that aspect of the decision,' Gelernt said.
Haines' ruling is contrary to other federal courts' decisions on the Trump administration's interpretation of the Alien Enemies Act, which the president invoked in March as legal justification for deporting hundreds of men whom his administration accused of being Tren de Aragua members.
Federal judges in New York, Colorado and Texas have ruled against Trump's use of the law to deport Venezuelans.
Haines, in her ruling, noted that her district has jurisdiction over the petition filed by A.S.R., even though he was transferred from an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Philipsburg, Pennsylvania, on 15 April to an ICE detention centre in Texas, despite a temporary restraining order issued that day barring his transfer from the Western District of Pennsylvania.
The Trump administration has deported alleged gang members to a prison in El Salvador under an arrangement in which the United States is paying the Central American nation US$6 million. It is part of Trump's hardline approach toward immigration.
The White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment. — Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
6 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
US begins uneasy World Cup countdown amid LA unrest
Los Angeles is one of several host cities for next year's World Cup in the US. (AFP pic) NEW YORK : US cities hosting next year's Fifa World Cup faced questions today about how to reassure international fans concerned by president Donald Trump's immigration crackdown and travel ban as the year-to-go countdown began. The US, along with Canada and Mexico, is set to co-host the finals, which will feature 48 teams and a record 104 matches in a tournament that Fifa boss Gianni Infantino said would usher in a new generation of football fans. Celebrities and football stars were due to walk the red carpet at the Fox Studio Lot in Los Angeles – one of the host cities – for the year-to-go event there, a day after president Trump deployed marines and the national guard to quell protests. California governor Gavin Newsom described the deployment as an 'unmistakable step toward authoritarianism', while Trump officials defended it and branded the protests as lawless, blaming local and state Democrats for permitting upheaval. Los Angeles is one of several host cities that will mark the year-to-go occasion, including New York-New Jersey, which will welcome fans at a waterside festival in Jersey City with the Statue of Liberty in view. 'If we look at American football as the US's sport, football is the world's sport and this is an opportunity for us to welcome people from all over the world,' Alex Lasry, the New York-New Jersey host committee CEO, told Reuters. Minky Worden, director of global initiatives at Human Rights Watch, said Fifa needed to work with the US government to ensure the rights of competitors, support staff, fans and media were protected regardless of their identities or views. 'Fifa should publicly acknowledge the threat US immigration and other anti-human rights policies pose to the tournament's integrity… (and) should establish clear benchmarks and timelines for the US policy changes needed to ensure respect for immigrants' rights during the 2026 World Cup and beyond,' she said. US Democratic leaders raised concerns over a national crisis yesterday as Trump moved US marines into Los Angeles to tackle civilian protests over his immigration policies. 'There are certainly things that are happening at the national level, the international level, there are going to be geopolitical issues that we don't even know right now that are going to affect the tournament,' Meg Kane, a host city executive for Philadelphia told reporters at a Paley Center event on Monday. 'So we recognise that we're planning within uncertainty.' Fifa did not immediately respond to a request for comment. Infantino confident Fifa president Gianni Infantino said last month after meeting Trump that he was confident the world would be welcomed in for the 2026 World Cup and this year's Club World Cup, which runs from June 14 to July 13. But the task of reassuring international fans was complicated by a travel ban that went into effect on Monday, cracking down on what Trump called 'foreign terrorists'. Of the 12 countries facing travel bans, Iran is the only one that has qualified for the 2026 tournament so far. Tehran said on Saturday that the ban showed 'deep hostility' toward Iranians and Muslims. European fans, supporter groups and former players contacted by Reuters said it was too early for anyone to be thinking about revising schedules or re-evaluating plans for attending the World Cup. Alina Hudak, the Miami host committee president and CEO, told Reuters she had been in touch with the local consular corps to address their concerns and to offer support. 'My responsibility is to make sure that we're ready, that we're safe, that we're coordinating logistically with all of our law enforcement agencies, that we've done everything we can to ensure that our mass transit system is ready and can handle the volume,' said Hudak. 'And so for me, you know, what's happening outside of that is something that we're monitoring, but not something that, quite frankly, I have an impact (on).'
Free Malaysia Today
7 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Trump says Washington's trade deal with Beijing is ‘done'
Donald Trump said China will supply the US with rare earth minerals and magnets. (AP pic) WASHINGTON : US president Donald Trump touted ties with China as 'excellent' today, saying the superpowers reached a deal after two days of talks aimed at preserving a truce in their damaging trade war. Trump said on his Truth Social platform that China would supply rare earth minerals and magnets – vital elements for American industries – while Washington would allow Chinese students to remain in US universities. His post came after top US and Chinese negotiators announced a 'framework' agreement late yesterday following two days of marathon talks in London. 'Our deal with China is done,' Trump wrote, adding that the agreement was still 'subject to final approval with president Xi (Jinping) and me.' 'President XI and I are going to work closely together to open up China to American Trade,' he said in a second post. 'This would be a great WIN for both countries!!!' US stock markets showed little enthusiasm despite Trump's statements, but major indexes edged higher in early trading. US treasury secretary Scott Bessent said today that it was possible to rebalance economic relations with China if Beijing proved a 'reliable partner in trade negotiations'. 'If China will course-correct by upholding its end of the initial trade agreement we outlined in Geneva, and I believe after our talks in London they will, then the rebalancing of the world's two largest economies is possible,' Bessent told lawmakers at the House Ways and Means Committee. The two sides agreed to reduce their tit-for-tat, triple-digit tariffs during talks in Geneva last month, but cracks appeared in the detente after Trump accused China of violating the deal. Washington was concerned at slower supplies of rare earths after Beijing in early April began requiring domestic exporters to apply for a licence – widely seen as a response to US tariffs. AdChoices ADVERTISING Rare earths are used in everything from electric vehicles to hard drives, wind turbines and missiles. US commerce secretary Howard Lutnick said in London on Tuesday that US measures imposed when rare earths 'were not coming' would likely be relaxed once Beijing moved forward with more license approvals. On Truth Social, Trump said China will supply 'full magnets, and any necessary rare earths' up front. Washington has infuriated Beijing by vowing to revoke the visas of Chinese students, a major source of revenue for US universities. Today, Trump said: 'We will provide to China what was agreed to, including Chinese students using our colleges and universities.' The US president also said that the US applies 55% tariffs on Chinese goods – a combination of his 30% additional levies this year and the rough average of pre-existing duties, a White House official said. He said Beijing charges 10% duties on US goods. The rates are the same as those that were previously agreed in the truce, which temporarily brought US tariffs down from 145% and those imposed by China from 125%. In a Chinese state media readout of the talks released today, vice-premier He Lifeng, who headed Beijing's team in London, stressed the need for the two sides to strengthen cooperation in future dialogue. 'As a next step, the two sides should… continuously enhance consensus, reduce misunderstandings and strengthen cooperation,' He said, according to state broadcaster CCTV. Speaking to reporters in London, China's international trade representative Li Chenggang earlier said: 'Our communication has been very professional, rational, in-depth and candid.'
Free Malaysia Today
7 hours ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Regretful Musk says some of his posts about Trump went ‘too far'
Elon Musk has deleted some social media posts critical of Donald Trump since their dispute began. (AFP pic) WASHINGTON : Billionaire Elon Musk said today he regrets some of the posts he made last week about US President Donald Trump as they went 'too far'. Trump and Musk began exchanging insults last week on social media, with the Tesla and SpaceX CEO describing the president's sweeping tax and spending bill as a 'disgusting abomination'. Trump said on Saturday their relationship was over but has since said that he would not have a problem if Musk called and wished him well. 'I regret some of my posts about President Donald Trump last week. They went too far,' Musk wrote in a post on his social media platform X. He did not say which specific posts he was talking about. Tesla shares in Frankfurt were up 2.44% after Musk's post. Since the dispute began, Musk has deleted some social media posts critical of Trump, including one signalling support for impeaching the president. Sources close to Musk had said his anger has started to subside, and that they believe he may want to repair his relationship with Trump.
