Trump wins rare court victory to use 1798 law in fast-tracking Venezuelan deportations
WASHINGTON, May 14 — A federal judge in Pennsylvania ruled on Tuesday that the United States can use the Alien Enemies Act to fast-track the deportation of accused Venezuelan gang members, in what appears to be the first court ruling that backs the Trump administration's interpretation of the 1798 law.
Judge Stephanie Haines, of the US District Court for the Western District of Pennsylvania, ruled that President Donald Trump has authority to declare the Venezuelan gang Tren de Aragua a foreign terrorist organisation and deport its members under the Alien Enemies Act, but she criticised the administration's practice of deporting people sometimes 'within a matter of hours.'
Haines, appointed by Trump during his first term, ruled that the administration must give potential deportees at least 21 days' notice and the opportunity to challenge their removals, to avoid the possibility that people who are not gang members 'may be errantly removed from this country.'
She made the ruling in court papers in the case of a Venezuelan man identified as A.S.R. Haines did not rule whether A.S.R. was a member of the gang, but she said people like him must be given more opportunity to challenge their deportations.
Haines required the government to provide notice in Spanish and English, and to provide interpreters when necessary.
Lee Gelernt, an attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union who is representing A.S.R., said he would appeal.
'We strongly disagree with the Court's decision to allow the government to continue using this wartime authority during peacetime, and will appeal that aspect of the decision,' Gelernt said.
Haines' ruling is contrary to other federal courts' decisions on the Trump administration's interpretation of the Alien Enemies Act, which the president invoked in March as legal justification for deporting hundreds of men whom his administration accused of being Tren de Aragua members.
Federal judges in New York, Colorado and Texas have ruled against Trump's use of the law to deport Venezuelans.
Haines, in her ruling, noted that her district has jurisdiction over the petition filed by A.S.R., even though he was transferred from an Immigration and Customs Enforcement facility in Philipsburg, Pennsylvania, on 15 April to an ICE detention centre in Texas, despite a temporary restraining order issued that day barring his transfer from the Western District of Pennsylvania.
The Trump administration has deported alleged gang members to a prison in El Salvador under an arrangement in which the United States is paying the Central American nation US$6 million. It is part of Trump's hardline approach toward immigration.
The White House did not immediately respond to requests for comment. — Reuters
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Free Malaysia Today
28 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
US sanctions Chinese, HK firms for aiding Iran's missile programme
The US noted that Iran continued to heavily rely on China for operations in the Middle East, particularly its oil and nuclear industries. (Reuters pic) WASHINGTON : The US on Wednesday unveiled fresh sanctions against six people and 12 firms – including several based in China and Hong Kong – for their support of Iran's ballistic missile programme. The action follows sanctions on a series of entities and individuals linked to Iran's oil industry and nuclear programme the Trump administration imposed in recent weeks. Wednesday's sanctions are aimed at organisations involved in 'efforts to help the Iranian regime domestically source the manufacturing of critical materials needed for Tehran's ballistic missile programme,' according to the US treasury department. 'The US cannot allow Iran to develop intercontinental ballistic missiles,' US treasury secretary Scott Bessent said in a statement. Tehran's attempts to produce missiles and components domestically 'represents an unacceptable threat to the US and the stability of the region,' he added. Those sanctioned include three Chinese nationals – Qin Jinhua, Qin Dehui, and Wang Chao – who work for a China-based firm which has exported carbon fiber precursor materials to a sanctioned Iranian firm, and another Hong Kong-based company. 'Iran remains heavily reliant on China to conduct its malign activities in the Middle East,' US state department spokesperson Tammy Bruce said in a statement. 'This is another example of how the CCP (Chinese Communist Party) and China-based companies provide key economic and technical support to Iran and its proxies,' she added. Wednesday's sanctions come a day after the US announced fresh sanctions on Iranian oil sales to China, as President Donald Trump's administration continues its 'maximum pressure' campaign against Tehran while backing ongoing nuclear talks. The sanctions follow similar designations in recent weeks, at the same time as Washington and Tehran have stepped up nuclear talks. The two sides held their fourth round of indirect talks over the weekend, which mark their highest-level contact since the US in 2018 pulled out of the 2015 nuclear deal.
Free Malaysia Today
29 minutes ago
- Free Malaysia Today
Trump says US personnel moved as Iran tensions mount
Donald Trump said he urged Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu to delay striking Iran but signalled growing impatience with stalled talks. (AP pic) WASHINGTON : President Donald Trump said US personnel were being moved from the potentially 'dangerous' Middle East on Wednesday as nuclear talks with Iran faltered and fears grew of a regional conflict. Trump also reiterated that he would not allow Iran to have a nuclear weapon, amid mounting speculation that Israel could strike Tehran's facilities. Iran threatened Wednesday to target US military bases in the region if conflict breaks out. A US official had earlier said that staff levels at the embassy in Iraq were being reduced over security concerns, while there were reports that personnel were also being moved from Kuwait and Bahrain. 'Well they are being moved out because it could be a dangerous place,' Trump told reporters in Washington when asked about the reports of personnel being moved. 'We've given notice to move out and we'll see what happens.' Trump then added: 'They can't have a nuclear weapon, very simple. We're not going to allow that.' Tehran and Washington have held five rounds of talks since April to thrash out a new nuclear deal to replace the 2015 accord that Trump abandoned during his first term in 2018. The two sides were due to meet again in coming days. Trump had until recently expressed optimism about the talks, but said in an interview published Wednesday that he was 'less confident' about reaching a nuclear deal. Since returning to office in January, Trump has revived his 'maximum pressure' campaign on Tehran, backing nuclear diplomacy but warning of military action if it fails. The US president says he has pressed Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to hold off striking Iran's nuclear facilities to give the talks a chance, but has increasingly signalled that he is losing patience. Iran however warned it would respond to any attack. 'All its bases are within our reach, we have access to them, and without hesitation we will target all of them in the host countries,' Iran's defence minister Aziz Nasirzadeh said in response to US threats of military action if the talks fail. 'Suffer more losses' 'God willing, things won't reach that point, and the talks will succeed,' the minister said, adding that the US side 'will suffer more losses' if it came to conflict. The US has multiple bases in the Middle East, with the largest located in Qatar. In January 2020, Iran fired missiles at bases in Iraq housing American troops in retaliation for the US strike that killed top Iranian general Qassem Soleimani days before at the Baghdad airport. Dozens of US soldiers suffered traumatic brain injuries. Amid the escalating tensions, the UK Maritime Trade Operations, run by the British navy, also advised ships to transit the Gulf with caution. Iran and the US have recently been locked in a diplomatic standoff over Iran's uranium enrichment, with Tehran defending it as a 'non-negotiable' right and Washington calling it a 'red line.' Iran currently enriches uranium to 60%, far above the 3.67% limit set in the 2015 deal and close though still short of the 90% needed for a nuclear warhead. Western countries have long accused Iran of seeking to acquire atomic weapons, while Tehran insists its nuclear program is for peaceful purposes. Last week, Iran's supreme leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei said enrichment is 'key' to Iran's nuclear program and that Washington 'cannot have a say' on the issue. During an interview with the New York Post's podcast 'Pod Force One,' which was recorded on Monday, Trump said he was losing hope a deal could be reached. 'I don't know. I did think so, and I'm getting more and more – less confident about it. They seem to be delaying and I think that's a shame. I am less confident now than I would have been a couple of months ago,' he said. Iran has said it will present a counter-proposal to the latest draft from Washington, which it had criticised for failing to offer relief from sanctions – a key demand for Tehran, which has been reeling under their weight for years.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Trump threatens ‘heavy force' as nationwide protests grow over immigration crackdown, LA troops hit 4,700
LOS ANGELES, June 12 — Protests against Donald Trump's harsh immigration policies spread yesterday across the United States despite a military-backed crackdown in Los Angeles and threats by the hard-right Republican president to use 'heavy force.' In Los Angeles, where the unrest began last Friday, an overnight curfew intended to keep people out of the downtown area was largely effective, with police arresting around 25 people who had refused to leave. Officers patrolled near government buildings, and storekeepers boarded up windows to protect against vandalism. But the area was quiet Wednesday. 'I would say for the most part everything is hunky dory right here at Ground Zero,' protester Lynn Sturgis, 66, a retired school teacher, told AFP. 'Our city is not at all on fire, it's not burning down, as our terrible leader is trying to tell you.' Around 1,000 troops from the 4,700 that Trump ordered to the city were actively guarding facilities and working alongside ICE agents, said Scott Sherman, Deputy Commanding General Army North, who is leading operations. The rest—including 700 active duty Marines—were mustering, or undergoing training in dealing with civil disturbances, he said. The Pentagon has said the deployment will cost taxpayers $134 million. The mostly peaceful protests ignited over a sudden escalation in efforts to apprehend migrants who were in the country illegally. Pockets of violence—including the burning of self-driving taxis and hurling stones at police—triggered a massive response from authorities using tear gas and other crowd-control weapons. Trump won the election last year partly on promises to combat what he claims is an 'invasion' by undocumented migrants. He is now seizing the opportunity to make political capital, ordering the California National Guard to deploy despite Governor Gavin Newsom's objections, the first time a US president has taken such action in decades. 'If our troops didn't go into Los Angeles, it would be burning to the ground right now,' Trump insisted on social media Wednesday. The White House doubled down on that rhetoric. 'President Trump will never allow mob rule to prevail in America,' White House Press Secretary Karoline Leavitt told a briefing. Governor Newsom, a Democrat, has charged that Trump is seeking to escalate the confrontation for political gain. 'Democracy is under assault right before our eyes,' he said in a televised address late Tuesday. 'California may be first, but it clearly won't end here.' Protesters hold signs during a protest against federal immigration operations at Pershing Square in downtown Los Angeles yesterday. — AFP pic Nationwide protests growing Despite Trump's threats to deploy the National Guard to other Democratic-run states over the objections of governors, protesters appear undeterred. Thousands marched in New York and Chicago late Tuesday. Republican Texas Governor Greg Abbott announced he was deploying the state's National Guard to counter a protest announced for San Antonio on Wednesday. Demonstrations were also planned Wednesday in New York, Seattle and Las Vegas ahead of what organizers say will be a nationwide 'No Kings' movement on Saturday, when Trump will attend a highly unusual military parade in the US capital. In a speech at an Army base on Tuesday, Trump warned that any protests during the Washington parade would face 'very heavy force.' The parade, featuring warplanes and tanks, has been organized to celebrate the 250th anniversary of the founding of the US Army but also happens to be the day of Trump's 79th birthday. The last large military parade in Washington was in 1991 after the first Gulf War. 'Inflamed' situation The Trump administration is painting the protests as a violent threat to the nation, requiring military force to support regular immigration agents and police. On Tuesday he cited a 'full-blown assault on peace, on public order and national sovereignty' from a 'foreign enemy.' Protesters and the beleaguered Democratic opposition party say Trump is manufacturing a crisis that has little to do with expelling criminals in the US illegally. Newsom said Trump 'inflamed' the situation and went 'well beyond his stated intent to just go after violent and serious criminals. His agents are arresting dishwashers, gardeners, day laborers and seamstresses.' Footage obtained by AFP on Wednesday shows what appears to be federal agents ramming a car in the Boyle Heights area of Los Angeles. Some kind of smoke device is deployed and masked men with assault weapons order a man from the car, leaving what witnesses said was his wife and two children badly shaken. — AFP
