Eruv with 12-mile route approved in Hale despite 900 objections
Plans to erect a series of poles to create a special area for Orthodox Jews have been approved by councillors despite hundreds of objections. The proposals for an eruv to be put in place around the village of Hale, Greater Manchester, on a Saturday were first put forwards a decade ago.An eruv is a symbolic boundary exempt from a Jewish rule that forbids the carrying or pushing of items outside Jewish homes on the Sabbath day.More than 900 local residents objected but Trafford's planning committee gave the plan the go-ahead.
The 52 street poles will each measure between 22ft and 26ft high and will appear at 26 individual sites.The area includes Hale Road and Grove Lane to the north; Shay Lane and Burnside to the east; Bankhall Lane and Rappax Road to the south and Ashley Road to the west.The poles will be placed either side of road junctions and connected by filament fibre cables.Members of the committee were told that the creation of an eruv did not require planning permission, only the physical infrastructure such as the poles and wires.Two of the sites are on green belt land and some are in local conservation areas, but councillors heard officers believed the application demonstrated "very special circumstances that overcome the harm by reason of inappropriateness". Six members of the public, split equally between those in favour and those against, addressed the committee.After a long debate, the committee voted in favour of approving the plans, with three councillors voting against.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas to northwest.newsonline@bbc.co.uk, external and via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mirror
12 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
'My kitchen feeds Jews with Muslims - Prince Harry's support has surprised me'
Salaam-Shalom Kitchen turns 10 years old this week, at a time when divisions between the two communities are under immense strain from events in the Middle East Ten years ago, Tanya Sakhnovich, a rabbi from Nottingham Liberal Synagogue and Saj Mohammed, CEO and founder of Himmah, a local Muslim-led social justice charity, sat down together to find a way to bring their communities together. With rising tensions in the city following a racist English Defence League march and an upswing locally in hate crime, the two faith leaders spoke about trying to do something 'meaningful' together to help people from all backgrounds who were struggling in Nottingham. "Tanya and Saj's vision was for the two communities – Muslim and Jewish – to come together to change the narrative, to show solidarity, community cohesion and to align to something that shows both faiths' values," explains Ferzana Shan, co-chair of the project. "Out of that came Salaam-Shalom Kitchen, from two greetings in Hebrew and Arabic." The Salaam-Shalom kitchen turns 10 years old this week, at a time when divisions between the two communities are under immense strain from events thousands of miles away in the Middle East. What began as a community meal for 30, has grown to a weekly dinner for around 100 people, and around 700 takeaway meals and 500 bags of groceries given out every month. But what's perhaps more remarkable, is that despite a national rise in antisemitism and Islamophobia linked to the war in Gaza and October 7 attacks, the project has kept going, dialogue has kept happening, and busy kitchen space is still shared by chefs and volunteers from both faiths. "The conflicts in Gaza and Israel have impacted us," says Ferzana, a mum-of-five, who works for a police force. "We have people on our steering group with families in Israel, we have pro-Palestine supporters and people who have anti-war beliefs. We had several conversations with each other where we discussed what we felt as individuals and what we needed from each other to carry on working together. We had to have those difficult conversations. We couldn't shy away, because people felt so different about things. But we came together, and we united on humanity. What we're doing here is what counts." Tensions closer to home including last summer's racist riots across England – which saw groups clash in Nottingham city centre – have also posed challenges to a project based on community cohesion. "We weren't affected by the riots last year, but we were very worried especially because of our faiths," Ferzana says. "The police were very good, and we closed early on the day of the protests in Nottingham." Now, on its tenth birthday, the charity's parent project, Himmah, has been recognised by Prince Harry, who made a 'significant donation' – four years after his wife Meghan gave £10,000 from the Royal Foundation. "To have been chosen by such a high-profile Royal once is amazing, but to have been supported by Prince Harry too left us completely gobsmacked,' says director Sajid, who added the charity feels 'hugely humbled'. Ferzana adds: 'We're delighted with the money from Prince Harry and Meghan Markle, it is incredible. The more money we have, the more we can give, but it also spotlights our great work.' Feeding people every Wednesday, Salaam-Shalom Kitchen is based in Hyson Green, the most deprived area in Nottingham and one of the most deprived in the country. The project has used premises at the United Reformed Church, the Nottingham Liberal Synagogue, and Himmah, one of the largest independent food banks in the city. "There is this kind of narrative in the world that we are two groups of people who are pitted against each other – that there is some reason why we don't get on," says co-chair Dr Karen Worth, a GP and University professor. "We wanted to show that isn't true. It's very powerful to reach out against perceived boundaries and perceived differences, because, actually, – in the words of Jo Cox – whenever we meet and talk we realise we have way more in common than that which divides us." With up to 120 guests for their weekly Wednesday night dinners, Salaam-Shalom is more than just a place to eat a hot meal. It provides takeaway food, a table with hot drinks and pastries, and groceries to take home – including fresh fruit and veg, loaves of bread and bouquets of flowers. Fareshare donates 80 kilograms of food and the rest comes from donations from local supermarkets – gathered, cooked and distributed by a network of 75 active volunteers. "While our primary function is to bring Jews and Muslims together, we are also bringing together all sorts of other people," Karen says. "Our guests also come together from different backgrounds – it shows people can get on really well. It's a beacon of hope for Jews and Muslims to see – and for the world to see – how we work together, but also a beacon of hope for those come here to be treated like human beings with love and compassion. "Obviously we all have our own feelings and upsets, but we have remained focused that difficulties elsewhere in the world should not affect our project. I'm very proud of what we do." To those attending tonight's meal, it's clear the food and community at Salaam-Shalom means so much. Tiffany Ramage, 27, comes with her four children, her partner and mum. "As a family we've been impacted heavily by the cost-of-living," she says. "I survive on Universal Credit but once we've paid the rent and bills, we're not left with much for food. My son has diabetes, so our budget has to cater for his dietary needs. The roof on our rented home leaks, so when it rains, we use a bucket. We've been on the council waiting list for months." Janet Winn, 66, is a mum and a carer to her disabled son, who became paralysed after an accident. "At first it was the social aspect, but now it helps a lot because I'm a carer for my adult son," she says. "Since his accident, I've been juggling things." It's in the kitchen where the people from the two communities work together to produce delicious, healthy meals, there is no time, or desire, for division. Volunteers at the project include a 90-year-old retired medical consultant, Dr Abdur Raoof, who is a grandfather of 12, and chops vegetables every week in the kitchen. "I just knew I wanted to be involved in this project, I have been here since it started. It is important to put my human values before anything else. The Quran talks about the importance of looking after our neighbours." Grandmother Nicola Barber, 44, is the operational manager, while her son Tristan Noble, 27, is a says the service is "a lifeline" to many families. 'You don't need a referral to come here, we don't ask questions, people can just come in for a hot meal and they can take home a packed meal and some groceries. For some this is their only hot meal of the week." One of the other volunteers tells us she grew up in the Middle East. "I grew up in a country where there was war and conflict," she says. "I grew up hearing air sirens. I was just two when my mother hid with us in shelters. I was traumatised. So, when I moved to this country in 2000, I wanted to get involved with a project that represented peace. "Here we are all about unity and creating friendships – we are one big family."
Spectator
3 days ago
- Spectator
Spinoza, Epicurus and the question of ‘epikoros'
With surprise, I heard from a Jewish friend that a Hebrew term for a heretic is epikoros, apparently derived from the Greek philosopher Epicurus (341-270 bc). The word cropped up recently in a row over a film on the life of Baruch Spinoza, showing that he is not forgiven more than 360 years after his expulsion from the Sephardic community in Amsterdam. An American professor of philosophy, Yitzhak Melamed, asked the Portuguese Jewish synagogue there for permission to film some footage. The rabbi pointed out that Spinoza had been excommunicated 'with the severest possible ban, a ban that remains in force for all time'. So, no he could not visit the synagogue. The rabbi's letter called Spinoza an epikouris, a form of the word used of him in the 17th century. The reason for Spinoza's excommunication (herem in Hebrew) is unknown. Spinoza did write difficult stuff later about all things being God, but not when he was cast out in 1656, aged 23. Anyway, 12th-century Jewish philosopher Moses Maimonides discussed the nature of an epikoros as someone who denies God's providence. That is what Spinoza was to deny, as far as I can understand him, and what Epicurus had denied. To add a complication. Maimonides said in an early work that epikoros came from Aramaic, and others have since derived it from the p-q-r Semitic root, signifying 'licentiousness'. By the time he wrote Guide for the Perplexed, Maimonides had learnt about Epicurus's philosophy. Do, then, epikoros and a modern form, apikoros, come from the Greek philosopher, or was his fame projected on to an extant Semitic word? Professor Melamed eventually received a letter from the Ma'amad (churchwardens) of the synagogue saying the rabbi had exceeded his authority and he was welcome to visit.
BBC News
3 days ago
- BBC News
Writers including Zadie Smith sign open letter calling for Gaza ceasefire
Writers including Zadie Smith, Ian McEwan and Russell T Davies have put their names to an open letter - signed by 380 authors and organisations - calling for an immediate ceasefire in letter, also signed by Jeanette Winterson, Irvine Welsh, Kate Mosse and Elif Shafak, describes Israel's military campaign in the territory as "genocidal".The writers urge people to join them in "ending our collective silence and inaction in the face of horror".Israel says it is working to destroy the Palestinian armed group Hamas and get back hostages the group has taken. It has strongly denied allegations of genocide, claims which are also being examined by the International Court of Justice. Israel launched a military campaign in Gaza in response Hamas' cross-border attack on 7 October 2023, in which about 1,200 people were killed and 251 others were taken least 54,056 people have been killed in Gaza since then, including 3,901 over the past 10 weeks, according to the territory's Hamas-run health a million people face starvation in the coming months, according to an assessment by the UN-backed Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC).Responding to the accusation of genocide made by rights group Amnesty International in December, Israel's foreign ministry described the group's 295-page report as "entirely false and based on lies", while the Israeli military said the claims were "entirely baseless and fail to account for the operational realities" it authors' letter is entitled Writers Demand Immediate Gaza Ceasefire and organised by writers Horatio Clare, Kapka Kassabova and Monique notes that Amnesty and Human Rights Watch, as well as independent experts appointed by the United Nations human rights council, have, it says, "clearly identified genocide or acts of genocide in Gaza, enacted by the Israel Defence Force and directed by the government of Israel".The authors call for the distribution of food and medical aid in Gaza by the UN, and a ceasefire "which guarantees safety and justice for all Palestinians, the release of all Israeli hostages, and the release of the thousands of Palestinian prisoners arbitrarily held in Israeli jails".Sanctions should be imposed, the letter argues, if the Israeli government does not take taking this stand, the authors also used the letter to "assert without reservation our absolute opposition to and loathing of antisemitism, of anti-Jewish and anti-Israeli prejudice". The letter continued: "We reject and abhor attacks, hate and violence – in writing, speech and action – against Palestinian, Israeli, and Jewish people in all and any form. We stand in solidarity with the resistance of Palestinian, Jewish, and Israeli people to the genocidal policies of the current Israeli government." The authors' letter begins by quoting the poem A Star Said Yesterday by the Palestinian poet Hiba Abu Nada, who was killed by an Israeli airstrike in goes on to say that Palestinians "are not the abstract victims of an abstract war". It continues: "Too often, words have been used to justify the unjustifiable, deny the undeniable, defend the indefensible. Too often, too, the right words - the ones that mattered - have been eradicated, along with those who might have written them."The term genocide "is not a slogan", it states. "It carries legal, political, and moral responsibilities."The 1948 Genocide Convention, enacted following the mass murder of Jews in the Nazi Holocaust, defines genocide as "acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group".In their letter, the authors emphasised their "absolute opposition to and loathing of antisemitism, of anti-Jewish and anti-Israeli prejudice".The letter continued: "We reject and abhor attacks, hate and violence – in writing, speech and action – against Palestinian, Israeli, and Jewish people in all and any form. We stand in solidarity with the resistance of Palestinian, Jewish, and Israeli people to the genocidal policies of the current Israeli government."
