Israel's 'Qatargate' scandal deepens with arrest of Netanyahu aides
Israeli police arrested two close advisers of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Monday, as the so-called 'Qatargate' scandal deepened in Israel.
Jonathan Urich, Netanyahu's senior media advisor, and Eli Feldstein, his military spokesperson, were arrested as part of an investigation into ties between the Israeli prime minister's office and Qatari officials.
The two officials were arrested on suspicion of contact with a foreign agent, money laundering, accepting bribes, fraud, and breach of trust.
Netanyahu, who was in court on Monday testifying in his own corruption and fraud cases, was forced to leave the courtroom to testify in the affair involving his confidants.
In addition to Netanyahu, a journalist, whose name cannot currently be published, was summoned for questioning on suspicion of involvement in the affair. According to Haaretz, the police will soon summon other journalists accused of being involved.
New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch
Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters
As of today, the investigation is under a gag order, so many details have not yet been disclosed. But according to reports in Israel, Urich, Feldstein and other suspects are alleged to have sent messages to journalists on behalf of the Qatari government. The messages allegedly looked as though they were sent on behalf of the Israeli prime minister's office.
Eran Etzion, a former deputy head of the National Security Council, told Middle East Eye that it was still too early to determine the severity of the affair, but 'to the extent that Urich and Feldstein worked in the prime minister's office and for officials in Qatar, they have been exposed to classified material'.
'At the highest legal level, it could be the use of double agents in the prime minister's office, which would be defined as harm to state security and treason,' two of the most serious accusations in Israel.
'Qatargate'
The affair, dubbed 'Qatargate' by the Israeli media, was first exposed by Haaretz in November.
According to the Israeli newspaper, Urich, Netanyahu's longtime adviser, and Srulik Einhorn, another adviser to the prime minister, were employed by Qatar ahead of the 2022 World Cup, which the Gulf state hosted.
The two, through Perception, their media consulting firm, allegedly provided services to whitewash Qatar's reputation and brand it as a country that aspires to achieve 'peace and stability in the world'.
In addition, they worked to promote the country's public relations in Israel by inviting Israeli journalists to Qatar.
'For a long time, Netanyahu has been waging an all-out war against the law enforcement system'
- Eran Etzion, former deputy head of Israel's National Security Council
In February, Channel 12 News revealed that Netanyahu's military spokesman, Feldstein, was also involved in the affair.
According to the report, Feldstein was employed by a private company funded by Qatar to improve its image in Israel vis a vis its role in the negotiations between Israel and Hamas, which Qatar is mediating.
Feldstein has also been arrested in the past on suspicion of delivering classified documents relating to Hamas to the Jewish Chronicle, a British newspaper, and Bild, the German newspaper.
These briefings were intended to boost Netanyahu's image and were aimed at influencing Israeli public opinion in relation to his handling of the release of hostages held by Hamas in Gaza.
It later turned out that the reports published by Bild and the Jewish Chronicle were false. The Jewish Chronicle was forced as a result to remove a series of articles from its website, sparking a row that led to the resignation of four of its most prominent columnists and to questions being asked about the involvement of Robbie Gibb, a non-executive director at the BBC.
Last month, Channel 13 revealed that as part of Feldstein's work for Qatar during the war on Gaza, he organised a visit to Qatar by Zvika Klein, the editor-in-chief of the right-wing Jerusalem Post newspaper.
Feldstein, who was not paid by the Israeli prime minister's office while working there, was reportedly employed by Jay Footlik, an American lobbyist who works for the Qatari government.
Netanyahu against the Shin Bet
Following the many press reports on this, attorney general Gali Baharav-Miara ordered the opening of a criminal investigation at the end of last month, following a 'security check' conducted by the Shin Bet, Israel's internal security agency.
Regarding Netanyahu, Etzion said, 'If he knew about the employment of his aides by Qatar, then he is in [a] bad situation, and if he didn't, then his situation is no less serious.'
'Netanyahu has his back to the wall. He is desperate, dangerous and unrestrained'
- Eran Etzion
'For a long time, Netanyahu has been waging an all-out war against the law enforcement system. Now, law enforcement agencies are weakened,' Etzion said. 'If in the past such accusations would have led to the prime minister's resignation, today this is not the case.'
'It is difficult to estimate the extent to which the law enforcement agencies will succeed or make the effort to render Netanyahu's tenure as prime minister untenable.'
Netanyahu has categorically rejected the accusations against his advisers. A statement issued by his party, Likud, called the investigation "a new low in the political hunt to bring down a right-wing prime minister and to prevent the dismissal of the failed head of the Shin Bet".
"This is not an investigation, this is not law enforcement. This is an attempt to assassinate democracy and an attempt to replace the will of the people with the rule of the bureaucrats," the Likud statement continued.
Earlier this month, Netanyahu announced his intention to fire Shin Bet chief Ronen Bar, in what is perceived in Israel as an attempt to thwart the intelligence agency's further investigation into the affair.
The dismissal of the head of the Shin Bet was frozen by the Supreme Court pending a hearing at the beginning of next month.
Since the 'Qatargate' affair came to light, Netanyahu has been promoting messages like those of his close ally, US President Donald Trump, about how the "Deep State" is involved in running the country.
In a recent TikTok video, Netanyahu said that the "leftist" Deep State wants "me and the government to be a flower pot".
Gaza genocide: How the hell did this happen, asks Pankaj Mishra Read More »
Yesterday, Netanyahu released a video in which he said that he was "amazed, I mean, I understood that there was a political investigation here, but I didn't know to what extent. They are holding Jonathan Urich and Eli Feldstein hostage".
Netanyahu's response has drawn criticism in Israel, including from families of those held captive by Hamas, considering his use of the word "hostage" in reference to his advisers.
"Netanyahu does not have the absolute support of all the members of the coalition in this affair," Etzion told MEE. Avi Dichter, agriculture minister and former head of the Shin Bet, said the scandal is serious and needs to be investigated.
"Netanyahu has his back to the wall," Etzion said. "He is desperate, dangerous and unrestrained. His entire system of considerations is based on this."
Netanyahu will not hesitate to 'carry out military moves in order to remove the affair from the public agenda', Etzion told MEE.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
an hour ago
- The National
Scarcity of currency adds to misery of war and hunger in Gaza
A shortage of currency in Gaza is pushing thousands of families deeper into poverty, as traders increasingly demand payment in cash and residents are forced to pay high fees to black market operators to convert funds in online accounts into banknotes. Bank branches in the territory are no longer functioning after more than 20 months of war between Hamas and Israel military that has devastated the Palestinian territory and displaced most of its population. Essential goods such as food and medicine are scarce after nearly two months of an Israeli blockade on humanitarian aid, pushing prices beyond the reach of most residents even when they are available. 'For the past two months, cash has all but disappeared,' Mohammed Al Haddad, 39, a resident of Gaza city, told The National. 'If I want to get 1,000 shekels ($287) in cash, I have to transfer 1,800 shekels. That's nearly half my money gone before I even buy food.' Mr Al Haddad, as a government employee, still receives a salary from the Palestinian Authority in the occupied West Bank, even though Hamas has run Gaza since it seized control of the territory in 2007. Mr Al Haddad is paid through online bank transfer, but cannot pay for goods digitally because banks in Gaza suspended a widely used payment app after several hacking attempts. In any case, most shops no longer accept such payments. He believes the aid blockade and shortage of currency – the Israeli shekel is used in both Gaza and West Bank – is part of Israel's war strategy. 'It's as if the occupation wants to create a new crisis, an economic collapse driven by cash shortages and rising hunger,' he said. Murid Al Mabhouh, 30, who was displaced from his home in Jabalia Camp to Gaza city, said the situation was 'suffocating'. 'We're under siege, under bombardment, living through famine, and we have to pay 40 per cent just to withdraw the little money we have.' Mr Al Mabhouh said people had no choice but to pay the high commissions charged by black market currency traders. 'There are no functioning banks, no official oversight, and the authorities are silent. It's not just exploitation, it's injustice on top of injustice,' he said. 'The money we're trying to access is for food, medicine, and paying off debts. Now we lose nearly half of it to commission traders getting rich off our suffering.' Mr Al Haddad said videos posted on social media showed that traders were able to import some goods in recent days, but 'it's all non-essential – instant noodles, snacks, breadcrumbs'. 'And everything is cash only, at outrageous prices,' he said. Amid the outcry, Gaza's Chamber of Commerce has accused some traders in Gaza of working with suspicious actors to obtain Israeli permits to import non-essential goods. 'These permits are being sold for hundreds of thousands of shekels for a single truckload of items that people don't even need,' said Aed Abu Ramadan, director of the Chambers of Commerce, Industry, and Agriculture in Gaza, told The National. 'This is unacceptable. It violates both commercial and national ethics.' He said that such practices are draining the last of the population's cash, pushing families to the brink while enriching a handful of traders. 'We've urged merchants not to engage in these deals. They drive prices up, increase suffering, destabilise the market, and destroy any hope for fair competition.' Mr Abu Ramadan called for immediate oversight by Gaza's authorities and co-operation with official agencies to prevent further economic manipulation. 'People are already crushed. We must not let profiteering deepen this humanitarian catastrophe.' With inflation spiralling, cash inaccessible, and markets flooded with overpriced, non-essential items, Gaza's families are left with shrinking options. As financial lifelines disappear, aid dependency increases, and with it, fears of long-term economic and political manipulation. 'This isn't just about money,' Mr Al Haddad said. 'It's about dignity. About whether we'll ever live normal lives again, or just survive, one overpriced bag of rice at a time.'
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
Three Palestinians killed in Israeli attack on tent in Khan Younis
Wafa news agency is reporting that three Palestinians have been killed in an Israeli attack on a tent housing displaced people in the Mawasi area of Khan Younis, in southern Gaza.
Middle East Eye
an hour ago
- Middle East Eye
US is not committed to a Palestinian state, Muslim neighbours could give land, US ambassador says
A Palestinian state in the occupied West Bank is no longer a US policy goal, but Israel's 'Muslim neighbours' could give up their land to create one, US Ambassador to Israel Mike Huckabee told Bloomberg news on Tuesday. 'Unless there are some significant things that happen that change the culture, there's no room for it,' Huckabee, an appointee of US President Donald Trump and longtime advocate of settlement expansion in the occupied West Bank said when asked about a Palestinian state. He added those steps probably won't occur 'in our lifetime,' he added. Pressed on the topic, Huckabee repeated an explosive claim floated by some Israeli officials, that neighbouring Muslim countries could give their land to the Palestinians to create a state. 'Where is it gonna be? Does it have to be in Judea and Samaria?' Huckabee asked. 'Does it need to be somewhere different? New MEE newsletter: Jerusalem Dispatch Sign up to get the latest insights and analysis on Israel-Palestine, alongside Turkey Unpacked and other MEE newsletters Huckabee did not rule out taking land from Saudi Arabia to create a Palestinian state, saying 'every option should be on the table,' when pressed. 'Muslim controlled countries have six hundred and forty-four times the amount of land Israel does. When people say Israel needs to give up something you kind of scratch your head and say let me see if I get this right…'why should these people [Israelis] give way when these people [muslim countries] have a lot of room that they could say 'we'll carve out something'.' Huckabee's comments are likely to irk Egypt and Jordan. Their leaders fear that Israel wants to forcibly displace Palestinians from Gaza and the occupied West Bank onto their land. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated in May that carrying out a plan US President Donald Trump introduced earlier this year to forcibly displace Palestinians from Gaza and turn it into a 'Middle East Riviera' was now a condition for ending Israel's war on Gaza. Displacing Palestinians Huckabee's refusal to rule out carving out a Palestinians state in Saudi Arabia is likely to inflame tensions. Netanyahu suggested in February that Palestinians should establish a state in Saudi Arabia, rather than in their homeland, in his latest dismissal of Palestinians' right to self-determination. His comments drew a sharp rebuke from Riyadh. In his first term, Trump floated a Middle East peace plan dubbed the Deal of the century that called for a de facto rump Palestinian state without full sovereignty. But at the very least, that plan focused on fashioning a pseudo-state in the occupied West Bank. Huckabee's comments are more hardline because he refuses to rule out displacing Palestinians in full. Since the 1950's, successive American administration have stated that their ultimate goal to end the Palestinian-Israeli conflict is a two-state solution. Many experts and diplomats have earmarked occupied East Jerusalem, the occupied West Bank and Gaza, which Israel seized from Egypt and Jordan in the 1967 war as the heartland of a future Palestinian state. Huckabee is a prominent leader in the pro-Israel evangelical Christian movement, who has repeatedly denied the Palestinian national identity. Huckabee advocated for the forcible displacement of Palestinians during the early days of Israel's war on Gaza. 'If the so-called Palestinians are so loved by the Muslim nations of the world, why wont any of those nations at least offer to give temporary refuge to their brothers and sisters in Gaza,' he said in October 2023. He has been an outspoken advocate for Israel's annexation of the occupied West Bank and Gaza Strip. 'I think Israel has title deed to Judea and Samaria,' he told Politico in 2017, using the Hebrew language terms for the occupied West Bank. 'There are certain words I refuse to use. There is no such thing as a West Bank. It's Judea and Samaria. There's no such thing as a settlement. They're communities, they're neighborhoods, they're cities. There's no such thing as an occupation,' he said at the time.
