HC questions BMC nod for construction on Goregaon wetland
MUMBAI: The Bombay high court (HC) on Thursday issued notices to the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC), the Maharashtra Coastal Zone Management Authority (MCZMA), and the Konkan Wetland Committee over alleged illegal permission for development on a recognised wetland in Goregaon West.
A division bench comprising chief justice Alok Aradhe and justice Makarand Karnik was hearing a public interest litigation (PIL) filed by environmental activist Zoru Bhathena. The PIL challenges the BMC's 2023 approval granted to private developers for landfilling and construction on a 191.39-hectare plot in the Pahadi area, which, according to the petitioner, has been identified as a wetland since 1991 by the MCZMA.
Wetlands are identified based on ecological significance, such as supporting migratory birds, maintaining biodiversity, or providing ecosystem services like flood mitigation.
Bhathena said the site falls under CRZ-1 (Coastal Regulation Zone), as per the Wetland Atlas prepared by the MCZMA. He alleged that developers—Beeline Impex Pvt. Ltd and Pearl CosChem Pvt. Ltd—applied in 2022 to build a compound wall and carry out landfilling work. This request was approved by the BMC the following year.
The petition further claims that 39,601 square metres of landfilling was already carried out around the edge of the plot, which borders mangroves. Satellite imagery used to demarcate the high tide line confirms the area is low-lying and influenced by tidal water, Bhathena said.
He accused the developers of manipulating the site conditions to deceive satellite monitoring systems by blocking the natural flow of tidal water. Bhathena emphasised that, as per previous court rulings, no reclamation or development is allowed on areas listed in the wetland atlas without court permission.
The PIL also states that in May 2023, the BMC altered the development plan for the same plot while allocating it for Maharashtra National Law University. The land's designation was changed to 'residential use' without altering its CRZ-1 classification.
Calling the BMC's actions illegal, Bhathena has urged the court to order restoration of the wetland and to issue a permanent stay on any further development.
The court has now asked the BMC, MCZMA, and the Konkan Wetland Committee to file their responses.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
BMC imposes Rs 8 lakh fine on engrs, contractors for piling up debris
1 2 3 4 5 Bhubaneswar: When it comes to disposal of construction and demolition waste, it looks like a govt department has been frequently penalised by the Bhubaneswar Municipal Corporation (BMC) for allowing debris to pile up at work sites. BMC officials said the works department and contractors who had taken up projects on its behalf were penalised to the tune of Rs 8 lakh this month for piling up debris during construction and repair of govt quarters and buildings "Executive engineers of division-2 and division-4 of the works department under Bhubaneswar circle were fined Rs 2 lakh each for piling up construction and demolition (C&D) waste. A construction company was fined Rs 3 lakh, and two contractors Rs 50,000 each," said BMC assistant commissioner N Ganesh Babu. According to BMC rules, waste generated through construction, repair, transportation, remodelling and demolition of private and govt establishments, households, roads and drains should be handled properly to avoid piling up on roads. He said the enforcement squads spotted the debris stacked for days on the roadside, thus encroaching on public spaces and causing inconvenience to pedestrians and motorists. The piled-up waste is an eyesore and can choke drains during monsoon. "In view of monsoon, the squads have intensified enforcement activities," Babu added. Dhyanchand Naik, chief engineer (roads) of the works department, said he would look into the matter and issue necessary directions to the divisions concerned to clear C&D waste. "I will look into what construction and repair works had created debris and the fine imposed," he told TOI. Last year, BMC issued a notice to educate people on how to handle C&D waste. "There are a lot of stakeholders as far as C&D waste litter and disposal are concerned. Through the notice, we conveyed to people that if they don't follow the norms of handling C&D waste, they will have to pay a penalty. Yet, we see both private and govt agencies keeping debris on roads," a BMC official said. BMC officials said they have provision for designated spaces for dumping such waste. "We have also given a toll-free number (1929), which can be used by owners of C&D waste to ask for BMC vehicles to clear the waste. For the removal, a certain amount will have to be paid. If they don't use BMC resources and take C&D waste to the designated station on their own, they won't have to pay anything," an official said. In another development, the civic body said payments will be withheld for city-based contractors unless they show certificates of clearance of C&D waste from work sites. "City engineers have been asked to write to the contractors to abide by C&D disposal rules; otherwise, their payments will be held back," a BMC sanitation official said.
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
‘Save Powai Lake' human chain plan off over BMC fee
Mumbai: A silent "Save Powai Lake" human chain scheduled for Sunday by local residents and nature lovers was cancelled after the BMC demanded a nominal "event fee" of Rs 11,000 to organise it at the lakeside. Green activists alleged they tried in vain to explain to civic officials that this was not an event but a public expression of concern to save the lake from pollution and floating weeds such as hyacinths. The human chain was planned for Sunday, June 8, to focus on the need to conserve Powai Lake as part of Mumbai region's biodiversity, said the activists. "For about a week the BMC was making us go round in circles for a simple no-objection certificate for the human chain after we obtained the police nod," said Pamela Cheema, chairperson of the advanced locality management committee (ALMC). Police suggested that the organisers seek the BMC's approval as well. Cheema said, "Despite the police forwarding them our request and we ourselves presenting the BMC's S ward office our request, the officials were searching for the documents till Friday." The BMC insisted on payment of "a nominal fee of Rs 11,000" for using the Powai Lake premises, she said. BMC's sub-engineer from S ward, Veer Alankar, said he sent the circular and the fee payable to Cheema since it is an event. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Giao dịch CFD với công nghệ và tốc độ tốt hơn IC Markets Đăng ký Undo "We are not holding a concert or any cultural event," Cheema said. Calling the BMC event fee for the human chain as unprecedented, NatConnect director B N Kumar said, "It amounts to scuttling the democratic rights of environmentalists to freedom of speech. The Constitution of India guarantees the right to a clean environment." Kumar further said they will regroup and discuss the future course to save the lake. In the past two weeks, though, following the local citizens' appeal to save the lake, the BMC has started mechanically removing the water hyacinths from the lake's surface. The process is still on at the lake site by using machines to cut and remove the hyacinths. Local resident and photographer Mukesh Trivedi said, "Perhaps the senior civic officials could have waived off the 'event fee' because none of us were going to form the human chain for any commercial gain." "As much as we have passionately worked towards this cause, we are being forced to not go ahead with it due to bureaucratic hurdles," said Milan Bhat, one of the organisers. "It has been a sad day for our environment, but we haven't lost hope. We will come back stronger," she said.
Time of India
a day ago
- Time of India
BMC to mark high and low tide lines for Ganeshotsav
Mumbai: The BMC will identify and mark low tide lines (LTL) and high tide lines (HTL) and install marine navigation buoys along with mooring at low tide lines at 43 Ganesh idol immersion sites in Mumbai. The BMC is carrying out the action to adhere to guidelines for Ganesh idol immersion issued by the CPCB, which mandates that idol immersions in the sea be done between LTL and HTL. Similarly, the civic body is also inviting expressions of interest for the shortlisting of manufacturers, authorised dealers, suppliers, and distributors of eco-friendly water-based, biodegradable, and non-toxic natural dyes for idols. The list of shortlisted suppliers of natural dyes for idols will be put in the public domain for the benefit of idol makers. Naresh Dahibavkar, president of Brihanmumbai Sarvajanik Ganeshotsav Samanvay Samiti, said, "We normally appeal to the Ganpati mandals to immerse idols during low tide as they can go farther into the sea. During high tide, some remains of the idols or parts used as a base for the idols are washed ashore."
