Tánaiste says Israel is committing genocide during bad-tempered Dáil spat with Catherine Connolly
The Journal
/ YouTube
TÁNAISTE SIMON HARRIS has told the Dáil that the Israeli government is committing genocide in Gaza during a heated exchange with independent TD Catherine Connolly this afternoon.
Last week, Harris had said that recent comments from the Israeli government
mean 'we are now very much in the space of genocidal activity'
– but today's comments are the first time that he has explicitly described Israel's actions as genocide.
The comment comes just one day after Taoiseach Micheál Martin also
told the Dáil that the Israeli government is committing genocide in Gaza
.
Speaking during Leaders' Questions, Galway TD Catherine Connolly took aim at what she described as 'cognitive dissonance' by the government in regards to Israel.
She said that it was time to 'make our words mean something'.
Catherine Connolly speaking during Leaders' Questions.
Oireachtas TV
Oireachtas TV
'We need to call out the narrative for what it is – and the narrative is that Israel is a rogue state, it is not a democratic state.'
Harris reiterated his call for a two-state solution, and noted a distinction between 'the Israeli government and the Israeli people'.
'I believe there's many people in Israel who would be utterly horrified at the decisions being taken by the Netanyahu government, which are genocidal, which are war crimes, which are starving children, which is in breach of international law,' Harris told TDs in attendance.
Yesterday, four Palestinians died when a UN warehouse storing food was stormed, as the food crisis in Gaza worsens.
Israeli attacks on Gaza have killed at least 55 people so far today, including 23 killed in an intense wave of strikes on central Gaza's Bureij refugee camps.
'Load of palaver'
Connolly slammed what she described as government inaction on the issue, adding: 'You're waiting for morally corrupt EU take action'.
'They're the second-biggest supplier of arms to the genocide. Let's call a spade a spade.'
She told Harris that while he 'had no issue' criticising Russia, the same criticism was not thrown at Israel.
Connolly also criticised the visit of US Congressman Brian Mast to Kerry last week. The Florida Republican is known for his controversial views on Palestinians – he previously called for Israel to enter Gaza and 'kick the shit out of them', referring to Palestinians.
Connolly slammed the visit, as she said the US politician was 'fêted' by Harris' Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil colleagues.
'Stand up and account for what we're going to do when you say that there are war crimes and genocide,' Connolly said, while Harris shook his head.
Advertisement
Harris slammed the criticism from Connolly as a load of palaver.
Oireachtas TV
Oireachtas TV
Snapping back at Connolly's criticism as 'a load of palaver', Harris said that she 'has such vitriol' against the government parties that 'you cannot ever rise above and rise to the moment'.
'We are the first government in the European Union to say that what Israel is doing is genocide,' Harris said.
'Then what are you going to do about it?' Connolly shouted back.
Visibly irritated, Harris replied: 'We're going to pass the Occupied Territories Bill', reiterating several times that 'We're going to pass that!'
'While you're standing there just throwing brickmats at me, we're working to support the people of Palestine.
Get beyond yourself with this narrative of 'you have all the moral authority, and we're terrible people'.
'The only chamber that I ever go into in the entire world that people acknowledge that the government of Ireland are standing with the people of Palestine, standing up for human rights, standing up for international law, is here, when you get up and distort with your ideology, the actions of this government,' Harris added.
'Slander'
Separately, President Michael D Higgins also described a 'slander' and 'propaganda' campaign against Ireland by Israel, which he said has labelled individuals 'antisemitic' for criticising the Netanyahu cabinet.
Higgins, who has been a vocal critic of Israel's actions in Gaza as its military continues its offensive in the country, he has condemned the country's aid blockade on the territory and its bombardments of the population.
Israel has issued pointed criticism against Ireland and other European governments who have been vocally opposed to its actions – oftentimes labelling them as antisemitic.
Speaking today, the president claimed he and other individuals who have criticised Israel have been subjected to a 'propaganda campaign in Ireland'.
He said the campaign is 'active' in the US, leading to questions among politicians and businesses on whether to continue relations with Ireland. He said it 'breaks my heart' that countries are still holding back on calls for a ceasefire.
He denounced suggestions that criticism of the Israeli government is antisemitic. He also condemned the practices of the Israeli-backed aid programme in Gaza,
which has led to deadly stampedes in recent days
.
One person died and dozens more were injured after the Israeli military opened fire at one of the centres in Rafah on Tuesday. An aid worker
told
The Journal
yesterday that the programme was 'humiliating and insulting' to people in Gaza
.
'The boxes that they're distributing [...] they're branded products, being credited for the future private sector of retail. You can just look at the wrappings,' President Higgins said.
'Imagine getting a starving person something wrapped in your own brand so that you will have opportunities in the future?'
He continued with his condemnation of Israel's claims that Ireland is antisemitic. The President said the Irish public are some of the 'best-informed people' on the actions of Israel.
He said this was as a result of the soldiers from the Defence Forces who have attended peacekeeping missions in Lebanon, where Israel clashes with Hezbollah militants.
'We are among the best-informed people, thanks to all those families who sent their soldiers – daughters and sons – on peacekeeping to the Lebanon,' he said.
'And I salute them because when they come back, they tell the truth of what was their experience.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
27 minutes ago
- RTÉ News
At least 20 reported killed near Gaza aid distribution point
Gaza's civil defence agency has said that Israeli troops have killed at least 20 people in the south of the Palestinian territory. The Israeli military said it fired shots at individuals about half a kilometre from the aid distribution site of US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Fund in Gaza in the Rafah area. It said the individuals were moving towards forces in a way that "posed a threat to them".
Irish Independent
5 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Letters: Ireland should make most of its intellectual capital and stop driving talent abroad
Its 2025 Global Tech Talent Guidebook reports that 52.4pc of Ireland's adults hold tertiary qualifications, making it Europe's densest pool of intellectual capital. This success reflects both the excellence of Ireland's universities – six of which are now globally ranked – and represents a vital resource for economic growth. However, for too long, Irish graduates have driven innovation abroad, enriching foreign economies while Ireland stands by. With bold investment in housing, infrastructure, and turning research into business, Ireland could reverse this brain drain and become the Singapore of the Atlantic. The groundwork is set; what remains is vision and action. Ireland can overtake the Netherlands and Sweden as the EU's top per capita destination for foreign direct investment in AI and biotech, but the opportunity is time-sensitive. This will require pairing educational excellence with clear strategy – turning talent into a lasting competitive edge. Enda Cullen, Tullysaran Road, Armagh Tapping the Atlantic to feed more data centres not the fix Barry Cowen thinks it is Fianna Fáil MEP Barry Cowen says data centres are 'currently accounting for around one-fifth of national (electricity) usage and projected to reach 31pc by 2030' ('Claim we must choose between data centres and housing is a distraction from the real challenge', Irish Independent, June 2). In 2022, data centres in the EU used an estimated 45-65 TWh of electricity (1.8–2.6pc of total EU electricity use). Data centres provide very little employment apart from the construction phase. They provide critical information to keep the world's economy running smoothly when they are commissioned, though. Why should Ireland be a soft touch in the EU for committing so much of our scarce energy resources to house servers for the AI and crypto revolution that are in turn destroying jobs everywhere? Try again, Mr Cowen. If your party can't even build sufficient houses for our young people, there is even less of a chance of you tapping the Atlantic to further our burgeoning demand for electricity. Tom McElligott, Listowel, Co Kerry World must act now to end the carnage inflicted on Palestinians by Benjamin Netanyahu It is way past time for the whole world to stop beating around the bush and wake up to the true horrors in Gaza. The misuse of the word antisemitic is making a lot of us ill. To be repulsed and outraged by mass civilian death is to be humanitarian. It has nothing to do with religion or political affiliation. Benjamin Netanyahu is responsible for the deaths of women and children every day. It is pure genocide. We know Hamas must be condemned for drawing down fire and killing their own people. But what Israel is now doing is inexcusable and must stop. Surely all Israelis have a responsibility to rid us of Netanyahu and end the carnage? Michael Twohig, Ballinasloe, Co Galway Words will not feed tens of thousands of children in Gaza who face starvation It's now estimated that nearly 71,000 Palestinian children under the age of five are expected to be 'acutely malnourished', with 14,100 cases expected to be severe in the next 11 months. The UN and other humanitarian organisations have rejected the new system for food distribution into Gaza, saying it would not be able to meet the needs of Gaza's people. The fear is that this new system allows Israel to use food as a weapon to control the population. At this stage, Palestinians need deeds, not words. John O'Brien, Clonmel, Co Tipperary Leinster players at risk of burning out before next season even kicks off Has anyone considered how the Leinster players may simply be burnt out? Some of them seem to have been playing non-stop for the past three years. The World Cup was mainly responsible for the drain. Of course, the longer they go in a competition, the more games. Next comes Lions duty, then some will be facing the All Blacks and the autumn internationals. All this before the season kicks off again. In the old days, professional heavyweight boxers were rested for months between big fights. Back then, the managers were often indifferent to their health and concerned only with performance. Michael Foley, Rathmines, Dublin Fans must not let cruel loss overshadow such a heroic performance by Munster How cruel it was for Munster to be defeated in a penalty shoot-out after such a heroic display. They seemed to have channelled the spirit of past giants like Anthony Foley and Moss Keane to resurrect the soul of Munster for what truly was a performance for the ages. To pull it out of the top drawer so far from home, and under such humidity, made it all the more remarkable. Leinster should take inspiration from this and close the deal for Ireland, being the sole Irish survivors in the tournament. To have kept what was mostly the Springboks team to a draw for 100 minutes of furious physicality was something to be immensely proud of. It could be the cornerstone for a revival, not just for Munster, but for Irish rugby. M O'Brien, Dalkey, Co Dublin Wonderful to witness such uplifting work by academy giving young people hope That was an inspiring article on Therese Coveney who found her passion in setting up The Together Academy, which provides young adults who have Down syndrome with certified training, experience, work placements and a social and support network, having being inspired to do so after the birth of her daughter, April ('If it wasn't for my daughter, I might never have found real career purpose', Irish Independent, May 29). It was uplifting to read of the difference the academy has had on so many young adults who otherwise would not have managed to live such happy and fulfilled lives. Well done to all concerned with this achievement, which will be an encouragement to so many families.
Irish Examiner
7 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Aid is being utterly weaponised, and the result is chaos
It's difficult to imagine things getting worse, but at every turn they do. Israel has inflicted a brutal and inhuman campaign against the people of Gaza, the charge of genocide laid bare. A population deliberately and cruelly starved by an occupying power hell bent on death and destruction. Since March 2, Israel enforced a near-total siege on the Gaza Strip, cutting off food, water, electricity, fuel, and medicine. The resulting humanitarian catastrophe shocked the world with the inevitability of famine becoming reality. The Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) warned that 1.1 million people, around half of Gaza's population, are experiencing catastrophic hunger. 930,000 children - 93% of the children in Gaza - are at risk of famine. An estimated 95% of Gaza's water is unfit for human consumption, with people forced to drink polluted water, leading to soaring rates of disease and child mortality. And at least 60 children have died of starvation and dehydration in recent weeks. Although aid agencies believe the real number is far higher and growing. Generations of children, their lives destroyed beyond repair. But instead of scaling up humanitarian access in response, Israel has doubled down on control. It has repeated its attacks on the UN and sidelined aid mechanisms that are established, effective and desperately waiting to get in. Just kilometres away from the suffering, over 9,000 trucks are desperate to get in across the border. The only legal and humane solution to alleviate the suffering is total and unfettered aid access, north and south, a flooding of the Gaza strip with food, shelter, medicines and clean water. Rather than really address the issue of starvation, Israel, through the US-backed Gaza Humanitarian Fund, will now control all aid distribution. Rather than focusing on what the starving population needs, it will decide where, when and to who aid is distributed to. They are using aid - one of the world's means of expressing care and humanity in crisis - to displace and control. Israel has made clear its intention to clear the north of Gaza. Already controlling almost 80% of the Gaza Strip, this aid distribution is another means to forcibly transfer the population illegally to certain areas and make humanitarian access conditional on screening or political and military criteria. In the last 10 days, 180,000 were displaced. Palestinians gather to receive a hot meal at a food distribution point in the Nuseirat camp for refugees in the central Gaza Strip on May 21. Up to 1.1 million people, around half of Gaza's population, are experiencing catastrophic hunger. Photo: Eyad Baba / AFP via Getty Images Deliberately designed to facilitate forced displacement from the north of Gaza, the Gaza Humanitarian Fund will have distribution hubs in central and southern Gaza, forcing starving families - many of them desperately injured, elderly and too ill to undertake long, dangerous journeys through militarized zones - to collect aid for their families. The UN described this as 'engineered scarcity', secured by private US security contractors, where those Palestinians who can reach them will receive rations. Since last week, about 900 truckloads were submitted for Israeli approval, and 800 were approved. But just over 500 could be offloaded on the Israeli side of Kerem Shalom, and even fewer made it to the Palestinian side, where the UN and others could collect just over 200 of them, limited by insecurity and restricted access. This is organised chaos inflicted upon a starving people. The core principle that aid must reach people where they are is ignored, with deadly results. It compounds the despair, desperation and trauma for people who have already borne too much to imagine. In the clamber to rush and get food, Al Jazeera reported that Israeli forces killed seven people and wounded 47, using gunfire to shoot at a group of starving and desperate families. There are huge concerns about Israel using biometric screening as part of their aid distribution. This is surveillance masquerading as humanitarian assistance. It's a calculated attempt to weaponise hunger and to reduce relief to a tool of control. Palestinians carry boxes containing food and humanitarian aid packages delivered by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation on May 27. Photo: AP/Abdel Kareem Hana This blurring of military and humanitarian roles endangers aid workers and civilians alike. We've already seen the cost. The humanitarian principles of impartiality, neutrality, and independence are not optional, but are binding under international law. Yet Israel is systematically eroding them. And while hunger and chaos grow, every day brings new atrocities. Just last week, Israeli forces killed nine of paediatrician Dr Alaa al-Najjar's 10 children in shelters designated as safe. Israel's war in Gaza has killed at least 54,000 people to date - mostly women and children - and displaced almost the entire population. What is happening is not just a war. It is the slow obliteration of an entire people. Ireland has a role to play and must act. Our long-standing tradition of supporting human rights and international law compels us to do more than offer words of concern. We must finally pass the Occupied Territories Bill, first proposed by Senator Frances Black in 2018. The decision by the Government this week to draft the heads of the Bill is welcome, but long overdue. An Israeli strike in Gaza City on Sunday. Israel has inflicted a brutal and inhuman campaign against the people of Gaza, the charge of genocide laid bare. Photo: AP/Jehad Alshrafi The outrageous atrocities we see over the last 20 months are the worst expression of a 70-year occupation of Palestinian territory. The level of violence is shocking, but it comes with this context of apartheid and occupation. This makes the exclusion of a ban on services from the Bill unacceptable. This is a vital and substantial element which would cover online platforms such as Airbnb which have a significant presence in some of the territories, offering tourist accommodation. Legal experts have verified this can be done. Meanwhile, many powerful countries, including the United States and EU members, continue to fund, arm, and diplomatically shield the Israeli government from accountability. At the same time, they issue platitudes about humanitarian concern. Karole Balfe: '[Israel is] using aid - one of the world's means of expressing care and humanity in crisis - to displace and control.' As well as passing the Occupied Territories Bill the Irish government must lead calls for sanctions, suspension of the EU-Trade Agreement and push for an EU arms embargo. If the Bill is passed at least Ireland can say it took action and gave example to the world at a crucial time when powerful nations were turning a blind eye. We can stand as a beacon of principled action, reminding the world that small nations can lead boldly when justice is on the line. Karol Balfe is CEO of ActionAid Ireland which supports humanitarian response in Gaza Read More Ireland lodges formal protest after Israeli gunfire near peacekeepers in Lebanon
