
The role of ESG policies in shaping sustainable businesses
Sustainability and ESG once buzzwords, have evolved to being seriously considered by both corporates and policy makers. Many argue what is the difference between the two.
Technically speaking, the scope of sustainability is much broader and ESG can be taken to be a sub-set of sustainability. ESG stands for environment, social and governance, which essentially when combined covers a broad spectrum of areas within which a business operates. Generally, both these terms are concurrently used.
With growing awareness, value chains are inquiring about the ESG practices of their business partners making a strong business case for implementation. Considering the importance, regulators have appropriately acted by introducing regulations and mandatory compliance with respect to sustainability.
One of the key requirements for corporations is having a policy for sustainability and ESG. SECP is the primary regulator of companies in Pakistan. It has implemented numerous changes pertaining to sustainability in the regulatory framework, particularly in the Code of Corporate Governance for Listed Companies, 2019 (the Code), requiring a company's Board of Directors to establish and maintain an ESG policy.
As per PICG ESG survey carried out in 2023:
On a question 'Does your organization have a defined action plan related to the ESG strategy?
This makes a very strong case for the companies to have a board level ESG policy to steer and speed up ESG agenda.
Having a board level ESG policy is also important from a governance perspective as it brings ownership and clarity at the highest level, thereby making it easier to navigate the specific agenda across the organization to achieve the desired objectives.
The Code requires companies to have a policy addressing the following: 'Environmental, social and governance (ESG) including but not limited to health and safety aspects in business strategies that promote sustainability, corporate social responsibility initiatives and other philanthropic activities, donations, contributions to charities and other matters of social welfare'.
The sustainability agenda can be better achieved through a board level policy that covers the following elements:
Linking the mission and vision statement and values:
A company's mission and vision statement and set of values, act as the foundation on which the company exists and operates. Embedding sustainability into these core principles is crucial for integrating sustainable practices into all aspects of the business. To achieve this, companies should review and revise their existing mission and vision statements to include sustainability.
Risk management:
Companies have risk management programmes in place to identify, analyze, and estimate the criticality and impact of business risks, including performing scenario analysis for better impact estimation.
It is important that a company analyze the possible impact of ESG related risks that could have an impact on the company's future business, profits, cash flows and market positioning and devise an action plan accordingly.
Ethical culture:
An important role of the board is to ensure that ethical values and culture are promoted and practiced company wide. Areas such as transparency in business dealings, maintaining confidentiality of data, anti-bribery, anti-harassment and anti-sexual harassment etc.
The objective should be for all employees to be aware of and adhere to ethical values. These values should ideally be consolidated into a code of conduct that all employees sign, demonstrating their commitment to uphold them. From the ESG lens, this approach represents compliance with the social aspects. Ensuring this is adequately covered in the ESG policy will help adherence to social compliance requirements.
Whistle-blowing programme:
A whistle-blowing programme is a vital aspect of governance. It helps identify wrongdoings within the company and throughout the value chain. This programme encourages employees, business partners, vendors, and suppliers to report any wrongdoings they observe or experience, with the assurance of confidentiality. Additionally, it serves as a platform for reporting issues related to ESG matters.
Action plan, KPI and significant issues:
Management must inform the board of any significant matters related to company business or operations. Additionally, management should bring any material ESG issues to the board's attention, including the status and challenges with respect to ESG policy; updates on ESG KPIs and milestones set and achieved; non-compliance and penalties imposed due to non-compliance with any regulatory body concerning ESG and updates on CSR activities carried out.
There should be adequate coverage of this in the policy.
Finally, to ensure the governance of the ESG policy framework, it is essential that the company's board includes a diverse mix of members, such as independent and female directors, who possess the necessary competency, experience, and exposure to support and drive the company's ESG initiatives.
The ESG policy serves as a document which not only aligns a company's internal processes to ESG but also enables a company to communicate this externally to business partners, customers and investors. This will support any enquiries about ESG indicators, and the actions taken by the company to ensure related ESG KPI's are met. Furthermore, a robust ESG policy framework will support any future requirements for independently audited statements.
======================================= Yes No Not sure In progress 30% 20% 10% 40 =======================================
Copyright Business Recorder, 2025

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Business Recorder
17 hours ago
- Business Recorder
Corporate board elections
Introduction: A reform that misses the mark In July 2023, the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP) amended the Code of Corporate Governance through S.R.O. 906(I)/2023, introducing a new regulation (7A) that mandates separate, category-wise voting for director elections in listed companies. Ostensibly designed to streamline compliance with board diversity requirements—such as the presence of female and independent directors—this amendment has produced the opposite of good governance. Rather than fostering inclusion or transparency, these reforms have imposed severe procedural limitations on minority shareholders, undermining the time-tested cumulative voting method enshrined in the Companies Act, 2017. As a result, the amended framework risks institutionalizing majority dominance and relegating shareholder democracy to a symbolic formality. The case in point: an unwinnable election In 2024, a minority shareholder controlling 12.51 percent equity in a listed company prepared to contest upcoming board elections under Section 159(3) of the Companies Act. With seven board seats available and the company's free float limited to 25%, the shareholder aimed to secure one board seat —an achievable strategy under the earlier cumulative voting framework that allowed aggregation of votes to elect at least one director. However, the company's new voting process, aligned with Regulation 7A, subdivided the election into three separate categories: female, independent, and other directors. Critically, it rigidly allocated voting rights to each category based on the number of seats designated for that group. For the 'Other Directors' category — where the minority nominee had filed — this meant that a candidate needed at least 20.10 percent of the total votes to win a single seat. In a company where the controlling shareholders held over 75% of the voting power, the outcome was a foregone conclusion. Even with controlling 12.51% equity, the minority shareholder found the contest practically unwinnable. Facing a futile effort, the nominee withdrew his candidacy. The company subsequently announced that all remaining candidates stood unopposed — rendering the election process an administrative formality. The problem: a procedural lockout This episode is not an isolated event, but a clear illustration of the deeper structural flaws introduced by the 2023 reforms: — Voting power is fragmented: By dividing voting into fixed categories, Regulation 7A prevents shareholders from strategically allocating their full voting strength—effectively neutralizing minority influence. — Cumulative voting is undermined: While the Companies Act guarantees cumulative voting to empower minority blocs, the new mechanism bypasses this intent by introducing category-based segmentation, which is arguably inconsistent with Sections 159 and 166 of the Act. — Uncontested elections are now the norm: The separation of ballots makes it easier for controlling shareholders to fill reserved seats (e.g., for female or independent directors) without competition, thereby complying with the letter of the law while violating its spirit. — Independence is compromised: Directors elected with majority backing, regardless of being labeled 'independent,' are unlikely to offer meaningful dissent or oversight — defeating the very purpose of their designation. Global best practices: where Pakistan falls short Across jurisdictions, mechanisms like cumulative voting or slate-based minority representation are considered essential tools for equitable corporate governance. For example: — The OECD Principles of Corporate Governance recognize cumulative voting as a legitimate and effective way to ensure minority shareholders have a voice in the boardroom. — Italy and the UK have adopted dual-voting or slate-voting structures that guarantee at least one board seat to the non-controlling shareholders. — Saudi Arabia and China require cumulative voting in listed companies to prevent entrenchment of control. Pakistan's shift to a segmented voting framework moves away from these norms, replacing proportional representation with category-specific majoritarianism. In practical terms, this means the controlling shareholders not only dominate the board but now do so with the veneer of compliance and procedural legitimacy. Recommendations: restoring balance and credibility To preserve the integrity of corporate governance in Pakistan and re-empower minority shareholders, the following reforms should be considered: Restore cumulative voting across a unified slate: Reinstate the cumulative voting method as originally provided in the Companies Act, allowing shareholders to allocate votes freely among all candidates. Introduce reserved minority representation: Mandate at least one board seat to be filled exclusively through votes cast by non-controlling shareholders, ensuring true minority representation. Enhance transparency through vote disclosure: Require companies to disclose, in advance, the vote thresholds typically needed to win a seat under the new system. This would help shareholders make informed decisions and organize support. Strengthen oversight and post-election review: SECP should introduce a mandatory review of election results, including unopposed outcomes, to assess whether procedural reforms are delivering on their governance objectives. Conclusion: a call to rebalance power The intention behind SECP's 2023 amendment may have been noble—ensuring compliance with board diversity mandates. But in its current form, Regulation 7A disables one of the few levers minority shareholders have to assert their rights. The cumulative result is a system where even a shareholder with controlling 12.51% equity cannot credibly contest an election, and where the majority's grip on governance is quietly tightened. Pakistan must not let formalism replace fairness. Regulatory reform must advance both diversity and equity. Otherwise, shareholder participation risks becoming an illusion—legally permitted, procedurally blocked, and practically futile. It is time to revisit these reforms—not to abandon them—but to realign them with the foundational principles of transparency, inclusivity, and balance that underpin good governance worldwide. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025


Business Recorder
a day ago
- Business Recorder
Pakistan in serious talks with Russia on steel mills issue
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is in serious talks with Russia to set up a new steel mills or restore the Pakistan Steel Mills (PSM) in Karachi to fulfill local demand. This was stated by the Special Assistant to the Prime Minister (SAPM) on Industry and Production Haroon Akhtar Khan in a chat with Business Recorder, saying that both the countries, in the past few months, have held two fruitful meetings on the subject and are moving ahead on the matter. The SAPM, responding to a question, said that 'technical experts are analysing the state of the present machinery of PSM and if 50 percent machinery is useable, the government is surely going to restore the PSM with Russian cooperation'. He said that the PSM owned 18,660 acres of land, out of which, 710 acres is under consideration for the setting up a new steel plant. Pakistan, Russia agree to establish new steel mills in Karachi According to officials, although Pakistan is rich in iron ore, with estimated reserves of 1.887 billion tons, it still imports about $2.7 billion worth of steel every year. Officials said that domestic steel production is not enough to meet all demand, with a supply gap of 3.1 million tons last year. The proposed steel plant site is strategically located near Port Qasim, which will help reduce transportation costs of raw materials, thereby, providing a competitive advantage. The SAPM further said that to safeguard the interests of the business community the government is to introduce some amendments in the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP). He added that the homework on amendments to the SECP law has been completed, a new clause will be added, amendment to the law regarding the investigation of the financial monitoring unit are also under consideration, in the name of suspicious transactions, the matter is being confused by sending it to investigative agencies without investigation. He said that the investigating agencies including National Accountability Bureau (NAB), Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) and other anti-corruption departments will have to seek permission from SECP before launching any investigation against any business entity or individual. Khan said that if there is suspicion of terror financing and money laundering, then after investigation, it should be sent to the relevant agency. Talking about the remittances and other payment transfers through banking channels, the SAPM said such payments are already reaching the country through reliable and proper channels, so there should not be any need to investigate the sources. However, illegal channels such as Hawala and Hundi must not be allowed. He said that to promote and encourage the investment in the country the government is considering to waive off additional fines and surcharges on investment in industrial sector, but it will take a little time. He said that his ministry has finalised the industrial package to run closed industrial units in the country and increase business activities. He said that for the first time in the country, the government has decided to introduce bankruptcy law. The purpose of the law is to enable the owners of closed industrial units to obtain loans from banks. Khan said that instead of auctioning bankrupt industrial units, the law will allow banks to give loans to such units, so, that they can restore themselves. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025


Business Recorder
2 days ago
- Business Recorder
Serious talks with Russia on steel mills issue
ISLAMABAD: Pakistan is in serious talks with Russia to set up a new steel mills or restore the Pakistan Steel Mills (PSM) in Karachi to fulfill local demand. This was stated by the Special Assistant to the Prime Minister (SAPM) on Industry and Production Haroon Akhtar Khan in a chat with Business Recorder, saying that both the countries, in the past few months, have held two fruitful meetings on the subject and are moving ahead on the matter. The SAPM, responding to a question, said that 'technical experts are analysing the state of the present machinery of PSM and if 50 percent machinery is useable, the government is surely going to restore the PSM with Russian cooperation'. He said that the PSM owned 18,660 acres of land, out of which, 710 acres is under consideration for the setting up a new steel plant. Pakistan, Russia agree to establish new steel mills in Karachi According to officials, although Pakistan is rich in iron ore, with estimated reserves of 1.887 billion tons, it still imports about $2.7 billion worth of steel every year. Officials said that domestic steel production is not enough to meet all demand, with a supply gap of 3.1 million tons last year. The proposed steel plant site is strategically located near Port Qasim, which will help reduce transportation costs of raw materials, thereby, providing a competitive advantage. The SAPM further said that to safeguard the interests of the business community the government is to introduce some amendments in the Securities and Exchange Commission of Pakistan (SECP). He added that the homework on amendments to the SECP law has been completed, a new clause will be added, amendment to the law regarding the investigation of the financial monitoring unit are also under consideration, in the name of suspicious transactions, the matter is being confused by sending it to investigative agencies without investigation. He said that the investigating agencies including National Accountability Bureau (NAB), Federal Investigation Agency (FIA) and other anti-corruption departments will have to seek permission from SECP before launching any investigation against any business entity or individual. Khan said that if there is suspicion of terror financing and money laundering, then after investigation, it should be sent to the relevant agency. Talking about the remittances and other payment transfers through banking channels, the SAPM said such payments are already reaching the country through reliable and proper channels, so there should not be any need to investigate the sources. However, illegal channels such as Hawala and Hundi must not be allowed. He said that to promote and encourage the investment in the country the government is considering to waive off additional fines and surcharges on investment in industrial sector, but it will take a little time. He said that his ministry has finalised the industrial package to run closed industrial units in the country and increase business activities. He said that for the first time in the country, the government has decided to introduce bankruptcy law. The purpose of the law is to enable the owners of closed industrial units to obtain loans from banks. Khan said that instead of auctioning bankrupt industrial units, the law will allow banks to give loans to such units, so, that they can restore themselves. Copyright Business Recorder, 2025