Trump team ordered to move Tufts student from Louisiana ICE jail after it couldn't ‘take a position' on her free speech
A New York-based federal appeals court has ordered Donald Trump 's administration to transfer Tufts University scholar Rumeysa Ozturk from an immigration detention center in Louisiana to Vermont.
The case of Ozturk, a Turkish international student and former Fulbright scholar working towards her doctorate in child development, is among several high-profile cases at the center of the Trump administration's targeting of international students for their advocacy for Palestine during Israel's war in Gaza.
In March, Ozturk's visa was revoked and she was arrested and detained by plain-clothes federal agents outside her apartment in Massachusetts in what her lawyers argue is a retaliatory attempt to deport her over an op-ed she wrote in a student newspaper.
The government has one week to transfer her, according to Wednesday's order, which arrived less than 24 hours after a hearing in which government attorneys failed to say whether they even agree with the administration's position that her pro-Palestine speech is not constitutionally protected.
Appellate Judge Barrington Parker, who was appointed by George W. Bush, pressed Department of Justice attorney Drew Ensign on whether Ozturk's statements — and statements from another international student who was arrested for support for Palestine — amount to protected speech.
'Your honor, we haven't taken a position on that,' Ensign replied.
'Help my thinking. Take a position,' Parked fired back.
'I don't have authority to take a position,' Ensign said.
Ozturk has been locked up in a rural Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention center in Louisiana for more than 100 days. In sworn statements in court documents, she reported experiencing several asthma attacks and sharing a cell with more than 20 others in cramped and unsanitary conditions.
Her detention is 'unprecedented and shocking,' according to Esha Bhandari, deputy director of the ACLU 's Speech, Privacy, and Technology Project.
'She has been held behind bars for six weeks while her health deteriorates for writing an op-ed,' she told a three-judge appeals court panel Wednesday. 'Detention is not the norm with respect to visa revocation, as we had here. The executive branch made a specific decision to detain Ms. Ozturk that was motivated by her speech.'
Last month, Vermont District Judge William K. Session ordered Ozturk's transfer to a detention center in the state, noting that her case has 'raised significant constitutional concerns with her arrest and detention which merit full and fair consideration in this forum.'
The Trump administration appealed the order, arguing that Ozturk can be deported under the Immigration and Nationality Act, which Secretary of State Marco Rubio has invoked against dozens of international students who he claims have 'adverse' impacts to the country's foreign policy.
But the administration does not appear to possess any evidence backing up claims of antisemitism and support for a terrorist organization to justify her arrest, according to court filings and government memos.
'No one should be arrested and locked up for their political views,' Bhandari said in a statement Wednesday. 'Every day that RRumeysa Ozturk remains in detention is a day too long. We're grateful the court refused the government's attempt to keep her isolated from her community and her legal counsel as she pursues her case for release.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
40 minutes ago
- The Independent
Judge blocks plan to allow immigration agents in New York City jail
A judge blocked New York City's mayor from letting federal immigration authorities reopen an office at the city's main jail, in part because of concerns the mayor invited them back in as part of a deal with the Trump administration to end his corruption case. New York Judge Mary Rosado's decision Friday is a setback for Democratic Mayor Eric Adams, who issued an executive order permitting U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement and other federal agencies to maintain office space at the Rikers Island jail complex. City lawmakers filed a lawsuit in April accusing Adams of entering into a 'corrupt quid pro quo bargain' with the Trump administration in exchange for the U.S. Justice Department dropping criminal charges against him. Rosado temporarily blocked the executive order in April. In granting a preliminary injunction, she said city council members have 'shown a likelihood of success in demonstrating, at minimum, the appearance of a quid pro quo whereby Mayor Adams publicly agreed to bring Immigration and Customs Enforcement ('ICE') back to Rikers Island in exchange for dismissal of his criminal charges.' Rosado cited a number of factors, including U.S. border czar Tom Homan 's televised comments in February that if Adams did not come through, "I'll be in his office, up his butt saying, 'Where the hell is the agreement we came to?' ' Adams has repeatedly denied making a deal with the administration over the criminal case. He has said he deputized his first deputy mayor, Randy Mastro, to handle decision-making on the return of ICE to Rikers Island to make sure there was no appearance of any conflict of interest. Rosado said that Mastro reports to Adams and 'cannot be considered impartial and free from Mayor Adams' conflicts.' Mastro said in a prepared statement Friday the administration was confident they will prevail in the case. "Let's be crystal clear: This executive order is about the criminal prosecution of violent transnational gangs committing crimes in our city. Our administration has never, and will never, do anything to jeopardize the safety of law-abiding immigrants, and this executive order ensures their safety as well," Mastro said. City Council Speaker Adrienne Adams, who is running in the Democratic primary for mayor, called the decision a victory for public safety. 'New Yorkers are counting on our city to protect their civil rights, and yet, Mayor Adams has attempted to betray this obligation by handing power over our city to Trump's ICE because he is compromised," she said in a prepared statement.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Migrant 'wrongly' deported by Trump appears back in US courthouse...but gets bad news about bid for freedom
Kilmar Abrego Garcia, the migrant who had been deported to El Salvador in March by the Trump administration, will remain in jail for now ahead of his trial on criminal charges of human smuggling. At the conclusion of a hearing on Friday in federal court in Nashville, U.S. Magistrate Judge Barbara Holmes said she would rule at a later date on Abrego Garcia's bid to be released on bail pending trial. Robert McGuire, the U.S. attorney in Nashville, said Abrego would be placed into immigration detention even if Holmes orders his release. Garcia pleaded not guilty on Friday to the charges with his wife, Jennifer Vasquez Sura, and a gaggle of protesters on hand. The detention hearing was the first chance the Maryland construction worker has had in a U.S. courtroom to answer the Trump administration's allegations against him since he was mistakenly deported in March to a notorious prison in El Salvador. Facing court orders and mounting pressure to return Abrego Garcia, the Republican administration brought him back to the U.S. last week. But it was to face criminal charges related to what federal prosecutors said was a human smuggling operation that transported immigrants across the country. Abrego Garcia´s attorneys have characterized the smuggling case as a desperate attempt by the Trump administration to justify his mistaken deportation three months after the fact. The charges stem from a 2022 traffic stop in Tennessee during which Abrego Garcia was driving a vehicle with nine passengers. His lawyers have called the allegations 'preposterous.' In briefings before the hearing, U.S. attorneys described him as a danger to the community and a flight risk, while his public defenders said the charges aren´t serious enough for detention. The charges against Abrego Garcia are human smuggling. But in their request to keep Abrego Garcia in jail, U.S. attorneys also accused him of trafficking drugs and firearms and of abusing the women he transported, among other claims, although he is not charged with such crimes. Friday's proceeding included testimony from a Department of Homeland Security agent who quoted three unnamed witnesses who spoke to a grand jury about Abrego Garcia´s alleged actions. Special agent Peter Joseph said that the witnesses saw Abrego Garcia trafficking people, guns or drugs and that Abrego Garcia earned upwards of $100,000 a year. One man said he saw Abrego Garcia bothering underage girls in a sexual way, Joseph testified, while a woman said Abrego Garcia had solicited nude photos of her when she was 15 and believed he was in the MS-13 gang. During cross examination, Abrego Garcia´s attorneys raised questions about possible conflicts of interest. One man is a felon who´d been previously deported and was serving a 30-month sentence when investigators contacted him, Joseph acknowledged. That witness is now living in a halfway house and on his way to getting work authorization. The second man is a very close relative of the first witness and 'said he would help in return for his release from jail,' said Richard Tennent, an assistant federal public defender. The third witness had previously been compensated for her work with law enforcement. Tennent pointed out that one of the witnesses told investigators that Abrego Garcia would drive roundtrip between Maryland and Houston - nearly 24 hours each way - two or three times per week. The witness said that Abrego Garcia nearly always had two of his children and his wife with him. Tennent pointed out that Abrego Garcia has three children, two of whom are autistic. Abrego Garcia is a citizen of El Salvador who had been living in the United States for more than a decade before he was deported. The expulsion violated a 2019 U.S. immigration judge´s order that shielded him from deportation to his native country because he likely faced gang persecution there. Proteseters gather for a protest before an arraignment and detention hearing for Kilmar Abrego Garcia at the US District Court for the Middle District of Tennessee in Nashville While the Trump administration described the mistaken removal as 'an administrative error,' officials have continued to justify it by insisting Abrego Garcia was a member of the MS-13 gang. His wife and attorneys have denied the allegations, saying he's simply a construction worker and family man. Before Friday´s hearing began in Nashville, Abrego Garcia´s wife told a crowd outside a church that Thursday marked three months since the Trump administration 'abducted and disappeared my husband and separated him from our family.' Her voice choked with emotion, Sura said she saw her husband for the first time on Thursday. She said, 'Kilmar wants you to have faith,' and asked the people supporting him and his family '`to continue fighting, and I will be victorious because God is with us.´' During a Saturday phone interview with NBC News' Kristen Welker, Donald Trump was asked what went into his decision to bring Garcia back. 'Well, that wasn't my decision. The Department of Justice decided to do it that way, and that's fine, as far as -- there are two ways you could have done it, and they decided to do it that way,' Trump told Welker. 'I think for speed, and, you know, it should be a very easy case,' Trump continued. Welker then further pressed the Commander in Chief, asking, 'you think, you think he's going to be convicted-- you think it's going to be an easy case?' US Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.) holding a meeting with Salvadoran migrant Kilmar Abrego Garcia, a US resident wrongfully deported to his home country, at a hotel in San Salvador on April 17, 2025 'I think it should be. It should be. You have two different cases. This would go faster,' Trump replied. Welker then asked Trump what he thought of Democrats who advocated for Garcia's return, including Senator Chris Van Hollen (D-Md.), who made a public case for Garcia being denied due process. 'He's a loser. The guy's a loser. They're going to lose because of that same thing. That's not what people want to hear,' Trump responded. 'He's trying to defend a man who's got a horrible record of abuse, abuse of women in particular. No, he's a total loser-- this guy,' Trump concluded. The decision to charge Abrego Garcia criminally prompted the resignation of Ben Schrader, who was chief of the criminal division at the U.S. Attorney's Office for the Middle District of Tennessee. He did not directly address the indictment and declined to comment when reached by The Associated Press. However, a person familiar with the matter who spoke on the condition of anonymity to discuss a personnel matter confirmed the connection. The smuggling charges stem from a 2022 traffic stop in Tennessee for speeding. Body camera footage released by Tennessee Highway Patrol shows a calm exchange between officers and Abrego Garcia. It also shows the officers discussing among themselves their suspicions of human smuggling before sending him on his way. One of the officers says, 'He´s hauling these people for money.' Another says Abrego Garcia had $1,400 in an envelope. Although the maximum sentence for smuggling one person is ten years, and Abrego Garcia is accused of transporting hundreds of people over nearly a decade, his defense attorneys point out there´s no minimum sentence. The average sentence for human smuggling last year was just 15 months, according to court filings.
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Hundreds of Marines enter LA ahead of mass protest... but their mission is not what you'd expect
Marines were seen standing guard outside a federal building in Los Angeles on Friday afternoon as they started to take over the post from National Guard members after protests erupted last week over immigration raids and President Donald Trump deployed the troops to the city. Major General Scott Sherman, the commander of Task Force 51 who is overseeing the 4,700 combined troops, said the Marines finished training on civil disturbance and are starting their operations by replacing Guard troops guarding the Wilshire Federal Building, which houses several federal offices. Guard soldiers can then be assigned to protect more law enforcement agents on raids, Sherman said. About 200 Marines out of the 700 deployed to the protests are in the city, Sherman said. It's unclear if the Marines will eventually provide security on raids. At 12:30pm, two Marines were seen standing at the entrance to the 17-story Wilshire Federal Building, wearing combat gear and carrying rifles as they mingled with Guard members, who have been checking IDs of people entering the parking lot. It is the same building that Democratic U.S. Sen. Alex Padilla on Thursday was forcefully removed from Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem's news conference and handcuffed by officers as he tried to speak up about the immigration raids. As the Trump administration targets migrants around the country for detainment and deportation, the raids have led to the arrests of asylum-seekers, people who overstayed their visas and migrants awaiting their day in immigration court. The Marines are taking their posts a day after the 9th US Circuit Court of Appeals temporarily blocked a federal judge's order that had directed Trump to return control of Guard troops to California, shortly after a federal judge had ruled the Guard deployment was illegal, violated the Tenth Amendment and exceeded Trump's statutory authority. Some 2,000 Guard troops have been in the city since last week. Some have provided protection to immigration agents making arrests. Another 2,000 Guard members were notified of deployment earlier this week. None of the military troops will be detaining anyone, Sherman said. 'I would like to emphasize that the soldiers will not participate in law enforcement activities,' Sherman said. 'Rather, they'll be focused on protecting federal law enforcement personnel.' Roughly 500 Guard members have been used to provide security on immigration raids after undergoing expanded instruction, legal training and rehearsals with the agents doing the enforcement before they go on those missions. An 8pm curfew has been in place in a 1-square-mile section of downtown. The city of Los Angeles encompasses roughly 500 square miles. Protests have ended after a few hours with arrests this week largely for failure to disperse. On the third night of the curfew, officers with the Department of Homeland Security deployed flash bangs to disperse a crowd that had gathered near a jail, sending protesters sprinting away. As with the past two nights, the hours long demonstrations remained peaceful and upbeat, drawing a few hundred attendees who marched through downtown chanting, dancing and poking fun at the Trump administration's characterization of the city as a 'war zone.' The protests began last Friday after federal immigration raids arrested dozens of workers in Los Angeles. Protesters blocked a major freeway and set cars on fire over the weekend, and police responded with tear gas, rubber bullets and flash-bang grenades. Elsewhere, demonstrations have picked up across the US, emerging in more than a dozen major cities. Some have led to clashes with police, and hundreds have been arrested. Demonstrations are expected over the weekend in cities across the United States, and governors are weighing what to do should Trump send troops to other states for immigration enforcement. California Gov. Gavin Newsom has called the troop deployment a 'serious breach of state sovereignty' and a power grab by Trump, and he has gone to court to stop it. The president has cited a legal provision that allows him to mobilize federal service members when there is 'a rebellion or danger of a rebellion against the authority of the Government of the United States.' Under federal law, active-duty forces are prohibited by law from conducting law enforcement. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, a Republican, has put 5,000 Guard members on standby in cities where demonstrations are planned. In other Republican-controlled states, governors have not said when or how they may deploy troops. A group of Democratic governors earlier signed a statement this week calling Trump's 'an alarming abuse of power.' The Trump administration has said the troops are necessary to protect federal officers and quell unrest. In Los Angeles, troops work in shifts, and the public is likely to only see a few hundred out at a time, Sherman said. Much of the sprawling city has been spared from the protests. There have been about 500 arrests since Saturday, the vast majority of which were for failing to leave the area at the request of law enforcement, according to the police In LA troops work in shifts, and the public is likely to only see a few hundred out at a time So far, the protests have been centered mostly downtown near City Hall and a federal detention center where some immigrants are being held. Much of the sprawling city has been spared from the protests. There have been about 500 arrests since Saturday, the vast majority of which were for failing to leave the area at the request of law enforcement, according to the police department. There have been a handful of more serious charges, including for assault against officers and for possession of a Molotov cocktail and a gun.
