'This is about the economy': What motivates Alberta separatists
Article content
With dedicated groups of Albertans pushing for the western province to secede from Canada, new polling shows that most of those living in the province reject this idea, while just over one-third support some form of independence from Canada.
Article content
Article content
The Postmedia-Leger poll also found that 44 per cent of Albertans identify as 'primarily Canadian,' while only 21 per cent identify as primarily Albertan. A further 32 per cent say they identify as both equally.
Article content
Article content
Sixty per cent of those who oppose separation say they identify as primarily Canadian; even among those who wish to see an independent Alberta, 23 per cent say they identify as primarily Canadian, while 45 per cent say they are primarily Albertan.
Article content
Article content
When it comes to a future scenario involving an independent Alberta, the most popular idea, which received the support of 35 per cent of Albertans, would be an independent western bloc, from Manitoba to the Pacific Ocean. Thirty per cent support just Alberta and Saskatchewan breaking away and forming their own country, while 29 per cent would support Alberta going it alone.
Article content
Just 17 per cent of Albertans are interested in joining the United States.
'I don't really see this as something that's been really steamrolling and gaining a ton of momentum. I think it's … probably been festering for a bit,' said Andrew Enns, Leger's executive vice-president, central Canada. 'Probably the re-election of the Liberals didn't help to diminish anything. But I wouldn't suggest also that it's actually added a bunch of fuel to the fire.'
Article content
Article content
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith has been a frequent critic of the federal government's approach to Alberta. When she met with Prime Minister Mark Carney prior to the election, she made a list of nine demands, many of them involving the energy sector, that she said she expected to see met within six months, or there could be an 'unprecedented national unity crisis.'
Article content
Article content
The majority of Albertans (53 per cent) support Smith's approach on those demands, while 34 per cent disagree. Eighty-three per cent of those who support separation also support Smith's approach, compared to 34 per cent of those who do not support separation.
Article content
'What she's doing is not completely offside with her voters and the electorate. I mean, her job is to represent Alberta and Albertans, and not necessarily do things that are going to make (Ontario) Premier (Doug) Ford happy,' said Enns.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Global News
33 minutes ago
- Global News
U.S. ambassador says Canada, U.S. goals on economy align
U.S. President Donald Trump's goal of enhancing American power aligns with Prime Minister Mark Carney's aim of making Canada's economy the fastest-growing in the G7, Trump's envoy to Canada said Friday. 'It's going to continue to be a very strong and friendly relationship,' Ambassador Pete Hoekstra told The Canadian Press in an interview Friday, adding the two leaders are in frequent contact. 'You've got two leaders that are invigorating and transforming their economies, to benefit the people of the U.S. and the people of Canada.' Hoekstra insisted there is no 'discrepancy' between his calls for win-win economic arrangements between Canada and the U.S. and Trump's repeated claim that America doesn't need Canadian imports and doesn't want Canadian-made cars. 'There is absolutely no discrepancy between me and the president. The president clearly is the decision-maker,' he said. Story continues below advertisement Though he said the U.S. intends to continue imposing tariffs on imports from multiple countries, including Canada, he argued there's room to resolve irritants in the economic relationship. 'The president is … saying tariffs are part of our new framework. That's not a Canadian problem. That's a global issue,' he said. 'The great thing is you've got the top leaders involved in the discussions, which means that both countries view this as being important, serious, and they want this to get resolved.' Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy He said the fact that Trump and Carney have been engaging in private talks that haven't been leaked to the media indicate a mutual focus on making progress. He also insisted the talks aren't happening in secret, although neither side has released readouts reporting on the content of the meetings. 8:09 Exclusive: New U.S. Ambassador has a special tie to Canada 'I don't think the president or the prime minister are going to put out a statement every time that, 'Oh, I texted the president last night, and he responded,' or you know, 'We had a five-minute call,'' he said. Story continues below advertisement 'Everybody knows that right now, tariffs, economic growth and these types of things are the top of the agenda. That for the prime minister being the No. 1 growing economy in the G7 is one of his goals and objectives, and knowing that our President Donald Trump is doing everything that he can he can to ignite the U.S. economy. 'Why is anybody surprised that there may be different levels of communications going on to make that happen?' Hoekstra admitted he isn't informed every time Carney and Trump talk. 'I'd be interested in knowing exactly how often it's happening. I don't need to know,' he said. 'There (are) multiple channels between key decision-makers that are open and are being used, but I don't need to know the quantity or the frequency. I just need to know that they exist, because that tells me that we can be making progress.' Hoekstra did not offer a timeline for trade talks as discussions continue between Ottawa and Washington on tariffs and a possible early start to a review of the North American trade deal this fall. The ambassador said Trump, Carney, U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick and various Canadian ministers are negotiating with advice from businesspeople on both sides of the border. 'They all understand that great negotiations, great discussions, end with a win-win,' he said. Story continues below advertisement Hoekstra said America wants strong borders, an end to fentanyl deaths and sustainable spending, and said Canada can partner with the U.S. on shared security and prosperity. 'Our objective is to stay the most powerful country in the world,' he said. The ambassador said he's had a warm reception in Canada, despite the tensions in the relationship that he had been reading about in the six months leading up to the start of his posting in April. 'I knew that there was a tension, a different tone and tenor than what we normally expected from our northern neighbours,' he said. 'But you know, we're going get past this.'
Vancouver Sun
an hour ago
- Vancouver Sun
Toronto resident cancels planned trip to U.S. due to travel ban: 'I feel so bad'
Hla Wynn was looking forward to his annual trip to New York this summer, eager to spend time with family and help his brother recover from surgery. But the retired college professor said his long-standing plans are on hold until further notice now that U.S. President Donald Trump has announced a travel ban on residents of more than a dozen countries, including his birthplace of Myanmar. 'We've been going back and forth, some years they come and visit us, sometimes we go and visit them, to go for a trip during the summertime, spend about a week or two with them,' the 73-year-old said of his summer travels. '… but because of this new development, I'm not comfortable visiting them.' Start your day with a roundup of B.C.-focused news and opinion. By signing up you consent to receive the above newsletter from Postmedia Network Inc. A welcome email is on its way. If you don't see it, please check your junk folder. The next issue of Sunrise will soon be in your inbox. Please try again Interested in more newsletters? Browse here. Trump announced Wednesday that citizens of 12 countries — Myanmar, Afghanistan, Chad, the Republic of Congo, Equatorial Guinea, Eritrea, Haiti, Iran, Libya, Somalia, Sudan and Yemen — would be banned from visiting the United States. Seven more countries — Burundi, Cuba, Laos, Sierra Leone, Togo, Turkmenistan and Venezuela — face heightened travel restrictions. Some of the 12 countries on the banned list were targeted by a similar measure Trump enacted in his first term. Wynn, who now lives in Toronto, has maintained close ties in his home country and worries about the broader impact of Trump's ban, which is set to take effect on Monday. He said he has been helping university students in Myanmar online after they lost access to education following a military coup in 2021, and he now fears the ban will make it difficult for those wanting to continue their studies. 'Everything was closed down or even if they are open, they are under military government, which is a very poor education system,' he said. 'I was so sad for these people because lots of people are trying to get into (the) U.S. and Canada … and now there are lots of students stuck to get a visa.' The head of an association representing the Myanmar community in Ontario said the new travel ban is 'cruel' to the people of his country. Napas Thein, president of the Burma Canadian Association of Ontario, said the people of Myanmar are already facing difficulties in their own country thanks to the coup and a new law mandating military service, and the ban will make it harder to move to a safer place. 'This has really put a strain on people that I know in Canada,' he said. 'I know a student, supposed to be incoming PhD student, who is supposed to go to a university in the United States, whose trajectory there may be completely halted because he's a Myanmar national.' Thein said he and fellow Canadian citizens from the Myanmar diaspora feel uneasy about crossing the Canada-U.S. border, and some have already started cancelling plans to attend conferences or visit their families. 'We really don't know, and even though, technically, people who are born (in Myanmar) but are Canadian citizens should be able to go, we're really not sure,' he said. Thein noted the new U.S. travel ban landed days after Canada introduced new border security measures that would, if passed, limit people's ability to claim asylum in Canada. Critics and advocacy groups are calling the wide-ranging border security legislation a threat to civil liberties in the immigration and asylum system. The government says the 127-page bill introduced on Monday aims to keep borders secure, combat transnational organized crime, stop the flow of deadly fentanyl and crack down on money laundering. One proposed change in the Liberal legislation would prevent people from making asylum claims if they've been in Canada for more than a year. That change would not affect applications that have been submitted already but would be retroactive to June 3, assuming the bill becomes law. 'It just felt like kind of a double whammy for my friends who are in Canada, who aren't Canadian citizens but are from Myanmar, because they've already been through over four years of personal struggle,' he said. 'Restricting the people who have studied here already from accessing the (Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada) or asylum, it could be really drastic for these people.' Dawit Demoz, vice-president of the Eritrean Canadian Community Centre in Toronto, said his organization is 'deeply concerned' about the implications of the new travel ban in the U.S. for the Eritrean diaspora. He said many families in the Eritrean community south of the border remain separated due to the ongoing political and humanitarian crisis in their home country, and the new ban further complicates their efforts to reunite. '(The ban) creates additional fear and uncertainty for those seeking safety and connection across borders,' he said. 'For our community, policies like this do not just impact travel but they deepen isolation, delay reunification and compound the emotional toll experienced by displaced individuals.' — With files from The Associated Press. Our website is the place for the latest breaking news, exclusive scoops, longreads and provocative commentary. Please bookmark and sign up for our daily newsletter, Posted, here .
Winnipeg Free Press
an hour ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Political tensions real, but when chips are down Canadians, Americans show up for each other
It's an odd contradiction. One day, we're in a full-blown trade war with the United States, boycotting American whiskey and throwing around retaliatory tariffs like poker chips. The next, we're welcoming U.S. firefighters with open arms to help battle raging wildfires in northern Manitoba. This is Canada-U.S. relations in 2025. On one hand, we have tit-for-tat tariffs on steel, aluminum, lumber and other goods. On the other, we have boots on the ground — Americans working shoulder to shoulder with Canadians, risking their lives to protect our communities from natural disaster. American fire crews prepare to leave the University of Manitoba in Winnipeg, Thursday morning to help battle the province's wildfires. (Province of Manitoba) It's a jarring contrast, but it reveals something deeper about the true nature of our relationship with our neighbours to the south: when push comes to shove, ideology takes a back seat to humanity. Let's rewind. When President Donald Trump reignited his tariff playbook earlier this year — slapping duties on Canadian imports ranging from paper products to maple syrup — Canada responded in kind. Ottawa announced retaliatory tariffs, and province, including Manitoba, didn't hold back. In a highly publicized move, Manitoba Liquor & Lotteries announced it would no longer stock American-made alcohols, including some popular Tennessee bourbons and California wines. The ban remains in effect. There's been a wave of similar symbolic boycotts across the country. Cities are pulling back from U.S. construction contracts. Local officials are urging consumers to 'Buy Canadian.' Many Canadians are refusing to vacation in the U.S., even for weekend getaways. Nationalism has found a new rallying cry. And who can blame them? Trump's America-First approach has always played well with parts of the Republican base, but it comes at a cost to long-standing trade partners, such as Canada. Jobs are at risk. Exporters are left scrambling. And everyday consumers are caught in the crossfire. But just as the rhetoric ramps up in press conferences and policy briefings, something remarkable unfolds on the ground. As fires raged across northern Manitoba in recent weeks, threatening dozens of communities and displacing more than 18,000 people, Canada could rely on its old friend — the United States (and others) — for help. Approximately 100 firefighters and 25 managerial or support staff from the U.S. arrived Thursday to help extinguish the flames. About 110 more American firefighters are expected next week. No conditions. No political games. Just help. It's not the first time, of course. Canada and the U.S. have a long history of mutual aid during wildfires, floods and other natural disasters. The agreements are baked into our shared protocols and border pacts. They're largely immune to whatever political storm is brewing in Washington or Ottawa at the time. When the Fort McMurray fires devastated Alberta in 2016, for example, American crews came north. Canadian crews returned the favour during catastrophic wildfires in California. This is what neighbours do — they help each other in times of crisis. What this juxtaposition reveals is a deeper truth often lost in the political noise: real people — firefighters, volunteers, displaced families — don't live their lives according to tariff schedules or party platforms. When disaster strikes, ideology melts away. What matters is compassion, co-ordination, and trust. The people fighting fires in northern Manitoba don't care whether their counterparts voted Democrat or Republican. They care about containing the blaze, saving homes and making sure everyone gets out safely. That kind of co-operation can't be legislated or sanctioned. It comes from a bond far deeper than economics or trade agreements. It's rooted in a shared history, a cultural closeness and the lived experience of two nations that, for better or worse, are joined at the hip. So where does that leave us? We're clearly in a period of strained political relations with the U.S., fuelled by the unpredictable and narcissistic behaviour of a deranged American president. Trade fights are real, and the consequences affect livelihoods from places such as Winnipeg and Flin Flon. Wednesdays Sent weekly from the heart of Turtle Island, an exploration of Indigenous voices, perspectives and experiences. But let's not let the politics define the entire story. Because on the ground, when lives are on the line, the Canada-U.S. relationship still works. In fact, it thrives. Maybe we should take a page from our own emergency playbook. If we can collaborate so effectively during wildfires — sharing resources, respecting protocols and trusting each other's expertise — why can't we bring that same spirit to trade talks and economic policy? It's tempting for politicians to rally around a common enemy, especially when that enemy is conveniently located just south of the border. But the real world is messier. The same country that imposes unfair tariffs is also the one helping douse the flames in our backyard. In the end, maybe the best measure of a relationship isn't found in balance sheets or tariff lists. Maybe it's found in the way people show up for each other — when it really counts. Tom BrodbeckColumnist Tom Brodbeck is a columnist with the Free Press and has over 30 years experience in print media. He joined the Free Press in 2019. Born and raised in Montreal, Tom graduated from the University of Manitoba in 1993 with a Bachelor of Arts degree in economics and commerce. Read more about Tom. Tom provides commentary and analysis on political and related issues at the municipal, provincial and federal level. His columns are built on research and coverage of local events. The Free Press's editing team reviews Tom's columns before they are posted online or published in print – part of the Free Press's tradition, since 1872, of producing reliable independent journalism. Read more about Free Press's history and mandate, and learn how our newsroom operates. Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
