Right to free speech doesn't cover hate: SC notice to 5 states; Centre on Wazahat Khan's plea to club cases
NEW DELHI: The
Supreme Court
stressed Monday that "hate speech" is not covered under freedom of expression, even as it restrained police from four states from arresting Wazahat Khan, who was instrumental in the arrest of social media influencer Sharmistha Panoli for her communal posts on Pahalgam killings.
FIRs have been lodged against him for posts on X expressing hate against Hindus.
On Khan's plea that the FIRs were in retaliation for his complaint against Panoli and his comments had been deleted, the bench said, "It is not so simple. All these comments are hate-mongering".
Wazahat Khan through senior advocate D S Naidu told a bench of Justices K V Viswanathan and N Kotiswar Singh the FIRs against his client were lodged as a retaliation against his complaint to West Bengal police against Panoli, leading to her arrest.
He said Khan had made these comments in 2023, had since deleted them, and even posted a video apologising to "Hindu brothers and sisters".
Naidu said Khan is already in police and judicial custody in connection with two FIRs in West Bengal and pleaded for consolidation of the FIRs in one place as the SC had done in the past in many cases, when the FIRs have been lodged for the same offence. "He is perhaps reaping what he had sown" and learnt the lesson the hard way, the counsel said, mirroring Khan's repentance.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Memperdagangkan CFD Emas dengan salah satu spread terendah?
IC Markets
Mendaftar
Undo
Though the bench restrained police from Delhi, Assam, Haryana and Maharashtra, where separate FIRs for the same posts of Khan had been lodged, from "taking any coercive step against him", it said these posts on social media cannot be said to be covered under right to free speech guaranteed under Article 19(1(a) of the Constitution.
"Your apology says the FIRs were a retaliation to you lodging a complaint against the social media influencer.
We do not know where we are heading. Incitement to violence may not be only physical violence. It could be many other forms of violence. Hate speeches take us nowhere," Justice Viswanathan said.
He reminded Khan's counsel about a proverb - "A wound inflicted by fire may heal, but not the one inflicted with tongue". The bench issued notice to all five states, including West Bengal, and to the Union govt on Khan's plea for consolidating the FIRs in one state, or on the alternative, club the FIRs in one state at one place within the state concerned.
The bench posted further hearing on July 14.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scroll.in
28 minutes ago
- Scroll.in
India, Pakistan extend airspace closure for each other's airlines till July 24
India and Pakistan on Monday extended the closure of their airspaces for aircraft operated by each other's airlines till July 24, The Indian Express reported. A Notice to Airmen announcing the extension of the ban was issued by aviation authorities in both countries. A NOTAM is a notification system used in aviation to communicate information about changes to or hazards in national airspaces. India and Pakistan had revoked overflight rights for each other amid escalating tensions in the aftermath of the terror attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam on April 22. On April 24, Pakistan banned Indian carriers from using its airspace, after which India on April 30 closed its airspace to Pakistani aircraft and airlines. On May 23, both countries extended the airspace closures till June 24. About 800 flights per week operated by several Indian airlines have been impacted because of the closure of the Pakistani airspace, The Indian Express reported. This was due to longer duration of flights, increased fuel burn and complexities related to crew and scheduling. The terror attack at Baisaran near the town of Pahalgam on April 22 left 26 persons dead and 16 injured. The terrorists targeted tourists after asking their names to ascertain their religion, the police said. All but three of those killed were Hindu. In response to the terror attack, India launched military strikes – codenamed Operation Sindoor – on what New Delhi claimed were terrorist camps in Pakistan and Pakistan-occupied Kashmir. The Pakistan Army retaliated to Indian strikes by repeatedly shelling Indian villages along the Line of Control in Jammu and Kashmir. At least 22 Indian civilians and eight defence personnel were killed. On May 10, India and Pakistan reached an 'understanding' to halt firing
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Step-mother forces me into prostitution, please save me': 9-year-old flees Agra home, seeks help from local; woman held
AGRA: A 34-year-old woman from Agra was arrested for allegedly forcing her nine-year-old daughter, whom she had adopted two years ago, into prostitution and brutally beating her, police said on Monday. The action came after the girl, in a state of shock and terror, managed to escape from her home and sought help from a local resident. In her statement, the girl said, "My mother is forcing me into prostitution. Please save me; she has brought me here to kill me. She beats me, takes money from people and allows them to sexually assault me." Later, a purported video of the girl emerged on social media, in which she could be seen repeating her statement while showing injuries to her neck and other parts of her body. The girl also named three men who allegedly sexually assaulted her. According to the police, the girl was adopted by the woman from people known to her about two years ago. Since then, she was allegedly held captive and tortured. Officials said more suspects could be named in the FIR as the investigation progresses. ACP Sadar Bazar, Hemant Kumar, told TOI, "The matter came to the attention of the police on Sunday evening when a local resident brought the girl to the police station. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like 임플란트 최대 할인 지원해드려요 임플란터 더 알아보기 Undo An FIR has been registered against the girl's mother and three men accused of sexually assaulting the girl under BNS section 70(2) (gangrape), as well as relevant sections of the Pocso Act, 2012, and the Immoral Traffic (Prevention) Act, 1956. He added, "The girl has been sent for a medical examination. The Child Welfare Committee and the Anti-Human Trafficking Unit have been alerted. After the medical examination, the girl will be transferred to a Child Welfare Centre and we are in the process of providing her with counselling."
Time of India
35 minutes ago
- Time of India
Father kills 17-year-old for scoring low in NEET test, despite 90% in class 10
Sadhna Bhonsle , a 17-year-old girl from Sangli in Maharashtra, scored 92.6% in her Class 10 board exams — marks that many students dream of. But over a year later, she lost her life because she scored poorly in a NEET mock test. Sadhna was preparing for the NEET exam (National Eligibility cum Entrance Test), which is needed to get into medical colleges. While practising for the exam, she scored low in one of the mock tests. Her father, Dhondiram Bhonsle — a schoolteacher — became very angry. In a fit of rage, he beat Sadhna badly with a stick. She was badly hurt, especially on her head, and was taken to Ushakal Hospital in Sangli. Sadly, she died before doctors could start treatment. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Thon Cau Thon: Unsold Furniture Liquidation 2024 (Prices May Surprise You) Unsold Furniture | Search Ads Learn More Undo Her mother filed a complaint with the police on June 22, saying that her husband had beaten their daughter because of the low marks, which led to her death. The father has been arrested and is in police custody till June 24. Police said the case is still being investigated.
