Federal judge to deny Trump administration's motion to dismiss lawsuit over block on wind projects
A federal judge in Massachusetts said Wednesday he plans to deny a motion by the Trump administration to dismiss a lawsuit over its blocking of wind energy projects, siding with a coalition of state attorneys general.
Led by New York Attorney General Letitia James, attorneys general from 17 states and Washington, D.C. are suing in federal court to challenge President Donald Trump's Day One executive order halting leasing and permitting for wind energy projects.
Judge William G. Young said during a hearing that he plans to allow the case to proceed against Interior Secretary Doug Burgum, but will dismiss the action against Trump and cabinet secretaries other than Burgum named as defendants.
He said he thinks states do have standing to sue, which the federal government had argued against. The states can proceed with claims that blocking permits for wind energy projects violates the Administrative Procedure Act, which outlines a detailed process for enacting regulations, but not the Constitution, Young said.
Young said his rulings from the bench were tentative and reserved the right to alter them in writing his formal opinion.
The coalition of attorneys general sued to ask that a judge declare the executive order unlawful and approve an injunction to stop federal agencies from implementing it. They argued that Trump doesn't have the authority to halt project permitting and doing so jeopardizes the states' economies, energy mix, public health and climate goals.
The government is arguing that the states' claims amount to nothing more than a policy disagreement over preferences for wind versus fossil fuel energy development that is outside the bounds of the federal court's jurisdiction. Department of Justice Attorney Michael Robertson said in court that the wind order paused permitting, but didn't halt it, while the Interior secretary reviews the environmental impact and that this effort is underway. He said states have not shown that they were harmed by a specific permit not being issued.
Turner Smith, from the Massachusetts attorney general's office, countered that the government has provided no end date and that Trump's order imposes a 'categorical and indefinite halt." She said states have been harmed and pointed to a offshore wind project for Massachusetts, now pushed back by two years because its three outstanding permits are delayed due to the wind order. She said Massachusetts can't meet its targets for procuring offshore wind energy without the SouthCoast wind project.
Wind is the U.S.' largest source of renewable energy, providing about 10% of the electricity generated in the nation, according to the American Clean Power Association.
Trump prioritizes fossil fuels and said last week that his administration would not approve wind energy projects except in cases of emergency. The administration had ordered a Norwegian company, Equinor, to halt construction on a fully permitted offshore wind project in New York, though Equinor has been allowed to resume work.
The coalition includes Arizona, California, Colorado, Connecticut, Delaware, Illinois, Maine, Maryland, Massachusetts, Michigan, Minnesota, New Jersey, New Mexico, New York, Oregon, Rhode Island, Washington state and Washington, D.C.
___
The Associated Press' climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
30 minutes ago
- The Independent
California preps for intense fire season – as Trump slashes federal aid
California, still recovering from a series of devastating January blazes, may not be prepared for the upcoming fire season amid changes made by the Trump administration. As temperatures soar in the West, experts say that Trump's weakening of federal agencies that respond to wildfires leaves the state in a potentially precarious situation, according to The Los Angeles Times. The experts specifically referred to changes at the U.S. Forest Service, FEMA and National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration. State officials believe parts of Northern California, the Sierra Nevada and areas close to the ocean are at risk of 'significant fire potential.' 'The level of anxiety is so extreme among people who understand the consequences of converging crises,' Daniel Swain, a climate scientist with the University of California Agriculture and Natural Resources, told the newspaper. 'It's every single one of these agencies, departments and entities that would be helping us either preemptively prepare or emergently respond to wildfire events and other kinds of disasters — all of which are dysfunctional at exactly the same moment.' Trump has requested a 63 percent reduction in the U.S. Forest Service's budget. This would include a 30 percent reduction in its workforce, amounting to roughly 10,000 employees. The agency is the nation's largest firefighting entity and oversees more than half of the state's forestland. There are about 11,000 firefighters set to work during the upcoming fire season. About 3,500 of those are in the Pacific Southwest. The newspaper reported that crews that cleared flammable vegetation, scientists who studied fire conditions and employees who managed operations, technology and machinery were not protected from staffing reductions. At FEMA, Trump's administration terminated the agency's Building Resilient Infrastructure and Communities grants. The payouts went to states to prepare for disasters like wildfires. The president has further suggested cutting $646m from FEMA's budget and eliminating the agency after hurricane season. Speaking on the budget cuts, Swain said: 'The problem is when there is an extreme event or a disaster or an where people are going to mess up and make mistakes — not on purpose, not due to lack of training or lack of professionalism, but because they're being asked to do 200 things simultaneously, and all of them are life-and-death critical.' In January, 12 people died in the Palisades Fire, a blaze that directly impacted Los Angeles. Over 6,000 structures were destroyed and more than 23,000 acres were scorched.
Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Coast Guard sharpshooter Peter Stinson who made threats to kill Donald Trump is freed from prison
The former US Coastguard lieutenant charged with making online threats to kill Donald Trump has been bailed on condition that he declares his home gun-free and pays for his internet use to be monitored, can reveal. Trained sharpshooter Peter Stinson, 63, was arrested on Friday charged with making a slew of disturbing social media posts against the President, including saying he needed to be 'Luigied,' a reference to Luigi Mangione, the man accused of killing UnitedHealthcare CEO Brian Thompson in cold blood on a New York City street. But in a hearing on Wednesday, federal magistrate judge Ivan Davis said he will order the self-declared Antifa activist released on home detention provided he reveals the whereabouts of his father's 22 rifle, among other conditions. The judge's release order came despite strong objections by prosecutors, who argued that Stinson was 'dangerous' to the president and the wider public. Prosecutor Natasha Smalky pointed to a chilling February 2025 online post in which Stinson allegedly asked 'How much collateral damage is appropriate? If, say, two of the top three targets can be completed, what sort of collateral damage is ok.' He is said to have followed up with a second post justifying it by saying: 'I'd say other fascists and [orange emoticon] sycophants are fair game for sure'. A raid of Stinson's home in Oakton, Virginia, by federal investigators last week found only two BB guns – and an empty safe in his truck – but the decorated veteran of three decades had also told agents he was looking after his father's rifle, which they could not locate. A copy of the order obtained by states Stinson – who has no valid passport – is banned from obtaining a new passport or travel document, must remain at his home except for court-sanctioned exceptions and 'refrain from having contact or affiliation with any extremist organizations'. Wednesday's hearing Federal Court in Alexandria, Virginia, was told Stinson expressed interest in traveling to Uruguay and used Signal and Proton email, the encrypted communication messaging apps and stated the benefits were the messages could self-destruct. The court also heard how Stinson's partner left their home when he was arrested and had refused to be a third-party custodian if he was granted home detention – a condition the prosecution had pushed for and the judge denied. Stinson was told that if he commits a federal felony while awaiting trial he would face additional penalties of up to 10 years in prison and a $250,000 fine tacked on to whatever sentence he received. Prosecutors argued for Stinson's continued detention, highlighting the large number of online threats over several years and their 'increasing specificity and escalation' around the time of the Butler assassination attempt on Trump and the Inauguration. Stinson's lawyers argued his posts were 'political hyberbole' and there was no single online statement in which he used the word 'I' and threatened to harm or kill the president. In a court memo arguing for his pre-trial release on Tuesday, Stinson's public defender characterized the 57-year-old Virginia father's threatening comments about Trump as mere 'political advocacy' that should be protected by his First Amendment rights. Attorney Geremy Kamens argued that Stinson, a trained sharpshooter, has engaged in 'abstract' political commentary on social media over several years and had no 'specific' or 'imminent' plans to harm the president. He is listed on LinkedIn as a coordinator for the MayDay Movement, which has the goal of impeaching and removing Trump as 47th U.S. president Stinson, who served in the Coast Guard for 33 years, was arrested on Monday after a 19-page FBI affidavit alleged he made a series of threats against Trump between April 2020 and June 11, 2025. Describing Stinson as a 'devoted father of five children' with 'deep ties to his community', Kamens pointed out that his client has no 'significant' prior criminal history and does not pose a flight risk or danger to the community. In an extraordinary statement, Kamens also noted that Stinson 'repeatedly disclaimed his own ability to carry out violence', which he argues 'demonstrates' that his posts 'constitute political hyperbole' and 'disclaim any personal intention to engage in violent conduct'. The apparent disclaimers were in reference to the posts in which Stinson stated he lacks the 'skills' and is 'not a good enough shot' and would serve only in a 'support capacity.' Stinson also allegedly made graphic threats against Trump on multiple social media platforms involving guns, knives and poisoning. Stinson served in the United States Coast Guard for 33 years from 1988 until 2021. He was a sharpshooter and an instructor with the Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) during that time. He is listed on LinkedIn as a coordinator for the MayDay Movement, which has the goal of impeaching and removing Trump as president. Stinson also made several references online to '8647,' which government officials recognized as a reference to an Instagram post made by former FBI Director James Comey. To '86' means to cancel or get rid of something. Many interpreted Comey's post as a threat against Trump, who was the 45th and is now the 47th president. Stinson's arrest comes amid heightened scrutiny by federal prosecutors, who are taking an aggressive approach to threats against the president and other government officials, following previous assassination attempts on Trump. Thomas Matthew Crooks shot Trump in the ear in an assassination attempt in Butler, Pennsylvania on July 13, 2024. Crooks was taken out by counter snipers – but not before the shooter killed a rally attendee and badly injured two others. Based on the timing of that attempt on Trump's life and Stinson's social media posts, investigators found that the former Coast Guard officer was referencing the attack when he wrote: 'A missed opportunity will not come around again.' Stinson referenced online on February 6, 2025 that he didn't have the 'necessary skills' to carry out an assassination and claimed that many people and groups were plotting action. He suggested, however, in other posts that he does have those skills. The court documents come as neighbors in the quiet rural enclave in Oakton, Virginia, where Stinson lives with his wife, two high-school aged sons and their dog Betty-Lou, told of the dramatic moment FBI agents and an armored vehicle swooped on the property on Friday evening at about 5pm. One neighbor, who did not want to be named, said about 10 FBI agents in multiple unmarked vehicles with blacked out windows took over the three-bedroom house for several hours. Some of the agents were wearing heavy military fatigues, he said, but he understood they were conducting a federal search warrant. Another said when she saw an 'aggressive' armored vehicle roll into the street – which appeared to have a machine gun mounted on the back – she took her family into their basement. 'We didn't know what was happening at this stage, and we were fearful of a shootout,' she said. The locals said they did not see Stinson detained by the authorities, but that his younger son was at home during the search as they saw him standing at the top of the street Many interpreted '86 47' as a threat against Trump, since '86' means to get rid of something and Trump is the 47th president Neighbors believe the FBI had been scoping out the house – which is set back from the road in a wooded glade – all day on Friday, as they'd seen several unfamiliar cars driving down the road. Documents show Stinson was arrested in Fairfax county, on Friday before news broke of the charges against him this week. Locals were in disbelief at the charges levied against Stinson, who they described as an 'unassuming, quiet guy' and a 'nice, down-to-earth man'. 'There was nothing that gave me cause to think he'd be accused of anything like that, but we didn't really know them too well,' one said. They said Stinson and his family had been renting their home for about a year-and-a-half and 'kept themselves to themselves'. Another neighbor, who did not want to be identified, said: 'I met him on Halloween, it was a two-second conversation, he seemed nice. 'So when Friday happened, I was like, "Ok holy cow, what's going on", but they [the authorities] didn't tell us anything. 'I went outside to take out the recycling and saw them up there, and was like oh "do I need to move my vehicles?" They were like "no" and I was like "Am I safe?" and they said "you're fine". 'My husband called me earlier because he heard news of it on the radio, I only just found out what it was about today. I didn't even know his name. 'It's kind of crazy. You never know who's living next door, but unfortunately this is a time when there's a lot of people upset with a lot of things on both ways.'
Daily Mail
37 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Donald Trump stuns soccer players with dig at trans athletes during their White House visit
President Donald Trump stunned the professional soccer players standing behind him in the Oval Office with his dig at transgender athletes, asking them if women could make their men's team. The guests of honor were all in town because of the FIFA Club World Cup, with the organization's president, Gianni Infantino, standing alongside players and representatives from Italian behemoth Juventus. Included in the Juventus representation were Americans Weston McKennie and Tim Weah, who are both expected to be on the United States national team for next summer's World Cup. Trump's initial question to the soccer players in attendance at the White House was to McKennie about transgender athletes. 'Could a woman make your team fellas? Tell me, you think?' Trump said to his fellow American. McKennie looked stunned, who deferred an answer to Weah, and then Italian star Manuel Locatelli, who respectfully responded with, 'Yeah.' Trump asks the Juventus players standing behind him if women could make their team and tries to bait them into endorsing his transphobia — Aaron Rupar (@atrupar) June 18, 2025 'You're being nice,' Trump responded to Locatelli. 'What do you think, think a woman could make the team? General managers, what do you think?' Trump said, turning to some of the Juventus leadership. 'We have a very good women's team,' Juventus general manager Damien Comolli said to Trump. 'You do have it, but they should be playing with women. It's one of those things. See, they're very diplomatic. Trump's opining to professional athletes comes after his bill to ban biological male athletes from competing in women's sports fell into the senate last month. Legislation that aimed to bar trans women and girls nationwide from participating in school athletic competitions designated for female athletes failed to advance in a divided Senate as Democrats stood united against an issue that Republicans leveraged in last year's elections. A test vote on the bill failed to gain the 60 votes needed to advance in the chamber as senators stuck to party lines in a 51-45 vote tally. The bill sought to determine Title IX protections 'based solely on a person´s reproductive biology and genetics at birth.' One of the latest examples of Trump and his administration trying to block transgender athletes from competing happened in California, before the Los Angeles protests, with track athlete AB Hernandez. The rule change is temporary, according to the CIF, and not a direct response to Trump's recent online criticism of California state policy, Governor Newsom and the 16-year-old Hernandez The California Interscholastic Federation (CIF) widened the field at the high school track-and-field championships as Trump 's Department of Justice investigates the participation of a transgender athlete. California opened the event to more girls after Hernandez drew criticism for qualifying for the meet. The CIF will now permit an extra competitor in three events featuring the 16-year-old Hernandez. The rule change is temporary, according to the CIF, and not a direct response to Trump's recent online criticism of California state policy or Governor Gavin Newsom. Now, if a transgender athlete medals at this weekend's state championships outside Fresno, their ranking will not displace a 'biological female' student from medaling. So if Hernandez medals in the high jump, triple jump or long jump, the podium will include an additional competitor, who will also be awarded a medal. The federation has not announced any plans to verify whether a competitor meets the definition of 'biological female.' The American Medical Association and American Psychiatric Association have both stated that gender is a spectrum and not a binary structure, as the White House argued in its January 20 executive order 'defending women from gender ideology.' Juventus was drawn into a Club World Cup group against English powerhouse Manchester City, as well as Wydad AC from Morocco and Al Ain FC from the United Arab Emirates.
