South Florida woman says home left vulnerable for nearly 3 years after Citizens Insurance denied roof's storm damage claim
An elderly woman in Southwest Miami-Dade said her home has been left vulnerable for nearly three years after her insurance company denied coverage for roof damage caused by a storm. Now, her son is taking legal action to get her the help she needs.
Donovan Barker said his 86-year-old mother, Jean, who lives with dementia, has been living under a tarp since a storm caused significant roof damage. Nearly three years later, large portions of the roof remain underneath a tarp.
"When it rains really hard, the water hits the plastic," Barker said, pointing to a clear tarp stretched across parts of the home.
Inside, buckets line the floor to catch dripping water, and stains mark the wall.
"They go through the floor [and] start soaking up through the walls," he said. "The damage is evident."
Barker said he filed a property claim with Citizens Insurance, but after months with no resolution, he said the company offered a settlement of just $1,500.
"That can't fix anything," he said. "The roof at this point is not even reparable."
So, the family filed a lawsuit against Citizens.
According to the company, they received the original claim in July 2022 and denied it after inspecting the home. They were served with the lawsuit a year later, on June 14, 2023. In an emailed statement, a spokesperson said Citizens cannot comment further, as the case is now in litigation.
"I would like them to take full responsibility and replace it," Barker said.
He estimates the cost of a new roof will fall between $40,000 and $60,000, not including the damage inside the house.
"For it to be leaking like this in several different spots, especially in her room, it's definitely not wear and tear," he said.
Barker believes his mother is being taken advantage of because of her age and condition.
An insurance industry expert not connected to the case tells CBS News Miami that legal action is the appropriate next step following a denied claim — and it's a step many policyholders often take.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Fireworks, Declaration of Independence readings highlight Fourth of July in Newport County
There are plenty of ways to celebrate the Fourth of July from cookouts to hitting the beach and so much more, but across Newport County you can bookend the day with that patriotic feeling. Options exist to start your day by harkening back to revolutionary times with readings of the Declaration of Independence and once the sun sets of course there are fireworks to enjoy. Some events also continue through the long-weekend to keep the celebration going. We've rounded up the events taking place this holiday to get you in the spirit and go beyond the hot dogs and hamburgers. Weather permitting, this year's display in Newport is scheduled to light up the harbor beginning at approximately 9:15 p.m. on Friday, July 4, with a rain date slated for the following day on July 5. With the Fourth of July falling on a Friday this year, Newport is expected to be especially busy, and the city is asking everyone to get involved in the celebration by donating to the City's Fireworks Fund. As in previous years, Premier Sponsorships will be offered for donations of $5,000, $2,500 and $1,500; however, donations of any amount are greatly appreciated. All donors – no matter the amount – will be recognized by the City both online and in print. If you're interested in making a donation to this year's fireworks display, please make your donation check payable to the 'City of Newport' with a notation of 'Fireworks Fund' on the memo line, and mail it to the attention of the Mayor's Office, 43 Broadway, Newport, R.I. 02840. More information about the City's fireworks display can also be found on the City's website at For over 100 years, the Rhode Island Society Sons of the Revolution has hosted Newport's Independence Day Celebration, and there is no more patriotic place to celebrate America's birthday than in Newport's Historic District. The Declaration of Independence was first read to the citizens of Rhode Island from the steps of the Colony House in Newport in 1776 and each Fourth of July, the event is recreated in celebration with music, cannons and a tribute to Newport's signer of the Declaration. All events are free. 9 a.m.: A commemoration of William Ellery, Newport's signer of the Declaration of Independence, at his grave site in Newport's Common Burying Ground on Farewell Street, led by the Daughters of the American Revolution and with participation of the Rhode Island Society Sons of the Revolution, and the Artillery Company of Newport. 9 to 11 a.m.: The Newport Historical Society will provide access to the Colony House, the fourth oldest State House inAmerica, with staff present to answer questions. 9:30 a.m.: Bike Newport will hold their annual bike parade from Ellery Park at Farewell and Thames Street. Decorate your bike and enjoy the fun. 10 to 11 a.m.: A rousing Patriotic concert in Eisenhower Park in Washington Square by the Newport Community Band at Salve Regina University, Peter Davis conducting. 11 a.m.: A reading of the Declaration of Independence by Colonel Roy Lauth, from the steps of the Colony House, the spot where it was first read to the Colony in 1776 by Major John Handy. 11:30 a.m.: In Washington Square, a 21-gun salute fired by the Artillery Company of Newport, using the fourcannons purchased from Paul Revere in 1798 by the new state of Rhode Island. The Common Burying Ground, established in 1640, includes the grave of Declaration signer William Ellery and the graves of other historic figures, such as Commodore Mathew Perry, who opened Japan to the West in 1854. God's Little Acre, a section of Common Burying Ground, is the largest cemetery of enslaved people in the United States. The Colony House was one of four seats of the colonial government in Rhode Island. Here on May 6, 1776, Rhode Island declared it no longer owed allegiance to the British crown, now known as Rhode Island Independence Day. The Continental Congress's Declaration of Independence was first read from the front steps of on July 22, 1776. Join fellow citizens at 9 a.m. on the grounds of Portsmouth Free Public Library to read aloud portions of our nation's founding document, the Declaration of Independence, adopted unanimously by a fledgling Congress 249 years ago on July 4, 1776. Copies will be available or bring your own. We welcome families – children are encouraged to read a passage. In case of rain the reading will be held inside the library in the Mello Program Room. Please provide your own chair or blanket and dress for the weather. Some participants like to wear red, white and blue for the occasion. By about 9:30 a.m., you will be on your way to parades and cookouts and other celebrations of the day. Escobar's Farm, 133 Middle Road, Portsmouth, announced they will have a fireworks display on Saturday, July 5, at 9 p.m. They will also host a tractor show beginning at 11 a.m. and the farm's concession stand will be open. At 9 a.m. the Tiverton Historical Society will hold the annual public reading of the Declaration of Independence at the WWI Doughboy memorial statue on the Tiverton Bicentennial Green by the old Stone Bridge next to Grinnell's Beach. This public reading is not like any other; those present are encouraged to read a marked passage from the Declaration so 'We the People' can all participate. Before the reading, a brief history of events of past years, including those leading up to the creation of the Declaration, is recounted. This typically takes less than half an hour, so you'll have plenty of time to celebrate the rest of the weekend. Held rain or shine. The event is scheduled for Sunday, July 6 at East Ferry. Music at 7 p.m. and fireworks at 9 p.m. This article originally appeared on Newport Daily News: July 4th fireworks, Declaration of Independence in Newport County
Yahoo
23 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Tracking heat, humidity, and sunshine
The hottest days of 2025 so far lie ahead for Northwest Missouri and Northeast Kansas as a heat wave builds into the region starting Friday and continuing through the weekend. A Heat Advisory has been posted area wide from 1 p.m. Friday to 7 p.m. Saturday. Heat index values of 100 to 106 degrees are expected both Friday and Saturday afternoon, increasing the risk for heat related illness. A sunny and toasty Thursday afternoon will give way to a pleasant evening, with temperatures falling into the 70s after sunset and clear skies through the overnight hours. Sunshine will continue on Friday with afternoon highs reaching the mid to upper 90s, and southerly winds of 10 to 15 mph. High humidity will result in triple digit heat indices Friday afternoon. Saturday will bring a repeat performance, with highs in the mid to upper 90s, abundant sunshine, and heat indices in the triple digits. Southerly winds will pick-up Saturday, at 15 to 25 mph with gusts occasionally over 30mph.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Earthquake reported Thursday in Northeast Ohio
[Get earthquake facts in the player above.] MADISON, Ohio (WJW) — The U.S. Geological Survey reported a 2.3-magnitude earthquake near Madison, in Lake County, on Thursday afternoon. It happened just before 1 p.m. a little more than a mile south-southeast of Madison, near Hogback Ridge Park, and about 3 miles below ground, according to the agency. Driver dies after car plunges into Portage Lakes As of Thursday afternoon, the agency had received 16 reports from people claiming they felt the shake. It was the third earthquake reported this week near the same geographical coordinates, according to the Ohio Department of Natural Resources' earthquake database. Two minor quakes of 1.3- and 2.0-magnitude — both at different depths — were reported in the early morning hours of Tuesday, June 17. LOOK: Winds tip over semi, damage cemetery Thursday's was the eighth earthquake reported in the area so far this year. The strongest was a 2.5-magnitude quake reported on May 12, according to the data. There were 38 earthquakes there in 2024, all under a 2.0 magnitude. Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
