History Shows Patients At Risk From Physician Associates
Press Release – New Zealand Nurses Organisation
The introduction of physician associates is an unnecessary quick and cheap fix to the doctor shortage when we have a competent and experienced nurse practitioner workforce available to do this work.
Avoidable harm caused to patients both in New Zealand and in the United Kingdom shows the introduction of physician associates is a risk to patient safety, New Zealand Nurses Organisation Tōpūtanga Tapuhi Kaitiaki o Aotearoa (NZNO) says.
Health Minister Simeon Brown has announced that physician associates will be regulated as a new profession in New Zealand.
NZNO President Anne Daniels says the introduction of the new, overseas trained workforce, leaves patients vulnerable to misdiagnoses or worse. Similar concerns have also been raised by the Resident Doctors' Association.
'Here in New Zealand there have been concerns physician associates have failed to take a patient's blood pressure, leading to a brain bleed and loss of vision.
'In the United Kingdom where physician associates have been part of the health sector for the past 20 years, there has been a litany of issues including the misdiagnosis of an aggressive breast cancer resulting in the death of a young mother, opiates illegally prescribed, failure to detect a deadly pulmonary embolism and a drain left in a patient's abdomen.'
Anne Daniels says nurses are focused on providing the safe, high-quality and culturally appropriate care New Zealanders expect and deserve.
'The introduction of physician associates is an unnecessary quick and cheap fix to the doctor shortage when we have a competent and experienced nurse practitioner workforce available to do this work. The Minister must immediately stop the introduction and regulation of physician associates here,' she says.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Techday NZ
36 minutes ago
- Techday NZ
Toast Electric expands to help families facing winter hardship
Toast Electric has announced its expansion into Horowhenua and Wairarapa as many New Zealand families enter winter unable to afford adequate heating for their homes. The community enterprise, which is currently serving 1,100 homes and supporting over 250 families through its Energy Wellbeing programme, was launched by Sustainability Trust in 2022. It uses a model where every four paying households or small businesses switching to Toast supports one household experiencing energy hardship. Phil Squire, Head of Toast and a national expert in healthy homes assessments, stated that current compliance measures are insufficient to ensure the wellbeing of families. Squire commented, "Too many New Zealanders are being failed by a system that confuses compliance with care. This winter, we're seeing families who are in homes that are technically 'compliant' with the rental Healthy Homes Standards but still living in freezing conditions, making impossible trade-offs between heating and food. Compliance doesn't guarantee wellbeing and it's time we stopped pretending it does." The Energy Wellbeing programme offers a mix of assistance, including affordable electricity pricing with a 30% discount during winter, reconnection services for families cut off from power, and in-home energy advice from trained assessors. Squire described the model: "It's not just a bill reduction - it's a full-circle model that focuses on what truly makes a home healthy and liveable." Households join Toast through a network of financial mentors and social service agencies that offer financial advice and broader support prior to referral. Data from Consumer NZ and the University of Otago indicates more than 360,000 households in New Zealand experience energy hardship. In the past year, over 140,000 families have taken out loans to pay energy bills, with more than 40,000 homes at risk of disconnection annually. Squire said, "These are not edge cases - they are the reality for hundreds of thousands of families, many of them renting in poor-quality housing stock that remains difficult or outright unaffordable to heat." Issues with compliance The Healthy Homes Standards were designed to improve rental housing quality, yet Squire highlighted limitations in enforcement and actual measurement of outcomes. He noted, "The current system allows landlords to self-certify compliance and take advantage of multiple exemptions, meaning many rental homes may appear up to standard on paper but remain cold, damp and unhealthy in practice." Toast is calling for a national Home Energy Warrant of Fitness (WOF), similar to systems in place in Europe and the UK. The Home Energy WOF would require independent, licensed assessors to verify whether homes are safe, warm, and energy-efficient. Squire posed the question: "We wouldn't let someone certify their own car as why are we doing that with the places people sleep, raise their children and try to stay healthy?" Programme impact The Toast model is underpinned by reinvested revenue and aims to offer not only electricity savings but also improved living conditions. The organisation stresses that support should go beyond asking families to use less power, ensuring homes become healthier and more affordable to run. Story examples from those assisted by Toast illustrate the ongoing need. One Wellington man who had been without electricity for two years was finally reconnected via the Energy Wellbeing programme, and described being able to take a hot shower without using a torch. Others reflected on the relief of being able to turn on heating without fear of an unaffordable bill. Research from the University of Otago has identified broader effects of reducing energy bill-related stress. Dr Kimberley O'Sullivan, who is leading research into Toast Electric's Energy Wellbeing programme, stated, "We've heard from Toast Electric's referral partners, Energy Wellbeing Customers and Regular Customers who all wellbeing and describe how relieving electricity bill stress enables them to feel more comfortable and relaxed at home and better connect with their family, friends and community. Regular customers also feel good about being able to help others in need while paying their electricity bills they would already be paying. Toast Electric's not-for-profit model is working within the market framework to deliver essential electricity and improve wellbeing." Looking ahead Toast's current plans include expanding into Horowhenua and Wairarapa, and doubling its customer base over the next year, in addition to growing its network of referral agencies. The organisation maintains its focus on supporting families and challenging existing systems of compliance and measurement within the energy and housing sectors. "Energy should be a right, not a luxury," says Squire. "And until we make that true for every family in Aotearoa, we're not done."
RNZ News
an hour ago
- RNZ News
The pluses and minuses in 12 month prescriptions
From next year, patients will be able to get prescriptions covering 12 months, rather than the current three. Announcing the move, the Health Minister Simeon Brown said it would put money in patient's pockets as they wouldn't have to pay for long term medications four times a year, and reduce GPs' paperwork. But GPs have raised concerns that patient safety could be at risk and that recommendations to extend the prescribing period to six months were ignored. Pharmacists say there will be benefits for some patients, but also funding implications, an increased chance of wastage and misunderstandings over those medicines not included, such as controlled drugs. Kathryn's joined by Luke Bradford the Medical Director of the Royal College of New Zealand GPs and Andrew Gaudin the chief executive of the Pharmacy Guild. Tags: To embed this content on your own webpage, cut and paste the following: See terms of use.
Scoop
3 hours ago
- Scoop
Elective Boost Delivers Over 9,500 Additional Procedures So Far
Minister of Health More than 9,500 additional procedures have now been delivered as part of the Government's elective boost, Health Minister Simeon Brown says. 'This is what putting patients first looks like. We are focused on increasing delivery of elective treatments – across both public and private hospitals – to reduce wait times for Kiwis needing procedures like hip replacements or cataract surgery,' Mr Brown says. Through this initiative, Health New Zealand is partnering with private hospitals to expand surgical capacity across the country. The plan aims to deliver over 10,579 additional elective procedures by the end of June – a target now well within reach, with 9,696 procedures completed by the week ending 11 May. Of those, 8,631 were delivered through outsourcing. Common procedures being delivered include: Hip and knee replacements Cataract surgeries Hernia repairs Tonsillectomies Ear operations Mr Brown says the programme is targeting those who've faced the longest delays, with almost 60 per cent of patients having waited over four months for their surgery. 'Our goal is clear – 95 per cent of patients receiving elective treatment within four months by 2030. This is a key health target, and we're getting on with the job of delivering it. 'We are investing a record $30 billion annually in health, with a strong focus on boosting frontline services, reducing waiting times, and ensuring better outcomes for patients. 'By unlocking capacity across the entire health system, we're delivering faster treatment and shorter wait times – and that's exactly what Kiwis deserve,' Mr Brown says.
