Yanfei Bao's killer Tingjun Cao removed from court after interrupting sentencing
Tingjun Cao is removed from court on Friday.
Photo:
CHRIS SKELTON
The man who murdered Christchurch real estate agent Yanfei Bao has been removed from his own sentencing hearing after constant outbursts and interjections.
Chinese national Tingjun Cao attacked Bao in July 2023 after luring her to a Hornby home she was selling, before killing her and burying her body in farmland.
He continues to protest his innocence, blaming a fictional Mr Tang for the murder.
Justice Preston closed the court to the public this morning following Cao's outbursts.
Photo:
CHRIS SKELTON
As the sentencing hearing began this morning, Cao would interrupt in Mandarin and gesticulate towards his lawyers.
He made protestations about evidence he claimed would demonstrate his innocence, leading to Justice Lisa Preston closing the court to the public to address his outbursts.
However, when court resumed, Cao again leapt to his feet and began interrupting in Mandarin.
As a result, Justice Preston ordered Cao be removed from the court.
As Corrections officers escorted him from the court, he continued speaking loudly and gesticulating.
His final protest came as he ripped up his papers, bundled them into a ball and threw them to the ground.
His seven-week jury trial last year was also marked by Cao's odd displays.
He sacked his defence lawyers during the trial and represented himself with the help of a trio of interpreters.
Justice Lisa Preston repeatedly warned Cao about asking irrelevant questions, making meandering and repetitive statements, and accusing witnesses of lying.
The prosecution described the case against Cao as an "absolute slam dunk" with compelling and overwhelming evidence demonstrating his guilt.
However, Cao claimed he was at the centre of a conspiracy and police officers had lied, fabricated, planted and doctored evidence to frame him.
In delivering his closing argument he regularly turned and spoke to the glass panes of an empty dock and at other times rambled through measurements and minutiae which were difficult to link to his claims of innocence or the case.
Cao lured the 44-year-old Yanfei Bao to the Hornby home on 19 July 2023 under the pretence of wanting to view the property.
There he attacked her, bundled her into the boot of his car and drove her to a remote rural road near Lincoln where he killed her.
He buried her in a shallow grave along the treeline of a farm in Greenpark where police found her remains almost a year later.
Bao's partner, Paul Gooch, reported her missing the day she vanished after discovering his wife had not collected her daughter from an after-school programme, had not come home for lunch and calls to her phone went unanswered.
Police found Bao's phone in grass beside the southern motorway two days later.
Cao was arrested on his way to Christchurch Airport in the days after her disappearance with a one-way ticket to Shanghai.
He was initially charged with Bao's kidnapping but the charged was later dropped. Cao was charged with murder in September 2023.
Following the jury's guilty verdict Gooch yelled at Cao: "You might want to get a refund on that plane ticket you scum bag".
The Sentencing Act contained a presumption convicted murderers would be sentenced to life imprisonment unless such a sentence was manifestly unjust.
If Justice Preston sentenced to life, Cao would spend no less than a decade behind bars, but the judge could also engage section 104 of Sentencing Act which allowed judges to impose a non-parole period of at least 17 years for particularly egregious murders.
Cao is now watching his sentencing hearing from another courtroom.
Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero, a daily newsletter
curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RNZ News
13 hours ago
- RNZ News
One dead, three injured in Waikato crash
One person died in the crash at Te Aroha. Photo: St John One person died and three were injured in a two vehicle crash at Te Aroha in Waikato on Friday afternoon. Police said the crash on Stanley Road South was reported just before 1.40pm. One person died at the scene, a second person was seriously injured and two people sustained moderate injuries, police said. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
14 hours ago
- RNZ News
Two arrested after man hid in ceiling, robbed Marton store while closing
Photo: A man has been charged after allegedly hiding in the ceiling space of a store in Marton and then threatening an employee with a weapon before fleeing with a large amount of cash. Police said that at 10pm on 10 May, the employee had closed and locked the store and was then confronted by the man. Detective Sergeant Carey Priest said the employee was not injured but was understandably shaken by the incident. A subsequent police investigation found the man, who police said also burgled the store a month earlier. Police have arrested and charged two men in relation to both incidents on counts of aggravated robbery and burglary. A 39 year old appeared in court on 12 June, while a 49 year old will appear on 17 June. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
RNZ News
14 hours ago
- RNZ News
Coronial inquest into LynnMall attack completes first phase
Ahamed Samsudeen coming out of the New Lynn train station, on the day of the attack on 3 September, 2021. Photo: Supplied The first phase of the coronial inquest into the LynnMall attack four years ago has concluded in Auckland on Friday. Ahamed Samsudeen was shot and killed by police, after stabbing four women and one man with a kitchen knife at a Countdown supermarket in Auckland's New Lynn. Two others were injured trying to stop him. Phase one of the inquiry began last week, with two more phases expected to sit later this year. Samsudeen was granted refugee status in 2013, identified by the SIS as a terrorist threat in early 2017 and under surveillance at the time of the attack. Coroner Marcus Elliott set out the path the inquest would take last year, ruling it would cover Samsudeen's path to extremism, his management in the community and what happened on the day he died. In the first phase covering the day of the attack, the coroner heard from survivors, who talked about their experiences and the impact the attack had on them in the years since. CCTV footage was examined frame by frame, with police staff providing evidence on tracking Samsudeen's movements and the actions taken by officers leading up to his shooting. Giving closing statements, police counsel Alysha McClintock said the task of the coroner was a delicate one. "In my submission, great, great care is needed with the precision of hindsight that we now have and with the precision of these stills we have been carefully working our way through," she said. "We have to take great care in trying to analyse in the cold light of day, in this courtroom, that material and use it as a possible ability to essentially rewrite what should have happened. In my submission, that is very dangerous indeed." Earlier in the day, the inquest heard officers had no option but to use lethal force , after failing to de-escalate the situation. McClintock said questions around using a taser to subdue Samsudeen were obvious, but ultimately, that wouldn't have changed what happened. "The evidence that has been given in this inquiry, in my submission, has made it clear that the carrying of a taser would have made no difference in this situation, given the risk presented by what Mr Samsudeen was doing at the critical time," McClintock said. Representing officers involved in the attack, lawyer Todd Simmonds said their decision not to follow Ahamed Samsudeen into the supermarket that day was sound. "It was, knowing what they knew at the time, an appropriate decision to make," he said. Simmonds echoed McClintock's warning about hindsight. He said surveillance officers were not equipped to follow Samsudeen into the supermarket. "Even if they had followed Mr Samsudeen into the supermarket on the afternoon in question... they would not have been in a position to incapacitate Mr Samsudeen from his ongoing attack on members of the public," Simmonds said. Simmonds asked Coroner Marcus Elliott to consider acknowledging the actions of police on the day in his findings. Representing the interests of Ahamed Samsudeen's family, lawyer Fletcher Pilditch said the benefit of the coronial process was that the coroner wasn't bound to label something simply wrong or right. "The court's not bound by those polar positions" he said. "The court's in the position where it can simply, calmly, with the benefit of a great deal of information, reflect upon the facts and invite those that were involved... in this incident to simply reflect on those facts and to invite consideration going forward. "That can be done, as I say, without any criticism, without any second-guessing of the IPCA or the findings of justified use of force - it can simply be the presentation of facts." Pilditch said earlier intervention could have made a difference. "His window of opportunity to inflict harm was the very opportunity created by not being surveilled within that time," he said. "The hard reality is that, if there had been an earlier intervention, a) no-one or less people may have been harmed, and b) Mr Samsudeen may well have found himself alone in the supermarket, but for armed [Special Tactic Group] officers. Lead counsel assisting the coroner Anna Adams was the last to give a closing statement, recapping the facts of the case, the surveillance of Samsudeen, his radical terrorist ideas and interests, and his history. She said Samsudeen's death affected many people. "First of all, of course, Mr Samsudeen has loving, surviving family members, who live overseas and grieve his death. "There are the survivors, there are the officers, people most affected by this phase of the inquest, but there are also, of course, Mr Samsudeen's lawyer, the people at the mosque where he stayed - they have all suffered trauma as a result of these events." Coroner Marcus Elliott concluded the phase, thanking those who took part. He acknowledged the profound personal consequences and harm suffered by so many due to the events leading up to and during the attack, before finishing with a karakia. Sign up for Ngā Pitopito Kōrero , a daily newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
