logo
Whistleblower protections failed 'superhero' Richard Boyle, calls grow for urgent reforms

Whistleblower protections failed 'superhero' Richard Boyle, calls grow for urgent reforms

Richard Boyle has faced the heavy price of being a whistleblower in Australia.
The law suggests that if you blow the whistle on wrongdoing, you will be protected.
But, in Boyle's case, it didn't protect him.
Nor did the federal government, which could have, at any stage, requested the Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (CDPP) drop all the charges against Boyle.
More than eight years after the former ATO debt collector internally spoke out about the ATO's heavy-handed debt recovery practices, Boyle has stopped fighting for justice.
His decision to reveal unethical practices at the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) — while helping the lives of many taxpayers — ultimately destroyed his, and his wife Louise Beaston's lives.
"I personally am broken, physically, mentally, and financially", Boyle said, in a recent public address at the 2024 Walkley Awards.
He talked of how he and Louise should have "been starting a family, buying a house, settling into the routines of life together", but instead were, "completely and utterly broken".
On Tuesday, Boyle pleaded guilty to four charges of disclosing protected information, making a record of protected information, using a listening device to record private conversations and recording another person's tax file number.
The 49-year-old struck a plea deal under which Senator Rex Patrick — who has long been fighting on behalf of Boyle for the charges against him to be dropped — said Boyle would avoid jail.
While many of the original 66 charges against Boyle were withdrawn by the CDPP before the case went to trial, it highlights that being a whistleblower in Australia isn't appreciated.
Boyle may have avoided 161 prison years, which was the potential penalty he could theoretically have faced under the initial very long list of charges, but the question still begs, why even prosecute a whistleblower?
Legal experts and human rights groups say the re-elected Albanese government must now urgently reform both public and private sector whistleblower laws and establish an independent Whistleblower Protection Authority to give support to, and better protect, those who blow the whistle.
It's worth noting that this is not the first time that people blowing the whistle on the ATO have claimed they have faced a lack of protections.
In 2012, when there were virtually no whistleblower protections in place for public servants, Ron Shamir uncovered how the ATO was wrongly tagging some claims as fraudulent. He lost his job.
The former senior ATO insider, who was sacked by the ATO in mid-2015 for non-performance (he took his case to the Fair Work Commission, winning initially but losing on appeal) told a federal inquiry that the body that promised to protect him failed.
In 2012, the agency was also accused by others of abusing its power and wasting taxpayers' money on court cases designed simply to chase revenue rather than enforce the law.
Boyle's case was the first test case of the Public Interest Disclosure (PID) Act introduced a year later.
This act is supposed to promote "the integrity and accountability of the Commonwealth public sector by creating a framework for facilitating the reporting of suspected wrongdoing and ensuring timely and effective investigation of reports".
Boyle first made a public interest disclosure within the ATO, internally, revealing the agency's heavy-handed tactics.
In mid-2017, while working as a debt recovery officer at the ATO's Adelaide office, he shared how agency staff across the country were instructed to take money out of people's bank accounts — regardless of whether the debts raised against them by the ATO were justified or not — thereby unjustly targeting many small to medium size businesses.
Boyle then made a complaint to the Tax Ombudsman before going public with his revelations in a joint Four Corners-Fairfax Media (now Nine) investigation.
Follow-up reviews confirmed that Boyle's revelations of aggressive debt-recovery practices at the ATO at the time were valid, with the small business ombudsman at the time saying the agency's then treatment of small businesses was "crippling".
And a parliamentary report later also found that the ATO's investigation into Boyle's public interest disclosure was 'superficial'.
Boyle's home was raided after he spoke out publicly, and he's spent almost a decade trying to claim protection under public interest disclosure laws.
The Albanese government is currently reviewing both public and private sector whistleblower laws, and many hope that changes will close existing loopholes that have failed to protect Boyle and other whistleblowers.
Senator Rex Patrick says it was accepted that Boyle's disclosure was not dealt with properly by the ATO and that the agency "botched the investigation into his claims" and did nothing until their inappropriate activity was aired as part of the joint Fairfax-Four Corners investigation.
He says the ATO charged Boyle, not for blowing the whistle, but for what he did in preparing his disclosure — namely using his mobile phone to take photographs of taxpayer information, covertly recording conversations with ATO colleagues; and uploading photographs of taxpayer information to his lawyer's encrypted email account.
Patrick says the Court of Appeal found that those preparatory acts were not covered by protections in the Public Interest Disclosure Act and as such, he was not immune from prosecution.
"Section 6 of the Public Interest Disclosure Act lists four objectives that seek to protect and encourage whistleblowers," Patrick said.
Kieran Pender, associate legal director at the Human Rights Law Centre says, "while it is welcome that Boyle will avoid jail, he should never have been prosecuted".
He says the fact that the Court of Appeal in Richard Boyle's case found that whistleblower protections don't apply to conduct before the blowing of the whistle, was a "very narrow approach".
"It means in cases like this when people record conversations and so on for blowing the whistle, there's no protection for that," Pender said.
AJ Brown, a professor of public policy and law at Griffith University and a board member of Transparency International Australia, says the prosecution against Boyle was a waste of taxpayers' time and money.
The former Tax Commissioner Chris Jordan in 2019 used parliamentary privilege to hit back at what he labelled "sensational" media reporting and said the ATO took "whistleblowing very seriously".
Brown said the ATO did not adequately respond to Boyle's disclosure about maladministration.
Brown says reasonable actions by whistleblowers to secure information to protect themselves against reprisal should attract the protections and immunity but in Boyle's case hasn't because of a "loophole that the ATO exploited".
"In this case, there were technical breaches of secrecy laws to secure the information used to then blow the whistle, but they have been legally able to treat it as separate to his whistleblowing," he said.
One of the other ways to ensure that whistleblowers aren't prosecuted is for the Albanese government to set up an independent national body that is tasked with hearing their complaints and protecting them.
Earlier this year the Whistleblower Protection Authority Bill was proposed and introduced by Andrew Wilkie, Helen Haines, Senator David Pocock and Senator Jacqui Lambie.
It seeks to do what lawyers and human rights groups have long been calling for — establish a federal body with the power to oversee and enforce whistleblower protections, facilitate whistleblower disclosures, and safeguard whistleblowers from inside government or business who expose corruption and wrongdoing.
Pender says such an authority — which many other countries have set up — would ensure that people like Boyle, who speak up for others, are properly protected and supported.
"It's been 31 years since a parliamentary inquiry recommended a whistleblower protection authority in Australia and we're still waiting for one," he said.
Senator Rex Patrick notes that while the prosecution has not sought a custodial sentence, a penalty has not yet been imposed.
Submissions will be made in August, when the case returns to court, with a sentencing outcome expected soon thereafter.
Patrick thinks it is unlikely the court will seek a jail term in circumstances where the prosecutor doesn't also seek that outcome.
But he says Boyle does still run the risk of having a conviction recorded against his name, which will be a "chain around his neck every time he seeks to apply for a job".
"We need more people like Richard in Australia."

Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

US reviewing AUKUS as Trump pursues ‘America first agenda'
US reviewing AUKUS as Trump pursues ‘America first agenda'

News.com.au

time12 minutes ago

  • News.com.au

US reviewing AUKUS as Trump pursues ‘America first agenda'

The US is reviewing the AUKUS defence pact with Australia and the UK to ensure it aligns with Donald Trump's 'America First' agenda. Australia has already spent billions on laying the groundwork to acquire and build nuclear-powered submarines and train personnel to crew them as part of the partnership. US defence officials said overnight the move was about 'ensuring the highest readiness of our servicemembers'. 'The Department is reviewing AUKUS as part of ensuring that this initiative of the previous Administration is aligned with the President's America First agenda,' they told media. 'As Secretary Hegseth has made clear, this means ensuring the highest readiness of our servicemembers, that allies step up fully to do their part for collective defence, and that the defence industrial base is meeting our needs. 'This review will ensure the initiative meets these common sense, America First criteria.'

With a strong mandate, heat is on PM to improve investment landscape for Aussie gas
With a strong mandate, heat is on PM to improve investment landscape for Aussie gas

News.com.au

time23 minutes ago

  • News.com.au

With a strong mandate, heat is on PM to improve investment landscape for Aussie gas

Anthony Albanese's second term showing positive signs for Australia's gas sector However, reform of approvals process is unlikely Investment still occurring in Queensland with Shell reported to be bringing in high spec rig Australia's gas sector has been in the doldrums for some time now thanks to a decade-long period of underinvestment caused by regulatory uncertainty, approval delays, policy interventions and unattractive investment climate. However, the strong mandate Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is bringing into his second term could deliver changes to revive the sector, particularly at a time where there is growing concern about gas supply constraints on the East Coast. Australian Energy Market Operator chief executive officer Daniel Westerman said earlier in 2025 that flexible gas-powered generation 'will remain the ultimate backstop in a high-renewable power system." 'Gas, alongside batteries and pumped hydro, will enable higher renewable contributions and support reliability as coal-fired power stations retire,' he added. Speaking to Stockhead, MST Access head of energy research Saul Kavonic said there were some positive signs, one of which is Queensland Senator Murray Watt replacing Tanya Plibersek in the high-profile environment and water portfolio. 'I think we'll see less politically driven holdups of approvals,' he noted. Kavonic adds that we have been seeing rhetoric, including from the Prime Minister, highlighting the role for gas. 'A lot of what's driving this is under nearly every scenario going forward where they see coal exiting or retiring from the grid, the need for gas capacity increases,' he said. 'What I think the government has realised ... (is) that gas capacity is actually going to be one of the biggest logjams to delivering any of the pathways for the NEM going forward. 'That's why you're seeing moves from Victorian Energy Minister, Lily D'Ambrosio, who really didn't want to even talk about gas for the last several years, now urgently wants to have taxpayers fund an import terminal to solve the gas capacity issue.' Managing expectations However, Kavonic was quick to douse hopes there will be major changes, saying reform of the approvals process is unlikely. While the delays faced by the North West Shelf extension was due to politically held-up approvals, Kavonic said, there was a broader issue where approvals for smaller projects take years rather than months like they used to. 'That's not the Environment Minister deliberately standing on a hose for political agenda,' he said. 'This is just an issue with a lot of inertia and, in some cases, hostility within departments, which just sees them sitting on things needlessly for a long period of time.' Kavonic also noted that the industry continued to view New South Wales and Victoria as being hostile to gas developments, which diminishes the appetite for investment. He highlighted Minister D'Ambrosio's apparent hostility to gas in her social media. 'If you're a gas company, why would you deploy money in Victoria if that's all the noise that you are getting out of the government.' Kavonic also noted that while Santos' (ASX:STO) Narrabri coal seam gas project had cleared some initial hurdles – including the recent ruling by the Native Title Tribunal that the New South Wales State Government can lease the land to Santos, it still had a lot more hurdles to clear regarding pipeline access. 'Narrabri is quite unique, it's got a much stronger local level of opposition there, which predates a lot of the more climate minded opposition we've seen to gas over the last five years,' he added. More generally, he said the language from the Labor Government, particularly post the election, has dramatically improved and become more pragmatic. 'But industry wants to see actions to match the words before they start deploying capital in a material way again.' What needs to be done? Kavonic says there are three things the government can do to really improve the gas sector's fortunes, the biggest of which is to streamline the approvals process. 'The government needs to put in place a clear one-stop shop for approvals, streamline the process, and provide a very clear and more rapid timeframe for a decision," he said. The second is to deliver on its commitment to reform the offshore consultation process, which Kavonic said was held up when a deal with the Greens emerged as a potential hurdle. 'I think industry is going to want to see that reform happen. It would be a very important indicator from the government that they are actually being more pragmatic," he said. 'There should be a lot more room to be pragmatic. First of all, the Greens have been completely destroyed in the lower house and while they still hold the balance of power in the Senate, they are also in complete disarray. 'If there was ever an opportunity to get something done it should be sooner rather than later.' The last area relates to the current review underway on East Coast gas policy regarding pricing. 'Industry really wants to see a sign from government that the interventions are going to stop,' Kavonic said. 'Pulling back from more draconian East Coast interventions would also be an important signal but everything right now suggests that they're going to go the other way and toughen up those approvals and potentially impose a form of reservation policy on the East Coast. "When you give contradictory signals uncertainty remains high and people don't want to deploy investment.' Gas investment bright spots It isn't all doom and gloom though. Kavonic points out there's still investment activity with Shell bringing in a heavy duty, high-spec rig to drill the highly prospective Taroom Trough in Queensland. The supermajor typically only makes major investments in upstream exploration when it is sure of its returns. Kavonic thinks increased discussions of LNG imports will eventually be good for local developers in Queensland and gas storage solutions, as increased development of assets to pipe gas from north to south looms as a better option than LNG. Queensland has also flagged its interest in attracting more upstream gas investment with the Crisafulli government releasing nine new areas across the Cooper/Eromanga and Bowen/Surat Basins in late May. 'The best way to bring down energy prices is to have more energy in the market, and that starts with exploration,' State Minister for Natural Resources and Mines Dale Last said. 'These steps are about unlocking new supply, securing an investment pipeline and getting the right policy settings in place so Queensland can lead the way on energy security. 'Unscientific decisions made by the southern states have left Queensland carrying the load for the East Coast gas market. We need a regulatory framework that supports new development, instead of holding it back.' Gas companies With Queensland still keen on gas, it is no surprise that some of the most active gas players on the ASX are focused on that state. QPM Energy (ASX:QPM) for one has been taking steps to progress its producing Moranbah gas project further. Since acquiring Moranbah in 2023, the company has increased the project's 2P reserve position by 166PJ to 435PJ (at April 2025), making its 315PJ of uncontracted gas reserves one of the largest uncontracted gas portfolios in the Eastern Australian market. At current production of ~10-11PJ/year, the company has ~40 years of 2P reserve life. It recently executed new funding agreements with foundation customer Dyno Nobel that includes a prepayment facility of up to $40m for gas delivered from April 2026 to March 2033. This adds to the existing $120m Development Funding Facility (DFF) which is not repaid in cash but rather amortises as QPM delivers gas into a gas sales agreement with Dyno Nobel. QPM is currently finalising planning for a new production well drilling program targeted to begin later this year to be funded under the DFF. It also expects to see improved economics from July when a new, much lower cost structure under the new contracts reached with Townsville Power Station and North Queensland Gas Pipeline kicks in. The project currently produces 22-24 terajoules of gas per day from more than 125 wells. Existing infrastructure includes over 500km of gas-gathering and water pipelines, a 150km electricity distribution network, 64TJ/d of compression capacity, the 160 megawatt Townsville power station and the 12.8MW Moranbah power station. Over in the Taroom Trough, companies such as Omega Oil & Gas (ASX:OMA) and Elixir Energy (ASX:EXR) have seen significant results from their respective projects. This lends further credence to the potential of the Taroom Trough that Shell seems so keen to pursue. Meanwhile, Comet Ridge (ASX:COI) holds a 57.14% interest in the Mahalo Gas Project joint venture with Santos, which has a proved and probable (2P) gas reserves of 266 petajoules and a further 315PJ in best estimate (2C) contingent gas resources. Santos is currently progressing a front-end engineering and design study for Mahalo while pipeline partner Jemena is pushing ahead with FEED for a 10 inch pipeline over about 80km that will connect the field with key pipeline infrastructure. The company also holds the Mahalo North and East projects that could feed gas into the Mahalo hub. Despite the concerns facing projects in the southern states, Advent Energy – an unlisted company that's 36% owned by BPH Energy (ASX:BPH) – is seeking a judicial review to affirm its PEP 11 permit in the offshore Sydney Basin. Advent continues to maintain that the permit is in force with respect to matters such as reporting, payment of rents and the various provisions of the Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage Act 2006. Its interest in PEP 11 is due to its belief that the permit could host multiple trillion cubic feet of gas, which could go a long way towards meeting East Coast gas demand.

Two bodies found at Sydney Northern Beaches granny flat
Two bodies found at Sydney Northern Beaches granny flat

News.com.au

time27 minutes ago

  • News.com.au

Two bodies found at Sydney Northern Beaches granny flat

Two bodies have been found in a granny flat on a property in Sydney's Northern Beaches. Officers found two bodies inside the home when they searched the property on Cannons Parade in Forestville on Wednesday evening. A police spokeswoman said a 'concern for welfare' was reported on Wednesday about 9.30pm. It has been reported neighbours raised the alarm after not seeing the home's occupants for several days, as per Today. A crime scene has been established at the property, with police yet to determine the circumstances of the deaths, the spokeswoman said. 'Officers attached to Northern Beaches Police Area Command attended and found the bodies of two people located in a granny flat at the rear of the property,' they said. 'The bodies are yet to be formally identified.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into the world of global news and events? Download our app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store