California to appeal after judge dismisses lawsuit over Trump tariffs
A United States judge dismissed California's challenge to Donald Trump's tariffs, allowing the state to file an appeal over the court's ruling that the dispute should have been filed in a specialized US trade court in New York.
The ruling, handed down late on Monday by US district judge Jacqueline Corley in San Francisco, did not delve into the merits of California's lawsuit. Now, three separate US appeals courts may simultaneously consider the legality of Trump's sweeping tariffs on US trading partners and a separate set of tariffs targeting imports from China, Mexico and Canada.
Since February, Trump has issued new tariffs, paused tariffs from taking effect, and raised and lowered rates as he attempts to negotiate new trade deals with other nations. The on-again and off-again tariffs have whipsawed businesses who work with international suppliers.
Although legal experts expect that the US supreme court will ultimately decide the legality of the tariffs, rulings from different intermediate courts in the meantime could further sow confusion.
A panel of three judges in the Manhattan-based US court of international trade and a federal judge in Washington DC have already declared that Trump did not have unilateral authority to impose tariffs without input from Congress. The Trump administration has appealed both rulings, in cases brought by 12 US states and several small businesses.
Corley's ruling is more limited than either of those decisions and does not address the legality of Trump's tariffs.
Instead, Corley ruled that California should have sued in the court of international trade, which has exclusive jurisdiction over tariff disputes in the US.
California, which opposed the transfer, had asked the judge to dismiss its case rather than transfer it, which will allow it to appeal to the ninth US circuit court of appeals.
The US court of appeals for the federal circuit in Washington has temporarily paused the trade court's ruling, which allows the tariffs to remain in place for now, while it considers whether to impose a longer term stay while an appeal of that ruling plays out.
California argues that any federal court can hear the case because it raises constitutional objection to Trump's use of tariff powers that are reserved for Congress unless delegated to a president.
The law that Trump has cited to justify the tariffs, the International Emergency Economic Powers Act, does not authorize tariffs at all, so it can not force California to litigate in the trade court, California's attorney general Rob Bonta said.
'Our argument is straightforward. Trump doesn't have the authority to impose these destructive tariffs,' Bonta said in a statement.
The lawsuits challenge Trump's so-called 'Liberation Day' tariffs on imports from most US trading partners, as well as a separate set of tariffs levied on China, Mexico and Canada.
The latter are related to his accusation that the three countries were facilitating the flow of fentanyl into the US, allegations the countries deny.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
26 minutes ago
- Reuters
Big central banks' forecasting lens gets fogged by US tariffs
LONDON, June 5 (Reuters) - Unpredictable White House tariff rhetoric and its impact on currency markets, oil prices and the inflation outlook have put central banks across the world in a tight spot. The European Central Bank cut interest rates on Thursday and looks set to pause, Switzerland appears to be moving back towards negative rates, Japan's resolve to drop ultra-easy monetary policy is wobbling, and baffling U.S. data could keep the Federal Reserve in wait-and-see mode. Here's a look at where 10 developed-market central banks stand. The Swiss National Bank next meets on June 19, and traders see a one in three chance that it will pull rates back into negative territory from 0.25% currently after consumer prices fell for the first time in four years. The safe-haven Swiss franc has gained 10% against the dollar so far this year on geopolitical and market volatility. That's challenging Switzerland's export-heavy economy and cheapened imports, giving the SNB reasons to be wary about deflation. The Bank of Canada held rates at 2.75% on Wednesday and said another cut might be necessary if the economy weakened in the face of tariffs. The BoC has held rates for a second time in a row after an aggressive cutting cycle which shrunk rates by 225 basis points over nine months. Markets price in a roughly 85% chance of another quarter-point cut by September. Money markets expect the Reserve Bank of New Zealand to hold steady on July 9 after a 25 bps rate cut to 3.25% in May to protect the China-focused economy. The RBNZ also warned that global trade uncertainties made future moves unclear. Sweden's central bank left its key rate unchanged at 2.25% in May but with on-again-off-again U.S. tariffs now having contributed to an economic contraction in the first quarter, the Riksbank has signaled more easing ahead. Its next rate decision is on June 18. The ECB cut rates as expected on Thursday and kept all options on the table, opens new tab for its next meetings even as the case grows for a summer pause in its year-long easing cycle. It has lowered rates eight times in the last year, and markets price in one more rate cut by year-end. The Fed, under consistent fire from President Donald Trump for resisting rate cuts, is expected to hold steady at its next June 18 meeting as tariff uncertainty makes wait-and-see its best option for now. With businesses spooked by Trump's aggressive trade talk, have increased, manufacturing orders have slumped and factory gate prices have surged, indicating stagflation risks that could moderate if the White House softens its stance. The Fed has held rates in the 4.25%-4.5% range since December, following 100 bps of cuts last year. Money markets price roughly 50 bps of further easing by year-end. The Bank of England, which has lowered borrowing costs slowly to accommodate bumpy inflation trends, cut rates by 25 bps to 4.25% last month and revealed an unexpected three-way split among its policymakers that signaled uncertainty ahead. Governor Andrew Bailey says the BoE was staying cautious amid unpredictable global trends. Traders expect no move in June and a 60% chance of a cut by August. Weak growth data and fears of Aussie commodities producers and miners taking big blows from a U.S.-China trade war means the Reserve Bank of Australia stands ready to ride to the rescue with rapid rate cuts. The RBA cut rates by 25 bps to 3.85% in May and traders see borrowing costs dropping to about 3% by year-end. Norway's central bank has ditched plans to ease monetary policy as its oil-linked currency weakens amid global trade uncertainty, posing a fresh inflationary threat. The Norges Bank kept rates on hold at a 17-year high of 4.50% in May, and markets anticipate no change at the June 19 meeting. The Bank of Japan, long expected to pursue rate hikes, faces a challenging mix of economic trends if tariffs hurt exports but inflation keeps rising. After the BoJ held borrowing costs steady at 0.5% in May, Governor Kazuo Ueda steadfastly refused to comment on the possible timing of the next increase.
Western Telegraph
27 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
Trump speaks with Xi amid stalled talks between the US and China over tariffs
The conversation was reported by Xinhua, a Chinese state media outlet. The White House did not immediately comment. Mr Trump had declared one day earlier that it was difficult to reach a deal with Mr Xi. President Donald Trump (Alex Brandon/AP) 'I like President XI of China, always have, and always will, but he is VERY TOUGH, AND EXTREMELY HARD TO MAKE A DEAL WITH!!!,' Mr Trump posted on Wednesday on his social media site. Trade negotiations between the United States and China stalled shortly after a May 12 agreement between the two countries to reduce their tariff rates while talks played out. Behind the gridlock has been the continued competition for an economic edge.
Western Telegraph
27 minutes ago
- Western Telegraph
European Central Bank cuts interest rate as Trump tariffs threaten economy
The bank's rate-setting council cut interest rates by a quarter of a point on Thursday at the bank's skyscraper headquarters in Frankfurt. Analysts expected a cut, given the gloomier outlook for growth since Mr Trump announced a slew of new tariffs on April 2 and subsequently threatened to impose a crushing 50% tariff, or import tax, on European goods. The bigger question remains how far the bank will go at subsequent meetings. Bank president Christine Lagarde's remarks at a post-decision news conference will be scrutinised for hints about the bank's outlook. ECB head Christine Lagarde (PA) Much depends on whether trade tensions can be resolved through negotiations, the bank indicated. 'A further escalation of trade tensions over the coming months would result in growth and inflation being below the baseline projections,' the bank said in its accompanying monetary policy statement. 'By contrast, if trade tensions were resolved with a benign outcome, growth and, to a lesser extent, inflation would be higher.' While the trade war and the uncertainty that goes with it is holding back growth, the ECB said the economy should get additional stimulus from higher government spending on defence and infrastructure. European governments are stepping up plans for defence purchases to counter Russia and its invasion of Ukraine. The spending boosts arrive amid concern that the US is no longer a fully committed ally in support of Ukraine. US defence secretary Pete Hegseth did not attend a recent meeting of allied nations created to organise Ukraine's military aid. It was the first time the US was not present since the group was set up three years ago. Mr Hegseth's predecessor, Lloyd Austin, created the group after Russia launched all-out war on Ukraine in 2022. Given the different possible outcomes the bank said that it was 'not committing to a particular rate path' for future policy meetings. Thursday's decision took the bank's benchmark rate to 2%, down from a peak of 4% in 2023-24. The bank raised rates to suppress an outbreak of inflation in 2021 to 2023 that was triggered by Russia's invasion of Ukraine, and by the rebound from the pandemic. But as inflation fell, the bank shifted gears towards supporting growth by lowering rates. With inflation now down to 1.9%, below the bank's target of 2%, analysts say the bank has room to take rates even lower to support growth.
